Dont get me wrong, I’m extremely grateful for my in-laws, and I know they mean well, but lately, they’ve really been getting on my nerves.
I’m seven weeks postpartum with my first baby boy. I absolutely adore him, but he suffers from silent reflux, which makes him extremely fussy at night and incredibly difficult to settle. He’s also a very difficult baby to burp, and watching him struggle with discomfort when he’s trying to sleep breaks my heart.
In the country I live in, it’s fairly common for people to hire night nurses to help with newborns if they can afford it. I’ve always been someone who needs sleep to function properly, and sleep deprivation really affects my mood and mental health.
My husband is back at work, and while he is genuinely helpful, I handle the nighttime routine on my own. By the time 7 AM rolls around, I’m completely exhausted, and then I have an entire day ahead of me taking care of my baby. I want to be present, patient and happy with my son, but it’s incredibly difficult when I’m running on two hours of sleep.
So my husband and I decided to hire a night nurse three nights a week. It’s expensive, and I fully acknowledge that it’s a luxury to have this option.
My own father has been incredibly supportive of this decision. He understands how important sleep is for me and wants me to be the best version of myself for my son. He even sent me money to help cover the expense.
Before telling my in-laws, I told my husband that I was hesitant because I felt they would be judgmental about it. This turned into a huge argument because he insisted his parents would never judge us. I tried explaining that my parents would naturally understand because I’m their daughter, and they see what I’m going through physically and mentally.
Fast forward to today. We were visiting my in-laws, and I mentioned to my MIL that I’d barely gotten two hours of sleep between midnight and 7 AM last night.
She kindly offered to take my son overnight on a day of our choosing. While I genuinely appreciate the offer, she’s older herself, and I wouldn’t want to put that burden on her. Besides, what I need right now is consistent, reliable help rather than an occasional night of relief.
I told her we’d arranged for a night nurse three times a week.
Her immediate response was, “I’m going to say something, and whether you take my advice or not, I’ll only say it once.”
She proceeded to tell us horror stories about night nurses giving babies gripe water to make them sleep through the night and warned us about how dangerous it could be.
I explained that I’d interviewed this woman twice, that I felt comfortable with her, and that my son was doing really well with her. But she kept pushing the subject.
I understand being concerned about your grandchild’s safety, but the entire conversation left me feeling as though I was being made out to be a careless mother for wanting a few nights of sleep. As if I hadn’t already considered the risks or done my due diligence.
Then there’s my SIL.
She exclusively breastfed all three of her children and is extremely proud of that, which she absolutely has every right to be. I breastfed for about a week, struggled with my supply, and ultimately decided to formula-feed for the sake of my mental health.
I’m aware of the benefits of breastfeeding. I made an informed decision based on what I could mentally and physically handle.
My son also has a cow’s milk protein allergy. Whenever I mention his reflux, baby acne or discomfort, she brings up breastfeeding again.
“Don’t you think you could get your supply back?”
“Have you tried getting your milk supply back?”
It’s happened multiple times now. I’ve explained that even if I managed to restore my supply, I would potentially have to eliminate dairy from my diet, which would add another layer of difficulty to an already exhausting postpartum experience.
But honestly, I shouldn’t even have to justify my decision.
What hurts me most is that these comments are coming from women who have experienced motherhood themselves. They know how exhausting the newborn stage is. They know how vulnerable you are postpartum. Why make another mother feel worse when she’s already struggling?
My mother passed away when I was 13, so I don’t have that constant maternal support that many women lean on during postpartum. I think that makes these interactions particularly painful for me. Sometimes I just wish I had a motherly figure who would tell me I’m doing a good job, that it’s okay to need help, and that I don’t have to sacrifice every ounce of myself to prove I’m a good mother.
Instead, I feel like I’m constantly having to defend my parenting decisions.
I’m not hiring a night nurse because I don’t want to take care of my baby. I’m not formula-feeding because I don’t care about his health. I’m making these decisions because I want to be a functioning, emotionally available mother to my son.
Why is there this unspoken expectation that motherhood has to involve suffering for you to be considered a good mother? Why is prioritizing your mental health somehow seen as selfish?
I can be grateful for my in-laws and still feel hurt by their comments. The two aren’t mutually exclusive.
I’m only seven weeks postpartum. I don’t need unsolicited advice, fearmongering or subtle criticism. I need compassion and reassurance.
Has anyone else experienced something similar with their in-laws postpartum? Am I being overly sensitive because of the sleep deprivation and hormones, or is it understandable that these comments are getting to me?
I guess I just needed to vent.