Question Looking to upgrade from a Garmin Forerunner 645 – Garmin, Huawei, COROS or Suunto?
I'm looking to replace my old Garmin Forerunner 645 and would appreciate some advice from people who have experience with different brands.
My budget is around NOK 3,000 (roughly €250–260). I'm based in Norway, so availability and local pricing are also relevant.
I'm not a particularly serious or competitive runner at the moment. I've been fairly inactive for a few years and want to get back into running and some basic strength training at home.
What matters most to me:
- Running data: GPS accuracy, distance, pace, time and heart rate.
- Tracking progress: I'd like to follow improvements over time – running faster or longer, lower heart rate at the same pace, and general fitness improvements.
- VO2 max: An estimate and the ability to follow the trend over time would be useful.
- Running dynamics: I'd be interested in cadence, stride length, ground contact time, vertical oscillation etc. I'm particularly interested in improving my running technique and avoiding overstriding. I realise wrist-based measurements have limitations.
- Everyday smartwatch features: Notifications are important. I mainly want to see who is contacting me and read messages, rather than reply from the watch. Good control over notifications and automatic Do Not Disturb / sleep mode would be a plus.
- Battery life: I'd prefer not to charge the watch every day.
- Basic strength training: I plan to do some kettlebell exercises, push-ups, planks etc. It would be nice to track these sessions and progress, but I don't need an elaborate training programme. I'm fine with manually correcting exercises, reps and sets if necessary.
What I don't really need:
- Built-in maps or advanced navigation.
- Music storage or streaming.
- A microphone or speaker for phone calls.
- Extensive training plans or coaching features.
- Lots of recovery/readiness metrics that tell me when I should or shouldn't train. I prefer to listen to my body and use the watch mainly to track what I actually do.
I'm currently considering watches from several brands, including:
- Garmin Forerunner 70 / 170 / 265, Venu 3 and vívoactive 6
- Huawei Watch Fit 4 Pro / Fit 5 Pro and GT Runner 2
- COROS Pace 3 / Pace 4
- Suunto Run / Race S
I'm not necessarily looking for the watch with the most features. I'd rather avoid paying extra for things I'll never use.
A few things I'd especially like to hear about:
- How do Garmin, Huawei, COROS and Suunto compare in everyday use, particularly notifications and smartwatch features?
- How good are their running metrics and long-term fitness tracking?
- How well do they handle basic strength training? Is automatic exercise/repetition detection useful, or do you end up correcting everything manually?
- For someone coming from an older Garmin, would switching to Huawei, COROS or Suunto feel like an upgrade, a downgrade, or simply a different experience?
- Are there any models in this price range that you think offer particularly good value?
I'd especially appreciate feedback from people who have actually switched between these brands, rather than just comparing specifications.
Thanks!