Link to the review (which has been shared here) for more reading and subbing purposes: https://panoramafilmthoughts.substack.com/p/the-hunger-games-sunrise-on-the-reaping
Thanks!
Well, if you’re going to make IP slop, at least stuff it with enough interesting surface-level ideas to mask all the shortcomings. The most flattering thing I can say about The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is that it does just enough to arouse curiosity, but never aspires or even tries to be something worthy of our attention.
Taking a page out of the increasingly well-worn IP playbook, Sunrise on the Reaping is a prequel focusing on Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) and how he survived the 50th edition of the titular Hunger Games. Given the amount of established world-building and character lore to mine, exploring Haymitch’s origin story is a good idea - in theory - because going from sympathetic young man to self-destructive alcoholic by the time we meet the first Hunger Games protagonist, Katniss Everdeen, some 24 in-universe years later is fascinating.
Sadly, there’s not really much there in the way of a character arc or thematic richness that makes Haymitch’s downfall interesting in ways that matter. Unless you’re a sucker for unabashed inhuman suffering with no rhyme or reason behind it. The Hunger Games is set in a grim world, but Sunrise on the Reaping is unforgivably dark or stupid in ways that’s too alienating to really be engaging.
Right off the bat, we’re introduced to Haymitch and his girlfriend Lenore (Whitney Peak) whispering sweet nothings to each other. And by that I mean trading overwritten lines about fate, free will, and choice, with a dash of exposition about what’s about to happen next. Okay, but what about what makes either of you attracted or interesting to one another? Nothing? Oh okay. Maybe flirting is different in the world of Panem. That basically sets the tone for how the movie is going to function until the credits roll.
This is a dystopian world and there are several prerequisite lines about fighting the good fight and taking down fascism. Haymitch’s ‘not letting them paint a poster with my blood’ line is a repeated motif that’s pretty evocative. But don’t mistake those moments as anything resembling actual depth. This movie does the really annoying thing of bringing up an interesting idea, having a character like Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons) sprout a line or two, and then completely ignoring it because there’s a set piece or plot point to focus on.
Clocking in at a gargantuan 158 minutes, Sunrise on the Reaping is the longest Hunger Games movie, and you really do feel the slog. The screenplay, written by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie, takes the longest route possible to get to any point. Events that transpire have very little impact on the narrative other than to elicit cheap shock or pad out the runtime, like the Tribute Parade sequence and about 90 per cent of the titular Hunger Games. 45 minutes could’ve been cut and the movie wouldn’t have lost anything narratively or thematically.
Beyond Sunrise on the Reaping feeling like a grind at times, I simply can’t comprehend how ugly this movie looks. Sunrises are meant to be majestic, yet the world of Panem is less inspired than a miner’s outfit. After helming four previous Hunger Games movies, you’d think director Francis Lawrence would’ve picked up a couple of new visual tricks. Yet, the whole thing is shot and coloured like Marvel CGI slop.
If the first couple of Hunger Games movies were all about excessive shaky cam, Sunrise on the Reaping is all about the close-up. We barely see anything of District 12 and Panem other than the inside of some houses, training arenas, and characters reacting to being in those environments. The only notable wide shots in the movie are when the titular Hunger Games start, and that looks like it was shot on a green screen. To be fair, the whole spectrum of colour is deployed throughout the movie, albeit with no narrative or emotional reasoning behind any of the design decisions. I suppose the colours do make Effie Trinket (Elle Fanning) and Drusilla Sickle’s (Glenn Close) fashion sense pop and help establish the difference between grass and roses - all of which look like CGI creations anyway.
The stacked cast do what they can with the material, but the tonal clash is so jarring that it feels like you’re watching two completely different movies. The tributes and younger actors are merely different shades of the same gloom (rightfully so since they’re literally fighting for their lives), whereas the adult characters are over-the-top ridiculous. Lawrence is clearly trying to juxtapose the ridiculousness of the powerful with the grim reality of the downtrodden, but he never quite strikes the balance because you don’t buy a world where these types of people can realistically co-exist.
Not a single character has much in the way of development, traits, or function beyond pushing the story forward. Maysilee Donner (McKenna Grace), one of two female District 12 tributes, is a badass who hates Haymitch for some reason. We never find out why and it’s bloody annoying. Give us some reason why he’s like oil to her water because it’ll at least give some tangible reasoning to their inevitable trauma bonding scenes. At least Plemons lends the movie some much-needed moral shading while Fanning is having the time of her life, but both are woefully underused.
Zada’s inherent nice boy energy goes a long way in making Haymitch a somewhat watchable protagonist, but there’s no character-driven proactiveness behind everything he does. He’s just there for the vibes and is ultimately incidental in getting this movie aligned narratively with all the prior Hunger Games movies. It truly is a shame because by the time we get to Sunrise on the Reaping’s most interesting sequence from a thematic and character perspective, there’s only 20 minutes of movie left and it makes you wonder why they couldn’t have done that for the whole thing.
But does the quality of this movie ultimately matter when the whole reason for its existence is to print money? After all, it’s why The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is a thing in the first place. In lieu of taking a genuinely interesting premise and characters, and making something interesting, the filmmakers did the bare minimum and are trying to convince you that the end result is exactly what you wanted because, hey, it’s faithful to the book. The sad thing is its target audience, who deserve better, will gladly volunteer as a tribute every time.