I've been deep frying turkeys for several years now, and here are some tips I've collected over time. By the way, if you've never tried deep fried turkey, it's AMAZING. Once you try it, you'll never go back to roasting.
Every year we hear horror stories about people burning down their homes trying to deep fry a turkey. There is a safe way to do it. First, this is assuming you're using a pot over an open flame. If you're using an electric deep fryer, those are much safer although the same tips below can still apply to a certain extent.
A lot of fires are started by people who overfill the pot with oil and then it spills over when the turkey is put in, and the oil catches fire. So make sure you don't overfill the pot with oil. With an electric deep fryer, there's no open flame, and the biggest danger is splattered or spilled boiling oil (which is dangerous too). So even with an electric fryer, measure the amount you’ll need.
Take your turkey and put it in the pot and fill with water until it's just covering the turkey. That's the amount of oil you'll need to cover the turkey too. Take the turkey out and note where the water level is in the pot. That's where your oil level should be. NOTE: This should go without saying, but when you put the turkey in and cover it with water, make sure it’s out of the packaging and that you’ve removed the giblets first, otherwise you will get a very inaccurate measurement of how much oil you’ll need.
Another issue is the type of oil. You need an oil with a high smoke point (that's the temperature at which the oil will start to break down and burn. Peanut oil is generally considered to be the best type of oil to use when deep frying a turkey because of its high smoke point. I have a relative who is allergic to peanuts so I switched to canola oil which I’ve found works just as well. Don’t use vegetable oil, the smoke point is way too low. And if you’re worried about taste, the turkey will not taste like peanuts if you use peanut oil.
Once your oil is at the desired temperature (usually 400 degrees Fahrenheit), you have to put the turkey in, and this is where people run into trouble. The turkey should be completely thawed and DRY. Water and oil do not play nicely together when the oil is boiling. If there are any frozen parts of the turkey they may very well explode. And any water droplets might shoot out of the pot. Take your time and pat the turkey as dry as possible, inside and out. I like to pat dry, let it sit at room temp for an hour, then pat dry again before putting it in.
And take your time when putting the turkey into the pot, don't just dump it in. It should take a minute or two to slowly immerse the turkey in the oil. If you haven't done it before, be careful - When oil is boiling, it won't look like water boiling, it won't be roiling or bubbling. But as soon as the turkey touches it, it's going to start bubbling and sizzling like crazy. Wear fire-resistant gloves and use a metal hook to lower it SLOWLY into the oil.
This is the most important step many people skip, and it is very important. Once your oil is at temp, and immediately before you put the turkey in - TURN THE FLAME OFF (obviously this doesn’t apply to an electric deep fryer). This will prevent a fire in case any oil splashes out while you're putting the turkey in the pot. Once it's safely in you can turn the flame back on, the temperature isn't going to be affected by turning the flame off for a minute or two. Make sure you use whatever devices your deep fryer comes with to get the turkey in, be it a basket or a stand, most have big hooks to hold onto, make sure you wear an oven mitt too.
When the turkey is done, do the same thing - turn the flame OFF before you take it out so any oil that drips off doesn't start a turkey volcano. If there's no open flame, you can't start a fire. Once it's off, SLOWLY take the turkey out, let the oil drip off, put it on a platter or roasting pan and cover with aluminum foil for 20-25 minutes to let it finish cooking on the counter.
The oil will remain hot for a while, so make sure it's somewhere safe. When it cools, strain it back into it's container through some cheesecloth so you can reuse it.
Also, and this should go without saying - do this outside, NOT on a wooden deck, not inside your garage. It should be on concrete or level grass if possible. That said, I use my electric deep fryer inside because there’s no open flame. If you’re using a deep fryer with a burner you’re insane if you do it inside.
Good luck and happy thanksgiving!