r/mathematics • u/MEDBEDb • 11h ago
Alpöge Should Publish His Entire Process and Prompt History Flowchart.
Isn’t this much more interesting than the lean result and furthermore in the interest of advancing scientific technique?
r/mathematics • u/MEDBEDb • 11h ago
Isn’t this much more interesting than the lean result and furthermore in the interest of advancing scientific technique?
r/mathematics • u/Sea_Ingenuity_5022 • 6h ago
I always thought Riemann was the biggest pure math problems but now that its solved what is it now. The only other big substancial problem I know of is P=NP but that's theoretical computer science rather than pure math
r/mathematics • u/adivinemessenger • 1d ago
r/mathematics • u/Old-School8916 • 4h ago
r/mathematics • u/Cojj25 • 15h ago
I haven’t seen any videos / postings. Curious to hear his thoughts.
r/math • u/Topoltergeist • 23h ago
There are too many good quotes in the essay The future of Mathematics by Henri Poincaré.
Highly recommend
r/mathematics • u/ECrispy • 8h ago
In light of the GRH news, there are still many maths problems that are far more difficult, and which we really have no clue how to even approach - like the normality of well known irrational constants, whether e+pi is irrational etc.
It is widely believed (and yes, this was said about RH too) that new mathematic techniques and major new insights will be needed for these.
But out of all these, is Collatz the 'simplest'? Its almost impossible to explain a lot of other problems to the vast majority of non mathematicians.
you can explain Collatz to a child in about 2min and they can happily start experimenting. This might be true of most problems in pure number theory, eg twin primes/goldbach, but prime numbers quickly get overwhelming. Nothing seems as approachable yet completely unfathomable like Collatz!
r/mathematics • u/Standard-Song-8590 • 21h ago
r/mathematics • u/nafizzaki • 1d ago
We just might have to admit that this is the beginning of a new era…
r/mathematics • u/Plenty-Value3381 • 1d ago
Which means we can rule out any "lean bugs". Right.?
r/mathematics • u/Old-School8916 • 16h ago
Riemann Theorem? Riemann-Alpöge Theorem?
r/mathematics • u/Equivalent-Lab-8852 • 5h ago
r/math • u/bladex1234 • 16h ago
Looking over the recent discussion around the claimed Anthropic proof of the generalized Riemann hypothesis for Dirichlet L-functions, I was wondering about other conjectures that rely on the Riemann hypothesis being true. Considering that Hodge and BSD both concern cohomologies of algebraic varieties, and algebraic motives give a unified framework for the cohomologies of algebraic varieties, does the Riemann hypothesis for motivic L-functions provide the framework for answering these other Millenium Prize problems? This is not my area of expertise so I only have a partial understanding of the proof and how these other conjectures are formulated so I thought I’d ask the community here.
r/math • u/translationinitiator • 22h ago
With the recent developments in RH and NS, I am not sure how I, as a grad student, should be making use of AI. I feel like there are so many different lines of thought, each suggesting something different,
If I treat math as a way to see new results: this tells me to use AI as a theorem producer: ask it a question and help refine its output until it produces a full proof.
If I treat math as a way to develop myself as a researcher, in the traditional sense (developing questions, thinking of answers independently or under some sort of supervision, but not to the point of handholding), this tells me to use AI only to the extent that i might ask questions to my advisor, but nothing more.
If I treat math as a vocation, in the sense of I need to get many papers out so I appear hireable, this tells me to use AI (as long as I’m understanding the output well)
I’ve heard a lot about how professors are talking about using AI, many of whom believe it should form part one’s tools (or at least will soon enough). Some people think mathematicians will simply be interpreting outputs given to us by AI oracles.
But professors are in a different boat than us grad students, who also are sort of “learning the ropes”. But this isn’t so simple, since we are also under pressure of publishing more important results, which are definitely made easier with AI.
So, to the grad students on this sub (and anyone else who might have an opinion on this, actually), how are you (or should you be) thinking about your role as a grad student these days, and what it means for how you do math on a daily basis with or without AI?
r/mathematics • u/drugkeeper • 18h ago
Given the recent advancements, is there any unsolved problem that is still intractable for the foreseeable future? For instance, something so completely out of reach and unsolvable with our current understanding and our limited tools available.
For instance, existence of odd perfect numbers which is unsolved for a very very long time. What about Collatz conjecture or twin prime conjecture?
I'm curious on what would be the hardest unsolved problem out there now, obviously we are all speculating here, but I wish to hear your thoughts!
r/mathematics • u/Gold_Ad4004 • 17h ago
I found this thing on GitHub, saying what I believe that the human made solution is wrong, can anyone explain to me or verify if this is true? https://github.com/prenjith/prime-trace-note
r/mathematics • u/Quick-Dragonfly-630 • 21h ago
I'm not a mathematician, just someone who did a small amount of math in university and I have been following all the discussion on the Masullo GRH draft. Some critiques I have seen show up in discussions of it are that it's: 1.) Incomplete and 2.) Some flaws have been discovered but are 'repairable'.
That second part threw me a bit because I thought proofs were pretty binary, either you got it right or wrong. But, clearly more advanced mathematics has different complexities to it that I do not know about.
When working mathematicians look at some massive draft like Masullo's, how does one discern between a bad step that is repairable and a back-breaking step that invalidates everything? And when a reviewing mathematician says "potentially repairable", is it usually grounded in optimism about the underlying proof or is it just more professional courtesy/caution before reading the whole thing?
r/mathematics • u/Queasy_Height2353 • 18h ago
I am not a mathematician, just a math enthusiast. I don't understand why a problem about the distribution of prime numbers is the most important problem in mathematics. For a layperson, it can sound a bit trivial.
Edit: Some people misinterpreted me. I am not claiming that RH is not important. I don't assume because I can't see its importance, that it is not important. I am saying that I don't understand its importance and came here to understand.
I tried to avoid coming over as intellectually arrogant and stubborn by using subjective language and saying that I am just a layperson ("for a layperson, it can sound trivial"), but clearly not everybody in the chat interpreted this in the way I meant.
If mathematicians regard this as one of the biggest problems (maybe solved problem by now) in math, I'll take their word for it. But I still don't understand why.
r/mathematics • u/Recent-Day3062 • 29m ago
For reference I am an engineer who has far more math than most of my colleagues, but I am certainly not a math major.
When I open a paper here, I simply get lost in the first two paragraphs in both notation and prior knowledge
But they almost always start with notation and what I call an assumption of prior math. To make up a silly concrete example, like “consider a function (.) such that it is a solution to a second order Bessel function root under the condition of Helmholtz equivalence <r, z> such that lambda^(~{iar omeag_subq)} module pi/2 is everywhere representable in a quasi-Hilbert space, which we shall notate as q’m(r\omega_n). Correspondingly ther is of course a tea gent bundle…
Obviously this is farcical. But you get my drift.
1) at what point in your education do you follow this from the start ?
2) does it always assume a deep knowledge of some field, and makes little sense if you haven’t studied that field?
I assume Tao can read many, but what is the norm? Are fields of math so deep and narrow that most mathematicians even have trouble undeerstanding the first page because it presumes a PhD in that niche?
r/math • u/non-orientable • 1d ago
I have done posts on category theory before on the Deranged Mathematician, but I have yet to prove any big and non-trivial category-theoretical result. What I intend to prove is that adjoint functors preserve limits and colimits---but before we can get into that, we first need to know what limits and colimits are, and that is the subject of this article.
The key takeaway, as I see it, is that limits and colimits are everywhere. The profinite completion of a group is a limit. Kernels of ring homomorphisms and linear maps are limits. Cokernels are colimits. Intersections of sets are limits. Metric space completions are colimits. Products (of sets, topological spaces, vector spaces, etc.) are limits.
This should give a hint that what we are planning to prove is indeed very powerful.
Read the full post (for free) on Substack: Limits and Colimits