r/ModernMagic • • 3h ago

Article “Not a story of success, but a warning for future TCGs”- Jason Yan on Riftbound, prizing and competitive Magic

49 Upvotes

In the eleventh week of the Modern Pilot League (MPL), thirteen Challenges were held, and 228 pilots reached the Top 32 at least once, and there are already 1,193 names in the table. Since the table only includes pilots who have made at least one Challenge Top 32, the top 10% of the table is almost 120 players, and the top 12 are its absolute top 1%! The season ends on 30 November, so the big final comes in two weeks; the top of the table won't change much, but before we get to the results, I invite you to an interview I conducted with Jason Yan, the reigning Australia/New Zealand Regional Champion. He won the Modern RC in Sydney in October 2026 with Azorius Chant, earning an invitation to Magic World Championship 33. Before that title, he had already put up strong results on the ANZ Super Series circuit. In the interview, he presents a very interesting and, in my opinion, accurate perspective on how prizes in tournaments can affect their atmosphere. It's really worth reading the whole thing, and I'm very curious about your opinions.

 

Karol (K): First of all, thank you so much for agreeing to this interview, and congratulations on your win at RC Sydney. To start, how long have you been playing MTG, and which format do you prefer: online or paper? We have several platforms for playing online, of course. Do you have a favorite?

Jason (J): Of course, it’s my pleasure! I was first properly introduced to Magic in 2019 after Throne of Eldraine was released (bad time to start playing) and played FNMs casually on and off for a year or two. I stopped playing 60 card formats for a couple years after my parents wanted me to focus on high school but returned around the end of 2025 when Vivi Cauldron was the top deck (again, bad time to start playing) and started really becoming interested in Competitive Magic around then.

I far prefer paper as one of the things I enjoy most about Magic is meeting new people and spending time with friends. I also find myself to be far more engaged with the game in person whereas online I get easily distracted and enjoy myself less overall. I prefer Arena over MTGO as I’m a teenager who needs his dopamine and MTGO looks too much like a spreadsheet…

 

K: You won playing one of the more difficult decks to pilot in Modern, especially at a large paper event with many rounds: UW Prison. Why did you choose that deck?

J: The first reason I chose Chant was that I thought it was well positioned in the meta. Apart from the large meta share online and at other RCs, I had a feeling that some of the bigger teams in ANZ were planning on bringing Broodscale (not from anyone leaking, to be clear, just a gut feeling), which made registering Chant, which has a fantastic matchup into Broodscale, a natural choice.

The second reason was that I’ve actually been playing the deck for a while, and my practice on other decks was limited. I briefly considered pivoting to Rakdos Delirium the week before the RC, but ended up staying the course. The thing that probably tipped the scales is the fact that the mirrors are extremely intricate, and mistakes often cost you the game on the spot. I felt confident in my ability to win against less experienced pilots who maybe picked up the deck with less practice due to its recent success (not that it mattered; I played zero mirrors over the weekend).

 

K: That brings me to my next question: how do you deal with fatigue during a large tournament?

J: I was perhaps fortunate to play in a smaller RC, as the ANZ RC only had 9 rounds of Swiss. I think that this goes for many aspects of Magic, but there are so many factors which influence your fatigue in long tournaments that you have little control over (length of games, rounds going over time, general health over the weekend, etc). I would recommend to always to make sure you are aware of the things you do actually have control over and address them. Make sure you get plenty of sleep the night before, pack snacks/lunch so you don’t starve throughout the day and practise sufficiently before the event so you don’t waste mental energy on decisions which are made trivial through reps.

 

K:  The Modern season has just ended. I’m curious how you feel about switching from Modern’s power level to Standard.

J: Personally, I’m not too fussed between the two formats. If anything, I’m slightly disadvantaged at Modern which rewards players for having played the format for a long time which I obviously haven’t. Also, the power level of standard has been slowly creeping upward over the last couple of years anyway…

 

K: Questions about the first Modern deck to get and how to get started in the format come up often on Reddit and Discord. Do you have any advice for beginners on where to start? Which deck should they choose, and what advice would you like to share with them?

J: I don’t really think I have many revolutionary ideas about this to be honest. Beginners are usually limited by format knowledge and budget, so playing proactive decks which care less about opposing gameplays is pretty obvious. Prowess is usually the default answer for a good reason, as it’s not only cheap and aggressive but also has a plethora of resources available for people looking to pick up the deck. Shoutout to u/ethanbirdmtg for consistently putting out educational content for the deck for ages, I would recommend watching him play to improve.

 

 

K:  As a die-hard Domain Zoo fan, I have to ask: how do you find playing against Zoo? I’m also curious what you think of Zoo in the current metagame.

J: Zoo is pretty tricky for Chant to deal with, simply because it pressures our planeswalkers with efficient creatures (similar to Boros). Casting Day’s Undoing fairly is also always scary because it shuffles our opponents' burn spells back into the deck, which can be dangerous if our new 7 is bad. Also stubborn denial… I’d definitely rather sit down against a different matchup, as I think it's slightly to noticeably favoured in favour of Zoo.

I’ve literally never played the deck so I’d only be guessing if I gave my opinion on its place in the meta. A couple of my friends in Adelaide think it’s well positioned though.

 

K:  I’ve recently read a lot of complaints from pro players about how Wizards treats them, and about tournament prizes being pretty poor compared with those in competing TCGs, pushing competitive gaming in MTG to the sidelines. What do you think about this?

J: It’s no secret that competitive Magic is becoming less and less of a priority for WOTC these days, and as a corporation that cares about little other than the bottom line, it makes sense. Why invest resources into supporting competitive formats when Commander is simply far more profitable? However I would strongly urge WOTC to reconsider their stance. I think that diverting even a fraction of resources that they put into other aspects of the game towards competitive Magic would have a drastic impact on players all around. The identity of Magic is very much rooted in competition, and to see the competitive aspect of the game continue to decline over the coming years as a result of WOTC’s inaction would sadden me greatly.

Obviously, there has been significant discourse of the rise of Riftbound, and the use of metal cards as prizing which rewards players for doing well at even side events of big conventions. There are many things I have to say about this.

Firstly, I want to look at Riftbound, not as a story of success, but as a warning for future TCGs with marketable IPs. While a relatively mediocre weekend playing side events at RQs being able to pay for an overseas trip is certainly appealing, it’s turned the scene into something I would be ashamed to call a competitive card game. I’ve been bombarded with stories of collusion between players in contention for best-ofs, people pushing each other over at the prize wall in hopes of claiming the most valuable legends, players treating other players in upsetting, horrible ways during matches as there is simply so much money involved.

I think that one thing that I’ve always loved about Magic is that almost everyone plays in these tournaments for the love of the game. Most players at the Pro Tour level bleed money travelling to and from events, and it’s simply not a lifestyle that people would tolerate if they didn’t love what they do. I’ve always felt that most players are keen to talk about card evaluations and deck choices because it interests them and brings them joy, and it’s impossible not to feel their love for this silly card game emanate from them as they describe how they’ve spent all their wildcards on a stupid RUG Bilbo brew rather than a real deck for testing (stay tuned for a new deck tech maybe? u/jasonyanmtg on yt shameless plug).

On the other hand, the amount of money on the table for Riftbound is eye-watering, and I’ve seen many people playing Riftbound almost as a better-paying part time job. I personally know many groups of people who fly to RQs to farm side events for metal cards, and I think that for many Riftbound players, the same love of the game will never be found. In my opinion, good prizing should always been a supplement or an additional benefit to the pursuit of your fun TCG hobby, but never the entire reason you participate, and this monetary incentive lends itself to some truly rancid behaviour from people who, perhaps predictably, behave in terrible ways when four to five figure sums are on the line. While I’m excited for TCG enjoyers to have a fresh game which looks to be really deep and interesting (I would certainly give it a go if I had the time), I want people to recognise that the insane prizing at these competitive events aren’t something to be celebrated blindly, but looked warily upon.

Secondly, we have to acknowledge that it is impossible for Wizards to replicate this kind of financial prizing through promos in Magic. I think most people are focused on the massive amounts of money these cards sell for, but surprising no one, Magic characters are nowhere near as marketable as LOL legends, and it would be ridiculous to expect WOTC to essentially throw money at players the same way that Riftbound does. It’s simply not a reasonable ask.

I don’t think us Magic players require the same financial incentives that other TCGs provide. There are plenty of competitive gamers out there who would want nothing more than to engage with the scene, but are constantly left disappointed by the way WOTC treats them. The recent RC promos have been a breath of fresh air. Kozilek’s Command and Elspeth are both home runs by metrics of playability across formats. Ocelot Pride and Urza’s Saga make people want to show up to Store Championships and have something worth playing for. But every time WOTC prints Jace Reawakened or Laughing Jasper Flint (don’t even get me started on the Spotlight promos) as the promo for a competitive event, players feel unvalued. Players start caring less. Players start looking for greener pastures, and why wouldn’t they, when better alternatives are right across the street? Ultimately, I don’t think that Wizards should compete with other TCGs by printing ridiculously expensive promos. Right now players feel invisible, ignored by a massive corporation that's lost its roots. I think that just by printing cool, playable promos (which would cost them literally the same as printing freaking Riddles in the Dark) would be a strong step towards getting RCQs to fire, towards stemming the bleeding of Magic players fleeing to other games, and towards restoring competitive Magic to what I’ve been told it once was.

 

K: From our conversation, I also know that you don’t often play challenges on MTGO. I run my own seasonal league for challenge players, and I’m curious what might persuade you to take part in a league like that. Of course, what I’m doing is unofficial, but I’d like to hear your ideas about what could attract players who aren’t on MTGO to the league.

J: I think the main barrier, at least for me, is navigating the UI of MTGO. It’s old, outdated, and pretty boring to look at and interact with. Call me a dopamine craving child who needs Subway Surfers in the corner of his videos (because I am), but I simply enjoy the game less and play much worse when playing on MTGO.

 

K:  I’m also curious whether there’s a particular match you remember especially well.

J: I think for me, my match in the finals of the RC against Christopher Tong was extremely memorable. I certainly didn’t play perfectly, nor would I expect myself in such a high pressure situation, but I got to execute a bunch of cool plays on coverage which ultimately culminated in an achievement I’m especially proud of.

Honestly, my opponents over the weekend were all amazing, and I think that irrespective of how my weekend ended, I would have looked fondly back on the event and felt really happy that I had so much fun playing a deck I really love against people who I really enjoyed spending time with. It’s definitely a reminder for me of the reason I play the game, and I’m already looking forward to the next RC where I’ll hopefully have an equally positive (and successful :D) time playing Magic.

 

K: And lastly, do you have a favorite card in your MTG collection? If so, which one, and why?

J: I think I would say the favourite cards in my collection would be the 14 HERBIEs signed by my PT team, Team Bananas, after the testing house concluded. It being my first PT, I definitely had concerns over perhaps not fitting in well with the team (I was around 6-7 years younger than the next youngest teammate) or the testing house having an unfriendly vibe or atmosphere. I was relieved that my fears were unwarranted, as it was an amazing group of people, and I got each person to sign a HERBIE (a card I valued perhaps higher than others) from the draft chaff left after testing. It’s a testament to my view on Magic above that, despite losing my win and in for day 2 at the PT and then another one at the Spotlight the week after that I look back on that trip as one of my fondest memories ever.

 

It's time to get back to the league and how the table looked last week:

nahuel10 had the best week in the league: 22 points from 9 starts, 7 Top 8 finishes and a Challenge win. Before this week, his lead over rastaf was 8 points; now it stands at 22. Throughout the season, nahuel10 has 93 points from 51 starts, 7 Challenge wins, and 11 finals, the most in the standings.

rastaf maintains 2nd place with 71 points after a Challenge win from 3 starts. It is worth noting that the first two have the same number of points per start, each with 1.82, and rastaf converts Top 32 finishes into Top 8s even more often: 49% versus 45%. The difference between them is the number of starts, 39 versus 51.

The most happened behind the podium. MeninoNey moved up to 3rd place by winning the Challenge and now has the most starts in the standings, 53. Venom01 jumped from 7th to 4th place, and xfile from 8th to 5th. Both have 55 points each. According to the tie rule, Venom01 is higher because he has fewer starts: 33 vs. 40. After a calm week, Mistakenn dropped from 3rd to 6th place. The point threshold needed to place in the top 10 increased from 34 to 42 points.

Lower in the table, MisterTwin made the biggest jump among pilots from the top 100: from 182nd to 55th place, with 10 points from 6 starts. The best conversion of the week belonged to O_danielakos. All three of his starts ended in the Top 8; he played in the final twice and won once. This gave him 12 points and a rise from 44th to 19th place.

Autumn closes on 30 November. The question now is less who finishes first and more who makes the podium!

See you next week

Karol Małota

aka WarLord1986pl / TribalFlamesInYourFace


r/ModernMagic • • 4h ago

Deck Discussion One Deck

9 Upvotes

So im looking to sell out of magic as a whole the whole lot of it but talking to some friends they all think i should keep 1 deck

i have the makings of just about anything in the meta right now. Some decks would need a little upgrade from the sell of the collection (like if i keep yawgmoth id need badgermole, tron needs the new ugins and a couple of sires, etc)

and theres three schools of thought here

  1. keep a deck that will pretty much never get banned out, even if i dont find it the most exciting or interesting deck (ruby storm)
  2. keep a deck that i might enjoy playing more but runs a level of risk of bannings (say like affinity with mox opal)
  3. keep a deck that i might enjoy playing but when upgrades come they might be expensive (like tron)

if it helps in your deliberations i have been playing a lot of domain zoo and find that deck a lot of fun lately, its got interaction, big creatures to swing with, removal and the sideboard feels balanced to be able to go head to head with the rest of the format.

but that could also be because noone where i play at has been teching for it

that being said

if you could keep one deck just one and sell out the rest of your collection which deck would it be and why? help me to make a better informed decision.


r/ModernMagic • • 9h ago

Deck Discussion Faerie's deck help

3 Upvotes

wanted to get some feedback on my faeries list. I haven't played modern in years and am looking to get back in with a tempo deck as tempo is my favorite play style. this is the list i came up with, feedback and suggestions for other decks with a tempo play style is welcome.

4 Bitterbloom Bearer

2 Brazen Borrower

4 Counterspell

2 curiosity

4 curious obsession

4 Darkslick Shores

3 Faerie Dreamthief

3 Faerie Fencing

4 Faerie Seer

4 Fatal Push

4 Flare of Denial

2 Island

4 Polluted Delta

2 Sink into Stupor

4 Spellstutter Sprite

2 Swamp

4 Thoughtseize

4 Watery Grave

SIDEBOARD:

4 Consign to Memory

3 Inquisition of Kozilek

2 Into the Flood Maw

4 Relic of Progenitus

2 Spell pierce

Moxfield link: https://moxfield.com/decks/AxLfJXf-L0S0yHQSxUrrIA


r/ModernMagic • • 1d ago

Sideboard/Matchup Advice Help with living end

8 Upvotes

Hey, i am relative new to modern, between 4 to 5 months, i decide to build living end because is one of the most tool box decks and thats fascinates me but i'm having a lot of difficult in closing the game, i feel so lost in some matchs after the G1, siding having been very difficult (i switch formats and my mainly format was commander so sideboard its something very new to me), basically in my LGS i am facing esper blink, grixies reanimator, uw chant, br delirium, devoted combo, ruby storm, domain zoo, neoform combo, Boros ponza.

Against uw chant sometimes i loose the G1 and win the G2 but loose the G3 and sometimes i win G1, loose G2 and loose G3.

Against esper blink i didnt win any game at all.

Against boros ponza i only loose G1.

Against br delirium i have no idea how to play it, one match i did violent outburst on T3 to survive and got 3 life and they strike me with lightning bolt.

I try to search on youtube good gameplays of living end but all of them (taking out mengucci) its outdated and i have no clue in how to play it, i would love to heard some tips and advices


r/ModernMagic • • 1d ago

Where to play? Where to play modern/draft near Andover MA?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ModernMagic • • 2d ago

Deck Discussion Uldaros Theorix in Modern

7 Upvotes

I was looking for the guy’s Charm on Moxfield earlier today, and seeing him properly I’m thinking [[Uldaros Theorix]] is a pretty good deep end game win-con for a heavy control Wan-Shi-Frog decklist so I thought I’d put one or two copies in.

I’m curious what you guys think about him, and whether he’s worth ever considering. Turn-6 just has a lot of combos with him Solitude+Erode soft wipes the board, Kaito+Psychic Frog/Wan Shi Tong is just absurd value, and of course there is a dozen other combinations that could come up, too

He seems pretty good, we just gotta get to 6 lands which seems doable, otherwise we can pitch him.

Decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/gkfr8A1HNUqgKS5CaZJunA


r/ModernMagic • • 3d ago

Played the new Anthropoligical Mission combo deck and it gives me real Underworld Breach vives.

34 Upvotes

r/ModernMagic • • 1d ago

Card Discussion Urza's Saga as a ban candidate: a serious discussion

0 Upvotes

Saga is one of those cards that no single deck absolutely needs, but that helps out a few specific decks immensely, especially those with Mox Opal or that revolve around specific 1 mana artifacts. Banning it kills no archetypes, but weakens a few of the most powerful in the format - Broodscale, Affinity, Amulet Titan. They would all survive, but would be less consistent without their "free" tutor and less robust plan B by making constructs.

On the other hand, there is no indication that any single deck with Saga is currently performing above the metrics that are deemed acceptable with the exception of maybe Broodscale. And in that case, it would make more sense to ban a card that is more specific to that archetype. But the most commonly suggested card to remove from that archetype is Kozilek's Command - a card that has a similarly broad play rate across archetypes as Saga. It's rare to hear someone suggest the ban of Basking Broodscale itself.

Does Urza's Saga make the format more interesting by enabling the types of decks that it does? Or is mostly helping decks that are already plenty strong without it and cementing the dominance of those decks within the upper tiers?


r/ModernMagic • • 4d ago

Article MTGO Modern Breakdown: Combo floods the Top 8s, Aggro steals the trophies, Amulet adopts Genesis Device

72 Upvotes

We all waitng to MTGO go back on-line so maybe you find some time to read my article!

Modern has a bit of a slow season, nothing big has happened regarding big tournaments in our favorite format, which isn't surprising since it's now a standard season. That doesn't mean players have abandoned Modern and it's boring. Now it's time to test new lists; Star Trek expansion has been released, and cards from it are already appearing in modern designs, so yes, people are testing, challenges are ongoing, so there's plenty to follow.

As usual, for everyone interested, here is an article with charts on Substack, and on the channel you can find a video with my analysis. On X, I try to post various interesting things several times a week, so if anyone feels like it, feel free to follow.

 

TL;DR

  • Combo 37 Top 8 lists, most of any archetype, 1 trophy
  • Aggro 5 of 13 trophies, after 1 in week 45
  • Moonshadow 3 trophies from 14 lists in Top 8, all Rakdos version
  • Prison 14 lists in Top 8 in 10 of 13 events, 1 trophy
  • Genesis Device (new Star Trek card) is tested by 8 Amulet Titan players
  • Midrange 9% of Chally meta, lowest of 12 weeks, 3 trophies
  • No deck or archetype change beyond normal variation

 

This week in numbers

  • 13 Modern Challenges, 403 Top 32 lists
  • participant coverage 65% (403 lists of 620 players)
  • 12 tracked decks, 0 changes beyond normal variation
  • 7 archetypes, 0 changes beyond normal variation
  • Rogue & unclassified 3%, −0.6 pp vs week 45
  • 10 different decks with a trophy, none above 3

Aggro

Aggro (archetype) | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 34% | Change vs last week: +4.2 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 32 | Trophies: 5 | Pilots: 81

 

And Aggro returns to the top of Modern and is again the most popular archetype of the format. Its share is almost 35% of the entire format. Quite a lot must be admitted; the archetype is quite granular, and its best deck is not the most popular deck in Modern.

 

Moonshadow

Moonshadow | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 10% | Change vs last week: +0.0 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 14 | Trophies: 3 | Pilots: 29

 

Moonshadow rebuilt its position somewhat after last week, where it didn't win any trophies; now it has three trophys. Moreover, the deck has the highest pilot dispersion in the entire format, with the best player accounting for only 7% of the lists. What does this tell us? Namely, despite its popularity and very scattered player base, the deck performs excellently. It's similar to Broodscale, where many different players played the deck, yet it still won. This contradicts the rule I observed earlier that a popular deck performs worse because many undertrained players play it. Moonshadow is easier to master than other decks in the format and is an exceptionally explosive deck, capable of closing games very quickly. Of course, it has weak points, but sometimes even a RiP played too late (and that might be the second OTD turn) doesn't guarantee a win. Moreover, the case with trophies shows something else: it's not worth worrying that the deck doesn't earn trophies in one week; it's just variance, not a weakness of the design. As you can see, a lot of a given deck in T8 challenges is a sign that the deck is strong. And all trophies were won by the most popular variant, Rakdos.

 

Card changes: none reported

 

Energy

Energy | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 8% | Change vs last week: +1.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 12/13 | Top 8 lists: 5 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 14

 

Energy jumped to second place in Aggro I currently has 8% of the finish; here we have two main variants, the dominant Boros and the more midrange Jeskai. This week Boros was better because all 5 lists in T8 belonged to this color combination.

 

Card changes: none reported

 

Affinity

Affinity | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 6% | Change vs last week: +1.7 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 12/13 | Top 8 lists: 10 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 14

 

This week, Robots are in third place, losing the popularity contest to Energy by 2 percentage points. However, Affinity won one trophy. The deck itself is also not uniform because we have several variants, but the variant with Emry dominates and put 10 lists to T8. Moreover, the deck is trying to adopt new cards from Star Trek. Will this bring the desired effect? We will find out in the coming weeks.

 

Card changes:

  • new this week: Blackcleave Cliffs, 2 pilots, 3 lists
  • new this week: Collation Trimatrix, 2 pilots, 3 lists

 

Prowess

Prowess | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 6% | Change vs last week: +1.2 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 12/13 | Top 8 lists: 3 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 19

 

Prowess lost in recent weeks on metagme, managed to introduce three lists to T8, and won one trophy. The reason for this is that the deck is more demanding and less aggressive than Moonshadow and loses direct duels to it. It's hard for me to predict how the deck will continue to develop, but one thing is certain: this build can still win Challenge and enter T8, though not as often as before.

 

Card changes: none reported

Combo

Combo (archetype) | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 31% | Change vs last week: −1.3 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 37 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 78

 

The combo drops to second place in terms of metagame positions; it's not a significant loss but still. What's more interesting is that this week the combo managed to win only one trophy. Similarly to Aggro, such a single event doesn't tell us much; it's more of a variance than a serious signal. If we observe this trend over the coming weeks, then yes, it might mean something, but for now, in my opinion, it's just a curiosity. And I would focus more on participation in T8 rather than trophies. If it doesn't change, the archetype or deck is doing very similarly.

 

Broodscale Combo

Broodscale Combo | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 12% | Change vs last week: −1.9 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 17 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 27

 

Combo is the second archetype of Modern, and Broodscale is his first deck. That hasn't changed for a long time, and I'm not surprised at all because the deck is very strong. Everyone is waiting for BnR, but does Broodscale really deserve a ban? Opinions are strongly divided; I try not to focus on that myself. Within the archetype, Broodscale won the only trophy. What's even more interesting is that in 7 weeks (since W39), Broodscale lost 10% of the meta share. This is not something you expect under an OP deck. During Boros Energy dominance, he maintained a much higher share and his sniffles were smaller than Broodscale.

 

Card changes: none reported

Amulet Titan

Amulet Titan | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 6% | Change vs last week: −1.1 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 11/13 | Top 8 lists: 6 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 14

 

The Titan Amulet is the second most popular Combo deck; it seems the Roiling Canopy buff had an effect, and the deck returns to the metagame after a brief absence caused by a lotus field ban. Moreover, in the latest set, something appeared that seems to strengthen the Amulet even more: the Genesis Device, which searches for land for three man, and also works like a Scapeshift but is uncontrollable? No wonder that more than half of the lists and half of the Amulet pilots are testing this card. The coming weeks will show whether it will be permanently included in the list or if it might just be an interesting experiment.

 

Card changes:

  • new this week: Genesis Device, 8 pilots, 13 lists

 

Ruby Storm

Ruby Storm | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 4% | Change vs last week: +0.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 11/13 | Top 8 lists: 4 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 10

 

This week, the favorite deck of the hero of our last interview, Hugo Freitas, did not win any trophy, but introduced four lists to the T8. Very typical for this build, the pilots of this deck are very focused; one-third of the letters belong to one pilot. I am very pleased that there are players and decks who have their loyal fans, and the format is not just a race for a trendier design.

 

Card changes: none reported

 

Control

Control (archetype) | Control | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 9% | Change vs last week: +2.0 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 15 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 21

 

Control does really well; it's the third archetype of modern and accounts for almost 10% of all decks included in the t32 challenge. However, remember that this archetype, unlike what we saw in the previous two, is actually one deck, or maybe one game strategy, meaning Prison.

 

Prison

Prison | Control | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 8% | Change vs last week: +0.9 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 14 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 16

 

Prison is currently the only significant strategy within controls; the deck is not pleasant to play against because no one likes not being able to attack or cast their spells. Unfortunately, in a combo-dominated format, it seems to be the best strategy. The deck is very focused; one-third of the decks are piloted by a single player. It's no surprise, control decks have always been specialist builds. Additionally, the deck started playing Fracturing Gust in sideboard, a very interesting strategy for Affinity. But it's hard for me to say if it's effective? Maybe someone here can say more in the comments?

 

Card changes:

  • new this week: Fracturing Gust (SB), 4 pilots, 5 lists

 

Midrange

Midrange (archetype) | Midrange | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 9% | Change vs last week: −2.1 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 6 | Trophies: 3 | Pilots: 21

 

My favorite archetype has been losing ground in recent weeks. It seems that Midrange is currently an archetype played by a few but successful finalists players; a drop from 20% (W36) to 9% (W46) is quite a lot.

 

 

Blink

Blink | Midrange | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 2% | Change vs last week: +0.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 7/13 | Top 8 lists: 2 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 7

 

Here's a surprise, because Blink hasn't appeared in rankings for some time due to a very low share in the meta, and now he's the biggest midrange deck, still 2% metagame, so it's not a lot. Interestingly, Blink introduced two decks into T8 and won one trophy. And here's another surprise: it's not the most popular variant Esper that wins the challenge, but his long-unseen brother Jeskai!

 

Card changes: none reported

Zoo

Zoo | Midrange | Weekly change: not tested | Share of Challenge Top 32: 2% | Change vs last week: +0.2 pp, not tested | Event presence: 6/13 | Top 8 lists: 2 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 3

 

My pet deck hasn't had a very good week, just two lists in the T8 challenge and only three pilots playing Zoo. This shows that Zoo is more of a deck played by a few regular players than something very popular. Overall, it is true for a long time now, it's only been interrupted by sprinkles of greater popularity when Zoo wins several times in a row in challenges or paper tournaments. Interestingly, this week the Zoo Frog version dominates, and one player experimented with cards like these: Assassin's Trophy, Consult the Star Charts, Prismari Charm, Questing Druid

 

Card changes: none reported

 

Graveyard

Graveyard (archetype) | Graveyard | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 9% | Change vs last week: +0.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 8 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 24

 

There are no major changes in grave-based decks, and as for many weeks, they are rather in the minority, although there is one surprise you will read about below.

 

Reanimator

Reanimator | Graveyard | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 4% | Change vs last week: +1.0 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 11/13 | Top 8 lists: 3 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 11

 

It's a promised surprise; I haven't seen a classic reanimator with Persist in a long time, and here you go, it jumps to the top spots in the GY archetype and introduces 3 lists into T8. Interestingly, this is not the result of a single player but rather several different pilots, and the deck is spread among different players. As of today, it's too much to talk about any significant growth, but the trend is going up, and if it continues, the situation will stop being a curiosity and become something to remember when preparing for the challenge.

 

Card changes: none reported

 

Ramp

Ramp (archetype) | Ramp | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 5% | Change vs last week: −2.5 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 9/13 | Top 8 lists: 4 | Trophies: 2 | Pilots: 12

 

Ramp is currently one deck, Tron. It has several builds, but a detailed description is below. Nevertheless, last week Ramp won two trophies, which is a very good result, especially considering that for T8 she introduced only four lists.

Tron

Tron | Ramp | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 5% | Change vs last week: −0.7 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 9/13 | Top 8 lists: 4 | Trophies: 2 | Pilots: 12

 

Tron is winning trophies very convincingly; in the last three weeks, he had 1 (W44), 2 (W45), and again two. The deck is not very popular in the metagame, but as you can see, it manages well in the hands of an experienced pilot. It also has several variants; the most popular is, of course, Eldrazi Tron, which accounts for almost 85% of all Tron lists in challenges, and this version wins trophies. The others are Mono Green and Mono Blue, but none qualified as T8.

 

Card changes: none reported

Card changes in decks outside the breakdown

  • Neobrand, new this week: Test of Courage (SB), 2 pilots, 2 lists
  • Vengevine and Birthing Ritual: new decks in the rules this week, older lists reassigned

On the Radar

  • Neobrand 14 lists vs 9 in week 45, not tested
  • Neobrand 4 Top 8 lists in 3 events, 11 pilots
  • Neobrand level: 2% in week 44, 3% in week 46
  • Belcher 8 lists, top pilot 38% of lists
  • Vengevine 4 lists, Birthing Ritual 3, both new in the rules

Trophy distribution, all 13

  • 3: Moonshadow
  • 2: Tron
  • 1: Broodscale Combo, Prison, Living End, Prowess, Affinity, Blink, Dimir Midrange, Mono-Black Midrange
  • archetypes: Aggro 5, Midrange 3, Ramp 2, Combo 1, Control 1, Graveyard 1
  • 10 different decks, none above 3

What changed in the data

  • DeckDB rules 37380967f3fb8a22 to c4310b586bc1a4d2
  • two new decks: Vengevine (Aggro), Birthing Ritual (Combo)
  • 317 of 24965 common lists with a changed deck
  • Rogue & unclassified to Birthing Ritual 294, Blink to Birthing Ritual 16
  • Rogue & unclassified to Vengevine 7; this week 4 Vengevine, 3 Birthing Ritual
  • Scryfall card data updated, cards of the newest set now recognised
  • week 45 recomputed on the new rules, all changes vs week 45

 

So all this week, as you can see, despite the slow season, something is happening, the metagame is changing, although I would call it more slight fluctuations than significant changes. New cards are appearing, people are testing them, checking new builds, so the situation looks as it should after the season ends: regeneration, new toys, and gathering strength before the next season. At this time, the most anticipated event is actually the announcement of BnR, which is less than two weeks away. What are your picks? How I'm still hoping for an un-ban Deathrite Shaman!

And as usual, if you reached the end of the text and liked it, you can buy me a coffe to support me. However, don't feel obligated to do that; my content will always be free, and I care that it only receives support if you truly appreciate it! If you prefer, you can also support me by liking my profile on YouTube or X! I would be equally grateful!

 

 

See you next week

 

Karol Małota

 

aka WarLord1986pl / TribalFlamesInYourFace


r/ModernMagic • • 3d ago

Modern Golgari Sacrifice: Update!

20 Upvotes

This is the first update to the original Golgari Sacrifice list I posted about 2 weeks ago.

Since I do not have a way to stream or capture footage of the deck I decided to donate to CntrlFreak and have him play it on stream:

Modern | Some People Get Value with Wight of the Reliquary, We Just Want to Go Aggro

I think this video shows off what this deck does great and some of the weaknesses it still has.

What were the weaknesses:

  • No plan B when graveyard hate is in the format.
  • Elvish Reclaimer not synergistic with our gameplan.
  • Life From the Loam "cute" , but not necessary.
  • Wight of the Reliquary was not used to his max potential.
  • Gravecrawler and Bloodghast had synergy with Flare of Malice, but is that good enough?

How do we address the weaknesses:

  • Urza's Saga is the biggest upgrade we can make to the deck.

    • It can be tutored with Wight.
    • It provides a plan B with constructs.
    • It can tutor other utility pieces.

+2 Urza's Sage , -2 Phyrexian Tower

  • Remove Elvish Reclaimer.

    • Easy way to find 2 more free spots in the deck.

+2 Hex Parasite, -2 Elvish Reclaimer.

  • Remove Gravecrawler.

    • Bloodghasts have tested better.
    • Cntrlfreak and others did not find value in this card.

+1 Shadowspear, +1 Nethergoyf , -2 Gravecrawler.

What stayed in the deck:

  • Bloodghast Stays!

    • The recursiveness of the bloodghasts works really well with Flare of Malice.
    • Most of my games with Domain Zoo go long and Bloodghast has gotten me over the finish line several times.
    • In my testing Bloodghast has proven itself.
  • Life From the Loam.

    • This has been great in games where we can really lean into our Safekeepers.
    • Sometimes we can mill a few extra cards and overrun with Dark Matter or Moonshadow.
    • Urza's Saga recursion?

Other issues / concerns:

  • What happens when everyone starts packing graveyard hate?

    • How did Delve / Hogaak survive when everyone was packing 4x Leylines in the mainboard?
    • We have green! Can't we can deal with enchantments!?

My main takeaways from looking at some other lists was we needed more enchantment hate. Looking at the side boarding for Hogaak, when it was legal in Modern, we see 5-6 pieces of enchantment removal. So, we added some Haywire Mites along with our existing Pick your Poison. This gives us 5 pieces of removal.

Here is the current list:

https://moxfield.com/decks/0eahAXVM13iH_jjsZkdWHQ

I think we have addressed alot of the weaknesses of the deck without making sweeping changes, which I am not a fan of.

From here I really want to test the power of Hex Parasite; it synergies with Moonshadow, Overlord, and can make our Urza's Saga stay on the battlefield forever. Right now, I'm thinking these 2 cards are going to have a tremendous impact on the decks performance.

Until next time!


r/ModernMagic • • 4d ago

Deck Discussion What's the Plan Here?

21 Upvotes

This deck has begun showing up on MTGO, and I don't know what to call it*.* It looks like it's combo-self-mill-into-Jace, but then there's Urza's Saga and ways to recur it. Does anyone know what the goal is?

I need to classify it for the next metagame update. While I don't fear committing to the bit, I don't want another Spike's Latest Mono-Green Thing on the Tier List. Nor do I want to do the MTGGoldfish thing of just naming it by its colors. Little help, please?

EDIT: Ok, it's Jace Cheri00s. Follow up question: Why only 1 Jace and not a Thassa's Oracle or two?


r/ModernMagic • • 5d ago

Mox Opal: Print them please, or ban them

276 Upvotes

Does a set of Mox Opals costing $1000 impact the amount of potential Modern players and create a substantial wall of cost around certain decks? Does it mean we see less artifact decks than we mgiht otherwise see if the card was $400 for a set, and thus the price is affecting the game itself?

Everyone that plays Modern regularly has to a certain degree adjusted to the price point. Mox Opal though, is an outlier in price and is far above the price of the rarest cards to the point that I assume even bought-in Modern players may avoid decks that use it.

Almost every deck that uses artifacts in volume, runs Mox Opal. Some decks are only competitive becuase of the speed Mox Opal provides them in rolling out their game plan.

Wizards could reprint these profitably selling packs of the set they are in, while also bringing down the price of this card allowing more players access to competitive Modern decks they like.

I am leaning toward the assumption that they are not reprinted at a volume that affects price becuase Wizards may ban them again and may not want to volume reprint a card they are considering banning.

Print Mox Opal down under $100 each or ban them please.


r/ModernMagic • • 4d ago

Amulet Titan: Genesis Device

38 Upvotes

Welcome back to my monthly series on Amulet Titan!

Decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/hscs-9KE9E2JCVBBxQhZbA

Last post I discussed Roiling Canopy's impact on the list, and it has significantly improved our capability of winning in a single turn. Since that post, most people have settled on one Canopy, one Yavimaya, and one Vesuva as enough to kill in most spots.

Turns out Canopy wasn't enough. Wizards printed Genesis Device for us, which acts as mid-game ramp and more copies of Scapeshift. I wanted the card to be good on release, but doubted its capability to compete in Modern. I 5-0ed within 2 hours of online release and placed 2nd in an 80-person challenge. The card is really good, and I'm not the only pilot that thinks so. So many people are putting up results that Amulet Titan is now 3rd on MTGGoldfish 30-day. Most lists are very similar to my initial list, which was supposed to be a first draft but just feels optimal at this point.

Link to my sideboard guide (now with Genesis Device): https://www.patreon.com/posts/175644316

Expanded thoughts:

  • To evaluate Genesis Device, compare it with Earthbender's Ascension in Standard Landfall. Ascension fetches a Forest out of your deck for 3 mana (slightly high-cost ramp), then provides much-needed trample and power in the late game. Device is very similar, but feels a little more Modern power level, since now Scapeshift is your late-game. The 5 mana activation compared to Scapeshift is negligible since Device fetched the extra mana already for you. Often the bottleneck for Scapeshift to be good is the quantity of lands on the field. Sometimes Device can be better than Scapeshift for this reason, even in fast-moving games. n+1 lands is a really big deal.
  • A glaring issue with Amulet Titan is that it's poor into Thoughtseize decks. Every piece does one thing, and you need to combine all of them. Device does TWO things (ramp, Shift) compacted into one single card. In this way it's comparable to how we used Stock Up in the past to combat Thoughtseize. Not only that, once it resolves you have a Scapeshift that can't be targeted with hand disruption.
  • Now for some downsides. Drawing multiple Devices feels terrible. This is the main reason I only play two. I have one in the sideboard for exceptionally grindy/interactive matchups where it would shine no matter how many I draw.
  • Device is too slow into the truly fast decks, like Ruby Storm and Neobrand. However against fair aggressive decks, perceived to be fast, I believe Device does a great job as a self-fueling Scapeshift. It actually provides speed into landing your Titan, despite seeming slow. Granted, this is excluding the possibility of it being your topdeck, where it would be terrible in that scenario.
  • Against Chant in particular, I want all copies. Lets you Scapeshift for Ba Sing Se through Orim's Chant.
  • Some deckbuilding changes need to be made:
  • We need 3 Forests so we don't run out of fetchables. To make space for Forest I cut from 8 to 7 bouncelands. 6 copies of Scapeshift doesn't play nicely with too many bouncelands anyway
  • Because I'm adding 2 3-drops to my list, having a turn 1 play is even more important. I added the 4th GSZ for this reason, to have 12 paths to 3 mana on turn 2 (Amulets, Grazers, GSZ for Dryad Arbor). My cut was a copy of Primeval Titan. A threat can replace a threat.
  • I added Aftermath Analyst to the sideboard. I still detest naturally drawing the card, but the upside of that effect is unquestionable in a list with 6 Scapeshifts, one more in the side.
  • Woodland did not make the cut. I've worked through all of the infinite and repeatable lines and they require these wild conditions that make me think they're just winmore.

That's all I have! If you enjoyed, here are my socials:
https://x.com/reid_stradling

https://www.youtube.com/@reidq7

https://www.twitch.tv/reidq7

(Also grab the sideboard guide. Even if you don't follow it to a T, it will give you significant insight on how to sideboard in a more streamlined way)


r/ModernMagic • • 4d ago

Deck Discussion First Deck in Magic the Gathering Query

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm pretty new to Magic and have only been playing for around 1–2 months. I've played in about 2–3 FNMs at my LGS and have also been playing Commander using my friends' decks.

I've realized that I really enjoy 60-card Magic, and I'm interested in getting into Modern rather than Standard due to it being more stable in value. I've been researching the format, deck choices, and ban cycles, but obviously I don't have much firsthand experience yet.

I'm currently looking at Eldrazi Broodscale Combo and Rakdos/Moon Shadow Aggro, but with the November 30 ban announcement coming up, I'm wondering if it would be better to wait before buying into either deck.

When I say I'm concerned about "value," I don't mean that I'm trying to invest in or flip Magic cards. I'm spending my hard-earned money on the hobby, so I'd simply like to get as much long-term play and enjoyment out of my purchases as possible

.
Would you recommend buying into either deck before the announcement, or waiting until after the bans before committing?

I'd really appreciate any advice or meta deck suggestions from experienced Modern players. Thank you!


r/ModernMagic • • 4d ago

Primal Prayers Discord?

4 Upvotes

Been having a lot of fun playing simic Primal Prayers combo, running a similar list to this one Spike had a month ago

https://moxfield.com/decks/-lR8-ftLl0Kcig58x1hK9A

Is there a discord? Tried looking in the directory and couldn't find anything.

If not, any other primal prayers truthers out there who would like to start a discord and cook up? Such a fun combo deck w mad cool lines


r/ModernMagic • • 5d ago

Brew First time getting into modern. What does my list need?

8 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/wmMq_0xySUOOJImnwEmMxw

Never had a modern deck before, just borrowed decks once in a while. Simic ritual is my favourite deck gameplay-wise, and I appreciate the budget, so this bant build with more hate pieces is very appealing to me. However I'm not totally sure how I should finalize it due to unfamiliarity with the meta... any tips?

I will be playing at an LGS, I'm only using lands I already own (that's why they're all islands except hall rn), and I'm trying to keep the budget pretty low.


r/ModernMagic • • 4d ago

First Deck in Magic the Gathering Query

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ModernMagic • • 5d ago

Deck Discussion Infect-a-Deck - 2026 uplift help wanted

3 Upvotes

Hey party people, you all were awesome in helping me before with my insanity of a burn deck with dwarves and I’m now a regular on a modern Monday (about 20+yrs removed from playing)

Help me make the most wu-tang and brutal infect deck that will absolutely irritate my playgroup - all awesome humans but they are playing with $1kUSD decks and I show up with sub-$100 and give them a good run every week. I’ve had about 9-10 games with the deck as is (I know I want the other moth just trying to source it and not get robbed) but also lets ad some flavor and fun - appreciate all of you and am really enjoying the game outside of prerelease and draft as a consistent thing to do. Cheers and thank you 🙏.

https://manabox.app/decks/AaEVYaB2dkCg4hAjcyN9qg


r/ModernMagic • • 5d ago

Deck Discussion Hardest deck to pilot in Modern

32 Upvotes

I often see posts in here with new Modern players asking about the easiest deck to pick up and that sort of thing, but after watching my friend throw lines all weekend playing Amulet Titan, I figured I'd pose the question.

Is Titan truly the most convoluted deck to win with, or is there something even weirder out there either from Modern's past or in the meta rn?


r/ModernMagic • • 5d ago

Deck Discussion ATLANTA MODERN CUP TOP 8

24 Upvotes

This last weekend, I made Top 8 of the MagicCon Modern Cup with Jeskai Ascendancy, going undefeated in the Swiss, and eventually losing to a good Zoo player. I was wondering if anyone had the full deck lists from the event. Thanks!


r/ModernMagic • • 6d ago

5-0 Trophy stream with Rakdos Delirium

10 Upvotes

r/ModernMagic • • 5d ago

UW chant should probably eat a ban too.

0 Upvotes

Conventional wisdom is that "an" eldrazi card will be banned on Nov. 30th. I think WOTC should hit chant too.

  • The deck is both good and well-positioned.
  • The deck is frustrating to play against because so much of its strength is due to how many chant/silence effects you draw.
  • The lock(s) is/are too easy to assemble (playing teferi with chant backup & narset + day's).

Personally, the cards to look at are 3feri, chant and solitude.

Obviously, not saying things will be banned but just this once WOTC, don't let me down!


r/ModernMagic • • 6d ago

Card Discussion Retract in Affinity Lists?

0 Upvotes

Can someone explain to me why in these affinity lists with Kappa Cannoneer, Pinnacle Emissary, and tons of 0 drop artifacts why they don't play a Retract or even Hurkyl's Recall to pull up and drop a ton of artifacts again for a giant Kappa or Pinnacle swing? I'm thinking just as a 1 or 2 of, as it could also be a good response to any number of destroy a bunch of artifacts cards. Just curious if anyone has toyed around with it recently?


r/ModernMagic • • 7d ago

Deck Discussion Getting back into Modern. What's still viable / easy to upgrade?

23 Upvotes

used to play a lot of modern, in recent years switched to mostly EDH or Duel Commander. Are any of my old decks still viable, or can I upgrade them without spending a fortune?

I do have all the fetch lands etc. and my decks have the staples from 3 to 5 years ago. From recent sets I do not have that much besides a bundle here and there (Hobbit, Lorwyn Eclipsed) and random cards from some drafts I did at MagicCon earlier this year.

My decks, all unchanged since 2023 or earlier;

  • Dredge
  • Hardened scales
  • Blue Green infect
  • Death's Shadow (Jund)
  • Red Green Valakut/Wrenn & Six
  • Mono white Stoneforge mystic, Phelia
  • UrzaTron blue green control

Which of these are still oke to play or can be renewed without spending hundreds? Thanks!