r/ReefTank • • 5d ago

No judgment questions zone - November 16, 2026

1 Upvotes

Here is the place to post questions about pest ID, coral/fish ID, your cycle, or any other questions that generally wouldn't start up a conversation. If you have an interesting or unique question please create a new thread so everyone can discuss it in length!

Pest ID guide

BRS pest guide

BRS beginner resources

BRS 52 weeks of reefing YouTube series


r/ReefTank • • 19h ago

[Pic] I sculpted and painted a blue green chromis!

Post image
337 Upvotes

One of my faves back when I had a reef tank going. Painted with acrylic gouache and mounted on slate.


r/ReefTank • • 22h ago

Let’s see some old tanks, 22 yrs this month

237 Upvotes

Cletus (Red sea sailfin) is 21 yrs old. I still love my slice of the sea


r/ReefTank • • 16h ago

Caulerpa Forest

56 Upvotes

r/ReefTank • • 10h ago

[Pic] emerald crab dabbing

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/ReefTank • • 13h ago

[Pic] Reaching out...

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/ReefTank • • 7h ago

Sump Tour/additional biological filtration.

7 Upvotes

I was running chaeto but wasn’t really happy with the results, so I decided to switch things up and add a 1-gallon bucket of Seachem Matrix instead.

I understand that chaeto and Matrix serve two completely different purposes, but increasing the available surface area for beneficial bacteria was something my system needed.
Also, check out how well-tuned my protein skimmer is! 👌

Amazon

1 gallon of Seachem Matrix $38.73

https://a.co/d/03Y8OnuE

Pool skimmer basket with handle $21.99 for 2

https://a.co/d/041rGU2V

Btw the matrix fills both baskets perfectly! Also that is a Gyre I also got from amazon.


r/ReefTank • • 8h ago

upgrading from a redsea 525 - need help with the art of the possible

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

We currently have a mixed reef in a Red Sea G1 525 and have the opportunity to upgrade and design a dedicated space in our house for a new tank. Since we’re starting with a blank slate, we really want to explore the "art of the possible" - whether that’s automation, unique livestock setups, custom plumbing/fish room hacks, or outside-the-box concepts we haven't even thought of yet (seeing Danny’s Aquariums and his planted reef tank on YouTube really got us thinking about what else is possible outside the norm in this hobby). Nothing is off the table, and we’d love to hear your ideas or the things you wish you had done when setting up your own dream build.

Here is a breakdown of our current setup (along with a few pictures showing how the tank has evolved over the years), followed by a few specific questions:

Corals: Torches, hammers, plates, acros, digis, pectinias, cyphastrea, montis, gonis, and a few others mixed in. We try to prioritize a good variety of species and colors.

Fish: Yellow tang, purple tang, four clownfish, a couple of damsels, a couple of blennies, a six-line wrasse, a royal gramma, and a handful of others.

Other Livestock: Plenty of inverts and a rainbow bubble tip anemone that keeps splitting.

Sump: ReefMat in chamber 1; refugium (not much chaeto thriving in there right now) in chamber 2; protein skimmer, UV, and GFO in chamber 3; return pump and dosing in chamber 4.

Water: Aquatic Life RODI + water saver kit (considering removing the water saver kit and adding a booster pump) feeding two 40-gallon containers in our mixing station.

Controller/Testing: Neptune Apex + Trident + Trident NP.

Tank Recommendations: We’re open to suggestions on the new tank itself - what would you go with if you were building out a dedicated space? Our house isn't huge, so we can't put in a shark tank, but we're open to stepping up in size from the 525.

Vermetid Snails: We’ve been fighting a bad vermetid snail infestation. We really don’t want to abandon the live rock we already have - are we stuck living with them in the new tank too, or is there a way to eradicate them during the transfer?

The "Art of the Possible": Beyond standard equipment, what are your favorite creative upgrades, fish room layouts, or automation tricks that made the biggest difference in how you run your tank?


r/ReefTank • • 2h ago

[Pic] Is this coraline algae?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Is this coraline algae?


r/ReefTank • • 18h ago

Micromussa that *everyone* online told me was dead has begun regrowing it’s skeleton 2 months after polyp bailout

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

The internet has exhausted me with all of its overconfident knowledge coming from users with no credentials.

Last photo shows the polyp bail out. Why did it bail out? Hydrogen peroxide bath to remove pest. Hard lesson learned even if forums or other places online have established this as an “ok” pest removal method for micromussa if the duration of the dip is minimal.

I’m 1.5 years into the hobby, and it feels like I cannot trust a single person for advice... especially considering each tank is it’s own individual ecosystem with varying parameters. At this point, I’ll be winging it and learning hard lessons from my own trial & error.


r/ReefTank • • 9h ago

[Pic] Tidepool Tank? 🤔

Post image
3 Upvotes

I've seen some of you pull off real low tech tanks and frankly, my most successful tank was my tiny pico so I definitely believe smaller is better. I've also heard of many "reef jars," so tell me why I wouldn't be able to pull off a tank using this, some hardy corals/inverts, and do daily 50% water changes. Lighting and heating are easy, and daily water changes should totally resolve nutrient buildup (plus I can add some chaeto) but how well do tidepool species (acros, montis, or even palythoas) do in stagnant water? Should I gradually lower the water level or even leave them above water level for short periods to replicate natural conditions?


r/ReefTank • • 1d ago

Started a saltwater tank.

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

It's Redsea shell 2, a 40l tank, the company is Orca I think. Found some coral bone?; Looking thing as hardscape for cheap. Light is Optimus reef nano 2.

How's it ? Considering keeping a clownfish, a yellow goby and a firefish


r/ReefTank • • 18h ago

Coral ID, Question on stars, Hi from Antenna Goby

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Good afternoon, I was given a couple of rocks with small frags on them and they have grown and do great in my tank! So first what would these be called? I have never been able to keep coral staying alive, in fact I've tried GSP, Xenia, and Kenya Tree and killed those off. I'd like a few varieties of coral, any suggestions that would keep like these two? BioCube 32 with stock lid.

Second, what gets rid of these star fish? I pick them out and net them out, they're not awful, but if there was something that would maintain them, I'd be open to it.

Third, just a Hi from my Antenna Goby. I tried waiting for his shrimp friend to come out for a photo, but he was bashful. I really love just watching those two, all the work the shrimp does and just the Goby standing by.

Thanks All!


r/ReefTank • • 17h ago

Too much flow?

10 Upvotes

Is this too much flow on my purple pulsing xenia?


r/ReefTank • • 12h ago

[Pic] Smoosh them or no

Post image
3 Upvotes

Anyone know what these things on my snail are and if I need to remove them or not?


r/ReefTank • • 9h ago

Banggai Cardinal Aggression

2 Upvotes

I recently moved my main set up to a larger tank. I started off with a 20gal. I had a pair of clowns, a pair of banggai, a bi color blenny, a C.U.C crew and an assortment of ment of corals.
I recently moved up to a 40 gal breeder, while the 40 was getting set up I added a fire fish and a dwarf flame angel.

The Issue started after I merged all the inhabitants of the 20 gal into the new 40. The first few nights were great everyone was getting along. Today I noticed the bigger of the two banggai’s was darting around the tank chasing the much smaller one. I figured it was a mating thing since I don’t know how to sex a fish. Then later that same day, I noticed he was chasing my fire fish around. After observing them for 30mins, it seems like the banggai only chases the fire fish and other banggai. When it was in the 20 gal I never observed and darting around or chasing.

Now I’m left wondering, is it because of the bigger tank or because of the new inhabitants?
Has anyone ever had this issue before?


r/ReefTank • • 17h ago

New 140 gallon set up advice

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I’ve been in the reefing hobby for a little over a year now with my 30-gallon reef tank. I’ve had a great experience so far and have been keeping mostly soft corals, a few SPS corals, anemones, and fish.
I’m currently having a custom 100-gallon display tank built, along with a 40-gallon sump. Since this is my first larger reef system, I’d love to hear advice from more experienced reef keepers on anything I should consider, change, or avoid before getting everything set up.

My goal is to build a mixed reef with soft corals, LPS, and SPS, eventually focusing more on SPS as the tank matures. I want to do things properly from the beginning rather than having to replace or upgrade equipment down the road.

Tank Specifications

Display: 54” L × 22” W × 22” H
Sump: 40 gallons
Bracing: Euro-braced along the front and sides, with the back left open to accommodate lighting mounts
Overflow: Three holes drilled through the bottom of the tank
Main drain: 1” PVC with a gate valve
Emergency drain: 1” PVC
Return line: ¾” PVC with a ball valve

Equipment I’ve Already Purchased

2 × EHEIM 200W heaters
Inkbird temperature controller
Bubble Magus Curve 7 Elite protein skimmer
Sicce Syncra ADV 5.5 return pump
40 lbs of Marco dry rock
Approximately 30 lbs of established rock from my current reef tank

Equipment I Plan on Purchasing

2 × AI Prime 16HD reef lights
AI Nero 5

Ive added photos of my current tank, sump with equipment and rock work I am working on by carving and adding more branching rocks.

Any advice or recommendations will be greatly appreciated.


r/ReefTank • • 8h ago

Next step for neglected saltwater tank?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/ReefTank • • 17h ago

Can't decide where to put everything

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I have a bunch of corals I can't decide where to put, and I'm paralyzed. My LFS helped me set up the rockwork originally, but it feels like there aren't enough places for everything. Between flow and lighting requirements plus the fact that some of them sting, I just don't know what to do.

How did you decide where to put everything?


r/ReefTank • • 16h ago

SPS/Acro Pictures!

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am looking for a new hobby and have been intrigued by so many videos and pictures of established tanks. One thing I've noticed, is a lot of this is all with camera filters and light changes during the recording. I say sps because when i look at the high end websites, most of them have a pretty large amount of photoshop adjusting the color outputs.

Is anyone willing to show off some SPS and any other beautful coral without using filters, and try and display them as you see with your own eyes?


r/ReefTank • • 16h ago

Hitchhiker ID! I think it's a brittle star? Found on the bottom of a new frag :)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
2 Upvotes

r/ReefTank • • 17h ago

ID Help

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I just noticed this thing in the back of the tank. Kinds squishy, but has a solid outside like a balloon. Hasn’t moved since I noticed it last week. Tank is about 200 days old, started from dry rock.


r/ReefTank • • 1d ago

RIP Hewbie

28 Upvotes

Hewbie passed away! This is not the update I wanted to make but he decompensated super quickly. I was with him as he crossed the rainbow bridge. It brings me comfort knowing how well loved he was and that he got the best vet care and had an amazing home. He was my little celebrity online and among people I knew. I watched him grow up from a small baby puffer and thrive. I know I gave him the best life and went above and beyond so it brings me comfort. I will be getting a necropsy done to give me some more answers and closure. Thank you all for loving him and interacting with my posts online and caring deeply about my updates and him.


r/ReefTank • • 20h ago

sea sponge?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

is this web looking/ slime mold thing growing on this torch skeleton a sea sponge or something else?