r/Stoicism • • 20d ago

Announcements Welcome! Read Me First.

16 Upvotes

Welcome to r/Stoicism.

This community exists for serious discussion of Stoic philosophy. It is not a forum for general self-help, motivation, validation, or professional therapy. It is also not a platform for promoting your content, your app, your channel, or yourself.

  1. Read the ancient texts. That's the baseline.
  2. Search before posting. Your question has probably been discussed.
  3. Show your thinking. Don't ask us to do the philosophical work for you.
  4. Ground your claims in sources.
  5. This is a discussion forum, not a generic advice dispensary or a content feed.
  6. Participate in existing conversations before posting your own.

Welcome. We're glad you're here. Please keep reading.

 

Community Mechanics

  • Karma threshold. New accounts and users without participation history in r/Stoicism may have posts automatically filtered. This reduces spam and low-effort content. Participate in existing discussions first, by commenting thoughtfully on others' posts, and this restriction lifts naturally.
  • Flair restriction on advice threads. Posts flaired as "Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance" have a special rule, by which only users with Contributor or Scholar flair can provide top-level responses. This protects advice-seekers from guidance that misrepresents Stoic philosophy. Anyone can reply to flaired comments. To apply for Contributor flair, see the application guidelines for details.
  • Text-based discussion only. No videos, no images (except for scholarly purposes), no memes. Summarize key arguments in writing and link sources as references.
  • No AI-generated content. Stoic philosophy is a practice of your own reasoning. Posts and comments deemed overly reliant on AI output may be removed. If you use AI tools for research, the interpretation, argument, and words must be genuinely yours, and you must be able to defend them if questioned.

What Stoicism Is (and Isn't)

Stoicism is an ancient Greek philosophy with a systematic doctrine covering logic, physics (the study of nature and the cosmos), and ethics. Its central ethical claim is that virtue is the sole good, and that external circumstances (such as wealth, health, reputation, even death) are "indifferents." Stoic practice involves training your faculty of judgment to distinguish what is truly up to you (your reasoning, your choices, your assent to impressions) from what is not.

Stoicism is not "being tough" or suppressing emotions, a productivity system, "just focusing on what you can control."

If your only exposure to Stoicism is through social media quotes or YouTube videos, you've encountered a simplified version. We encourage you to engage with the actual texts. We encourage you to engage with this community in collective pursuit and refinement of Stoic study and practice; that's what this community is for.

For an accessible short introduction, see Donald Robertson's Simplified Modern Approach, Big Think's interview with Prof. Massimo Pigliucci on YouTube, or Stoic scholar John Sellars' Lessons in Stoicism.

For a thorough introduction, see our FAQ. For encyclopedic overviews, see the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, or the Routledge Encyclopedia.

READING QUOTES IS NOT THE SAME AS PRACTICING PHILOSOPHY

Many people arrive here by way of a Stoic quote pointing toward a better way of thinking. Quotes can be wonderful entry points to the practice of philosophy.

A quote gives you the conclusion of someone else's reasoning. But philosophical engagement involves doing the work to work out your own reasoning, rather than simply acquiescing to a conclusion. Reading "you have power over your mind, not outside events" and nodding along is about as transformative as watching a video of someone else doing pushups. Nothing in you has changed. Stacking up maxims does not move you forward.

To work with a text philosophically, you take a passage, work out what it actually claims, check that claim against the rest of the system, and then hold it up against your own opinions to find where you disagree and why. And that is still only the initial analytical part, because a conclusion you have arrived at through reasoning is not yet one you live by. To get there means working deliberately to apply it in relevant moments, again and again, until your judgments run that way by default. The vigilant attention this demands of you is prosoche, defined below.

One of our contributors recently wrote an excellent piece on this, working through a passage from Epictetus' Enchiridion 13 to show what active engagement with a text looks like.

ESSENTIAL CONCEPTS FOR THOSE NEW TO THE PHILOSOPHY

These form the backbone of Stoic ethics. Understanding them will help you participate meaningfully.

  • prohairesis — Your faculty of rational choice and judgment; the seat of moral character and the one thing truly up to you.
  • impressions and assent — External events give rise to impressions (phantasiai): appearances to the mind about what is happening. Oftentimes they arise with an evaluation already built in, supplied by our own prior judgments and dispositions. Your work as a practitioner is to examine these impressions before accepting them, testing whether what appears true actually is and whether you're treating indifferent things as good or bad. This examination is the seat of Stoic practice. The evaluation can often be observed within a single word: "My boss humiliated me in front of the whole team." (event and evaluation combined) "My boss pointed out errors in my report during a team meeting. I'm the one who added 'humiliation.'" (event and evaluation separated) Most of what this community does, in terms of analyzing situations and correcting misjudgments, comes back to this mechanism. See Epictetus' Discourses 2.18 on pausing an impression to test it before it takes you wherever it wants. See also Meditations 8.49, where Marcus separates hearing a report (that someone spoke badly about you) from what he adds (that he has been harmed).
  • virtue as the sole good — Wisdom, justice, courage, and moderation are the only things genuinely good. Vice is the only genuine evil. Everything else is an indifferent.
  • preferred and dispreferred indifferents — Health, wealth, reputation are "preferred" but not good. Disease, poverty, disgrace are "dispreferred" but not bad. Your virtue is not determined by which indifferents you happen to have.
  • oikeiosis — The Stoic theory of natural affinity, extending from self-concern outward to family, community, and all rational beings. The foundation of Stoic social ethics.
  • prosoche — Vigilant attention, sometimes called "Stoic mindfulness." The ongoing practice of watching your own judgments and catching yourself before assenting to false impressions.

For deeper reading, see our FAQ and wiki.

Before You Post

ALREADY-ANSWERED QUESTIONS

These come up constantly and have been addressed thoroughly.

  • "What books should I read?" See our reading list for a carefully sequenced guide. If you want the short version: start with Epictetus (Discourses, Hard translation), then Seneca's essays (Hardship and Happiness), then Cicero (On Obligations), then Marcus Aurelius (Meditations, Waterfield translation), then Seneca's Letters. Read the ancient sources before the modern interpreters. The reading list explains why this order matters.
  • "What do you think about Ryan Holiday?" Search the subreddit as this has been discussed extensively. Popular authors can be a useful entry point, but this community prioritizes classical sources. If your understanding of Stoicism comes entirely from modern interpreters, you're missing critical aspects of the philosophy.
  • "How can Stoicism help my problem?" This question is addressed at length in our FAQ section on advice. Stoicism is not a set of instructions for specific life situations. It trains your faculty of judgment so you can reason through situations yourself.
  • "Do Stoics suppress emotions?" No. See our FAQ section on misconceptions. The Stoics distinguished between pathē (passions arising from false judgments) and natural emotional responses, including involuntary reactions like flinching, grief, or a sinking feeling, which the Stoics called "first movements" (propatheiai) and considered entirely natural and not within our control. The goal is correct judgment rather than emotional numbness.

For more previously discussed topics, see our frequently discussed topics page, which links to high-quality past threads on common subjects.

HOW TO ASK A GOOD QUESTION

This is a discussion community. We foster dialogue grounded in philosophy and not quick-hit advice dispensing. Don't copy-paste a description of your life situation and append "what would a Stoic do?" That's asking strangers to do the philosophical work for you.

Instead, show that you've done some thinking. What Stoic concepts or passages have you considered? Where specifically are you stuck applying them? What judgments are you making about your situation, and which ones are you questioning?

The following is an example of a good "Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance" post:

"I read Enchiridion 5 about being disturbed by our opinions of things, and I understand it intellectually, but I keep treating my job loss as genuinely bad. How do others work through this gap between understanding the theory and putting it to practice?"

The following is not, because it lacks philosophical engagement:

"I lost my job. What would a Stoic do?"

WHAT GETS REMOVED

  • Generic self-help content. If your post could appear identically in r/GetMotivated with no changes, it doesn't belong here. We require engagement with Stoic philosophy specifically.
  • Quote-dropping. A Marcus Aurelius quote with no citation, no interpretation, and no discussion prompt violates Rule 4. Quote posts require: (1) full citation (author, work, chapter/section, translator), (2) your interpretation, and (3) a point for discussion. The reasoning behind this requirement is explained under 'Reading quotes is not the same as practicing philosophy' below.
  • Misattributed quotes. Many viral "Stoic quotes" are modern fabrications. Verify before posting.
  • Videos, images, and memes. Summarize key arguments in writing and link sources as references. See Rule 6.
  • Engagement farming. Posts designed to generate engagement rather than to pursue genuine philosophical inquiry (eg: vague provocative questions, polls with no philosophical substance, hot takes that invite argument rather than discussion) are removed. Accounts that show a pattern of this behavior across subreddits are banned.
  • Self-promotion and content marketing. See next section.

THIS IS A DISCUSSION FORUM, NOT A PLATFORM

r/Stoicism is not a place to build your audience, drive traffic, or promote a product. This applies regardless of whether you think your content "helps people."

  • All self-promotion belongs in the weekly Agora thread. This includes blogs, YouTube channels, podcasts, newsletters, courses, coaching services, books, and apps. No exceptions.
  • Chatbot output, "Stoic AI" tools, and similar projects are not welcome as posts. We don't care that you trained a Marcus Aurelius simulator. Stoic philosophy is a practice of human reasoning and judgment. An AI that pattern-matches Stoic-sounding language is not Stoic practice, and promoting one here is self-promotion regardless of whether you charge for it.
  • Implicit self-promotion is still self-promotion. If your post is functionally an advertisement (ie: if the point is to drive people to your profile, your links, your project, or your platform) it will be removed. "Check out my profile for more" or similar language pointing users toward your external content is treated the same as a direct link. We've seen every variation of this. Don't be coy about it.
  • We ban engagement farmers. If your account shows a pattern of posting low-effort, high-engagement content across multiple subreddits to farm karma or followers, you will be permanently banned on sight. This is not a gray area.

If you have genuinely non-commercial work that you believe offers significant value and want to share it outside the Agora, message the moderators first.  

Community Resources

Getting started:

Learning from the community:

Participating:


r/Stoicism • • 11h ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

Pending Theory Flair Guys im struggling with the determinist aspect of Stoicism

26 Upvotes

Ive been reading that hard determinism is mostly dead now thanks to quantum mechanics and so now the scientific consensus is leaning towards "probabilistic determinism" wherein the future can only be predicted in broad probabilistic terms.

The virtue of wisdom (to me at least) would encourage us to adopt the modern scientific interpretation of physics. Stoic physics was great for its time but we have advanced 2000 years since then.

So where does this leave Stoicism? Does probabilistic determinism still work with the concept of the Logos? I always interpreted it as more of a hard determinist concept.

Help?


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

6 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

New to Stoicism What made you adopt stoicism? Can stoicism help with what I am looking for?

9 Upvotes

Hi experts, new to this sub and fairly new to stoicism.

I am going through some life transitions. Dealing with it all like a champ, incredibly proud :) But there are times when I wish I could talk to someone about some difficult experience, after I already handled it well and after it already happened. I am noticing that people aren't really available to chat with when needed - not complaining, just stating facts. This adds to loneliness.

Today someone I tried talking to suggested I should start therapy lol - after they reassured me two days back that I am not imposing by texting them. I don't even text that much, I just did today coz we were chatting about something sensitive. When I said I already have a therapist, and they think I am doing everything one can do, this person suggested I find a better therapist lmao.

What I am looking for: It made me think, and I no longer want to have the need to talk to someone after a particularly difficult experience is over. I am considering turning to stoicism to achieve this. Could you please let me know if this is something Stoicism can help with? Thank you!


r/Stoicism • • 2d ago

Stoicism in Practice LRB | Dying, or Doing Something Else Lydia Davis on Marcus Aurelius and Other Stoics

Thumbnail
lrb.co.uk
20 Upvotes

r/Stoicism • • 2d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance The difficulty of accepting failure.

20 Upvotes

Normally accepting failure is difficult because we sometimes dont want to admit we failed, comes from a place of ego.

But for me, i find it difficult to accept failure because i feel like im “ getting away with it “ if i immediately forgive myself.

For a little context, i have a stutter, and i was afraid of asking someone how many sets they had. In the gym.

Ive dealt with this before, i already know my mind is just being fed a handfull of false perceptions in that moment. I know there is no actual harm that could happen. Even if for some reason the whole gym started laughing at me, this still doesnt actually harm me in any way.

So i had no excuse to not go and ask, but i didnt. I somehow slid myself out of the situation.

Now, i know the correct next step would be to instantly forgive myself and keep moving. To not let this take any more of my time. And a bunch of other logical and philosophical reasons you could think of. But i cant fully move on.

Yet again, its like my soul doesnt trust my brain when it tells it its okay.

I feel, if i dont suffer for this that i cant move on. Because ill just feel like im getting away with failure.

This is the one thing i dont understand about us humans. How can we know something, yet still fail to believe it? How can i know nothing bad will happen if i ask that dude his set count, yet i still feel fear?

( also, i believe what im doing, not accepting failure because i feel like i dont deserve it, is also coming from a place of ego. )


r/Stoicism • • 2d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

6 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 2d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Worried I might've messed up my future

10 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm pretty new here.

I've known about stoicism for a long time now, but never really spent a ton of effort practicing it. I haven't studied any texts, I just watched a few youtube videos (video essays, not the ai slop) years ago and tried incorporating a few beliefs in my daily life whenever I saw the opportunity. I have a lot of things I'm grateful for, and while my life isn't perfect I was content with the bare minimum philosophy needed to keep me happy.

Recently I've been faced with my greatest obstacle yet. Long story short, I made a bad decision and I'm in trouble with my university. I thought I was doing the right thing but in hindsight it was wrong and doesn't help anyone. I've been temporarily suspended and I'm worried I've jeopardized my future. While I still have hope that it'll be resolved quickly, in the worst case scenario that it takes a long time to resolve, I won't be able to take my finals for the semester. I would have to retake all my current classes, become a semester behind, and would graduate late with an extra 18k of debt.

I've been trying to stay calm and composed, telling myself things like even if that somehow happens, I'll still have my whole life ahead of me and I could be far worse off. But despite my best efforts I'm still quite nervous about the uncertainty of the situation and my heart rate has been a little faster today.

I can't undo my actions, but a stoic would use this as an opportunity for growth which is what I would like to do. Do any stoics out there have any advice, whether its for my situation or any relevant texts I could study? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

Stoicism in Practice How to stop being so hard on yourself

13 Upvotes

So, dealing with humans is going to be slightly different every time. It's hard to predict in advance how to handle everything. Even though I understand human rudeness, it often takes me by surprise because it's not how I choose to treat others and unprovoked childish behavior just makes you look bad.

Whenever I handle something, even if I can say it was assertive or a reasonable reaction in the moment. I always beat myself up later that I didn't handle it 'better'. I should have had a stronger reaction, I should have been firmer, I was too nice when this person didn't deserve it. I let an 'injustice' slide and thus I allowed such things to perpetuate in the world. I have a strong personal responsibility for my actions and so if I fall short of an ideal, I treat it as a total failure. On the other hand, if I was too aggressive/harsh I would probably be beating myself up for being too much of a jerk if I decided later, it was unwarranted.

This happens too often. ...I suppose I'm seeking some tangible proof that the ideology of my identity isn't false. I am who I believe myself to be and my actions back that up. What stance does stoicism take on personal identity as it relates to expression of. I tend to believe intentions define a person more than actions. Yet your choices are more often reflected in your actions and people often struggle to see themselves objectively.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance How to deal with people who don't respect me or who are unfair?

37 Upvotes

How do I protect myself against people disrespecting me or being unfair without becoming resentful and misanthropic. I also tend to be very avoidant and just push away those who are doing those things to me and that include my girlfriend and close family.

The issue is that most people end up doing something I dislike. Appart from a handful of people I have a hard time creating the connection and I feel very lonely.

I know Aurelius talk a little bit about that subject.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

Analyzing Texts & Quotes Quotes you live by?

61 Upvotes

Quotes and reminders you live by and are reminded of everyday especially when going through harder times


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

Stoicism in Practice Doing good and virtuous work

6 Upvotes

I've been reading and applying stoic philosophy for a couple of years. One of the biggest things that has helped change my life is understanding the cardinal virtues, and trying to live virtuously and and in agreement with nature.

My values and nature lean very humanistic and towards sensitivity and creativity. I also have a reasonably strong sense of justice and am civically-minded and desire a lot of societal change to be more just, inclusive, humane, and sustainable.

I currently work in the corporate world (in Canada), and I'm very unhappy with my work due to the exploitative nature of the industry I work in, and also because I'm being discriminated against at work in subtle and unsubtle ways. Every day is a challenge which this philosophy very much helps me navigate through.

My central question or point of discussion is around why it seems so difficult to do work that is virtuous and in line with my values (I think there's a lot of overlap there) and would be compensated enough to live comfortably. To me, coming from a working-class background, that's just being able to pay all bills and rent/mortgage etc, and being able to take my spouse and I out on dates from time to time, and take a vacation every couple of years.

It has been incredibly difficult for me to pivot my career path. It seems genuinely near-impossible to do. I do volunteer and that gives me a lot of purpose and loving connection and community, but I'm very drained from the work and people I currently am around in my professional life.

Why is finding and doing good and virtuous work that pays enough so hard?

What do you think? All perspectives are appreciated. Thank you


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

Stoicism in Practice Dear Senaca, I've received your fifth letter...

5 Upvotes

"Inwardly everything should be different"

I want to ensure you that I too, hope that I can make myself daily a better man. As you mention, not to satisfy a craving for attention, but rather for my own improvement. It is my hope to continue reading your letters often and thoroughly, and that by putting them into immediate practice, I might continue to walk the path to developing the inner man.

From this letter I learned that there is a first promise in philosophy, that we should have a feeling of fellowship and of belonging to mankind and our communities. Rather than conform to the way of the mob, that we practice simple, yet pure, way of life. Living life at its very core - from the inner man.

Further, you've given me much to think about with your insights about the relationship between hope and fear, and the value in limiting one's desires to cure one of fear. "Fear keeps pace with hope". I must confess, I usually regard hope as a good thing. Yet your guidance that foresight (hope), being a great blessing, can be transformed into a curse if we let it "keep our mind in suspense or anxiety".

Today, I saw nature teach this very message. The first snow fell, and one tree still held on to its leaves. Snow collected, until eventually the weight snapped several branches. Do you suppose the tree, if it could think, might have feared it would be naked without its covering? I thought of my own worries, fears, and desire, each as light as a leaf. Yet, how much unnecessary weight do they capture, when I am meant to let them go?


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

New to Stoicism Seneca?

14 Upvotes

In the "Consolation to Helvia" Seneca explains he's very content as an exile, yet in his "Consolation to Polybius" he seems to say -- in not so many words -- that he wishes a return to Roman life. Also in the latter, he wishes everlasting fame on Polybius through his literary talent, while in the same piece informing us that nothing is immortal. Also in "Consolation to Marcia", Seneca reflects on the woman wanting everlasting memory of her son's character and deeds. Does he seem contradictory in these things, and perhaps even un-Stoical at times? Or have I totally mis-read things? (Quite possible!)


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 5d ago

Stoic Theory Is the Logos the Principle of Flux or the Principle of Being?

12 Upvotes

I was researching into Parmenides and Heraclitus and I wanted to see what Stoicism holds as a perspective on that matter:

Do Stoics believe time is an objective structure of reality or that it's more like a human construct and there is only but the Present as what is happening right now? If that's the case , then wouldn't becoming and flux be an illusion because there exists no timeframe to compare beings so we could claim there's becoming? So if there is no becoming and flux then wouldn't it be better to say that the Logos isn't the principle of flux but rather the principle of Being? (As in to say that reality cannot unfold in the present while carrying contradiction which is an ontological violation. So like for example you cannot have a square with no sides because by nature a square is a being that has sides.)

I personally don't think Parmenides and Heraclitus contradict each other , I mean to Heraclitus he is going under the assumption that time exists and therefore we can derive that flux is real. But from a pure present moment, how can we derive change as real when there are no 2 distinct timestamps to compare?


r/Stoicism • • 5d ago

New to Stoicism The movie ‘seneca ‘

8 Upvotes

I was just reading the letters of
Seneca and then stumbled upon the movie. The character of Seneca by Malkovich is such an ass that it s hard to appreciate the book now..


r/Stoicism • • 5d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

6 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 5d ago

Analyzing Texts & Quotes Don't add to your troubles

38 Upvotes

I was re-reading Discourses and one of my favorite passages were in the beginning of book 1, where Epictetus tells of Aggripinus.

"What, then, did Aggripinus say? He said, "I am not a hindrance to myself." When it was reported to him that his trial was going on in the Senate, he said, "I hope it may turn out well; but it is the fifth hour of the day"- this was the time when he was used to exercise himself and then take the cold bath- "let us go and take our exercise." After he had taken his exercise, one comes and tells him, "You have been condemned." "To banishment," he replies, "or to death?" "To banishment." "What about my property?" "It is not taken from you." "Let us go to Aricia then," he said, "and dine."

This it is to have studied what a man ought to study; to have made desire, aversion, free from hindrance, and free from all that a man would avoid. I must die. If now, I am ready to die. If, after a short time, I now dine because it is the dinner-hour; after this I will then die. How? Like a man who gives up what belongs to another."

Just because something less preferrable happens to us, does not mean that we are incapable of enjoying other things that are not cut off from us. Like I tell my wife often, don't let 15 minutes ruin your 24 hours.


r/Stoicism • • 5d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Finding it hard to go on

22 Upvotes

As title suggests, I am finding it hard to have motivation to do anything. I am enough self aware to know that it is bad, and well the outcome of it will not be good for me, but I am quite sad and well dont feel like doing anything, I am saying that and still do do work, just not at the pace I used to.

Any help / wise words / motivation you can enlighten me with?


r/Stoicism • • 5d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Somewhat somber reflection

7 Upvotes

I chose seeking personal stoic guidance mostly because I didn't see a more applicable flair.

Ive taken a very passionate interest in stoicism. All schools of philosophy catch my interest more than most topics, but specifically stoicism in the last few years. I did what I considered decent following the teachings that made me fall in love with this school of philosophy for a couple years. But in august, i started a divorce that was long overdue, and since she started putting an effort into making life difficult, I have fallen into bad habits. I picked up nicotine again, stopped working out every day, started drinking, and setting up hookups. I am not looking for sympathy whatsoever, I want to specifically not receive it. Anybody looking to show sympathy, I would prefer you keep the comment to yourself, and i mean no offense by that. But they are my decisions, and sympathy would be misplaced. I dont feel bad, and im not exactly sad about my decisions. Im still happier than I've been since I started the relationship with my ex wife almost 9 years ago now.

For context, she has been stealing my mail, she stole my key, and claimed I "put my hands on her" to the cops when I had to call them on her. I was very intentional in my actions the day I had to call the cops. It was the day I told her I thought we should split. I went to the spare bedroom to separate myself from her because she was berating me, and after a while, she went into the doorway to start a confrontation. I told her to leave me alone and that she was only trying to hurt my feelings, and i tried to shut the door, but she put her body in the way of the door so I couldn't. I told her to get out of the way and that I was leaving, and she moved to the hallway. She put her arms on both walls of the hallway and tried to prevent me from leaving. I told her "get the fuck out of my way" twice, and when she refused to yield i tried to force my way through (she is a big woman, a little under 260 pounds). She braced herself harder, so i put my left arm between her body and the right side of the wall, and i stepped through her with only as much force necesarry to get out. I worked out every day for about a year, so i am in good shape. For lack of a better reference, it probably looked like the kool-aid man in the commercials walking through a wall. I rushed out the door fully clothed, but without shoes on because I was trying to get out, and i immediately called the cops. When they got there and i told them my side of things, I actually had to move to the grass while talking to them because the pavement was too hot on my feet with only socks on.

Im writing this more because I respect all of the common contributors to this sub, and honestly, I want your opinions on the matter. Im happy with the decision I made. I am genuinely happier now than I've been in more than 10 years, but I want feedback from some of the people in this sub that, from what i have seen, are more wise than a majority of the people I know in day to day life.

To everyone who sat down to read this, i know it was a long read, and I appreciate your time and input if you feel compelled to give it. Thanks everyone. I hope everyone here has had a good, fulfilling day.


r/Stoicism • • 6d ago

Stoicism in Practice A Response to Senecas Third Letter...

6 Upvotes

Dear Seneca, I've had the privilege of reading your third letter to Lucilius. This is a letter I've given much reflection, as you seem to be teaching many things at once.

Upon my first reading, it seems rather clear to be about friendship. Where friendship is, trust should be also. Our friends should be our intimate acquaintances. You seem to be telling Lucilius (and myself) rather clearly that there should be an abundance of trust within friendship and specifically, a removal of fear. For fear has that nature of where it exists it multiplies. While I certainly agree in principle, I can't help but consider your thoughts on betrayal? Why, in your very own Roman Empire, Caesar himself was betrayed by those whom he might call friends.

I'd like to tell you a little about friendship in this modern world 2,000 years later. I recently told you about a technological device almost all people hold in their hands. For simplicity, think of looking down into a mirror, but rather than seeing your immediate reflection you see whatever you choose. Initially these remarkable devices gave nearly everyone access to the world's greatest libraries. Well, would you believe me if I told you that people themselves now connect with one another through this same device? In fact, when they make a connection between two devices, they might call themselves "Friends". I suppose you might have a few words to say about this.

What has resulted may (or may not) surprise you, rather than nurturing a deeper friendship between people, it seems people are more concerned with "collecting" friends and living vicariously through these devices. You see, everyone can see how many friends another person has, so rather than it being about friendship at all, it's become more a game of status - of collecting strangers as friends. And thus the birth of a paradox -- people are more "connected" than ever, but many have never been lonelier. This is only one minor aspect of this modern ecosystem, but I ensure you many others exist as well.

I want to give you a glimpse of a type of friendship that seems to be on the horizon in this future world. This is new even for me. Let's call it artificial friendship. You must understand there is something called artificial intelligence (AI). Since all the worlds libraries and peoples have been connected by these devices, some technologists have created artificial people that have learned from this information and exist within these devices. These artificial people have an instantaneous exchange with real people in the same way you and I communicate by letter. Since many people are lonelier than ever, some speculate people will nurture friendship with these artificial people, rather than real people. Do you have any ancient wisdom for this modern dilemma? I suspect many are shrinking deeper and deeper into dark corners where the bright daylight seems quite blurred.

I close with a slightly separate thought about what I learned upon my second reading of this letter. All men have a natural tendency. For one it is to trust, and another to not trust in friendship. For another it is to be busy and restless, while for another they gravitate towards idleness. It's the task of man to acquire a "balanced combination" be use of reason. Wisdom should govern our tendancies and we must not mistake our tendancies for wisdom.