Just rewatched this 1959 western, and I liked it a lot. Sure, the poster art's a little misleading: Tina Louise (later Ginger on Gilligan's Island, of course) has a significant role, but the poster is clearly meant to titillate! I'll block out a few of my comments in case they serve as spoilers for anyone who hasn't seen this movie.
First off, this is stark and intense: set in the very small town of Bitters, Wyoming (not sure if that's a real place) in winter, this is all snow and wind and interiors that barely feel like interiors: there is none of the lavish, colorful barrooms of some westerns, just what appear to be quickly built and poorly furnished wood buildings. (Check out the general store with almost nothing on its shelves!) It all gives the movie a bit of a "hanging on by the thread of your heavy coat" feeling in a good way.
So does the conflict: Robert Ryan's established cattle rancher Blaise Starrett is none too happy with the newer homesteaders, one of whom plans to fence off his farm with barbed wire. Coming into town, Ryan confronts his chief nemesis, and a showdown seems very much on the verge. But into this situation comes Burl Ives's former Union major Jack Bruhn and his gang who have just robbed (a stagecoach?) and mean to hide out in Bitters while Bruhn recovers from a gunshot wound. At the same time, Bruhn struggles to keep his lusty gang away from the liquor and the town's (four!) women. Naturally, complications ensue.
Ryan's at the center of this one, and as usual, he's just fantastic, all coiled anger and bent on having his way. (Robert Ryan gets my vote for the most intense actor of the classic era, and also one of the very best.) Ives is also wonderful (check out that bullet removal scene!), and based on this and his performance in The Big Country, he made an invaluable contribution to the western genre. The rest of the cast is also excellent, with Jack Lambert as Tex especially memorable.
Besides the performances and a strong script, much of the appeal of this movie goes to the direction and the stark black and white cinematography. The first two acts mostly take place indoors, but the final act is outside Bitters in a blizzard, and the movie, while certainly worthy on its own, also seems to anticipate such later snowy westerns as The Great Silence and Jeremiah Johnson. There's also a relative lack of actual action (i.e. gunplay): a welcome deviation from the norm in my book, as some westerns seems to feel the need to pile on the action and gunplay. This one has just enough so that when it does come, it has impact.
I am at least slightly ambivalent about the ending. The movie seems to present Ryan's Starrett as becoming aware of the errors of his ways ā but I'm not convinced he was so much in error in the first place. At the very least, the original conflict between the rancher Starrett and the new farmers seems to remain largely unresolved. But maybe the point is that we all need to adapt to new situations ā whether we entirely like them or not?
Overall, this is a very good movie, and I'm giving it a strong recommendation for fans of the genre. I'll rate it at 4/5 ā or maybe even 4.5/5.
If you've seen it, what are your thoughts?