r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Feb 19 '22
No Spoilers Monday, February 28: r/AskHistorians AMA Crossover Event!
In anticipation of the S6 premiere in a couple weeks, we have a special treat for you:
r/AskHistorians will be doing an AMA right here on the sub! Our guests will include:
| Expert | Specialty |
|---|---|
| u/LordHighBrewer | World War II nurses |
| u/Georgy_K_Zhukov | French duels |
| u/mimicofmodes | fashion history |
| u/jschooltiger | maritime history |
| u/uncovered-history | 18th century Christianity; early American history |
| u/PartyMoses | the War for Independence; American politics; military history |
| u/GeneralLeeBlount | 18th century British military; Highland culture; Scottish migration |
| u/MoragLarsson | criminal law, violence, and conflict resolution in Scotland (Women and Warfare…) |
| u/Kelpie-Cat | Scottish Gaelic language |
| u/historiagrephour | Scottish witch trials; court of Louis XV |
| u/FunkyPlaid † | Jacobitism and the last Rising; Bonnie Prince Charlie |
† u/FunkyPlaid was scheduled to give a talk at an Outlander conference in 2020 that was canceled due to the pandemic.
The r/AskHistorians are experts in their fields, but don’t assume they know anything about the books and show. Try to phrase your questions so that you don’t need to know the plot or characters to answer them. Here are some examples:
| Bad Question | Good Question |
|---|---|
| Would Jamie be teased for being a virgin? | What were the cultural norms around premarital sex in Highland culture? |
| Is Lord John Grey’s relationship with Jamie plausible for that era? | What were the penalties for homosexuality in the military? What was the perception of homosexuality in Scotland versus England in the 18th century? |
| How realistic is Lord John Grey’s career trajectory? | How common was the purchasing of commissions? Would an officer who purchased promotions be held in the same regard as someone who earned them in the field? How would the enlisted view such officers? How would someone get tapped to be the Governor of Jamaica? |
| How would Ulysses’ demands be received on the Ridge? | What kind of standing would a freed black man have in the hinterlands of North Carolina? Could he threaten a rebel landowner? Could he act on behalf of the Crown? |
No Character Names
In general avoid using character names because in all likelihood the r/AskHistorians won’t know who you’re talking about. Instead try to explain their role in the story. So not “Claire” but “a World War II nurse.” Not “Dougal” but “a War Chief.” If you’d like help phrasing your questions so the r/AskHistorians will be able to answer them, feel free to post them here for advice.
It’s also a good idea to check out r/AskHistorians to get a feel for the kinds of questions that generate good discussion. (Also check out the links in the table above as they pertain specifically to Outlander.)
No Spoilers
Out of consideration for our guests the AMA will be flaired NO SPOILERS. As usual, if you post spoilers in the thread your comment will be taken down and you’ll be asked to either delete or cover them >!with the spoiler tag!< before the comment can be let up again.
Practically speaking though, you shouldn’t be posting spoilers at all, because the subject of the AMA is the historical context of the series, not its plot. You’re also welcome to ask questions that don’t figure into the plot directly, but are otherwise related, like general questions about Highland culture, the Gaelic language, French court life in the 18th century, so on and so forth.
Make Sure You’re Asking A Question
Finally all TOP-LEVEL comments in the AMA must contain a question. We will remove comments like “can’t wait” or “I’m so excited” or “when does this begin” or anything that doesn’t have a relevant question for the experts. We’re doing this to cut down on clutter and keep the thread tidy so they can find what they’re looking for.
If you’d like to voice your feelings about the AMA you’re welcome to do so in this thread, or post any other general questions or suggestions. Thanks for reading, and we hope you enjoy this special event!
18
u/reeziereen Feb 19 '22
Wow - this is great thank you for setting this up! it will be interesting to hear the answers to questions that come up a lot on the sub! Suggestion - can there be someone to answer any American history questions. I know that’s a broad term and could be culled down to a specific speciality.
7
u/Terragethen Feb 20 '22
As a historian and fan something that annoys me is the Anglisisation of the British redcoats. Culloden had many Scots (mostly lowlanders) on the British side yet the show/books act like redcoats were almost never Scottish. How was the makeup of both sides in reality?
4
u/immery I love you…a little…a lot…passionately…not at all Feb 20 '22
Would it be ok to ask questions about being a historian? I want to ask them if Frank could have lied in his book , and maybe other things about Frank's and Roger's career?
3
u/anonymous_1983 Feb 19 '22
Thanks for setting this up! I'm not familiar with the AMA format. Do we ask questions now and they answer the top-rated ones later or will it be live and they can choose whichever ones to answer as they're asked?
8
u/BelgianCat22 Feb 19 '22
That's such a treat, thanks to all involved!
2
u/hotphoenixfeathers Feb 20 '22
Amazing!
1
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Feb 23 '22
u/DameDrunkenTheTall