r/gaming •

Hey r/gaming, what if we pooled all of our unused games together to create an infinite video game collection. Introducing 99Gamers.

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

437

u/heyyouwtf Jun 18 '12

Isn't this what goozex is?

160

u/Jman1984 Jun 18 '12

Yup. Also, check out glyde.

248

u/flounder19 Jun 19 '12

Do video game libraries need to have names that could pass for brands of lubricant?

21

u/bonsmoth Jun 19 '12

"honey, grab the goozex"

167

u/SweetNeo85 Jun 19 '12

I heard the Simpsons did it too...

→ More replies (2)

27

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Yup, also check out the failed Barterbee.

Except you can't because it tanked.

11

u/AnomalousX12 Jun 19 '12

Also Flakwolf.com... but that died.

9

u/Joshua8195 Jun 19 '12

Yeps. Came here to say this. I love Glyde. So cheap and easy to buy and sell

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/rockydil Jun 19 '12

Goozex is hurting right now. Just spend a few minutes in the forums. Users complain that site admins have been gone too long and autopilot isn't good enough any more.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Is goozex running automagically? If so, that is so incredibly cool

→ More replies (2)

2

u/madstar Jun 19 '12

Goozex is dead, it was great when the community was larger though. There are currently 53 PS3 games available for trade, 113 Xbox 360 games and zero 3DS games. A game like Uncharted 3, which I could pick up off Craigslist for $20, is worth 1000 Goozex points, which is the equivalent of $60.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (151)

117

u/IAmThePat PlayStation Jun 19 '12

This is an interesting idea. I just have a few questions regarding the operation

  • Who sets the price/value of the game?
  • Is the shipping cost also factored into the credits?
  • Is this going to be US Specific? (I am Canadian)
  • How will scammers be dealt with?
  • Will credits be given after game is received?
  • What if receiver says they didn't receive it when they did?
  • What if the sender says they sent it when they didn't?
  • What if the package is legitimately lost in the post?

10

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

This please, though I am Australian....

→ More replies (46)

635

u/sombrejester Jun 18 '12

This could turn into a big project, I'd love to see it happen.

103

u/FourGrapeJustice Jun 19 '12

I would too! I'd gladly contribute some of my old N64 games considering I have added most of them to my Wii.

44

u/sombrejester Jun 19 '12

Putting them to good use.

17

u/Mikey-2-Guns Jun 19 '12

This is actually a very good idea. Is there another complete 'game library' for lack of a better term?

→ More replies (3)

15

u/afishinthewell Jun 19 '12

I just found my copy of NFL Quarterback Club 98 today. I'll start the bid at $500.

11

u/Wolf_Everstone Jun 19 '12

Best I can do is $10.

22

u/Thassodar Jun 19 '12

$3.50

EDIT: Oh wait am I suppose to bid higher than you?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

16

u/DownvotesAllYourShit Jun 19 '12

I'd be very interested in your N64 games. I only have 3 and there is no retro gaming store I know of in my area.

I'm liking this idea already.

8

u/squirrelboy1225 Jun 19 '12

Yeah, all we have is GameStop. It's quite annoying considering the oldest system they carry for is PS2.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

there is something similar to this, it's called Goozex. I used to use it a while ago, but i think it's only 2nd/3rd gen games though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

79

u/pudquick Jun 19 '12

So ... fraud. How are you preventing it?

If user Fraudster123 lists a mid value game and new user Fraudster123Throwaway signs up and performs a trade transaction for said game (that no one can prove either of them have it / sent it) ... now the free credits every new user gets are transferred to the core account, getting Fraudster123 one step closer to Skyrim, etc. from a real user.

Oh, no free credits for new users? How will anyone be able to start the first personA->personB transaction if there's no credits in play somewhere?

Oh, your registered tradable games is your starting bank? What keeps me from registering amazingly valuable games, trading out my "bank" of credits for real ones, then simply folding up shop?

Please, I am interested in these details if no money is involved at any time and you're not providing an escrow service yourself.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

We need these answered.

2

u/gingerninja300 Jun 19 '12

fuck. I'm trying to figure out how it could work and my brain hurts.. we're gonna need experts for this! maybe he could buy games with credits backed by a game or money gaurentee, stockpile them, and send them out on request. of course he'd need to hire someone to do all the mailing.. whose salary could be covered by advertising i suppose.. but i don't think it would scale well enough to even break even, much less become profitable.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BeffyLove Jun 19 '12

There is already a good website for this, called Goozex. I don't understand why OP is trying to force this idea. It's good in theory but people aren't honest, and it's not going to work well in it's current form.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jamesified Jun 19 '12

You could limit one account per address like goozex does.

→ More replies (6)

169

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Make a sign up for the website. No need to turn away folks because we don't use facebook.

→ More replies (13)

23

u/Xenshin1231 Jun 18 '12

Like what other people said this is like goozex. I think it's a great idea but we need a lot of people to keep it going. Hopefully it will make it big on r/gaming because issues with these kinds of sites is the lack of people and games being put into the pool. I'm hoping this turns out well because i want to contribute.

2

u/kafekafe Jun 19 '12

My question is how this would be different than selling things on ebay. It sounds like it would pretty much have little to no security, or buyer/seller protection, and it would be totally up to the buyers/sellers to handle shipping (both similar to ebay). The only difference is that you would get credits that can only be spent within the site, rather than money that can be spent on anything.

19

u/donutsalad Jun 19 '12

Yes what an excellent idea. We can keep the collection at my place. Yes...Yessssss excsssselent.

7

u/pktgumby Jun 19 '12

Sucker! The keeper of the stash has to supply all the beer when we crash your place.

→ More replies (7)

16

u/azulhombre Jun 19 '12

So unlike Gamestop, you'll send your game in for credits and the next day it will go out for double the credits?

Don't get me wrong, it's a great idea, but what about all the values? Who will decide how much each game is worth?

Something like /r/gameswap makes a lot more sense because there's just a deal between the two parties. No "credits" and no third-party website to go through, all of the dealings are done directly between two people.

You should make an option to where people can trade games straight across if they happen to find the respective games they want and are willing to trade. That way they don't need to worry about the credit values and such.

→ More replies (30)

23

u/High_Infected Jun 18 '12

This is... Interesting...

6

u/Mr__Random Jun 19 '12

This idea would have been great 10 years ago but with the ever increasing DRM, ioncluding console DRM and more game being sold as an online copy, as opposed to being on a disk I really don't see this idea surviving the next console generation.

3

u/frostburner Jun 19 '12

i don't know people could hack and just get a fuck-ton of free games

3

u/Van_Wilderr Jun 19 '12

No offense but isnt this EXACTLY what Gamestop does, except you put on a different name.

3

u/nerdshark Jun 19 '12

For the love of God, DON'T REQUIRE FACEBOOK LOGIN. I HATE LINKING SHIT TO MY FACEBOOK ACCOUNT. IT INEVITABLY RESULTS IN SPAM ON MY PAGE. You should use OpenID instead.

7

u/Moosey_Doom Jun 19 '12

Calling it now: this won't amount to anything.

5

u/tythuy Jun 19 '12

I hope there will be a sort of ''Canada'' section , that's why i would love that ; most similar websites only ships and deal on the US . Also a more friendly steam swap game area would be nice.

5

u/evolvedant Jun 19 '12

Not trying to be negative, but how is this an improvement over selling games you don't use anymore on ebay, and then using your paypal credit to purchase games other people don't play anymore off of ebay?

As well, through ebay it is self limited. In that I mean, where are all the games in this infinite collection going? With ebay you keep your games with you until someone wins your auction. Are you expecting everyone to just send all their games to some warehouse where you will have workers who will handle distribution like Netflix or Gamefly?

I'm guessing that is out of the question... which means the games would stay in your own house until someone requested to play a game that we had. That means if I have 100 games I don't play anymore, that I have to CONSTANTLY check some website every single day, to see who wants to play the games I have. And then I'd have to ship it to random addresses, and pay for shipping since the local post office won't accept 'credits'.

I'm sorry but this just doesn't sound feasible at all if you are someone like me with a ton of games across various systems.

4

u/dannygno2 Jun 19 '12

I would like to see older consoles on here as well. I need NES and gameboy color games.

4

u/taggartbridge Jun 19 '12

Why not run this like /r/bookexchange? I'd rather trade redditor to redditor than have to deal with credits based on the age and popularity of the game.

2

u/Shanix Jun 19 '12

No PC game trading?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

How do we know you wont just take the games for yourself?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Good idea. I don't have a facebook though...

2

u/bobbybridges Jun 19 '12

first, change it so its not log in with facebook, that's trash and you'll never be taken seriously. otherwise its good stuff

2

u/jekrump Jun 19 '12

where do the initial credits originate from? I don't understand! how can one buy games if they haven't sold any?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I was on board until I had to use Facebook.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

All I see is advertising.

2

u/Isunova Xbox Jun 19 '12

This already exists, and it's called Goozex.

2

u/ohebb Jun 19 '12

But isn't this just like what we do over at /r/gameswap except you pay?

2

u/kamoh Jun 19 '12

This idea sounds cool, but it reminded me of Game Trading Zone (gametz.com) - I've been a member since 2003 and totally forgot that thing existed 4 years ago! Anyone else use that one?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I'm pretty sure this is illegal.

2

u/hated_dil Jun 19 '12

there would be SOOOOO MANY MADDEN XXXX games its not even funny lol

just like the gamestop sale boxes...you know those ones you go through to find something for cheap and just see more sports games?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

So is the

Text

<Rage face>

Text

<Rage face>

text

<rage face>

format the default one every time something gets pitched?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

dude.. this has been around for A LONG TIME! Check out www.goozex.com Your reinventing the wheel here...

2

u/unaki Jun 19 '12

FYI, there is a site that exists for this very reason. Cheapassgamer.

2

u/ToQuEOnE Jun 19 '12

This is a stupidly good idea.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Are we witnessing history?

2

u/crystalblisters Jun 19 '12

For god sakes rename this. It just bring 9Gag to mind too much.

2

u/_deffer_ Jun 19 '12

I would like to shamelessly point out /r/gameswap

2

u/Brash_Attack Jun 19 '12

Best of luck to you but I've completely stopped trading in games for money/credits/etc since I started trading with /r/gameswap. Nothing can beat it.

2

u/jointheredditarmy Jun 19 '12

This isn't some awesome new idea he just came up with, this is an attenpt at social marketing. normally I wouldn't call something like this out but this is just too blatant. Check out 99dresses.com, they JUST presented after graduating from an incubator (don't want to say which one, can't remember if they are launched or not)

2

u/Bad_Sex_Advice Jun 19 '12

wouldn't this be illegal? Basically the reason copyright laws exist?

2

u/epicgeekfail Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12

Hi there! I imagine you are probably swamped with posts and messages from your /r/gaming post, but I have a few ideas and suggestions I'd like from this service. This is an amazing replacement to /r/gameswap - gameswap currrently has a problem where people value their items way, way to much. This fixes a lot. But, while swapping new games is great, retro games is a big hit on Reddit. I have a great money making opportunity you could build into the site.

I call it 'Cartridge Purchase and Backup.' Many customers have loads of cartridge games (N64, SNES, NES, Sega consoles) that they would rather play on their computers as ROMs. Using a "Retrode" device or an N64 Gameshark, you could use the already in place "purchasing" system for 99gamers to buy the themselves cartridges, then charge the seller a fee ($5.99?) to remove his save data and ROM and then email it too him/her. Then just resell the cartridge for whatever amount of tokens like any other seller would.

As for shipping, I live in the US, and we have flat rate postage service. Since most games live in a plastic small case, using the USPS's "flat rate envelope" for a fee of (i believe) $3, provides a cheap and large enough package to send mail for the US. If you were to make a deal with the USPS and create a purchase plan for the site, you could charge $2-5 more on a plan and take your own cut. Example: $22 for 5 shipouts, $44 for 10, and so on. That is still incredibly cheap for sending out games. When selling a game, I think the sellers should need to provide three photos - Picture of back of disc, so that all scratches and other marks are shown CLEARLY. These are all used games, and to prevent people from sending out broken discs, make sure that the back of the game is provided. A picture of the front of the disc, and a picture of the game case (if any.)

As for tokens, here's how I believe you should make the 99gamers "economy" work: Before listing a game, sellers need to say how many tokens they think the game is worth. Then, have them go through a survey asking about the condition of the game, the case, and how much they enjoy it. That survey should give them a 'reccomended tokens' worth based upon the condition of the game, the amount of self-worth it is to the player, and other sales of that game. Sellers can then choose the survey token amount or their own token amount. That way, its not a 1:1 token listing

One thing I have to let you know before I go - NEVER, EVER, EVER, CHARGE FOR TOKENS. The minute you start charging for tokens, your entire economy you will have built will go fucking haywire and screw you over. Putting Ads on your website will get you just as much money or possibly more.

2

u/OobleckSnake Jun 19 '12

Why not just have a sub where players can trade games? Is that a thing?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I'm in if I don't have to use Facebook.

2

u/EquationTAKEN Jun 19 '12

Title looks too much like "9gag".

2

u/Snitchdoga Jun 19 '12

i smell a rat

2

u/batrobin Jun 19 '12

can you change the name of the project, never put 9 and g together

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Can you PLEASE create a way to sign up without using Facebook?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/I_hate_kids_too Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12

This is a fine idea but it suffers from one very big critical flaw; credits. You can call it whatever you want but I'm guessing it would be the currency and I don't think you can give 1 credit to someone who gives a game and take a credit from someone to takes a game. Not all games are equal so unfortunately you can't put an equal value on all games or else you'll end up with a market crammed full of Superman64 while everyone is hoarding credits and looking for the lost copy of HL3. And since it has a currency and every game has a different give/take price, people will naturally be greedy and try to obtain as much as they can for as little as they can and only sell to the highest bidder. This contradicts and undermines the very concept of pooling resources together. When you pool resources together, everything belongs to noone and everyone at the same time. You can't act like this is a system built by everyone, for everyone and everyone is working together to trade games back and forth freely just because everyone is a gamer and mutually respects each other and wants each other to have a good time and all that other wholesome stuff. With a system like this you will certainly be giving the finger to Gamestop but only because you're trying to create some competition for them. To make this clear, it will definitely not eliminate all the bullshit that comes with buying/selling used games, but instead it will only be changing what kind of bullshit we deal with. If you really want to create an environment for the people, made by the people then you must design a system that rewards those who give(which is different than putting a higher value on those who have more to give) and punish those who are being greedy without wrongfully harming those who are just borrowing from the system. However if you want to be the next Gamestop then you could keep this system and make all your money off advertisements. But no matter what you do, you must either stop acting like everyone is pooling resources together or ditch/rework the credits idea.

EDIT: It's also worth mentioning that not all of us use facebook so it may not be the best idea to create a system that is dependant on it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

This is gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay

2

u/Ordal Jun 19 '12

I think this is a great idea but you literally have zero (0) chance of getting me to sign up for anything by forcing me to sign up via facebook.

Sorry, but good luck.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I really don't care if this has been done before, I like this idea, and I like the concept of doing it with reddit and r/gaming.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Snap4Life Jun 19 '12

Yeah great idea... For the console users among us. I hope the most of us know pc gaming is the real deal. No offence to the console users btw.

2

u/OptimusCannabis Jun 20 '12

This is a bad idea if it were to become very popular! by buying games, we support game developers, and in turn they have enough money to create new games! if you make it so people start buying less games, then game creators wouldnt be able to make nearly as many new games for us to play!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Getting ripped of by gamespot...or you know a valid business model.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/manlycaveman Jun 19 '12

Seems like TF2 Warehouse and Glyde combined. I'm definitely interested in how this all turns out. :)

2

u/qazydude Jun 19 '12

but tf2 warehouse was easily exploitable for hats because prices could change relatively quickly.

3

u/Mozzy Jun 19 '12

What's wrong with Game Stop selling games for more than they paid? Were you under the impression that Game Stop is a nonprofit?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

This is the EXACT same concept as Goozex, which already exists, and already does this.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/flounder19 Jun 19 '12

a virtual currency called credits

If you want to improve this idea, use bitcoins instead

17

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Not a good idea. Bitcoins haven't exactly proven themselves to be stable or safe as a form of currency.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/m0nkeybl1tz Jun 19 '12

The problem is that would require an infusion of real-world currency, and I believe the idea here is that no cash is involved.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

3

u/Aznsituation Jun 19 '12

Shut up and take my money...I mean credits

3

u/JasonUncensored Jun 19 '12

The name is too similar to 9gag. I will not be participating, sorry.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Or, you know....ebay.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

What happens if there's a physical problem? My first thought when I saw this was disk swap, scratches, etc similar to redbox and others

2

u/MRqman Jun 19 '12

Not sure if its been said before but this exists its called goozex

2

u/e_dawg_nuts Jun 19 '12

paperbackswap.com and swapadvd.com already do this with their respective mediums and it worked well while i used the services

2

u/polar_fawkes Jun 19 '12

You're probably gonna get sued if this is successful. You've stated that you're trying to kill GameStop(paraphrasing), and that you want your users to never run out of games. The people who make and sell games won't like this.

Just reminds me of something that happened at my old job. We had proper approval to create a unique DVD ripping tool. Then Real Networks jacked the idea and rushed out a prototype, with the tagline that went something like "Copy. Anything. LEGALLY." Except they hadn't gone through the right channels, and freaked out big people and got mega sued. We had to scrap our project after that.

Be careful how you market ideas that fuck people with more money than you.

2

u/NewspaperBlanket Jun 19 '12

Sounds a lot like Bookmooch but for games. I like it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Backupusername Jun 19 '12

So, since no actual currency is involved, and all games are going to be used no matter what, I'm guessing there's no depreciation?

Like, suppose I spend 500 points on a game, play it, finish it, and sell it back to 99gamers; I get 500 points back, right?

Also, what's to stop people from just giving the site their old games, getting a bunch of highly-valued new titles, and selling them to GameStop for personal profit?

2

u/haddock420 Jun 19 '12

I imagine highly-valued new games will cost a lot more credits than old games, so you'd have to sell a lot of old games to get enough credits for one new game. So if that's the case, you'd be just as well selling the old games at Gamestop and getting the same amount of cash as you'd get for the new game.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Points_To_You Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12

The only way I would use this is if I could send you a big box full of video games and you would give me the credits for whatever is in the box. I would be willing to list ahead of time what will be in the box, but I'm not going to make a shipment for every game and I'm not going to send it directly to someone trading me credits.

I would only do it where I send 99gamers the game, they give me credits, then I click buy on their site and 99gamers sends me the game. I don't want to deal with sellers or buyers, I don't want to worry about being scammed. If I have to worry about that, I would rather them sit in my closet.

See:

Amazon Trade-In

Gazelle

To be honest, I strongly doubt you have to resources to pull off what is needed for what is, in my opinion, a useable service.

Edit: After reading how Goozex works, I think their service is closer to something I would use than what you seem to be suggesting. Even if Goozex is a terrible name.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cdcox Jun 19 '12

Not going to mention you 'borrowed' the idea from 99dresses? I assume you will use the same monetization scheme?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

So I'm trying to work out why this comment was downvoted. It certainly wasn't for lack of truth, this is 99dresses in every way but the dresses.

Not that that's bad, but remix culture and open source culture is different from stealing in that it references the original source.

99dresses for those who haven't heard of it.

2

u/99dresses Jun 20 '12

Hey bkruz11, if they say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery then I am incredibly flattered. I'm the founder of 99dresses.com which does exactly what you are proposing for 99gamers but for fashion (and has been for a while). But you'd know this because you basically copied everything about the site (how it works, the copy, the pitch - heck, even the name!).

I do think its a great idea to do for games, though perhaps you could be a bit more original with your marketing? At the VERY least change the name.

Shoot me a tweet (@99dresses) if you want to chat. I've got 2 years of learning behind me about how this system works for fashion - maybe I can help you come up with a swapping system for games that isn't so blatantly ripping off 99dresses. I can already name several problems that you are going to face if you do this for games.

Happy to impart my learning (we need more community-driven trading platforms out there) but please don't blatantly rip off other people's stuff like that. The name 99gamers really gives it away :-)

Nikki

→ More replies (1)

1

u/hero1012878 Jun 19 '12

great idea

1

u/Waffle842 Jun 19 '12

I would fucking love this

1

u/Beanboy112 Jun 19 '12

Sounds great!

1

u/thetorsoboy Jun 19 '12

I'm down for this assuming people don't rip others off if there's a way to monitor that.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

It was if the angels came down from heaven and became business people.

1

u/Liquidator47 Jun 19 '12

I don't have facebook, but I'm totally in. What do?

1

u/qwertytard Jun 19 '12

does it have to be facebook?

1

u/GoochToomor Jun 19 '12

what stops me form "selling" games that aren't mine, or, buying games with credits and selling them for money outside the website? Will all games be the same amount of credits? if not, is this not just an electronic eb games?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Great idea and i'd like to offer my help if you need it. I have a background in the usual html, php and so-on. Though i must confess at sucking hard at graphics which you seem to have covered anyways.

Do It Up!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Too bad i don't facebook but I'm totally in for this.

1

u/3-Fiddy Jun 19 '12

and a girlfriend ain't one

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I'm not going to be a whiny hipster bitch and sign up via my Facebook account which I use to talk to my friends.

1

u/Naly_D Jun 19 '12

I could get behind this. I have a lot of games I don't play. This was my 360 collection last August. I've since run out of room to keep them all, got a lot in shoeboxes under the bed.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

So, what would the trade in value be? Full, or a little off? I'd be fine either way, as both are better than Gamestop.

1

u/maskredd Jun 19 '12

i hope this ends up working. having spent probably a few hundred dollars on my game collection, it'd be nice to be able to get some more variety without losing too much to shops like gamestop. i'm also interested to see how the game economy works out.

1

u/underworlder Jun 19 '12

If you don't give the game to the buyer, yo lose credits, and also if you send a game with scratches you also lose credits good idea?

1

u/james9075 Jun 19 '12

there should also be a trade feature. and categories for different platforms

1

u/JSBUCK Jun 19 '12

How does my game leave my house? Will there be locations to drop it off, or will I ship it directly to this so called infinite games collection my self? This seems like a lot of trouble to get a video game. I'd rather just go to the store and buy a game IMO.

1

u/jostler57 Jun 19 '12

My critique:

*gauge

1

u/majesticjg Jun 19 '12

So basically it's a giant lending library of games. GameFly, but instead of a monthly fee, you pay in games. Sounds awesome!

Any chance the publishers would sue you?

Any chance you can divorce Facebook and do your own thing, eventually?

1

u/Stoichio Jun 19 '12

Basically this is /r/pif you could hook up with the admins of pif because they have worked out a pretty good system

1

u/quaxon Jun 19 '12

lol, r/gameswap is already pretty active and I've made a couple of trades off it .

1

u/Krispyz Jun 19 '12

There was a website called ChanceXchange.com that I used a long time ago. It did something like this, only with a wide variety of media/things. So you'd put up old books, movies, comics, video games, etc. Get credits when you sent it out and could spend those credits on things you wanted.

Reddit seems like a good place to start one of these, as you need a large number of people starting it to get it going.

1

u/lemonade_brezhnev Jun 19 '12

Wow, someone should do this with books!

1

u/Jusscurio Jun 19 '12

This is exactly like the website Barter Bee. I searched for it and it seems to be a blog now though. It used to sponsor diggnation and I even used it once to get a free game. That was years ago though and I had never used it since. The website you are going to make is exactly the same service Barter Bee provided yet that website seems to be gone. I guess you can fill the gap and take its place.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Via iPhone, I can't contribute very much. I bestow my upvote. It is not much, but it will help.

1

u/AnomalousX12 Jun 19 '12

This is the exact idea that the site Flakwolf.com did a couple years ago. However, I don't mind that the idea is being so blatantly recycled since Flakwolf died rather quickly. I hope 99Gamers actually works out.

1

u/mattrubik Jun 19 '12

Will this work in the UK? Is there a similar thing already in the UK?

I need answers!

1

u/loki312 Jun 19 '12

i think that this is a great idea iam sick of being ripped off by gamestop and they get triple even what they give me

1

u/titofrito Jun 19 '12

just put this on steam and the industry collapses

1

u/megachimp Jun 19 '12

As a game developer, I'm not going to sit here and preach about how used games or swapping games is taking money out of fellow developer's pockets.

But...

Please do consider the people who make the games. Not sure what the answer is, but it would be cool to Perhaps embrace the developers and carve out a portion of the "credits" to go back to the studio that made the game. Just a thought.

1

u/throwaway29183 Jun 19 '12

So, explain to me how this isn't exactly eBay, except that the only type of money you can receive for selling is spendable only at the site you sell on.

1

u/Riseofashes Jun 19 '12

Seems like a chicken n egg situation,

How can someone get their first set of credits? They'd have to trade a game right? But how does that buyer first get credits?

1

u/non_anonymous Jun 19 '12

How would this credit system work? Will it be value based (game valued at $40 will get you enough credits to buy a $40 game) or contribution based (1 game will give you credit for 1 game)?

1

u/hard_to_explain Jun 19 '12

Can't you just do this with real money?

1

u/-Nobody- Jun 19 '12

Take a look at Paperback Swap. It has the same concept, but with books; it seems like something similar could work quite well.

I think it's a great idea as long as it's done right. I'll be keeping an eye on it.

1

u/killeronthemoose Jun 19 '12

99gamers sounds eerily similar to 9gag...

1

u/Brainasaur Jun 19 '12

Dragons den this if it works enough

1

u/ZackScott Jun 19 '12

I've always wondered about systems like. I've seen them implemented in various ways. It would seem the way to get credits normally would be to sell games, but where do the very first credits come from? How does one get credits to begin with?

1

u/Salvia_dreams PC Jun 19 '12

Where do I sign!?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

If I remember anything from my childhood videogaming, it's the "NOT FOR RESALE" signed smeared across every cartridge and box. I wonder if this would be breaking any laws. I hope not because it sounds great.

1

u/quakeaddict Jun 19 '12

It sounds like there are some kinks that need to be worked out, but I love the idea. I have some games I picked them up for PC in Steam Sales but if this gets going I would definitely be willing to donate some of them.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Are you planning on adding other systems besides the 360, Wii, and PS3 to the arsenal? I've got a few DS games that I'd like to trade for some old school stuff, like NES.

1

u/gunju11 Jun 19 '12

I would suggest to add new categories for new games as in NDS and Sega etc.

1

u/gamemaster257 Jun 19 '12

It would appear we are overloading the site :/

1

u/iRateSluts Jun 19 '12

1: This already exists

2: This wont work for much longer, and only really works for console games (lol, who the fuck cares?).

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

you sir, have just won my heart for this outstanding idea!

1

u/Deekman Jun 19 '12

Great job you invented (an unworking) Goozex.com

1

u/nickbernstein Jun 19 '12

How about instead of "credits" we just use money, and instead of a new website, we just use ebay?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I'd change the name to 100gamers because 99gamers looks just a bit too close to 9gag. the whole "9g" thing

1

u/giggl3puff Jun 19 '12

I can't help but think of 9gag whenever i look at the name... Damnit...

Amazing idea, though!

1

u/AustinYQM Jun 19 '12

I'd like this if it didn't have the saleing/buying aspect.

Bear with me for my ideal option.

Player1 want to play ME3 for XBOX so he fills out a request.
Player2 sees the request and puts up their ME3.
Player1 accepts and gets the game mailed to them, losing 1 credit.
Player2 mails ME3 getting one credit.

Everyone starts with one credit.

What you have no is just gamestop without a real currency so I don't really like this.

1

u/Revolan Jun 19 '12

You have my sword

1

u/Geikamir Jun 19 '12

This is a really cool idea. I like it.

1

u/reginwoods Jun 19 '12

One important question: When someone "buys" a game from someone else, then whats stopping that person from not just selling it on eBay. Is it really just an honor based system? Also what about if someone doesn't ship the game? would they still get credits? Is there some way to track the games location?

Other then these points this is an awesome idea, can't wait to here more about it!

1

u/Maday65 Jun 19 '12

What about an over abundance of shitty games that would likely pile up? Because then there'll be like one Skyrim and then 47 copies of Shaq-Fu and Madden 5: Rise of the Kraken.

1

u/Nano_Engineer Jun 19 '12

I'd like to make it more of a library. Run by people donating their time and possible money donations rather than point based systems.

1

u/Grizzlywilds Jun 19 '12

It would be full of every previous Madden game.

1

u/dewey_do_me Jun 19 '12

Sign me up. I would love to try it maybe a spotlight on users. And also a mascot. Hmmm like something to do with giving.

1

u/JSixgun Jun 19 '12

What would stop someone from trading in a bargain bin game like, Spider Man II for Skyrim. Not all games hold the same value.

One could take that Skyrim sell it on ebay for $35-40. How would you stop that?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I'm skeptical but hopeful about the success of this website. I'll check it out again in a few weeks and hope you have everything together! Good luck!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

YES!!!! genius!!! And if this works let's fucking boycott the ISP's together.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

How do the first credits get created? We have to buy with real $?

1

u/itstwoam Jun 19 '12

How do you plan on getting around silly DRM? Install limits and cd keys and such?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Senor_Wilson Jun 19 '12

I hope you can buy games for the same price as selling them, if not, this is gamestop with funny money. Please create equal buy - equal sell pricing.

1

u/mosmorsan Jun 19 '12

How do you start buying games at launch? No one will have credits. Do you give sign-up credits? How do you make that non-exploitable?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Squishpoke Jun 19 '12

So much repost

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I want this to happen. Message me if there is anything I can do to help make it possible

1

u/TIGGER_WARNING Jun 19 '12

I guess I'll be the first to game the gaming system:

"Credit" parity between two games with different market prices will wreak havoc on the system. Credit values will have to be updated constantly in order to reflect the shelf price and resale value of all the games in the system, as well as account for a general depreciation differential between various aging games. Exploiting the time lag between the credit system and changing market prices would be straightforward and could make some people a chunk of money.

Even a basic sort of arbitrage system would turn the system upside down. Partners in the US and countries that get new titles much later could easily exploit the influx of copies of a new game right after its release.

1

u/dbbo Jun 19 '12

"Infinite" does not mean "very large".

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I like this idea! It's like r/bookexchange with games!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/titaniumhud Jun 19 '12

Well I can see one particular flaw.

I see people going out and mass-buying all of the cheap "under $5" games at any retailer (specifically gamestops) and turning them in for credits. Then in a "turn-around" using said gained credits to cash in on games with high trade value and selling them off to retailers/pawns.

1

u/habacutter54 Jun 19 '12

i will buy the shit out of valkyria chronicles if someone has it

1

u/pyro357 Jun 19 '12

You should check out /r/gameswap

1

u/zenith2nadir Jun 19 '12

Why charge? In its current state it's just Goozex.

Make it free and you'll have GameSwap in site form, and that I'll get behind.

1

u/flamethrower78 Jun 19 '12

Nice try gamestop

1

u/Spiderdan Jun 19 '12

Can't we just make a subreddit for people who want to trade games?

1

u/Ult Jun 19 '12

I tried going to 99gamers and went to a porn site.

1

u/Ecuatoriano Jun 19 '12

Dude, you need to do away with the game boxes, you can ship a c/dvd for cents (in the US), think of NetFlix envelopes, I am 100% sure you can cut a deal with the post office for massive shipping.

1

u/EvilHom3r Jun 19 '12

I'm not sure I can respect anyone that posts an image with so many JPEG artifacts.

1

u/MayorMair Jun 19 '12

you should also have it so people can use their credits to bid on games

1

u/yourafagyourafag Jun 19 '12

Can't wait to rip these guys off!

1

u/fireinthesky7 Jun 19 '12

I almost never use my Xbox, except for the occasional really good game I can get my hands on months after it's come out. I'd absolutely add my Xbox games to the collection. OP, there's certainly more to this than games; what else could a common gamer do to help get this going?

1

u/drsamwise503 Jun 19 '12

So... I have a few questions.

  • How does this work with games for Xbox or PS3? Like, is it just for PC? Do we ship the games?
  • If we buy, say, Call of Duty: World at War for, say, 200 credits (I have no idea). Anyways, after we've had our fill of it after like 5 months, is it encouraged to sell it back for 200 credits, or less?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Or we could pay in karma. That would work.