r/soccer • u/DannDannDannDann • Jul 10 '12
The best and worst transfers of all time?
Was just thinking about how Juve picked up Pirlo and how it has to be one of the best deals ever. Then remembered Eto'o plus £35 million for Ibra, which is just crazy. Any thoughts on others?
20
Upvotes
22
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Really the ibra deal was, expensive, but not bad. He held his own at Barca and won them plenty of games and goals, him and Guardia just had a falling out.
43
u/Tommyjw Jul 10 '12
Dont know about all time, But both Vidic (£7m) and Kompany (£6m i think) have always struck me as amazing value.
14
u/bonoboboy Jul 10 '12 edited Jul 10 '12
I follow the EPL, so it's a bit "top heavy"
Best:
(Early?) Demba Ba and Papiss Cisse to Newcastle
Thierry Henry (to Arsenal)
Cantona
Drogba
Lampard Vidic
Kompany
Worst:
Andy Carroll
Fernando Torres
Emmanuel Adebayor (to City)
Winston Bogarde Kaka (to Madrid)
Robinho
Shevchenko
Wayne Bridge (to City)
High priced but worth it:
Cristiano Ronaldo
Zidane
Buffon
Sergio Aguero
Rio Ferdinand
Rooney
Dani Alves
EDIT: Added changes as per comments below, and Wayne Bridge.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12 edited Jul 10 '12
Best
Shearer: 15 Million Pounds (a lot but considering all he did)
Ba: Free Transfer
Cisse: 9 Million Pounds
Cabaye: 5 Million Pounds
Tiote: Around 4 Million Pounds
Santon: 6 Million Pounds
Worst
Owen: 16.8 Million Pounds
Bramble: 6 Million Pounds
Marcelino: 6 Million Pounds
Boumsong: 8 Million Pounds
Xisco: 6 Million Pounds (plus a crazy contract)
20
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Kaká. 57 million GBP (70 million Euros). The only player who comes even close to that productivity:transfer fee ratio is Torres.
33
u/jusfunky Jul 10 '12
Woodgate to Real Madrid. One of my fave worst transfers. Cantona from Leeds was one of the best.
20
u/LawlNoodle Jul 10 '12
Nicolas Anelka brought for £500,000 then sold 2 years later for £22.3 million.
17
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Gaizka Mendieta to Lazio for €48m.
15
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Worst:
Best:
29
u/crnulus Jul 10 '12
€15M for Mesut Ozil and he's one of the best mid-fielders in the world right now!
29
u/cjzoom Jul 10 '12
No one has mentioned Ronaldo to United for 12 Million? Surely that's the best transfer of all time, especially as he was sold for £80 Million
14
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Bebe
34
u/thatrandomfatguy Jul 10 '12
Owen To Bolton
22
u/My_favorite_things Jul 10 '12
Worst: Breno to Bayern.
11
u/brazijl Jul 10 '12
BVB wise
best: Kagawa for 350k €
worst: Amoroso for 25m €
9
u/zSolaris Jul 10 '12
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Peter Schmeichel cost us so little.
Also, I think it was John Obi Mikel's transfer to Chelsea that resulted in United being awarded money (something about United havin first option or the like).
9
u/Taffy711 Jul 10 '12
Middlesbrough's signing of Afonso Alves has to be up there in terms of worst, at least for us. It was a record transfer for us, over ten million pounds which at the time basically represented our entire transfer budget. Too bad he was absolutely useless and never looked like a PL level player. In the end we had to cop a massive loss on him and to add insult to injury he sued us for £300,000.
9
u/skidoos Jul 10 '12
Ali Dia
9
u/AminoManUVA Jul 10 '12
David Beckham's $32.5 million (yes the $250 mil is a made up PR stunt number) was probably a really good transfer for the entire MLS.
16
u/TheContradiction Jul 10 '12
Henrik Larsson. 650,000 GBP. My god, what a legend.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Sammi Hyppia must be up there, nice story too
37
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12 edited Jul 10 '12
Thierry Henry - £11 mil
Kolo Toure - 150k
Robin Van Persie - £2.75 mil
Anelka - 500k
Cesc - 500k
Clichy - 300k
Pires - £6 mil
Sol Campbell on a free.
Viera - £3.5 mil
Oh right this is just Arsenal.
18
u/Killagina Jul 10 '12
Best: Pirlo to Juve - Free.
Hi Milan fans! ;)
5
u/koalaokala Jul 10 '12
The worst? Benni McCarthy to West Ham. Got too fat and never scored. That bastard.
4
u/cantsleep2nite Jul 10 '12
Milan buying Gianluigi Lentini from Torino in 1992 for £13, which made him the most expensive footballer in the world at the time. His career got derailed by a car crash and a very serious injury, but still, quite a splash of cash for that kind of player
4
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Xabi Alonso-£10m
4
u/paper_zoe Jul 10 '12
Worst:
Seth Johnson from Derby to Leeds for 7m, gave him a contract that was way more generous than he expected and he was constantly injured. Was he ever that good to begin with?
Chris Sutton from Blackburn to Chelsea, 10m. Played 28 games in the league and only scored one goal.
Tore Andre Flo from Rangers to Sunderland for 7m.
Luther Blissett from Watford to Milan for 1m in 1983, then went back for half that a year later. It was rumoured that they got him mixed up with John Barnes. Luther Blissett is now the name of an Italian political activist group.
Best:
Jimmy Glass. A loan signing goalkeeper that scored that goal that kept Carlisle in the league. One of the best moments in football history. It was only his 3rd appearance for Carlisle and he'd never play for them again.
Ruud Gullit from Sampdoria to Chelsea for free. Started Chelsea on the road to where they are now.
12
u/Refuser187 Jul 10 '12
Van Der Vaart to Tottenham was pretty cheap, £8m I think.
10
u/valaranin Jul 10 '12
Juan Sebastien Veron to Man Utd sticks in my mind, not because he wa a bad player he wasn't he just didn't work out at Utd and they paid a lot for him.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Javier Hernandez was pretty cheap and did well in his first season with Man Utd (I think?)
Thiago Silva cost Milan about €10 million which for what he's worth now is very good.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Best: Ozil to Madrid for £12m. Worst: Downing to LFC for £19m.
3
u/stephenmario Jul 10 '12
Sami Hyypia
5
u/Pivatelli Jul 10 '12
Pirlo to Juve one of the best ever? You joking with me or did you just start watching Italian soccer!?
Milan got Pirlo AND Brocchi for a bargain from Inter.
An even better deal must be when Milan got Seedorf in exchange for Francesco Coco (also from Inter).
Juventus getting Cannavaro from Inter in exchange for Fabian Carini (Juves reserve GK) must also be mentioned as one of the greatest.
Pirlo to Juve was a good deal short-term but it is impossible to determine whether it is one of the best deals ever after only one season. Pirlo is 33 this year and will be 35 when his contract expires. If he does not keep performing like he did last season he will only be a high paid liablility for Juve.
And lastly, while Pirlos season with Juve was impressive, it was not because of Pirlo that Juve won the Scudetto, just like it was not because of Pirlo that Milan won last year (Pirlo was injured most of the season). Milan lost the Scudetto due to injuries (Milan players missed 237 matches due to injuries, Juventus players missed 33). With all the injuries Milan got I was surprised to see that the Milan still had a shot at the scudetto so far into the season.
5
u/Bettet Jul 10 '12
Alfredo di Stéfano: 510 Appearances, 418 goals, 8 La liga, 5 CL (in a row) he scored four goals in four consecutive winning finals, and then a hat trick in the fifth.
2
u/Jampur Jul 10 '12
The best and worst summed up in one player - Tino Asprilla to Newcastle from Parma. If I remember rightly he cost about £6.5m in '96. He played some unreal stuff at times, but was a complete and utter liability. Got sent off a few times, lashed out often, disappeared back to Colombia without telling anyone at the club.
His hat-trick against Barca made him legendary though. What a guy!
2
u/tkcom Jul 10 '12
£4.5m that Man Utd paid for Massimo Taibi.
2
u/baris96 Jul 10 '12
Kagawa to Dortmund is considered as one of the best deals in Germany, came for 350k I think. Reyes could have been better at Arsenal, at least he got us 10M£ back of his original 17.5M£.
2
u/wierdfish Jul 10 '12
Schmeichel to United in 91 for £505,000 was an amazing piece of business. He won so many games for United over his 8 years. Kleberson may be one of the worst. £6.5m for a world cup winner who was dreadful.
2
u/ju29ro Jul 10 '12
Best: Zidane from Bordeaux to Juve for a transfer fee of £3.5mil. Then flipping him for €75mil to Real (used to purchase Buffon, Thuram and Nedved, btw). Luciano Moggi, santo subito!
2
u/dimitrije83 Jul 10 '12
One of the worst has to be the transfer of Denilson to Betis in 1998, which was the world record at the time. Betis paid £21.5 million for him.
2
u/TheNyo Jul 10 '12
Best: Del Piero to Juventus (FUCK THE MONEY)
Worst: Felipe Melo to Juventus (€25m)
2
u/FUCK_CAPTCHAS Jul 10 '12
demba ba and papiss cisse
2
u/ACMBruh Jul 10 '12 edited Jul 10 '12
Here's a few recent, good transfers that may have not been mentioned: ........Pastore to Palermo for 7M-Sold for 42M........Reus to Gladbach for 1M.......Diego Forlan to Villareal for 3.2M-Sold for 22M..............Alexis Sanchez to Udinese for 3M- Sold for 26M............Dzeko to Wolfsburg for 3.5m-Sold for 32m........ANTONIO DI NATALE to Udinese for 100k!!
2
u/snones Jul 10 '12
Kaka to Madrid was pretty awful, he cost like £70 mil just to warm the bench.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
35 mil Andy Carrol lol
1
u/yermmm Jul 10 '12
Not the worst but Matt Mills to Leicester from Reading last year - £5m. Just been sold to Bolton for less than half of that.
1
u/jingy10 Jul 10 '12
Cassano and Owen to Madrid comes to mind.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
Buffon, Zidane, Cannavaro, Edgar Davids and Pirlo were probably the best 5 transfers in the past 20 years for Juventus.
1
u/scottiescott23 Jul 10 '12
Carlo Cudicini - £300,000
1
u/DormantPigeon Jul 10 '12
sigh, Emile Heskey £3.5 Million from Wigan
1
u/jusfunky Jul 10 '12
Fernando Morientes was a real bad bargain for Liverpool from Real Madrid - He was as effective as a proctologist on a ship full of dead people.
-2
u/righteous_punch Jul 10 '12
Historically when Chelsea buys already great players it ends poorly: Shevchenko, Deco, maybe Torres. Time will tell on that one. A great transfer (for each individual club) would be anything from Chelsea recently or Man City recently and nothing from Liverpool.
0
u/JackGunner93 Jul 10 '12
Arsenal wise, Patick Viera for £3million and The King for £12million are probably up there. Worst, possibly Squillaci, or the legendary Francis Jeffers. Aside from us, the worst I can think of is Mateja Kezman for Chelsea, and the best surely has to be Pirlo, probably the best deep lying playmaker in the world for FREE. Incredible.
-4
u/DoctorFantasmo Jul 10 '12
I think Torres would be a highly priced player but worth it. Around the beginning he sucked but he is getting better and better and Chelsea couldn't have won the champions league without him.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment