r/soccer • • Jul 16 '12

It has come to my attention that the MLS is changing. For the better.

For the first time in 6 years, I've watched the majority of this MLS season and I must say, the style of play has improved dramatically during that span.

No, it doesn't boast the same cohesive, tactical buildup play of La Liga and other European leagues. No, it's not about to start churning out loads of international superstars that can compete on the world cup stage.

However, I must admit, certain aspects of the American game shows signs of stark improvement. The finishing, especially, is bold, inventive, and technically sophisticated. This point is evidenced by the many long-distance finesse shots, sharp precision headers, and quality long crosses.

In short, I honestly believe the US is on its way...

747 Upvotes

939 comments sorted by

47

u/TimothyThomas Jul 16 '12

I agree, and think that it is also evidenced by the plethora of playing styles teams are approaching with. You've got your stoke-like teams, booting the ball, the smash and grab teams like LA galaxy, stocked with talent but forgoing build up play in favor of chance after chance, and teams like DC who continue to opt for (IF they can dictate the game) a passing/possession game. I think that it shows even lower-level players and coaches can have ingenuity and tactical awareness on a game-by-game basis....

22

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

You're right. I really like the diversity; it's like we're watching the evolution of a sport in a microcosm.

→ More replies (1)

84

u/Hencher27 Jul 16 '12

Love the points you made and agree with pretty will everything you said BUT..."American game", "US is on its way" is implying that this is an American domestic league when its not at all. The three Canadian teams in this league all have incredible support which exceeds some teams from the below the border. Just had to add that in.

25

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

My apologies. It's a North American league and I especially like the verve shown by the Montreal fans recently.

8

u/AnthonyCrispino Jul 16 '12

Idk...portland's fans are nuts. I was wow'd when I watched them rip seattle at home. Haha when that big bastard chops the tree is great!

6

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Saws the tree. THIS is chopping the tree. Fuckers.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/GodSamnit Jul 16 '12

Uh, yeah right, Canada is "not American."

Isn't Canada cute?!?

4

u/Hencher27 Jul 16 '12

hahahah, I love the Onion.

59

u/corylew Jul 16 '12

I mean, you guys are okay I guess...

29

u/leafsleafs17 Jul 16 '12

okay is stretching it. Have we had a Canadian team finish in the top half of the league before? I realize that this mostly TFC's fault...

29

u/Hencher27 Jul 16 '12

haha its Montreal's first season and Vancouver's second. Due time my friend, due time.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Hencher27 Jul 16 '12

...hey now, be nice.

6

u/TheScarletPimpernel Jul 16 '12

Swansea, Cardiff and Wrexham all play in the English football league and it is still called as such.

Edit: Wrexham used to.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (5)

382

u/CircleTheFire Jul 16 '12

Most of the big leagues world wide have been around for a hundred years or more, literally. MLS has been around for 17. The top young athletes in those countries go into soccer almost exclusively. In the US, there's football(American rules), baseball, basketball, and hockey to compete with. Most of the top leagues around the world are in close proximity to each other, so there is lots of crossover competition, player movement, and community. The US is really only in close proximity to the Mexican leagues.

That MLS has come so far in such a short time is amazing.

152

u/Kamien Jul 16 '12

Don't forget most other countries have true training academies. The current American system needs a lot of work.

30

u/Quachyyy Jul 16 '12

We do have academies. I know a good amount of people who play for Sounders Academy, both U23 and U16.

36

u/crollaa Jul 16 '12

U23 isn't an academy. It is our associate team in PDL.

We do have U18, U16 academies and pre academy teams.

→ More replies (4)

56

u/CircleTheFire Jul 16 '12

Indeed. In most of the soccer-dominant nations, pro teams have academies that stretch all the way down the the pre-teenage level. In the U.S. There is a growing youth system, but it is completely disconnected from the pros. And it's very regional.

146

u/spisska Jul 16 '12

Every MLS team runs an Academy. It's now a league requirement.

26

u/portomerf Jul 16 '12

I must say, the Chicago Fire has a very good youth development program here in Louisiana. I played D1 and premier for the Chicago Fire Juniors (louisiana). The teams are ranked at different quality levels, and i must say the premier teams are very good.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/emericuh Jul 16 '12

European modeled training academies will never exist in the United States, at least not in any substantial way. So very, very few players ever make it from academy to first team. Faced with the 1% chance that their child may become a soccer superstar one day and the chance at a college education, American parents will undoubtedly resoundingly choose the latter.

24

u/KrangShredder Jul 16 '12

Faced with the 1% chance that their child may become a soccer superstar one day and the chance at a college education, American parents will undoubtedly resoundingly choose the latter.

The obsession of the Canadian hockey parents proves that North American parents will sacrifice education for a shot at a pro-contract.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/bedrutton Jul 16 '12

I don't get the american obsession with entering college straight out of high school. If the soccer career fails, enter college at 21, 23 or 25. What does a few years matter?

28

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

you cant play for a scholarship if youve played professkonally

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/snemand Jul 16 '12

What countries go into soccer almost exclusively? I think that's pretty rare for a country.

I played two sports growing up. That's very common here and I imagine that being the case in many places.

18

u/fucuntwat Jul 16 '12

Just a curious American here, but what youth sports do you guys typically play in other countries?

29

u/danvasquez29 Jul 16 '12

Tennis, basketball, cricket, rugby , track & field, swimming.

→ More replies (27)

13

u/snemand Jul 16 '12

Here in Iceland football is the biggest sport followed by basketball and then handball. We're really good at handball despite our small size. Silver at the last Olympics and generally a top 8 team. Basketball, not so much.

Big teams in handball. Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, France, Spain, Iceland, Poland, Croatia. Basically most of the big nations in Europe besides the UK, Italy and Portugal. Netherlands are becoming better.

Similar with basketball but the Balkan nations are strong as is Spain and Italy.

We're also decent swimmers and there's a fine amount of people in gymnastics and athletics.

Fitness sports is the craze here now with an Icelandic woman being named the most fit woman in the world for the 2nd year in a row now.

I myself mostly played football whilst being a goalie in handball during the winter when my team existed.

→ More replies (11)

6

u/Sacoud Jul 16 '12

We didn't even have a football team at my school. We only had Rugby..

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

In Scotland, esp West coast, football accounts for ~90% of sports that people play/ follow. Both my primary and high school only had football teams.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

South African here: soccer is huge here! Cricket, rugby and to a slightly lesser extent hockey are massive sports here too. Most kids will play 2 or 3 sports at school.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (12)

11

u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Jul 16 '12

Greetings from Brazil.

7

u/snemand Jul 16 '12

You guys also have volleyball and beach soccer and you are race car enthusiasts as well. But everyone loves football, sure. It's not exclusive though.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/jajandio Jul 16 '12

Argentina.
We have other sports, mainly Rugby, Basketball and some Volley. But it's pretty much football all around.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

30

u/tne Jul 16 '12

people don't realize that America's modern soccer history basically starts in 1989, so the fact that we have come so far in that time frame really is something amazing

14

u/ewankenobi Jul 16 '12

wow Pele and Beckenbaur must have been ancient when they played in the US

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (57)

60

u/ibpants Jul 16 '12

There is improvement, but these long distance goals you speak of are mostly down to midfielders shirking their defensive responsibilities and allowing too much space to open up around 25-35 yards out.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

midfielders shirking their defensive responsibilities and allowing too much space to open up around 25-35 yards out.

Isn't that true for almost all long distance goals everywhere.

36

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

plus a lack of quality goalkeepers/defenders, which is a constant across developing leagues.

72

u/crollaa Jul 16 '12

Our goalkeepers are generally pretty decent. I'll agree on lack of quality defenders though.

19

u/pcrackenhead Jul 16 '12

I've only started following soccer in the last few years, but I didn't even know having a good goalie and a terrible defense was a thing that could happen.

Well, the Timbers sure showed me it's possible...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/H00bear Jul 17 '12

The keepers are pretty solid, IMO. Johnson of the Fire got a trial with Man United, there was also Frank Rost with NYRB who came over from the Bundesliga. I wouldn't be surprised to see some older keepers come over from Europe in the near future, especially as they can generally play til ~40 years old. Friedel's still kickin' at 78 or however old he is at Spurs

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AnnieIWillKnow Jul 17 '12

Which is also why you see so many long distance goals in women's fooball.

→ More replies (12)

6

u/victor_foxtrot Jul 16 '12

This. I don't totally disagree that the quality of play in an MLS is on the up and up, but you wouldn't say that the quality of play in the NBA is appreciating because Blake Griffin has been throwing down some thunderous dunks.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

I would equate long distance strikes to 3-point shooting not dunking

10

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

What is also important to note that not all of MLS teams are making the improvements you observe. There is a clear difference between the mob-soccer teams and the more advanced teams. I feel like an outsider's opinion of the league will weigh heavily upon the match up they watched.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/cjschlos Jul 16 '12

You may not be aware but MLS is now 7th in the world in attendance

ATTENDANCE FOR WORLD’S TOP PRO SOCCER LEAGUES Top 10 leagues are as of the last 30 days (updated July 10, 2012) Sources are ESPN Soccernet and worldfootball.net

Bundesliga (GER): 45,726 (as of end of 2011/12 season)
Premier League (ENG): 34,601 (as of end of 2011/12 season) La Liga (ESP): 30,272 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Primera Division (MEX): 25,288 (as of end of 2011/12 Clausura season) Serie A (ITA): 23,459 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Eredivisie (NED): 19,516 (as of end of 2011/12 season) MAJOR LEAGUE SOCCER (USA): 18,851 (as of July 10, 2012) Ligue 1 (FRA): 18,665 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Coca-Cola Championship (ENG2): 18,824 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Chinese Super League (CHN): 18,242 (as of June 29)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

i think it needs to be pointed out that neither Argentina nor Japan are seen here. I am pretty sure that they have a higher attendance average than MLS. I love MLS but lets not spread lies.

18

u/Tasslehoff Jul 17 '12

The 2012 J. League season has an average attendance of 16,474, which puts it below MLS. The 2011/2012 Primera Division averaged 18,112 - also below the MLS. The list aggregator missed a few leagues, yes, but the conclusion is still correct.

3

u/CaptainRon19 Jul 17 '12

Well this is just embarrassing for Ligue 1.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/ceruleancity Jul 16 '12

I think the MLS would improve significantly if we got some more non-American coaches/managers. Almost all coaches/managers in MLS played in MLS and in my opinion some international influence would make a huge difference in the quality of play.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Aron Winter and Carlos de los Cobos, anyone?

11

u/spisska Jul 16 '12

Please do not remind me about Carlos de los Cobos ...

6

u/ostermei Jul 16 '12

You don't miss this?

/sarcasm

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Jadentheman Jul 16 '12

I agree we need more international coaches, even refs. Just don't import the english coaches. we had enough of that.

5

u/warpus Jul 16 '12

The thing is that the MLS is a very quirky league - That's why teams here will usually go for experience over someone who's never managed here.

Even Winter had an MLS-experienced technical director helping him out @ TFC

2

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Hans Backe aint exactly lighting up the league right now.

2

u/eugal Jul 17 '12

MLS needs american mangers because of how different the MLS is. European mangers are never prepared for the amount of traveling MLS teams have to do.

also

Implying big European coaches would make the league better.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Kazan Jul 16 '12

I also agree - i love soccer and i couldn't watch MLS circa 1998-2002

10

u/Chodles Jul 16 '12

I found it hard to watch 3-4 years ago even... It seemed like they should have counted 3+ passes in a row as a goal because that was just as hard to pull off for either team as putting the ball past the keeper.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/cliffordbeshers Jul 16 '12

I've had exactly the same reaction. Five years ago, a random game looked like high school ball: everybody needed four touches to control a pass and by that time they were surrounded. I watched Montreal play this weekend and it's clear that adding a player like Di Vaio changes the way the other players think. You can see them trying to solve the puzzles of where the passing lanes are, but they are really still guessing and even when they get it right, just can't quite do it fast enough. But they clearly know what they are missing. Add in Nesta, whose presence in training has apparently already had a huge impact on the other players, and in a month I expect Montreal will be playing a very different game.

12

u/Hencher27 Jul 16 '12

huge impact? ...but puns aside that Montreal team is looking good. I think the European feel of the city and its proximity to Europe has helped them bring in the top level talent they have. Vancouver might have to look towards the Asian leagues to tap into talent that would feel right at home in Hongcouver.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

All these MLS debates make me want to watch the MLS haha (I'm not American)

2

u/carpetano Jul 17 '12

Me too. There's no Liga until August, so it could be interesting to see a couple of MLS games for science.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/tmh8901 Jul 16 '12

The next step is having MLS become a strong enough league that American players will want to stay and not want to go to Europe for more experience and money.

43

u/abysmaldefending Jul 16 '12

I'm actually completely fine with MLS being a selling league, as competition overseas is definitely better. Many nations that are powerhouses have domestic leagues that are selling leagues (Netherlands, France, Portugal, Brazil, Argentina, etc.). As long as the MLS can develop talent and then get the old players to instill their experience on the younglings, MLS will continue to grow in the right direction

13

u/spazerson Jul 16 '12

This. I would prefer MLS as a selling league. Have our best players go overseas and make names for themselves, and then when they are in their late 30's they can come back home for a few years

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Landon Donovan?

8

u/Rcp_43b Jul 16 '12

He's a special case. It's odd really, I am not sure anyone can explain it.

26

u/schnansen Jul 16 '12

Being rich in California is better than being rich almost anywhere else?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/TheFlashGordon Jul 17 '12

Landon Donavan is an american saint. he could easily sign in La Liga or EPL or Bundesliga, but honestly him staying here is just making our league better.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/jairobonilla Jul 16 '12

You really think that'll happen?

→ More replies (76)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/3THMANOL Jul 16 '12

Its improving... but it will not be the second big thing... bundesluga will be the real deal in few years... world class league...

6

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

I support RSL (live in Idaho, it's the closest team) but I really don't see the problem with supporting a team that's not in your city if one isn't there. I've read lots of comments about people saying they don't support the MLS because they don't have a local team. I've got no local teams that are in my state. But i've found MLB, NHL, and NFL teams I support. If there's not a team in your area, find a team you like. Even if it's not local. Because supporting an EPL team if you live in Iowa sure as hell isn't local.

5

u/rogue4 Jul 16 '12

Go Vandals?

6

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

As a Mexican fanatic of soccer, I am slightly jealous at the fast pace that American soccer is growing, at this pace, their national team will reach the World Cup Championship first than Mexico's team. Its the good kind of jealousy though, glad to see them grow.

3

u/compscidood Jul 17 '12

Not a lot of fans like you say that. As well as myself being an US soccer fanatic, I am jealous (of the good kind) of the talent and infrastructure you have now.

5

u/Sacoud Jul 16 '12

I thought this would be about Kenny Miller signing for Vancouver...

5

u/ArmchairPhysicist Jul 17 '12

I always make it a point to watch MLS when I can. Leagues grow with support, you can't ignore your local clubs and then bitch when they're struggling to reach the level of European leagues.

17

u/chrishamer09 Jul 16 '12

Love watching MLS compared to big leagues sometimes because honestly all teams have a fighting chance..If you watch La Liga...the only teams that have a chance are Real Madrid and Barca......Fucking Boring.

17

u/njndirish Jul 17 '12

I believe you have stumbled on the reason that draws many fans to MLS and Bundesliga. Both leagues have different financial regulations that prevent a club from advancing far and above their competition. Bayern and LA are two great setups, they attract stars (albeit of different ages), they have money, they have facilities, etc, but in the end, they don't manage to win year-in year out

2

u/koniges Jul 17 '12

I would love to get into Bundesliga for this reason, but don't know when to watch the games, and haven't decided on a team to support yet. Luckily I have friends in Germany to help me decide.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

thats because of the salary cap and revenue sharing, American leagues discovered years ago that caps make all teams competitive and so all the league as a whole makes more money at the cost of a few big market teams, there some great articles out there that compare the NFL and MLB, MLB(which doesnt have a salary cap)is really dependent on a few teams(Yankees, Red Sox, etc.) while the NFL has a salary cap and complete revenue sharing(all the money is thrown into a big pot and distributed relatively evenly)

8

u/theswanqueen Jul 17 '12

Bravery levels off the charts itt

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Joelico Jul 16 '12

I am really glad this is happening, sometimes I feel like I don't get enough soccer and MLS is a great addition to the leagues I watch

→ More replies (3)

4

u/what_im_working Jul 16 '12

I hadn't watched the MLS for a while, but coming off the recent Euro, I started to watch it more, and I also noticed the improvement in quality of play.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

I thought I saw the same thing, but when asking others, everyone else thought it was still going nowhere.

I love being able to watch D.C. United without getting bored now :)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Quachyyy Jul 16 '12

I love MLS, especially the academy system because it gives youth in North America hope that they can make it to the 'big leagues'.

On another note: Sounders are gonna go all the way and win their 4th consecutive US Open cup! Go Montero!

2

u/redbeardedone Jul 17 '12

As you've beaten us Soundly I hope you go tear shit up.

112

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

I thoroughly detest American "soccer fans" that hate on the MLS, like it's any worse than most local leagues in Europe or South-America.

It's your fucking league. Yeah, watching top teams in the Champions League square off is great (but often boring as fuck).

I remember a time when English soccer was technically and tactically shite, mostly just kick-and-rush, before all the continental players and coaches came in. But the whole world loved to watch EPL games because it was so fucking entertaining. And so would you lot, if you had been watching EPL at the time.

And most people on the planet would enjoy Timbers vs Sounders more than watching two big Italian team chess-move each other to a boring stale-mate.

So stop all this bitching about the "quality" of the game, and fucking enjoy your own league and support your own teams.

52

u/big_gordo Jul 16 '12

I'm from Wisconsin, a place where most sports fans are extremely loyal to Wisconsin teams and despise all teams from Minnesota and Chicago. My friends and I love soccer, we heavily support our local NPSL team and watch European soccer, but we can't get into the MLS because we don't have a dog in the race. Choosing to support some team from Portland or Philly or Kansas City would just feel fickle and fake. And god damnit I won't support the fucking Chicago fire.

21

u/danvasquez29 Jul 16 '12

I'm the same way from Detroit. My girlfriend is in Chicago and I took her to a Fire game last year because I wanted to check it out. I had a blast and would go again, but choosing a Chicago side as "my team" is just not happening.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/pip89 Jul 16 '12

I'm in the same boat living in North Carolina. It's no man's land in the southeast in terms of MLS teams, so I don't watch MLS.

21

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

dude the railhawks just beat the galaxy!

→ More replies (5)

5

u/stylushappenstance Jul 16 '12

Same thing here. I watch MLS as a neutral occasionally, but I'm not going to watch it a lot until i have a favorite team, and that's not going to happen until there's a team in the southeast, at least in Atlanta, preferably in NC.

On the plus aide, we do have some of the best collegiate teams, and I love going to those games.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Yep I really wish the South East would get a team. If the were good they could become the Atlanta Braves of Soccer. The Braves own the Southeast because they were the only show in town for a long time and were also good for a while.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

I used to love the Milwaukee Rampage and still do love the Wave

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ul49 Jul 16 '12

Same story here in Atlanta. And I can't believe we don't have a team as there's a huge market (evidenced by frequent sell-outs when European teams come on tour) and great facilities.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (26)

77

u/monkertrol Jul 16 '12

"care about things the same way I do!"

13

u/danvasquez29 Jul 16 '12

Here's the thing about the MLS and the US though: only a fraction of us live close enough to have "a team". The closest MLS teams to me are 4 hours drive in any direction. I don't hate on the MLS, i watch it once in awhile when i remember theres a game on and hope the best for the league, but there's no real exposure here or any reason for me to become personally attached to a team.

12

u/pharaohjackson Jul 17 '12

I really want to make it clear that I am in no way shape or form trying to attack you, but I hear this point brought up again and again with soccer fans here in the States and I have to admit I'm baffled by it. How is it that because the nearest MLS teams are "4 hours drive in any direction" that means you can't support them, but you can support a team like Man City that you couldn't reach in a 4 hour flight?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

I would say it's because it's an American city. Think of a how hard it would be for a Houstonian supporting a Dallas team (I know we both have our own teams, just giving an example here). I would rather wait it out until the MLS rather gets a team in my city (assuming it's a major city, that way they have more hope).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

34

u/schneid3306 Jul 16 '12

And I hate American "soccer fans" that look down on those of us who don't watch the MLS and choose to watch other leagues. I learned to love the game while living in London. Due to that, the EPL has always been my primary league. I try to watch some of the big MLS games during the summer to support the league, but once Fulham is back in action my attention is on the EPL/Champions league. I don't see how your fandom is superior to mine simply based on choice of leagues.

33

u/ptfreak Jul 16 '12

I don't think he's saying that his fandom is superior, but if you are an American fan of soccer who believes the game should be bigger here, you absolutely must support the MLS. The EPL or any other foreign league is not the way to get soccer into Americans' hearts. Damn near every game is at 8am Saturday morning, and it would cost you thousands of dollars to go to a game. Diehard fans will be ok with that, but the sport's popularity is built on the casual fan.

If you aren't concerned with the sport's popularity in America, then ignore the MLS. I know it probably sounds like I'm being sarcastic and telling you that you must support the MLS, but I'm not. It's ok to just want to watch the matches and not care if anyone else does. But I doubt many American soccer fans are like that, and the only way to grow the sport here is to support US Soccer in some form.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/Sehs Jul 16 '12

I don't think he looks down at those that don't watch the MLS. I think he's referring to the people that actively put down the MLS as being an inferior league.

13

u/ravniel Jul 16 '12

fucking enjoy your own league and support your own teams.

That sounds to me like we're being told to actively support MLS, not just stop shitting on it. There's a big difference. It's completely fair to tell me I should stop disrespecting someone else's preferred entertainment - not so fair to tell me it's my responsibility to prefer it also.

5

u/ravegreener Jul 16 '12

I try to watch some of the big MLS games during the summer to support the league,

You're not who he's talking about.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/FuckThe Jul 16 '12

So what you're saying is that we must force ourselves to watch something we don't enjoy? Just for the sake of not being judged by people like you?

I watch a few games and I attend a couple of the Chivas USA games when I can, but I wouldn't be able to watch a whole season.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/GuitarWizard90 Jul 16 '12

If the MLS had a relegation/promotion system in place with the lower leagues, then I would be much more interested. It creates a sense of competition and adds meaningfulness to the games. Also, keep in mind that there are not many teams in the MLS and the US is a large country. What that means is most of Americans do not have a local team. Their nearest team could be hundreds of miles from them. So it isn't fair to rail on Americans for not supporting their local team...they probably don't have one unless they live in a large city. They also see all of the big talent playing in other leagues, so it's not much of a mystery to why other leagues appeal to them.

17

u/HAWG Jul 16 '12

This is hard to do when you have owners putting in millions to start a team, You tell them that they start a team and suck for a few years that they will be in a lower league and you will never see MLS take off. I dont believe that style can be used to create a league any more.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (10)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Yeah, watching top teams in the Champions League square off is great (but often boring as fuck).

if you find watching the top teams play a boring experience you may want to try out other sports. this is not a criticism, but if you genuinely don't find CL elite football interesting you'd probably get a lot more enjoyment out of something else.

12

u/danvasquez29 Jul 16 '12

Its interesting if you love the sport and understand the movements but not terribly exciting. the trend lately in big games has been some seriously boring tactical games when teams are on even par. Sometimes you get teams with positive philosophies like arsenal v barcelona last year and it's thrilling, other times you get city v united in last years 0-0 lullaby.

For example: I thought the Spain - Portugal game in the semis was boring a fuck, even in extra time. Same with England - France.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

the champions league is often boring as fuck? what the hell games are you watching.. boring games in the CL are a rarity, not often.

Also stop generalizing to hell, what the hell do you know about "what the rest of the planet" would enjoy? You come across as angry and a bit thick headed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

3

u/BoloPR Jul 16 '12

I agree. I started following Portland and Seattle and they haven't disappointed me. Really entertaining.

10

u/ravegreener Jul 16 '12

what incredibly low expectations did you have, that Portland hasn't disappointed you?

5

u/BoloPR Jul 16 '12

I just started following them and I'm not from Portland. My expectations are to watch an entertaining game of football; they met those expectations. Also it feels better to be a average team and win than a winning team and losing. just my opinion though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Hey just in case anyone missed it, check out Once in a lifetime, last I checked it was on instant on netflix. Pretty cool story and that will show you how far MLS has come as well.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Honestly, and I may be way out of line, MLS reminds me of a less-developed version of the Dutch league. I think the aggressive focus on scoring and attack is similar, and I feel that the MLS will bring more and more talent to the top five european leagues much as the Dutch one does. The fact that teams like Seattle are developing a solid fanbase also shows that we still keep many good players who can entertain the fans in the US. I'm so excited to watch the potential growth of soccer in the US.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/splinked Jul 17 '12

Why is there no Irish team in MLS - that's what I want to see.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

Yes, but the defense in the league still has a loooooooong way to go. Every team is really sloppy at some times.

5

u/taywes18 Jul 16 '12

As a Mexican futbol fan i'm glad the MLS is improving. The quality of play will make the Concachampions better to watch and might give Primera Division teams a real match.

5

u/BengaliBoy Jul 16 '12

I have been really skeptical of the MLS, mainly based off what I hear from other people. Then, I went to an actual game ("The California Clasico") this year, and it totally changed my mind. Honestly, the match was way better than I ever expected. Beckham scored, Donovan scored, an own-goal, yellow cards, a fight broke out, and San Jose even came back from a 1-3 deficit to win it 4-3 at home (even though technically it was played at Stanford stadium).

8

u/spisska Jul 17 '12

For a first game, that was a hell of a match. They're not all like that, but that really is the kind of skill and passion that defines the league.

Try to get to some more. It doesn't take many matches to convince people that it's a damn good way to spend an evening ...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Tourettes_at_best Jul 17 '12

Yeah, I like soccer too.

2

u/4realthistime Jul 16 '12

The few games I've managed to watch hav been very exciting. The scores were much higher than your average (2 MAYBE three goals being the average) but the style of play and dynamics are exciting.

2

u/sacredstones Jul 16 '12

i agree that the finishing has vastly improved. But all in all, i think the tactical level is way behind. I don't understand how the tactics can be so far behind. This goes for defense as well as offense. In terms of technicality, that has improved as well. i just wish teams would exploit the increase of talent and pass the ball smartly.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hldstdy Jul 16 '12

The finishing, especially, is bold, inventive, and technically sophisticated. This point is evidenced by the many long-distance finesse shots, sharp precision headers, and quality long crosses.

Unfortunately, with the growing technical ability of young Americans and those snatched up from Central & South America, MLS is now suffering from a very, very obvious defending problem.

See: the comical defending from this week's Galaxy match.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Chicago1871 Jul 17 '12

Each year it gets a little bit better. The new crop of young American kids replace the old cloggers who have a lot of heart, but not a lot of skill.

I can't think of many leagues where you can say that, I almost feel like a proud pappa and I've only watched the league since 06. I can't imagine what it's like for the people who've stuck by it since 96 and can remember the dark ages of the 80's and early 90s. They must be ecstatic.

5

u/spisska Jul 17 '12

We are.

I saw the Diplomats play at RFK back in the old NASL days. Granted, I was too young then to know a whole lot, but I certainly thought it was a mighty good show.

Then ... nothing. There simply wasn't any pro or international soccer at all in the US between 1984 and '94 World Cup. The local PBS station (run by American University) showed the NCAA final the year American made it, but other than that I don't recall seeing a single game before the '94 WC.

But the '94 WC was a watershed. Few people here are old enough to really appreciate what it did for the sport in the US.

One of the things the US committed to in order to get the WC was forming a real pro league. That league is MLS, and they started in 1996.

I went to a DC United game in 1997, and had a brilliant time. But all the same, it was clear that the level of play back then left a little something ...

You can't argue with numbers, though. The 1994 World Cup set all kinds of attendance records, and TV broadcasts for every major international tournament since have been more comprehensive and more watched. Since 2004, every match of the WC and the Euro has been broadcast live in the US.

The thing is that Americans get and love the international game. They (we) have not yet embraced the club game.

But this is changing. You won't hear about it on ESPN, and you won't read about it in the local US paper.

But go to an MLS match an hour or two before kickoff, and you'll see things I never saw growing up -- people just kicking a ball in a parking lot for fun, discussing league news, making fun of opposing supporters, and just preparing themselves to sing, shout, and stomp in support of their boys.

Only the most delusional will say that MLS is a top league. And that doesn't matter. It's the top league here, it's getting better every day, and it's a damn good show.

My theory is that ESPN and the papers don't cover it because they're scared of it. Sportswriter is a job that far more people want than have, and you get to be sportswriter by knowing baseball, basketball, and football. To the point of knowing who the local high-school prospects are.

This, also, is changing.

I'd be curious to look back on this thread five years from now. Because five years ago, I wouldn't have thought that MLS by now would be drawing more people per game than the NBA.

I don't think promotion/relegation will be any more desirable or feasible in five years than it is now.

And I also think by then we will have heard a lot more stories about clubs in Europe collapsing from unsustainable business practices. Or: The collapse of Rangers is not a statement about the past, it's a hint of what's to come.

I could go on, but this is long enough already.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/AC-M Jul 17 '12 edited Jul 17 '12

Have to agree 100%, better youth coaching from euro technique will make a big difference. Living in Florida I know their are a lot of good youth academy's, and even though their isn't an MLS team Orlando city soccer has been dominating in it's first/2nd season as a team. I'd be happy to see them get moved to MLS somehow and maybe a team in Miami too.

Edit: I know MLS has had Miami Fusion / Tampa Mutiny, but those were over 10 years ago. I would like to see an MLS team here now.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TheFox51 Jul 17 '12

much better! im actually a fan of the timbers and the sounders..... and im from Los Angeles... and in Mexican. before i wouldnt be caught watching the mls..... but i gotta say its changing and growing quickly and for the better

2

u/rabbitvinyl Jul 17 '12

No love for Canadian MLS teams? Surely we've helped build the sport across America as well!

19

u/EnderMB Jul 16 '12

Most people on this subreddit seem to be oblivious to just how good MLS actually is. I often read about how football in England or Spain is much better, but to be frank I think the better MLS teams could give a good account for themselves in La Liga or the Premier League.

I often read on here that MLS is equivalent to League 1 in England, but as someone that watches the Championship I think the level of play in MLS is probably better. The one thing that MLS seems to lack is real defensive talent and diversity in tactics.

The reason why we see such great goals in MLS is because the defending is often terrible. A team built on a rock-solid defense would probably do very well in MLS, and I hope that this is something that a team decides to build within the league.

Finally, I really want to see a team try to build a Arsenal/Barcelona type approach in the league. It's the lack of this type of football that makes people believe that MLS is a poor league, and the simple inclusion of an idealistic manager with a possession-based mindset could turn the league upside down.

51

u/DerpSalad Jul 16 '12

as someone that watches the Championship I think the level of play in MLS is probably better

I watch both as often as possible and I have to disagree. Championship defences are a lot stronger in my opinion and I think the majority of MLS teams would struggle for this reason alone across a full season in the Championship, never mind the Premiership.

That's not to belittle the MLS. Just my opinion.

7

u/EnderMB Jul 16 '12

I agree that defensively they are on another level, but outside of a select few teams I would say that they are pretty even in regards to their attacking options. There are also a lot more games in the Championship than MLS so it's hard to really judge.

4

u/DerpSalad Jul 16 '12

Yep I'll agree with that.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12 edited Jul 16 '12

San Jose this year is built on fantastic defense, but they lost their rock (Bernardez) early in the season to injury. He returned a few games ago and they've landed two shutouts since. If their starting four are healthy (Beitashour, Bernardez, Hernandez, and Morrow), their defense as is as good as their fantastic offense (40 goals in 20 games). They're honestly the best MLS team I've seen in the 3 years I've been watching.

6

u/Bulseye6 Jul 16 '12

Such a drastic turnaround from last year, this team is so much fun to watch.

6

u/laxed Jul 16 '12

yea, go quakes!

(sorry, i just wanted to say something..)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/CACuzcatlan Jul 16 '12

A team built on a rock-solid defense would probably do very well in MLS, and I hope that this is something that a team decides to build within the league.

That's pretty much how the LA Galaxy won the Supporters Shield (regular season most points) and MLS Cup last year. Then we lost our best defender to injury and everything went to shit.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Nokel Jul 16 '12

The MLS and J League are both growing at the same rate, and it truly is awesome to watch.

29

u/Buelldozer Jul 16 '12

"The one thing that MLS seems to lack is real defensive talent and diversity in tactics.'

I agree and do you know why I think that is? I think it's because American Soccer Coaches are far too focused on the offense!

My son, 12, is an adroit defensive player. He's been playing at the club level since 8 with the same group of boys. They are the current state champions for their age group and many of the same boys also make up the ODP team for the state. I've spent hundreds of hours watching them practice and play. I even coached most of them from age 4 through age 8 when they left recreational league play.

We've been to tournaments throughout the region and the one thing I see everywhere is absolutely lousy defense. I mean just horrible horrible defense. Keepers that consistently make shit decisions, defenders that don't know how to delay and contain (or jockey), defenders passing the ball across the goal, terrible goal kicks, coaches that try and play man defense with slow of foot defenders, etc.

We totally and completely -snack- on teams like this. We eat 'em up like goldfish crackers, run them into the ground, break them, and then score at will.

Yet, and yet, even on a team like ours with a phenomenal defense it's -still- the forwards and midfielders that get all the glory! It's maddening! At the end of June we traveled to another state in our region and defeated the #1 and #2 teams in that state by 4 - 0 margins. You can't do that with poor defense and yet...

Offense gets all the credit for those four goals but without a stonewall defense, including the keeper, we still may have lost. Nobody, and I mean nobody, wins consistently without solid and consistent defense so why is it that so many American Soccer coaches treat it like an afterthought?!

This post is getting pretty long so I"ll forgo listing what I think makes a proper defense but you know one when you see it in action and many U.S. Soccer teams at the club level need a serious overhaul in their thinking, their training, and their execution!

4

u/danvasquez29 Jul 16 '12

I think that's because of the mentality of the kids and leagues treating soccer as just a reason to get the kids some excersize in the summer. They place too emphasis on making sure everyone is having fun and being included, and most 7 year olds arent going to find keeping a defensive line very fun.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/wjbc Jul 16 '12

As a coach of 9 and 10 year olds who will be coaching 11 and 12 year olds next year, I would really like to know more about what makes a proper defense. One of the problems is that many of the coaches in our league (including me) are parents who did not grow up playing soccer. I do the best I can, but I'm learning as I go.

8

u/Buelldozer Jul 17 '12

Good question!

A good defense starts with trust. The defense has to trust one another, be trusted by the Offense, and everyone has to trust the keeper. Otherwise alllllllllll the kids try and swarm the ball and that's bad defense.

In a proper defense one defender will delay and contain while the others move to the side most likely to receive a pass and and least one more defender will move behind the one delaying and containing. Additionally ALL defenders should be using body position and physicality to move the ball towards a sideline. You absolutely do not want the ball anywhere near the center of the field. By this time the midfielders should be involved by blocking passes and attempting to take the ball.

Another key element of proper defense is consistently making good decisions. NO passing across the front of the goal, kicking the ball out of play when over-pressured or over-matched, passing TO a team mate instead of "boom-balling" out into space.

The defense should also attempt to push up to center field as much as possible and when practical. No loitering around the box with Keeper. If the other team has a "leg" that is kicking the ball deep then the D should sink to roughly the back of the arc and work forward instead of trying to fade back. Try and force the other team into offsides position. Teach your players to resist the temptation to fade back as the offense is pushing up. The opposing offense CANNOT receive a pass if they're standing offsides! Oh, and drill drill drill your offense to keep a consistent formation, typically a straight line, you don't want one kid standing 5 yards behind the rest. It will take a lot of reinforcement but they will eventually get it.

Keeper, the keeper needs to make good decisions and CONSISTENT decision. If they're going to come out and challenge then they commit to that action so the D knows that one of them, usually the closest, needs to sweep in behind and make sure nothing goes in the goal.

Your Keeper should also be positioning their Defense on the field and the D should be ready and willing to take those directions. The keeper should be yelling a lot when the ball is on his half of the field.

Along with all of this your midfielders / forwards need to understand their positions. Our boys spent a long time learning that the Defense needs someone to pass to when they've taken the ball and if the M and O are all loitering around the box then they can't get the ball forward to the opposing half.

Other things of note: Train your keeper to always kick or roll out to the side. The keeper should never roll out when the receiving player is under pressure. Train your keeper to only challenge if they think they can beat the play, otherwise they should stay home. If your keeper has a weak leg allow another player, a defender, to make the goal kicks for now. A weak GK starts play with terrible field position and puts too much pressure on too quick. That ball needs to fly and preferably to an M or O downfield.

Teach your defense to give your keeper room to work! I can't count the number of goals I've seen where the keeper could have blocked the ball...if he could have seen it! Teach your keeper to call his ball, teach your Defense to call keeper ball and then make them run their balls (or boobs) off if they disrespect each others calls.

Make sure your team plays as a team and don't let them fall into the trap of bickering with each other about who did what wrong. Soccer is a team sport and without a team working together the results won't be as good as they should be. Ask the French!

Uhhh, this turned into a stream of consciousness novel. I'll stop here.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/Otracervezaporfavor Jul 16 '12

Toronto FC tried the possession-based thing, and it didn't work out too well, however had the circumstances been different (i.e. cohesive management rather than several twats wanting to go in different directions), along with a solid defense, then the results could have been much better. One thing the management has gotten right so far though is the academy set up.

However I still agree with you, I'm just pointing out that the Arsenal/Barca approach is difficult to replicate.

16

u/denMAR Jul 16 '12

Agreed. Also, something about having 7 managers in 6 seasons feels unsettling to me.

19

u/seemylolface Jul 16 '12

Wow you guys are almost keeping up with Chelsea in the manager count!

6

u/TimothyThomas Jul 16 '12

I really think Ben Olsen, if he can be given many years on the project, has in mind a high-pressing possession game. Some of DC's better players really excel at this and I think things look good for the future. There are other teams who seem to be hinting at this approach, but of course, the technical ability of two-four players can't make up for the whole team, and thusly, possession gets lost quicker than these coaches would hope for.

5

u/moonty Jul 16 '12

A number of factors play into 'turning the league upside down,' but there's more of a possession-based mindset than you might think. I'm quite biased, but Real Salt Lake is exactly what you're looking for. Guardiola-esque? Well, no. That's the product of a long, long process involving an academy system that produces players that understand the system.

But if you're looking for a team that, under most circumstances, plays the ball on the ground, looks for the pass, and is generally quite successful with it, look at Jason Kreis's RSL side. Defensively, we're usually (ugh) very strong, the last five weeks or so excepted. We build from there. It may be a relatively 'unsophisticated' 4-4-2 (nuanced with two box-to-box midfielders instead of wide midfielders) but that shouldn't be more than a passing concern.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

As a Coventry fan the championship is below most leagues. I've played better park football than some of the tripe I've paid to watch

23

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

As a Coventry fan

There's your problem, not the Championship ;)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Hey, one season outside the top two leagues in over 40 years, some teams would dream of such a record.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/yourwhiteshadow Jul 16 '12

all valid points that i strongly agree with, but none more so than the last point. this sport is about entertainment, the leagues that are perceived to be the best are also the most popular, because they are the more entertaining leagues.

13

u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Jul 16 '12

MLS teams can barelly win CONCACAF Champions League (2 times, last one 12 years ago) and you want to compare MLS to the Premier league?

Please, don't think too high of yourselves.

9

u/EnderMB Jul 16 '12

MLS teams can barelly win CONCACAF Champions League (2 times, last one 12 years ago) and you want to compare MLS to the Premier league?

Do teams even care about the CONCACAF Champions League? Last time I checked MLS teams were sending mostly reserves to those games when they disrupted the league calendar.

Please, don't think too high of yourselves.

I'm English (hence the Bristol City crest), and I watch enough Championship football to know that MLS is of a similar standard.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/SomeCruzDude Jul 16 '12

The San Jose Earthquakes are probably the closest thing to that "rock solid defense" model. They're starting back four consists of Justin Morrow, a speedy left back, Jason Hernandez a Quakes vet and great central defender (got save of the week last week as a matter of fact) Victor Bernardez, a rock...should win newcomer of the year. World Cup vet that some people were skeptical about the Quakes signing. Finally up and coming Steven Beitashour. He is pretty good defensively and is second on the team in assists...he apparently is already closing in on the career record for assists for any MLS defender.

All of this paired with an amazing offense (41 goals in 20 games), a super striker (Chris Wondolowski has lead MLS in scoring for the 3rd year now, he's looking to destroy the current MLS single season scoring record of 27), and a great midfield makes for entertaining and fun soccer. I can't wait to see them in CONCACAF Champion's League next year (knock on wood) because they have a defense that I think can finally win an MLS team the competition.

2

u/doctorthinker Jul 17 '12

If you think that the MLS teams can compete with the teams in Europe that means that the mexican teams definitely can.

2

u/dfjuky Jul 17 '12

but to be frank I think the better MLS teams could give a good account for themselves in La Liga or the Premier League.

No, just no. What a laughable statement. It's cool that you enjoy your domestic league but don't ever convince yourself that the MLS is anywhere near the standards of the big European leagues nor will it ever be.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/warpus Jul 16 '12

Finally, I really want to see a team try to build a Arsenal/Barcelona type approach in the league. It's the lack of this type of football that makes people believe that MLS is a poor league, and the simple inclusion of an idealistic manager with a possession-based mindset could turn the league upside down.

The salary cap would prevent a team from acquiring the players necessary to play like that.

7

u/ravniel Jul 16 '12

What about Swansea? Martinez and Rodgers built a possession-based team on a fairly modest budget. Playing that kind of football requires targeted player acquisition, but it needn't necessarily be expensive player acquisition.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/EnderMB Jul 16 '12

Why? Blackpool manage to play entertaining football that won them a lot of fans in the Championship and the Premier League with very little investment.

Yes, it could mean poor results, but over time I reckon a MLS team could build an effective system without amazing talent and the fans will appreciate them for it.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (18)

3

u/RXkings Jul 16 '12

as a philadelphia union supporter: we're getting there. definitely getting there.

when the current old heads like donovan and co. get into coaching roles it's going to improve tenfold as well.

9

u/jamesey10 Jul 16 '12

If you have local soccer around you and you don't go, you're not a soccer fan. That goes for any sport.

10

u/iamsodaft Jul 16 '12

I am going to have to disagree with you. What if your life just does not allow you to attend local matches? What if you are a single mother working two jobs (and there are many of these type of people, my mother being one for some years in the past) and your tight schedule just does not allow you to go to the local Tampa Bay Rowdies matches? Yet you have your friends text you updates about the game while you're at one of your two jobs and you try to hold back your cheers when you get a text that says "Goal Rowdies!!!". And you're able to catch a stream of the games online as much as possible when you're doing the dishes or waiting for dinner to be cooked while you wear your green, macaroni and cheese-stained Rowdies shirt that your friend James bought for you as a birthday gift. You look up game highlights on the computer at work the next day when you're supposed to be calling people, trying to get them to buy your company's refrigerators.

Are you not a fan?

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/jamesey10 Jul 16 '12

so why not go to DCFC? You can still go and drink and support your team.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/quantumcatz Jul 16 '12

As an Australian who wishes I could say they say thing about my league....I couldn't agree more and I'm extremely jealous.

FUCK YOU.

...sorry about that.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

It's sad right? When our 'big name' signing was Harry Kewell, who is now being chased by Swindon Town...

5

u/searage Jul 16 '12

I think its structure is the main obstacle here, why go against the league format thats been so successful everywhere else in the world?

19

u/kuyakew Jul 16 '12

because without it, MLS would not have survived as long as it has. we'll get rid of it someday.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/diabloblanco Jul 16 '12

Which structure are you referring to? I think it's only a matter of time until a salary cap comes to euro leagues. The unbalanced schedule is a demonic necessity due to the size of the US (close geographic rivals, Portland and Vancouver, are further apart than the farthest teams in the EPL). Pro/Rel likely will never come, but is simulated in post-season tournaments (playoffs reward winners).

3

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Structure - franchised teams, revenue sharing (ie rewarding teams that aren't successful in order to keep a whole league stable), draft priority for poor team performance, playoffs etc. I don't know the economics of the MLS so I don't know exactly how apt the comparison is, but I'd assume its pretty close.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (25)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

As a longtime fan, it feels like its still just starting to turn the corner. They've done a good job in recent seasons in bringing in enough foreign talent to keep the games watchable.

But youth development and the poor quality of the officiating are two big question marks still.

2

u/djaccidentz Jul 16 '12

I think the absolute biggest downside to American football is the goalkeeping, which is perhaps why the majority of DPs are generally forwards.

Another aspect that I think could improve the MLS is if they teamed up the with lower divisions and created a tier-level league system. Even just to start, have only one or two teams being relegated and promoted. I think it would bring forth more competitive spirit across the nation and increase also, the awareness of the sport. The problem with that, I think is, at the moment they don't have quite enough 'professional' clubs of the kind of stature they are looking for. This is America, one of the mottos is: Think Big (although it may secretly also be 'eat big.') The problem is, that can get out of hand quickly, as their is a common trend in America to spend more than is actually available, on only a whim or a mere speculation, rather than on proven fact and/or appropriate analysis on the investment. There have been other leagues in the past that have failed and many teams have gone bankrupt quickly, not just in football/soccer, but it quite a few sports.

Also, the MLS is competing with the NBA, NHL, MLB and NFL, among other sports, and each of these leagues have been around for many more years then the MLS. The MLS was created in 1993, mostly to help improve the US bid to host the 1994 World Cup, which worked btw.

I am an MLS fan and I do agree, it is improving. There have been some incredibly exciting games this year and the offensive aspects have been increasing, with more creativity and sophistication being present. I hope it see it continue upward and give clubs in Europe a genuine run for their money. It would be nice to see us also provide true competitive on the International level as well. We can all dream can't we xD

→ More replies (1)

2

u/roxya Jul 16 '12

You always get ridiculous goals in lesser leagues (e.g. the lower English leagues) due to awful defending.

2

u/B0M85H311 Jul 16 '12 edited Jul 24 '12

There's no doubt the MLS game is climbing in quality, I for one believe with the pure population and interest in competitive sport in america, the MLS will be the biggest league in the world at some point (probably quite a long time away yet), and just so you know I'm not bias, I am english.

2

u/evilmilhouse Jul 16 '12

agreed. the league is still so very young compared to those across the world. I think that most teams are still sharing nfl stadiums, if most of them can get there own (like Portland), something small and upclose like the English stadiums this will help the league become more popular. You can see it with the Portland fans constantly singing right now thats the only stadium i would love to go see a game at because the atmosphere is amazing!

6

u/CorbenW Jul 16 '12

Actually only 4 mls teams dont have a soccer specific stadium right now. These are DC United, Seattle sounders, New England Revolution, and San Jose Earthquakes. Seattle is perfectly fine with their stadium and the Earthquakes are building their own as we speak so it's not really that big of a problem.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/MuckBulligan Jul 16 '12

Portland's is a converted baseball stadium. It's nice, but we need more seats. Every MLS match is sold out before the season starts.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/stonyninja Jul 16 '12

Wando is a stud for real.

2

u/twohourstillweekend Jul 16 '12

I understand we're having MLS or American Footballplayer related Threads up on the Frontpage on a regular Basis. And very often they seem rather meaningless or oversensationalist. See Bradley or this, supposed to be, 'Great pass' by some Kansas player that turned out to be an average assist.

I understand the urge of you guys discussing the developments and events of the wonderfull game in your country. I know I'm priviliged by just having to go 20 Meters to a bar, to School or to Work where I can talk about it all day long.

But my dear American friends: You're not alone on this page. And oppinions that you don't like because they see the developments less enthusiastic or even critical might be valid. Downvoting them just because they see the situation from a different perspective is just bad taste and results in this sub becoming a bigger circlejerk than it already is.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Futfanatico Jul 16 '12

Midfield play has also gotten loads better - no more long balls from defenders to corner flags! Well, less of them at least.

1

u/TheElPistolero Jul 16 '12

Can someone look up the actual percentage of Americans playing in the MLS? Sure the play might be looking up, but their are more foreign imports in it than ever. Good for the MLS, neutral for Team USA

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Digapony49 Jul 17 '12

Canada has a lot of foreigners and is very multi-cultural Foreigners love the soccer. Cha-Ching.

1

u/flea61 Jul 17 '12

I'm going to the Galaxy-Tottenham game during the All-Star Break (No Donovan or Beckham for LA, but Gonzalez and Keane will probably play, right?). I vow to watch the rest of the season if they perform well against Spurs.

1

u/cliffordbeshers Jul 17 '12

Another mark of the league's growth: I care who wins and loses, most games. I have my heroes and villains. I'll root for the heroes as long as they aren't playing my home team. And there are teams I hate regardless of how I might respect their abilities. Anyone who takes down SKC gets a cheer from me, for instance. And any time Sideshow Bob gets tackled from behind, I quietly mutter that he deserved it.

1

u/mackinder Jul 17 '12

you haven't been watching TFC games then. ughhhhh

1

u/cclurve Jul 17 '12

I agree, especially with the interest being shown in the MLS from abroad. My little brother may end up with the chance to move over and do soccer schools and study in the US, which is a massive boost seeing that years ago people wouldn't have had these opportunities and would have to find a way into coaching experience.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12

This inspires me to support my city's MLS team :)

-12

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

Why do we have these "America has arrived" discussions every fucking week? The league is average and improving, we know. If I was a European on this forum, I'd be really annoyed seeing these discussions all the time when we never talk about the Belgian, Polish, Greek, or Swiss leagues, which are all comparable to the shithouse MLS. Same with the Dempsey circlejerk. Decent player, yes. Good enough to warrant 5 of his own transfer update threads every day, not at all.

6

u/Vinxhe Jul 16 '12

The only good thing about the Swiss League is the FC Basel. This season one team got relegated for going bancrupt after an apparently rich guy bought the club. Another club got a penalty of 36 points after they used players they werent allowed to use (... after beating Celtic Glasgow in the 3rd Quali round for the EL).

Basel won the Championship by like 20 points and the relegations got decided before half of the season was over.

This season was the saddest thing I have ever seen in a teamsport.

There, now you know it all. Now lets never again talk of it.

3

u/throwawaysmoker Jul 16 '12

You said it yourself, it's an american website.

31

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12 edited Jul 16 '12

Yeah me neither, it really interests me reading about football from the American perspective. I even watched a bit of Portland v LA Galaxy on TV yesterday. Seems about the same level as the Championship.

→ More replies (11)

-4

u/TerryPhelan Jul 16 '12 edited Jul 16 '12

Watched maybe seven or eight games out of curiosity. Thought the standard was pretty shit. Worse than I expected to be honest. I hope it gets better. It would be great for football. But let's face it it's pretty bad at the moment. Bad is maybe the wrong word. These things take time.

EDIT: It was an expression of opinion. This is probably the most ignorant subreddit in all of reddit.

10

u/RabbaJabba Jul 16 '12

This is probably the most ignorant subreddit in all of reddit.

you haven't been on many subreddits, have you

4

u/axolotlolol Jul 16 '12

You can't say anything bad about the MLS in this subreddit, which is a very sad disregard of rediquette.