r/soccer • • Jul 16 '12
It has come to my attention that the MLS is changing. For the better.
For the first time in 6 years, I've watched the majority of this MLS season and I must say, the style of play has improved dramatically during that span.
No, it doesn't boast the same cohesive, tactical buildup play of La Liga and other European leagues. No, it's not about to start churning out loads of international superstars that can compete on the world cup stage.
However, I must admit, certain aspects of the American game shows signs of stark improvement. The finishing, especially, is bold, inventive, and technically sophisticated. This point is evidenced by the many long-distance finesse shots, sharp precision headers, and quality long crosses.
In short, I honestly believe the US is on its way...
47
u/TimothyThomas Jul 16 '12
I agree, and think that it is also evidenced by the plethora of playing styles teams are approaching with. You've got your stoke-like teams, booting the ball, the smash and grab teams like LA galaxy, stocked with talent but forgoing build up play in favor of chance after chance, and teams like DC who continue to opt for (IF they can dictate the game) a passing/possession game. I think that it shows even lower-level players and coaches can have ingenuity and tactical awareness on a game-by-game basis....
84
u/Hencher27 Jul 16 '12
Love the points you made and agree with pretty will everything you said BUT..."American game", "US is on its way" is implying that this is an American domestic league when its not at all. The three Canadian teams in this league all have incredible support which exceeds some teams from the below the border. Just had to add that in.
382
u/CircleTheFire Jul 16 '12
Most of the big leagues world wide have been around for a hundred years or more, literally. MLS has been around for 17. The top young athletes in those countries go into soccer almost exclusively. In the US, there's football(American rules), baseball, basketball, and hockey to compete with. Most of the top leagues around the world are in close proximity to each other, so there is lots of crossover competition, player movement, and community. The US is really only in close proximity to the Mexican leagues.
That MLS has come so far in such a short time is amazing.
60
u/ibpants Jul 16 '12
There is improvement, but these long distance goals you speak of are mostly down to midfielders shirking their defensive responsibilities and allowing too much space to open up around 25-35 yards out.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
What is also important to note that not all of MLS teams are making the improvements you observe. There is a clear difference between the mob-soccer teams and the more advanced teams. I feel like an outsider's opinion of the league will weigh heavily upon the match up they watched.
42
u/cjschlos Jul 16 '12
You may not be aware but MLS is now 7th in the world in attendance
ATTENDANCE FOR WORLD’S TOP PRO SOCCER LEAGUES Top 10 leagues are as of the last 30 days (updated July 10, 2012) Sources are ESPN Soccernet and worldfootball.net
Bundesliga (GER): 45,726 (as of end of 2011/12 season)
Premier League (ENG): 34,601 (as of end of 2011/12 season) La Liga (ESP): 30,272 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Primera Division (MEX): 25,288 (as of end of 2011/12 Clausura season) Serie A (ITA): 23,459 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Eredivisie (NED): 19,516 (as of end of 2011/12 season) MAJOR LEAGUE SOCCER (USA): 18,851 (as of July 10, 2012) Ligue 1 (FRA): 18,665 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Coca-Cola Championship (ENG2): 18,824 (as of end of 2011/12 season) Chinese Super League (CHN): 18,242 (as of June 29)
18
u/ceruleancity Jul 16 '12
I think the MLS would improve significantly if we got some more non-American coaches/managers. Almost all coaches/managers in MLS played in MLS and in my opinion some international influence would make a huge difference in the quality of play.
9
u/Kazan Jul 16 '12
I also agree - i love soccer and i couldn't watch MLS circa 1998-2002
16
u/cliffordbeshers Jul 16 '12
I've had exactly the same reaction. Five years ago, a random game looked like high school ball: everybody needed four touches to control a pass and by that time they were surrounded. I watched Montreal play this weekend and it's clear that adding a player like Di Vaio changes the way the other players think. You can see them trying to solve the puzzles of where the passing lanes are, but they are really still guessing and even when they get it right, just can't quite do it fast enough. But they clearly know what they are missing. Add in Nesta, whose presence in training has apparently already had a huge impact on the other players, and in a month I expect Montreal will be playing a very different game.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
All these MLS debates make me want to watch the MLS haha (I'm not American)
17
u/tmh8901 Jul 16 '12
The next step is having MLS become a strong enough league that American players will want to stay and not want to go to Europe for more experience and money.
6
u/3THMANOL Jul 16 '12
Its improving... but it will not be the second big thing... bundesluga will be the real deal in few years... world class league...
6
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
I support RSL (live in Idaho, it's the closest team) but I really don't see the problem with supporting a team that's not in your city if one isn't there. I've read lots of comments about people saying they don't support the MLS because they don't have a local team. I've got no local teams that are in my state. But i've found MLB, NHL, and NFL teams I support. If there's not a team in your area, find a team you like. Even if it's not local. Because supporting an EPL team if you live in Iowa sure as hell isn't local.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12
As a Mexican fanatic of soccer, I am slightly jealous at the fast pace that American soccer is growing, at this pace, their national team will reach the World Cup Championship first than Mexico's team. Its the good kind of jealousy though, glad to see them grow.
5
u/Sacoud Jul 16 '12
I thought this would be about Kenny Miller signing for Vancouver...
5
u/ArmchairPhysicist Jul 17 '12
I always make it a point to watch MLS when I can. Leagues grow with support, you can't ignore your local clubs and then bitch when they're struggling to reach the level of European leagues.
17
u/chrishamer09 Jul 16 '12
Love watching MLS compared to big leagues sometimes because honestly all teams have a fighting chance..If you watch La Liga...the only teams that have a chance are Real Madrid and Barca......Fucking Boring.
8
u/theswanqueen Jul 17 '12
Bravery levels off the charts itt
4
u/Joelico Jul 16 '12
I am really glad this is happening, sometimes I feel like I don't get enough soccer and MLS is a great addition to the leagues I watch
4
u/what_im_working Jul 16 '12
I hadn't watched the MLS for a while, but coming off the recent Euro, I started to watch it more, and I also noticed the improvement in quality of play.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12
I thought I saw the same thing, but when asking others, everyone else thought it was still going nowhere.
I love being able to watch D.C. United without getting bored now :)
7
u/Quachyyy Jul 16 '12
I love MLS, especially the academy system because it gives youth in North America hope that they can make it to the 'big leagues'.
On another note: Sounders are gonna go all the way and win their 4th consecutive US Open cup! Go Montero!
112
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
I thoroughly detest American "soccer fans" that hate on the MLS, like it's any worse than most local leagues in Europe or South-America.
It's your fucking league. Yeah, watching top teams in the Champions League square off is great (but often boring as fuck).
I remember a time when English soccer was technically and tactically shite, mostly just kick-and-rush, before all the continental players and coaches came in. But the whole world loved to watch EPL games because it was so fucking entertaining. And so would you lot, if you had been watching EPL at the time.
And most people on the planet would enjoy Timbers vs Sounders more than watching two big Italian team chess-move each other to a boring stale-mate.
So stop all this bitching about the "quality" of the game, and fucking enjoy your own league and support your own teams.
3
u/BoloPR Jul 16 '12
I agree. I started following Portland and Seattle and they haven't disappointed me. Really entertaining.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
Hey just in case anyone missed it, check out Once in a lifetime, last I checked it was on instant on netflix. Pretty cool story and that will show you how far MLS has come as well.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
Honestly, and I may be way out of line, MLS reminds me of a less-developed version of the Dutch league. I think the aggressive focus on scoring and attack is similar, and I feel that the MLS will bring more and more talent to the top five european leagues much as the Dutch one does. The fact that teams like Seattle are developing a solid fanbase also shows that we still keep many good players who can entertain the fans in the US. I'm so excited to watch the potential growth of soccer in the US.
3
u/splinked Jul 17 '12
Why is there no Irish team in MLS - that's what I want to see.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12
Yes, but the defense in the league still has a loooooooong way to go. Every team is really sloppy at some times.
3
u/Francomilano19 Jul 17 '12
Yes it is
5
u/taywes18 Jul 16 '12
As a Mexican futbol fan i'm glad the MLS is improving. The quality of play will make the Concachampions better to watch and might give Primera Division teams a real match.
5
u/BengaliBoy Jul 16 '12
I have been really skeptical of the MLS, mainly based off what I hear from other people. Then, I went to an actual game ("The California Clasico") this year, and it totally changed my mind. Honestly, the match was way better than I ever expected. Beckham scored, Donovan scored, an own-goal, yellow cards, a fight broke out, and San Jose even came back from a 1-3 deficit to win it 4-3 at home (even though technically it was played at Stanford stadium).
5
u/Tourettes_at_best Jul 17 '12
Yeah, I like soccer too.
2
u/4realthistime Jul 16 '12
The few games I've managed to watch hav been very exciting. The scores were much higher than your average (2 MAYBE three goals being the average) but the style of play and dynamics are exciting.
2
u/sacredstones Jul 16 '12
i agree that the finishing has vastly improved. But all in all, i think the tactical level is way behind. I don't understand how the tactics can be so far behind. This goes for defense as well as offense. In terms of technicality, that has improved as well. i just wish teams would exploit the increase of talent and pass the ball smartly.
2
u/hldstdy Jul 16 '12
Unfortunately, with the growing technical ability of young Americans and those snatched up from Central & South America, MLS is now suffering from a very, very obvious defending problem.
See: the comical defending from this week's Galaxy match.
2
u/Chicago1871 Jul 17 '12
Each year it gets a little bit better. The new crop of young American kids replace the old cloggers who have a lot of heart, but not a lot of skill.
I can't think of many leagues where you can say that, I almost feel like a proud pappa and I've only watched the league since 06. I can't imagine what it's like for the people who've stuck by it since 96 and can remember the dark ages of the 80's and early 90s. They must be ecstatic.
2
u/AC-M Jul 17 '12 edited Jul 17 '12
Have to agree 100%, better youth coaching from euro technique will make a big difference. Living in Florida I know their are a lot of good youth academy's, and even though their isn't an MLS team Orlando city soccer has been dominating in it's first/2nd season as a team. I'd be happy to see them get moved to MLS somehow and maybe a team in Miami too.
Edit: I know MLS has had Miami Fusion / Tampa Mutiny, but those were over 10 years ago. I would like to see an MLS team here now.
2
u/TheFox51 Jul 17 '12
much better! im actually a fan of the timbers and the sounders..... and im from Los Angeles... and in Mexican. before i wouldnt be caught watching the mls..... but i gotta say its changing and growing quickly and for the better
2
u/rabbitvinyl Jul 17 '12
No love for Canadian MLS teams? Surely we've helped build the sport across America as well!
19
u/EnderMB Jul 16 '12
Most people on this subreddit seem to be oblivious to just how good MLS actually is. I often read about how football in England or Spain is much better, but to be frank I think the better MLS teams could give a good account for themselves in La Liga or the Premier League.
I often read on here that MLS is equivalent to League 1 in England, but as someone that watches the Championship I think the level of play in MLS is probably better. The one thing that MLS seems to lack is real defensive talent and diversity in tactics.
The reason why we see such great goals in MLS is because the defending is often terrible. A team built on a rock-solid defense would probably do very well in MLS, and I hope that this is something that a team decides to build within the league.
Finally, I really want to see a team try to build a Arsenal/Barcelona type approach in the league. It's the lack of this type of football that makes people believe that MLS is a poor league, and the simple inclusion of an idealistic manager with a possession-based mindset could turn the league upside down.
3
u/RXkings Jul 16 '12
as a philadelphia union supporter: we're getting there. definitely getting there.
when the current old heads like donovan and co. get into coaching roles it's going to improve tenfold as well.
9
u/jamesey10 Jul 16 '12
If you have local soccer around you and you don't go, you're not a soccer fan. That goes for any sport.
4
u/quantumcatz Jul 16 '12
As an Australian who wishes I could say they say thing about my league....I couldn't agree more and I'm extremely jealous.
FUCK YOU.
...sorry about that.
5
u/searage Jul 16 '12
I think its structure is the main obstacle here, why go against the league format thats been so successful everywhere else in the world?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
As a longtime fan, it feels like its still just starting to turn the corner. They've done a good job in recent seasons in bringing in enough foreign talent to keep the games watchable.
But youth development and the poor quality of the officiating are two big question marks still.
2
u/djaccidentz Jul 16 '12
I think the absolute biggest downside to American football is the goalkeeping, which is perhaps why the majority of DPs are generally forwards.
Another aspect that I think could improve the MLS is if they teamed up the with lower divisions and created a tier-level league system. Even just to start, have only one or two teams being relegated and promoted. I think it would bring forth more competitive spirit across the nation and increase also, the awareness of the sport. The problem with that, I think is, at the moment they don't have quite enough 'professional' clubs of the kind of stature they are looking for. This is America, one of the mottos is: Think Big (although it may secretly also be 'eat big.') The problem is, that can get out of hand quickly, as their is a common trend in America to spend more than is actually available, on only a whim or a mere speculation, rather than on proven fact and/or appropriate analysis on the investment. There have been other leagues in the past that have failed and many teams have gone bankrupt quickly, not just in football/soccer, but it quite a few sports.
Also, the MLS is competing with the NBA, NHL, MLB and NFL, among other sports, and each of these leagues have been around for many more years then the MLS. The MLS was created in 1993, mostly to help improve the US bid to host the 1994 World Cup, which worked btw.
I am an MLS fan and I do agree, it is improving. There have been some incredibly exciting games this year and the offensive aspects have been increasing, with more creativity and sophistication being present. I hope it see it continue upward and give clubs in Europe a genuine run for their money. It would be nice to see us also provide true competitive on the International level as well. We can all dream can't we xD
2
u/roxya Jul 16 '12
You always get ridiculous goals in lesser leagues (e.g. the lower English leagues) due to awful defending.
2
u/B0M85H311 Jul 16 '12 edited Jul 24 '12
There's no doubt the MLS game is climbing in quality, I for one believe with the pure population and interest in competitive sport in america, the MLS will be the biggest league in the world at some point (probably quite a long time away yet), and just so you know I'm not bias, I am english.
2
u/evilmilhouse Jul 16 '12
agreed. the league is still so very young compared to those across the world. I think that most teams are still sharing nfl stadiums, if most of them can get there own (like Portland), something small and upclose like the English stadiums this will help the league become more popular. You can see it with the Portland fans constantly singing right now thats the only stadium i would love to go see a game at because the atmosphere is amazing!
2
u/stonyninja Jul 16 '12
Wando is a stud for real.
2
u/twohourstillweekend Jul 16 '12
I understand we're having MLS or American Footballplayer related Threads up on the Frontpage on a regular Basis. And very often they seem rather meaningless or oversensationalist. See Bradley or this, supposed to be, 'Great pass' by some Kansas player that turned out to be an average assist.
I understand the urge of you guys discussing the developments and events of the wonderfull game in your country. I know I'm priviliged by just having to go 20 Meters to a bar, to School or to Work where I can talk about it all day long.
But my dear American friends: You're not alone on this page. And oppinions that you don't like because they see the developments less enthusiastic or even critical might be valid. Downvoting them just because they see the situation from a different perspective is just bad taste and results in this sub becoming a bigger circlejerk than it already is.
1
u/Futfanatico Jul 16 '12
Midfield play has also gotten loads better - no more long balls from defenders to corner flags! Well, less of them at least.
1
u/TheElPistolero Jul 16 '12
Can someone look up the actual percentage of Americans playing in the MLS? Sure the play might be looking up, but their are more foreign imports in it than ever. Good for the MLS, neutral for Team USA
1
u/Digapony49 Jul 17 '12
Canada has a lot of foreigners and is very multi-cultural Foreigners love the soccer. Cha-Ching.
1
u/flea61 Jul 17 '12
I'm going to the Galaxy-Tottenham game during the All-Star Break (No Donovan or Beckham for LA, but Gonzalez and Keane will probably play, right?). I vow to watch the rest of the season if they perform well against Spurs.
1
u/cliffordbeshers Jul 17 '12
Another mark of the league's growth: I care who wins and loses, most games. I have my heroes and villains. I'll root for the heroes as long as they aren't playing my home team. And there are teams I hate regardless of how I might respect their abilities. Anyone who takes down SKC gets a cheer from me, for instance. And any time Sideshow Bob gets tackled from behind, I quietly mutter that he deserved it.
1
u/mackinder Jul 17 '12
you haven't been watching TFC games then. ughhhhh
1
u/cclurve Jul 17 '12
I agree, especially with the interest being shown in the MLS from abroad. My little brother may end up with the chance to move over and do soccer schools and study in the US, which is a massive boost seeing that years ago people wouldn't have had these opportunities and would have to find a way into coaching experience.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12
This inspires me to support my city's MLS team :)
-12
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '12
Why do we have these "America has arrived" discussions every fucking week? The league is average and improving, we know. If I was a European on this forum, I'd be really annoyed seeing these discussions all the time when we never talk about the Belgian, Polish, Greek, or Swiss leagues, which are all comparable to the shithouse MLS. Same with the Dempsey circlejerk. Decent player, yes. Good enough to warrant 5 of his own transfer update threads every day, not at all.
-4
u/TerryPhelan Jul 16 '12 edited Jul 16 '12
Watched maybe seven or eight games out of curiosity. Thought the standard was pretty shit. Worse than I expected to be honest. I hope it gets better. It would be great for football. But let's face it it's pretty bad at the moment. Bad is maybe the wrong word. These things take time.
EDIT: It was an expression of opinion. This is probably the most ignorant subreddit in all of reddit.