r/singing • u/ghoti023 π€ Voice Teacher 10+ Years β¨ • Jul 23 '12
Some common vocal problems and new ways to think about them.
For reference: I'm a 21 y/o female with 7 years of classical training. I'm currently enrolled in a vocal performance program for opera. I don't have a degree in vocal pedagogy and I'm not a replacement for a voice teacher, but I've been seeing some trends and I'd like to throw out a few ways you might be able to fix them yourselves (or at least improve upon them) by yourself at home. Keep in mind that many of these things are also still issues I have as well- you won't fix all your issues in a day. Singing can be a lot like getting really good at figure skating. Sure, you might be able to do that really complicated move one day- but can you replicate it the next? There's tons of muscle memory that's needed in order to get good consistency in your singing. If your style of singing isn't classical (which it probably isn't. ;) ) it would still probably help you to look through this anyway. Basic singing technique applies to all types of singing. There are stylistic differences in placement of the sound and the amount of vibrato used etc... that differentiates from one style of singing to another. Anyway- ONWARD!
The most common issue is breath support. I know this is mentioned in the FAQ (as are a few other things I'm going to talk about) but I'd like to expand on what's already posted.
Your breath is the most important thing to your singing. Being connected to your breath is even more vital. Sit on the edge of a chair with your elbows on your knees. Take in a deep breath. Feel the expansion in your lower back? (Didn't know that was something you had to use did ya?) Now exhale with KEEPING the expansion. That's a little more work than most people are used to, but it's that kind of expansion that will give your voice a nice, full and free sound. Breathing is strongly related to posture, but I'll get to that in a minute. Now take in a few deep breaths and exhale with the expansion but engage your lower abdominals. This should feel like you're doing an eternal crunch, and should have more pressure on it the less air you have in your lungs. WHOO! That's a workout. You can also get this effect by doing short bursts of lip trills feeling the energy come from your lower abs. Whenever anyone tells you to "sing from your diaphragm," but you have no idea what that means- that's okay. Your diaphragm is actually an involuntary muscle, that simply separates your lungs from your intestines. you can pull down on it to allow more expansion and air into your lungs using your intercostal muscles (muscles that expand/contract the space between your ribs), your lower back muscles and your abdominals. This confused me for a long time, because instead of focusing on control from my abs, I was doing some weird thing where I was trying to control my diaphragm itself, in which case all of my effort was lying too high up in the body. Your lower abs actually do most of the work. Your chest and shoulders should never move because you took a breath. All of the expansion in your lungs should feel as low as possible.
POSTURE! The only difference between sitting posture and standing posture is the use of your legs. If you're standing, your feet should be about shoulder width apart with one slightly in front of the other. Knees loose with your pelvis tucked under. You should be able to shift your weight and use your thighs with ease. If you're sitting, sit at the EDGE of a chair or on a stool. Don't use the back of the chair. A trick to having better posture is to have one leg tucked under the chair/stool while the other one is out making a 90 degree angle. From either of these two positions, your core is the most important part. "Sitting/standing Tall" is how most voice teachers go about explaining this, but here's the nitty gritty details. Your lower ribcage should feel expanded, your shoulders back. You should feel like at any given moment you'll be asked to chest bump a football player- that's how expanded your chest should be. Not tense! just expanded. Don't over extend your shoulders back either- that can be tricky too. Your neck should remain loose, but as though you were a marionette, and someone was pulling an invisible string towards the ceiling (essentially making your chin parallel to the ground). I cannot stress enough that this should all be relatively relaxed- just controlled. Tension is never a good thing.
Vocal freedom is vital to a singer. If your voice hurts after a song or two, you're doing it wrong. You should not feel any pressure on your larynx- it should all sound and feel free. Your soft pallet should be raised, but not the point of an extreme yawn. Just relaxed and up. Control your dynamics and your pitch with your breath support, not by trying to manipulate your voice box. If you try to sing from your throat rather than from your gut, you're risking giving yourself vocal nodes (calluses on your chords. You never sound the same again, even if you get them removed), or you can actually paralyze a chord (this JUST happened to a colleague of mine) which takes an immense amount of therapy to fix. The voice is like a pretty sounding whoopee cushion. All of the work comes from the exhalation of air- and the vocal chords just do what the air tells them to do. A whoopee cushion doesn't make sound because you manually slap the flaps together, it makes a sound because there's a stream of air. Your voice is similar. Large culprits of "singing from your throat" tend to be musical theatre people who do a lot of belting. There's nothing wrong with belting, I do it on occasion myself- but you have GOT to use the right technique. Know why Idina Menzel had to take a long break? Too much improper belting in Wicked. You can seriously hurt yourself if you sing from the throat guys- I can't stress it enough. Of course, don't confuse singing from your throat with vocal fatigue. Vocal fatigue is like running a marathon and being tired because your muscles have been working for a while and you need to take a break (singing while you have fatigue can damage you as well, but so long as you have proper technique you'll be fine so long as you take a few hours to break. Plenty of professionals get vocal fatigue, especially after long and tiring operas. It's normal and fine, just don't ever over do it). Singing from your throat is like running a marathon only hitting yourself with a hammer in the thighs at every step.
Common with musical theatre and pop/rock singing is nasality. You don't want this. It's not going to hurt you like singing from your throat, but it is going to make you less pleasant to listen to and your sound won't travel as far, so you'll be harder to hear. You can check to see if you're ever singing nasally simply by pinching your nose. If you have nasality issues, keep pinching your nose while you sing to help yourself find a placement that is more desirable.
RESONANCE! Resonance, or rather, where you place your sound, is tricky and it doesn't work the same for everyone. Some people need more mouth resonance, others more mask, and others more chest. Mouth resonance is what projects your sound and makes it easy to hear. You DON'T have to sing at your loudest at all times, just use mouth resonance. It's easier on your chords and the audience will be able to hear you better than if you were shout-singing. Mask resonance is placed in the mask of the face (around where your sinus cavities are. Don't confuse this with singing through your nose though. They are two different things). Mask resonance will bring warmth to your voice. Many people try to accomplish warmth by swallowing their sound and keeping it in the back of their throat. This will only sound good to you- and be barely audible from an audience. Bring your sound forward and use mask resonance to warm your tone. Chest resonance makes your low notes audible. I'm sure most of you have felt chest resonance before, as it's the easiest one to obtain. As you're in your lower register, feel the vibrations coming out of your sternum. TADA! CHEST RESONANCE. The trick is that you can never JUST use chest resonance. There must always be a mix of all three resonances. Where you are in your vocal range determines what mixture you should use. The higher you get, the more mask resonance you should use. The lower you get, the more chest. Mouth resonance should ALWAYS be a thing, and all three should always be used.
Many singers have intonation or rhythm issues. For rhythm- practice with a metronome. You can find online metronomes with an easy google search. For intonation issues you need to determine whether or not you're hearing the right pitch or if there's a flaw in your technique. Many singers HEAR the right pitch in their head but the wrong one comes out because their technique needs work. Most of the time it's breath support or placement issues. Record and listen to yourself and be honest with yourself. Did you hit that right? Practice intonation by singing chromatic scales and intervals. There are plenty of online resources that can teach you how to do that as well.
Don't EVER try to sound older than you are or try to manipulate your sound so you can sound like someone else (at least, not without proper technique for the latter. Even then, don't compromise technique in order to sound like someone else). It ends up sounding funky to the audience and disingenuine. The best part about the vocal instrument is that it DOESN'T sound like anyone elses. Own your voice and be proud of it. Want to do a cover of Johnny Cash but sound nothing like him? Do the cover anyway, but do it YOUR way, not his way. There will be songs you can't do, or at least can't do as well as you'd like. It's okay- there's TONS of music out there that you CAN do, or you can try changing the key it's sung in.
9
u/CrAzY_MoFo_13 Lyric Tenor - Opera/Musical Theatre Jul 23 '12
Good point on the diaphragm, since it is an internal it is impossible to actually feel it from the outside; we know we are engaging our diaphragm correctly by the responses of the muscles surrounding it (intercostals, etc.).
On another note, it is common for younger singers to inhale too much air on the breath. If the lungs are filled too full they will naturally expel some air in an antagonistic fashion, which will impede proper singing.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '12
This is definitely a lot of the major problems that beginning singers are likely to encounter, so thank you for taking the time to explain them - I hope it really helps a lot of the singers here. I'm in a similar boat of having had a decent number of years of training, and I agree that perfecting these aspects of technique can take years and years - and then being able to perform consistently takes even more!
That being said, I do feel that it's worth mentioning the level of generalization that takes place when you're discussing technique in a general sense rather than with a specific person.
For example, while it's true that most singers suffer from a failure to support adequately, it's also true that many singers, when instructed to "support more" or "use more abs" will end up overdoing it, and thus also choke the breath mechanism.
It is also worth pointing out that body type is a fairly significant factor in singing - your body is your instrument, and the way it's constructed will alter the way you produce sound. I've found personally that because I have an extremely small abdominal/chest cavity, it is impossible for me to get a full breath without my chest also rising. This isn't the unhealthy "shallow" breathing, but simply a mechanism of my rather slight body type, combined with other medical conditions that have made things a bit tight in space. So while as a general rule of thumb breathing should be low and full, some people, especially children, simply do not have room in their bodies to take a low, full breath without some visible movement in the upper chest or even the shoulders. It's possible to tell the difference when a voice teacher is looking at a student, but it's hard to describe the difference just through words. Thus, I really appreciate your encouragement to supplement any advice here or elsewhere with actual training by a professional voice teacher or vocal coach.
At any rate, I generally think the advice here is really good, and things most singers will benefit from improving. I just also personally advise a grain of salt that of course everything should be taken in moderation. Overextension or overcompensation is just as dangerous, at times. And of course ultimately - TAKE LESSONS! They're worth it.
2
u/whitedevious Jul 23 '12
This is great. Thank you.
1
u/Gumpster Jul 23 '12
Thanks for this! I'll save it and reflect every time I'm having vocal issues. :)
1
u/kissimmeekate Jul 24 '12
Those are all very good points. I have had no training but I love singing classical/opera and this helped a lot! I didnt realize that I was focusing on trying to control my diaphragm so much until now. I'm only 16 and have a lot to learn :)
1
u/afrael Jul 24 '12
Awesome piece, and great discussion. Gold star for you!
1
u/kissimmeekate Jul 25 '12
Oh yeah I didn't mean that I am trying to sound like an opera singer. That is just the type of music I like and the way I like to sing. I do have singers that inspire me, but I don't try to copy them. Thanks for helpIng, though :)
1
u/Mahl3r Tenor, Opera/Classical Aug 21 '12
I'm a little late to this, but I was wondering if you had any advice/resources that could help me with my [i] vowel. This vowel more than any other causes me a lot of tension. Either my larynx shoots up or my tongue gets tight. I'm trying to place the tip right behind my bottom teeth while elevating the middle of the tongue to the roof. Is this a good start?
1
u/Snoo729411 Nov 04 '22
Could you explain the improper belting that Idina Menzel does? What technique did she do that caused so much damage
0
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '12
[deleted] β view deleted comment