r/anime • u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler • Sep 15 '22
Rewatch [Rewatch] Yama no Susume (Encouragement of Climb) Season 2 Episodes 9-10 Discussion
Episodes 9 - 10
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
Questions of the Day:
- There were lots of touristy attractions at the base and the ascent, what did you find most interesting or surprising?
- Do you think Aoi being left behind will knock her confidence going forward?
Mata Ashita! Yahhoo 🎵
42
Upvotes
9
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Sep 15 '22
Host Rewatcher
Ep 9
Bus corners, my gosh distant memories have returned.
Cute Hinata altatude sickness.
Hinata eating a whole volcano 👀
I saw one of these when I traveled to Hakone and I foolishly did not pick it up. Regret!
That wishing wall... looks like a photo on top. Not the cleanest compositing there.
Non nom nom.
Aoi is leading the charge till the 7th station but by the 8th she is tireing.
Kaede rub.
Gloves on, things getting serious.
Ganbate Aoi!~
Aoi looking out (stitch)
I really loved the simple bounce engetic energy through the start of this episode, which was mostly worn away as everyone climbed. That energy early on helps lay things out later on to show how hard the climb is.
Ep 10
Aoi determined to go on. But double vision isn't normal.
Altatude sickness for sure.
3 Hours to the top, traveling only 2k, oof.
NO REST IN THE LODGE
[Season 3 spoilers]I am pretty sure Kokona and Hinata whistle the song that Hinata sings at Karaoke in season 3.
Climbing requires consumption! (My god I can't get enough of Hinata poking things in her mouth.)
Remember when that guy asked you to do that thing? Gotta love that generic foreigner babble
Aoi star gazing (Stitch)
Aoi not having a good time though.
7
u/TiredTiroth Sep 15 '22
First Time Climber
Well, I actually really like this pair of episodes despite how the trip is going to end for Aoi. There’s no pretense here that enough effort will overcome any and every obstacle, and when poor Aoi tries Best Senpai is there to tell her no, take care of yourself, there’s no shame and you can always come back another time. The mountain is not going anywhere.
As nice as it would be to see Aoi make it to the summit in time for the sunrise, this is something that really does need to be said. Sometimes you don’t make it, and that’s okay.
Still, hopefully there’s a repeat attempt waiting for us later, even if it’s only shown briefly to tell us she made it this time.
I don’t…really have much else to say right now? It’ll be interesting to see what happens next, episode eleven’s title has implications. But we’re only half-way through season two so I’m sure Aoi will be fine eventually.
13
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Sep 15 '22
Rewatching Mountain Climber
-- Location Trivia
Ep 9
Ep 10
Animation bits I liked
9
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Sep 15 '22
First-Timer
On today’s episodes of Yama no Susume: Failure. Or at least, it sure seems like a failure. I was not anticipating there to be a genuine setback and failure to climb up a mountain here. But with the benefit of hindsight, it was actually well set up and made perfect sense.
Episode 9
And very delicious
Episode 10
So pretty
I really do need to praise the smart set up here. Back in episode 8, during Aoi and Kaede’s talk, they discussed the question about whether travelling to Mt. Fuji would even be worth it if they failed to climb to the mountaintop. Back then, Kaede motivated Aoi by saying they could always come back later if they failed. That’s some great foreshadowing back there.
Now, that’s actually come true. And it turns out that Kaede meant what she said. She isn’t going to push ahead if she thinks it endangers Aoi. Kaede really is such a fantastic friend, looking out for Aoi like that. I just love her more and more.
This opens up so many possibilities. Aoi made the decision to challenge Mt. Fuji and she failed. How will she deal with this going forward? Will it affect her desire to keep climbing mountains? Will she lose her motivation? How we handle failure says a lot about who we are as people, so this can make for some fascinating character stuff.
Perhaps Aoi will come to terms with how far she did get and see that as motivation to “take another step” in the future. It would fit with the theme of “one step at a time.” It would also fit with the triumphal end of Episode 9. After all, Aoi still accomplished something that she never did before. I think that will encourage her to keep going.
This episode also shows Aoi’s nightmare coming true. Hinata (and Kokona) really did leave her behind to go to the mountaintop. Yama no Susume is really consistent about this theme for Aoi and Hinata. I have to praise this series for how well done the payoffs have been.
Another thing that’s cool about this series is its portrayal of the difficulties in mountain climbing. It is not an easy task and this series shows that. We see the girls get exhausted by it and now we saw Aoi actually get altitude sickness. That level of realism is appreciated.
QOTD
9
u/zadcap Sep 15 '22
Back for another Late Night Good Time!
Oops, I started rewatching 8... Benefit; excuse to watch the OP an extra time tonight!
Ah, Reminded me of Super Cub. You can indeed bike up Fuji, at least in theory!
Ohhh Mystery Meal, scary. Aaaand what a letdown lol.
Again, I want to know, how much money do these kids have darn it. They spend more than I do on vacation lol.
... English? Surprisingly good English?
Did she just drop her food out of her mouth onto the ground? This girl...
Wait we're following the English couple haha!
Yup, I remember that thing from Super Cub too lol.
Kokona, how would it have ended up in front of her that far if it fell off...
Hey, girls, let the one who's having trouble decide when you're heading out again. She already said, the mountain isn't going anywhere.
Ah. Another two part climb. Or, well, it's Fuji so probably three?
For a show I've been comparing to Yuru Camp so much, how is it only by the opening of episode 10 when it sticks, this is a summer group, not a winter one. Not that it makes any difference, I've just been looking for all the comparisons between these outdoorsy feel goodsy Iyashikei.
All future potential mountain climbers, make a note, please don't leave your weakest climber alone at the back of the pack.
Oof, yeah, the altitude sickness and lack of sleep. She's not making it to the top, is she? Darn it this isn't supposed to be the type of show I cry over.
Darn Americans lol.
Yeah, Kaede's got it right. Stay safe now, and try again next time. Because as long as you don't hurt yourself, there will be a next time!
This is a very sad place to end my happy show of the night :(
8
u/HereticalAegis https://myanimelist.net/profile/XthGen Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
Encouragement of First Timer
Episode 9:
If we're doing Fuji now though, what mountains will be left that compare to it in future episodes/seasons?Welp, got that question answered pretty handily.Episode 10:
I can only speak for myself, but if I was climbing Fuji—or any mountain for that matter—with friends and one got sick and was unable to finish, I sure as hell would not continue. I can't imagine leaving my sick best friend behind for something so trivial as watching a mountain sunrise, and I'm really disappointed that's what Hinata and Kokona are doing.
Tbh, this episode is making everyone look incredibly irresponsible. Hinata and Kokona's excitement blinded them to how dangerously Aoi was over exerting herself. Aoi failed to communicate her physical state properly to the rest of the group despite just recently having a communication breakthrough regarding her concerns about this climb. Kaede, as the most experienced and de facto leader of the group, bears the most responsibility for recognizing the danger the group was putting Aoi in past the seventh station and took far too long recognize Aoi's condition. Most importantly, the group as a whole should already know from their previous climbs that Aoi should not, at any point, be at the back of the group. She struggled mightily on their previous climb, and that was like a third the elevation of Fuji at most. Aoi's struggles were easily foreseeable, and they didn't do nearly enough to adequately prepare.
Oh, and it seems highly irresponsible on all the parents' parts to not have a single adult supervising this climb. Hinata's dad has done this before, so I kinda thought he'd be accompanying them to ensure their safety, and I also figured that would be the reason Aoi's mom would even entertain the idea. I'm flabbergasted Aoi's mom allowed her to attempt Fuji without any adult supervision.
This episode has left me very frustrated with everyone, and—can't believe I'm saying this—I'm off the Aoi x Hinata ship for the moment. I hope the next episode or two involve a lot of self-reflection. Everyone needs to do better than they did today.
QotD:
8
u/ChonkyOdango myanimelist.net/profile/chonkyodango Sep 15 '22
First Time Climber
Fuji-San Here We Come!
And we continue up Fuji-San
I loved episode 10 but that’s because it’s the climax of the climb. I’m happy with how they handled it from Aoi yearning to climb to Hinata being bummed out but still wanting to complete it. It’s yet another obstacle they will surely grow out of. Hinata’s care and concern for Aoi is unparalleled, it’s really sweet.
Aoi’s Path Up
S2E1 - A vocal reflection with Hinata as she reminisces the time she climbed with Hinata when they were younger and the time they spent that day which brought her so much joy. With this she voices out her next wish to climb a mountain with her dearest friends one day
S2E2 - Aoi gets worried as she prepares for her first climb. But thanks to Hinata and her own will, she knows that there’s something beautiful awaiting for her and it’s only by taking thing step-by-step can they reach that beautiful scenery
S2E3 - We climb to see the view but what makes the view better than looking at it through pictures or books is not because you see it with your own eyes but because of the trials and tribulations we go through. “The greater the effort, the sweeter the reward”
S2E4 - Similar to the previous episode but this time Aoi remembers that despite wanting to give up multiple times, looking back, it was really fun for her. So she craves for more adventures
S2E5 - Aoi learns that Conflicts are unavoidable but it’s important to make-up quickly instead of putting up fronts. This means being honest with your feelings, even if it’s just a bit, even if it isn’t easy
S2E6 - ”As long as there’s a strong desire, a path will open up”. Instead of sulking and giving up, assessing the situation to see what you can do and what you can’t can open new paths forward
S2E7 - Things don’t always have to go as planned, sometimes the best memories are made because of them just as Aoi has gained a precious summer memory after the group couldn’t swim in their desired location.
S2E8 - ”You can’t see fear. You’ll only see and understand fear when it hits you. For the time being, I should push on. Once I hit it, I’ll think of something”. Fear and anxiety are similar but different, it’s not easy to differentiate them but once you can, you’ll be able to face the unknown with excitement instead of fear just as Aoi goes to bed excitedly today.
S2E9 - Aoi reflects on her climb so far - she’s glad she overcame her fear and reaffirms herself to take it one step at a time
S2E10 - Aoi’s sad and just wants to go back in this episode :(
Qotd
8
u/Rumpel1408 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rumpel1408 Sep 15 '22
First Timer
Think it's safe to say I'll be adding Natsuiro purenzto onto my playlist. Also would like to point out a short bit a minute into the OP where Hinata and Aoi are shown atop some monkey bars, having conquered a small sumit and Aois trauma.
S2 EP 9 + 10
First we got to Fuji San (and Aoi sneakily grabbed onto Hinatas tights) and arived at the 5th Station. Loved how Kokona squeed over the Uma. She sounded so smart while essentially saying nothing new, but I was wondering about the Stations as well, wonder how long it would take to climb from the first station...
I would feel betrayed as well. Why is the Volcano curry really cool, but the cloudtop Ramen just normal Ramen... Those Fuji San plushis seem familiar btw
That staff is a cool souvenir, like a stamp card but more sturdy.
It's went pretty smooth in the beginning, a break after 30 minutes climb and reaching several stations in quick succession, but somehow I felt like something was bound to happen, it could not be that easy all the way right? Like they where constantly raising flags...
When Aoi started struggling I would really have liked it if someone would be behind or at least with Aoi, not to ensure that she keeps up with their pace but to make her not feel alone.
Following that ominous title shit really started to go down. When Aoi broke down, I still felt like they weren't0 taking this and Aois struggles as serious as they should. But thank god for Kaede who just wanted her to reach a place to properly rest.
With how present he was, I was hoping for Mike to somehow end up helping them, but in the end he really was just a loud forreigner, shudup Mike!
Kaede ended up putting her foot down and took a loss for Aois sake as well, really proud of her as the oldest of the group. Aoi might feel miserable but it's for the better, she can always try again and they are still watching the same sky
QotD
I think having a temple isn't that outlandish, but a whole shopping mall screams capitalism
It would be weird if it wouldn't, but she will move on and try again
7
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Sep 15 '22
First-Climber
This was very cute.
Wow, there's a whole, like, tourist town halfway up Mt. Fuji?
Neat. Riding a horse up a mountain sounds interesting. You can Skyrim in real life!
Volcanic curry sounds deliciously spicy.
That is so much effort to go through for a dish, but damn if it doesn't look good!
Definitely wait to buy souvenirs.
That's an incredible idea for a souvenir!
Woah, English-speaking climbers! I actually took a screenshot for this, but then realized it was an unsubtitled landscape shot.
Many of these stations are untrue, apparently.
Alright, I'm not familliar with fugashi. Looks like an umaibo? Fugashi is apparently dried wheat gluten coated in brown sugar.
Got a choice of flavors!
Ooh that was scary.
I like the contrast contrast between the ?American? climbers and our girls.
Gorgeous view.
She needs a strap on her bag for the stick.
So close you can almost taste it.
Oh that's bad!
She's totally passed out..
The English is subbed this episode, huh.
Wow, flashback.
Good on Kaede for making the tough decisions.
No, it's really okay sweetie. Please take care of yourself.
Ooh, just two words but Yoko Hikasa's English isn't too shabby.
You can hear it in her voice, she's still hurting. Yuka Iguchi is a hell of a VA.
I.. wrote the line below about the OP before watching the episode and now it's kinda heartbreaking, seeing Hinata and Kokona make memories without Aoi.
Aoi got to see the Milky Way, at least.
Stop, this cute girls show isn't supposed to do these things to me!
I forget if someone's mentioned this before, but I quite like the OP's framing of "shared memories" as "presents."
Questions
7
u/Nebresto Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
First time clime
Subarashii..?
Actual English speaking in the background??
Ahhh, I'm so scared. I keep expecting Aoi to keel backwards any moment here
Oh man, that's tough. Idk if I'd keep going or go back with the friend who had to drop out. I guess it would depend on what they wanna do and what kind of place we're climbing
Questions:
Maybe the horse ride potential? The stick branding was also cool
Hope not, but it might have the opposite effect on her determination to
fistclimbPics time, there wasn't specified interest in a bigger album so I just picked some highlights
7
u/Barbed_Dildo Sep 15 '22
Rewatcher
I like the realism of Aoi falling sick and not being able to make it. It makes for a more interesting story than succeeding first time. It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not a weakness. That is life.
This part of the story is mainly about Aoi, but Kokona still manages to bring the knowledge on Mt Fuji when needed.
6
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Sep 15 '22
Rewatcher who wants Aoi to get better
No Production Notes today for my external keyboard isn’t working so well and I’d have to type these out using my laptop keyboard. My fingers hurt when they type too long on them!
Episode 9
Takaaki Wada is on today with an impressive hat trick since he’s solo KA’ing, storyboarding, and episode directing this whole shebang.
Tag yourself, I’m curry w/pork cutlet.
Lots of spacious layouts today that emphasize wide rooms and crowds. It’s an effective way to demonstrate how freeing this whole adventure feels in the beginning. My favorite one is this cut of Hinata showing off the effects of the altitude on the potato chip bag. It’s economical yet eye-catching with how Aoi reaches out to the foreground.
And now we start the climb in earnest with Aoi coming up to the screen. However, as they ascend higher and higher, the camera descends lower and lower, matching the girls as they scale the Mt. Fuji. Naturally, this allows the shot where Aoi peers down the mountain to be more powerful since we’ve been seeing low-angle shots for the past few minutes. Of course, the climb isn’t nearly over as Aoi once again ascends the mountain.
Episode 10
My fingers are starting to hurt. There isn’t a whole lot visually that I wanted to discuss in this episode anyway. However, I do want to say this episode was the turning point for me on YnS.
I wrote that almost a year ago on the dot and this was the episode that was the impetus for those lines. This episode truly solidified my opinion of the show. Sure, the animation and direction have been top-notch but you have to marry those technical aspects with the warmth of character and narrative. I don’t want to just go on to Sakugabooru to see clips of the show; I want to see it become a showcase of story too. Shows turn from good to great once both medium and content start to work in tandem. They’re equally important.
One thing I noted this time around though is how great Aoi’s friends are. Hinata leaves behind a token of her love in the hopes that it’ll help Aoi and Kaede stays behind to make sure Aoi is fine. It’s really wonderful to see them care about their friend.
6
u/cyberscythe Sep 15 '22
Rewatcher
One of the things I love about this arc is how detailed the hike up Mt. Fuji is. Not just the various backgrounds and vistas that seem like they're taken from reference pictures, but also the whole experience like the tourist stop at the fifth station, the ad-hoc commemorative spaces in the mountain huts where people post their business cards, and the loud American tourists.
Another thing I love are the callbacks to the previous episodes. Aoi's dream that started off the season with Hinata leaving her behind, Aoi's wish to see the milky way at the end of season one, and Kaede's reassurance that the mountain's not going anywhere. I like these things because it ties a lot of the episodes together and makes makes for a more cohesive experience.
And of course there's Aoi herself. Watching this episode and knowing that she's suffering from altitude sickness and not getting enough oxygen made me take sympathetic breaths. This is the first time she's experienced a major setback and it's something that she just doesn't have the experience to deal with, and I feel glad that Kaede's there to keep her from going further in her condition.
One thing I was thinking about while watching this episode is how much inner monologuing there is. I think having watched Super Cub and Akebi-Chan (both series which have very little internal monologues), I kinda feel like hearing their thoughts like "whoa, this is tough!" and "the air's so thin!" is kind of superfluous, especially when it's animated well enough that you can see the characters gasping for breath and wincing in pain.
5
u/Stargate18A https://myanimelist.net/profile/Stargate18 Sep 15 '22
First timer
Sorry for the missed posts, caught Covid and it knocked my whole rewatch schedule off.
Episode 3
They're still keeping things secret!
It's a Burdha stone?
And it's a litter sign.
...Too many benches.
A vieweing fork?
Haha, her immediate realisation is great.
She found it!
And she worked out what the surprise was!
That's nice.
It's getting harder!
She's not having fun...
They're having a break.
And she knew everything.
This is a nice moment.
They're worried about her...
Yeah, walking sticks are good.
Looks nice!
She's pacing herself!
Yeah, I'd stop here.
She's doing it!
And she made it,
Fantastic view!
Episode 4
They're going to the peak!
Oh good, there's a safer path than that.
She can see it!
Yeah, this is cute.
She loves it eo much!
And it's a long walk back.
A hot spring!
She doesn't like it?
...Ah, that makes sense.
She fell!
She loves the benches now, huh.
She got knee braces!
So far to go...
She wants to go in!
And she missed some steps.
Ah, that's why she was worried.
And she stood up.
This is sweet.
Hinata running from the scale was funny.
Bears!
They made it on the last train.
Just so cute.
Episode 5
Crepe?
She's telling Hinata stories!
Oh.
A secret project!
It happened again!
And Aoi ran off...
Yeah, no, still careless.
Her colelction grew!
...Hinata, why did you do that?
Aoi's actually pissed!
And she's committed to it.
It's fair, though. Hinata screwed up.
She misses her...
Oh. That's what it was for.
Hinata understands.
She's going to knit something herself!
Aoi pretending to still be pissed at her...
This is sweet.
Haha, Hinata still wants her hat.
And it happened in reverse!
Oh, she's mocking her now!
Episode 6
Interesting!
...Thst actually sounds really cool.
Haha, that's funny.
Sounds amazing.
Hinata's down to climb with her!
Good point.
And she needs to wrap up warm!
Lots of equipment needed. It sounds expensive.
Oh, there's rock climbing!
Headlamps are very important.
Hinata's paying!
Why is everything so expensive?
...Also, if my rushed Google calculations are correct, the temperature on rhe mountain couldn't be more than a couple of defrees below zero. Do you even need a coat for that?
She'd let you use it?
Yep, her mother's forbidden her from sll of it!
...And she's properly hurt.
Yeah, that's awkward.
And he's talking to her!
Yeah, that makes sense.
And she gave her a very thorough explanation!
She gave her the jacket!
She's happy Aoi's actually caring about things.
This is nice.
5
u/IWishIWasAShoe Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
Rewatcher
So the funniest part about the Fuji climb is hands down the American couple, i have no idea why, but hearing them pop up everywhere is just bliss.
Also reminds me of the fact that when visiting tourist attractions myself that you more or less end up with an informal group with everyone who arrive at a similar time. I've found myself seeing the same strangers throughout a museum, a temple or even a grocery store. By the end when I leave, sometimes even next to these people i somehow feel as if I've started to know them. Almost like when you drive behind the same car for a long time on the highway. Or in this case with the American tourists.
The branded sticks are also something that I've been curious about ever since I first sav this show. I've never been to Fuji, and the people I know who have been don't recall these sticks at all. After all these years I've still to learn if these sticks are a thing, how much they cost and everything about the branding at the stations.
Also, how do you even book a stay at a station?
Regarding the second QOTD, Aoi giving up is probably the best part of the Fuji arc, and very well executed. Splitting the group of course give us some nice character pairings, but mostly I like that Aoi didn't want to. That she feel responsibility and regret for letting her friends down, although none of them blame her, or even complain. How she feel disappointed in herself, as if her getting sick was her fault. Everything went wrong, maybe she just isn't cut out for outdoor activities after all? Extremely relatable.
That being said, i do feel that the altitude sickness thing was Chekhov's Gunned a little bit to obvious in the earlier episode... anyway...
"REMEMBER WHEN THAT GUY ASKED YOU TO DO THAT THING!?"