r/soccer • u/Thadderful • Dec 28 '13
Change My View thread
Can we have a Change My View thread here? The basic premise is people present opinions and the replies are attempts at changing that person's view in an attempt to generate some good discussion.
Here is the link to the original subreddit: www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/
I think this might work best with rather 'out there' views but any and every viewpoint is welcome!
154
Upvotes
70
u/lelolelolelolelol Dec 29 '13
Its a miracle Jonathan Walters and Cameron Jerome are professional football players
50
u/Thadderful Dec 28 '13
I'll start:
After Suarez, Rooney is the second best player in the Premiership.
27
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
Only young people think that CR7 and Messi are the greatest players ever.
55
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
Competitions like the Eredivisie (and similar ones) have no chance on keeping up with the big leagues and therefore will never be able to really compete for the Champions League anymore. And the gap is only going to get bigger.
72
u/rewindthegamer Dec 28 '13
The Prem is the best league in the world.
209
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
If most of history's football greats pre~1970 played in their prime today they would be distinctly average
29
u/Zankman Dec 28 '13
O.K., since I genuinely am curios:
As someone who is ignorant of any of the supposed reasons for such a thing, change my view on this:
I like Leeds.
Why are they hated?
155
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
/r/soccer is full of morons. CMV
75
u/ChedduhBob Dec 28 '13
ITT: Statements that are nigh impossible to argue
37
u/tross840 Dec 28 '13
Also..building off of my earlier point. I do believe Messi may be the best player ever and that CR7 is in the top 10 or so already.
But without a doubt. Cr7 and Messi are the most effective players in the history of the sport. The way they have performed week in week out is baffling. When you add it all up - the level of competition and their dominance of it, it leads to the simple fact that no other superstars have been as consistently as devastating as Cr7 and Messi. Even Ronaldinho in his prime was not nearly as consistent as these two have been for the past 4 seasons or so.
81
u/proud_feet Dec 28 '13
The Europa League isn't a tournament worth participating in.
You might get TV money and an increased profile, which in turn can lure higher calibre players, and it's another chance for silverware. However I think altogether being in the tournament is detrimental to your season; you need a large squad to cope with the demands of playing on a Thursday night ahead of the domestic weekend matches. The strain will be too much for a club with a small squad, and their league performances would suffer as a result.
Look at Liverpool this season - we have benefited from not being in the EL, as it allows us to pay undivided attention to what's left to us; the Premiership and the FA Cup.
Another problem I have with it is when the Champions League teams who never progressed out of the group stages get dumped into the knockout rounds automatically - teams who might have done fantastically well to qualify earn naught but the right to get tanked by Juventus (to use a contemporary example).
37
u/TheDrySkinOnYourKnee Dec 29 '13
Malky Mackay deserved his sacking and was much more at fault for the fiasco than Vincent Tan.
Sure, Tan doesn't know much about football but he gave Mackay a specific budget, and he decided to overspend that. For a manager to blatantly break his chairman's trust is pretty bad, but then he had the nerve to actually go and complain to the media that Cardiff needed to buy more players, knowing full well that Tan had no money left.
Mackay knew exactly what he was doing; now, all the pressure was on Tan to either provide extra money or face the blame from fans and the press for not helping Cardiff.
All the sugary, sweet drivel from Mackay in his last few post-match interviews nearly made me gag. He knew all along that either he was going to get the extra money or leave the sinking ship with his reputation intact, or even better than before.
25
u/RoyalPi Dec 29 '13
An Asian team will win the World Cup before any North American or African teams.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
if Vincent Tan takes over as manager of Cardiff, it would be the greatest publicity the premier league could ever wish for
also, possibly the first homicide committed in a dugout
94
u/fleamarketguy Dec 28 '13
If Messi wins the worldcup with Argentina , he's the best player ever.
27
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
I don't think City have what it takes to win the title.
Also, I think the point in this type of thread is to post controversial and unpopular opinions and people try to convince them otherwise, but most of the posts here are things everyone in /r/soccer agrees with.
17
u/TheTrotters Dec 29 '13
In the long term, many European leagues should merge. Otherwise they'll forever remain irrelevant. For instance, Swedish league will be almost always exclusively watched by Swedes; Swedish cups will achieve precisely nothing in Europe. On the other hand, Scandinavian League could become very interesting to watch from people from all over the world.
CMV.
66
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
Ronaldo is better player than messi
2
u/AlkanKorsakov Dec 29 '13
The United States will never make it to a world cup final.
29
u/momin_q Dec 28 '13
"Total Football" by the Dutch isn't as groundbreaking as popular opinion claim it to be. It is mostly a copy of the unique play style used by Hungary's Golden Team of the 1950's.
8
u/TheTrotters Dec 29 '13
For major European clubs, there are only two important trophies: domestic league and Champions League. Supercups, domestic cups, league cups, World Club Championship etc. are glorified friendlies (with domestic cups such as FA Cup, Copa del Rey etc. being semi-relvant due to legacy). Related: Wenger was correct--fourth place (or more broadly: CL qualification) is kind of a trophy, in that it is much more important than any all those cups I mentioned above.
CMV.
28
u/nay_ Dec 28 '13
It was a mistake to give leagues more than 2 CL qualification spots. This rule change significantly decreased the prestige of both the UEFA cup/CWC/Europa League and in turn every domestic cup out there.
There is no reason whatsoever for a 4th placed team to qualify to the champions league over a team that actually won their domestic league.
Also, the rule that teams can drop out of the CL and down into the EL is fucking stupid.
7
u/Toddler33 Dec 29 '13
The MLS will never become a respected leauge
36
u/GoodBananaPancakes Dec 28 '13
Manchester United will finish in the top 2.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
Brazil will win the World Cup comfortably on home soil.
44
u/Ryannnnnn Dec 28 '13
Man City bought the title.
24
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
Mourinho's Porto wasn't some genius managerial achievement but an average side playing at a time when European football was in a quality slump, and rode a wave of luck and easy ties to win the Champions League.
First you have to look at who was competing in that Champions League. The best teams that season were Arsenal (Invincibles), Valencia, Werder Bremen, and post-January Barcelona. Neither Werder Bremen, Valencia nor Barcelona played the Champions League. Milan won the Serie A, but they were abysmal away (8 out of a possible 57 points away in the league) which is why they were eliminated by Deportivo in one of the great Champions League matches.
Instead, the teams Porto faced were United (3rd in the Premier League), Lyon (Ligue 1 champion), Deportivo (3rd in La Liga) and Monaco (3rd in Ligue 1). So Porto only faced one league champion in that Champions League including the group stages, and it was the Ligue 1 champion at that.
When they faced United and Deportivo, which were the harder matches they had to play, they were helped by a wrongly disallowed Scholes goal and a ridiculous Andrade sending off.
13
u/taz82 Dec 28 '13
Huddlestone should be in the England squad for Brazil 2014.
17
u/tross840 Dec 28 '13
The only reason LA Liga seems to top heavy is because of Ronaldo and Messi, when they begin to decline and/or leave/retire you'll see things normalize. It baffles me that people complain about Madrid & Barca dominance without mentioning the fact that these two teams may have the most effective players of all time.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
Sir Alex returning to United would be detrimental to the future of the club. Short term fix that would create a problem for every manager after him until he died.
And to be a bit more controversial:
Change my view- Despite my appreciation for what Barca and Spain have achieved, I can not ignore the chance that someone/a few of those players were doping/on PED.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13 edited Dec 29 '13
I have watched Paul Scholes play somewhere around 50 games since the year 2005. Not as much as some of you are going to claim I needed to watch to have an opinion, maybe, but I am comfortable making a judgement on him: I never knew what made him better than other ball retaining players. By the end of his career, I feel like he was given way too much credit for the teams success on the field. He was a fantastic player, but he was constantly in the talk amongst the best midfielders, and sometimes players in the world when I was watching him... I don't think that's even close to true.
3
u/Le_Euphoric_Genius Dec 28 '13
Pele in his prime is not as good as the best modern forwards in the current game. Newer "best" teams are better than older "best" teams because football is quickly evolving. There are better tactics, more players so it's likely that you'll find more good players which makes competition tougher, and players are simply better taken care of health and fitness wise.
3
u/billbee Dec 29 '13
ronaldo is a better player than messi. ronaldo could play in a bad team and drag them i am not sure if messi could do the same
14
u/AhoyDaniel Dec 28 '13 edited Dec 28 '13
Pep Guardiola's Barcelona was the best team to ever play the game.
EDIT:
I think it's because they simply dominated almost every aspect of the game (except corners haha). They were really defensive without leaving their "always attack" mentality. They didn't concede that much and scored high amount goals. They were consistent. They forced other teams with amazing players to play ultra defensively football. They had individual talent that compesated when teamplay wasn't working. They had it all.
3
u/REGISTERED_PREDDITOR Dec 29 '13
Gary Mackay-Steven is the best top flight skiller in Europe. Other players pull off a trick every once in a while but Mackay-Steven does them almost every dribble and succeeds most of the time.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
Amount of money that exists now in football is ruining football. CMV
3
u/thepresidentsturtle Dec 29 '13
Football teams need a wage cap. Teams like Man City just came out of nowhere, spending so much money on several players well over £100k a week. Each team needs a weekly wage cap much lower than what the top teams are currently playing. If each team had a wage cap of what the likes of Newcastle, or Everton are paying, then that should be it. Some teams still won't be able to afford it, but it would be so much fairer IMO. And it should be across all leagues or else Everyone would fuck off to other leagues.
4
u/somethin1234 Dec 28 '13
If this sub was a more intellectual one then this idea would work, but since it isn't we will just continue to voice our opinion by down voting to oblivion.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
If you get knocked out of the Champions League, finishing 3rd in an easy group, and go on to win the Europa League, you shouldn't continually chant 'Champions of Europe' in every game.
0
u/skull36 Dec 28 '13
I think Mesut Özil is better than Andres Iniesta, and the statistics are in my favor. CMV
2
u/michaelisnotginger Dec 28 '13
Arsenal's playing philosophy as determined by wenger has become a larody of its former self and has been recently actively detrimental to their overall performance. CMV
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
A serious world club tournament should be organized every May. Opening up markets in Asia and North America.
2
u/ballsmunchen Dec 29 '13
A three back formation is ineffective and should never be favored over a four back formation
2
u/aggieinaustin Dec 29 '13
Suarez is the best player in the world right now.
1
u/sjekky Dec 29 '13
The UEFA coefficient system, which includes nations in deciding seeds, is one of football's biggest problems. It is totally geared towards getting the biggest TV money in.
1
u/animay Dec 29 '13
I think Ronaldo is better than Messi in terms of an all round game. CMV
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
Micheal Vorm is the most underrated keep in England.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
The EPL doesn't accurately represent English football.
1
u/vyno Dec 29 '13
A player's personal life or opinions or non-football related actions should not be held against him while judging his professional life. Read: Affairs, racist/political views, etc. CMV.
1
u/Zalindras Dec 29 '13
Romelu Lukaku is the best player Chelsea own.
1
u/NFeKPo Dec 29 '13 edited Dec 29 '13
England will never compete at the WC until more English players go abroad to ply their trade.
Edit: CMV