Edit: Made a mistake and published with a bad title. I’m basically arguing black Americans understand anti-black racism in a way no one else can, this could be applied to any other ethnic group, but because this knowledge is tactile, it’s hard for other groups to understand. But because I failed to catch my mistake you are free to attack my post at either angle.
My arguments come from personal experience as a black person, a recent job, and a bit of history.
I will accept arguments that poke significant holes in the idea that “Racism” is something a black American uniquely understands in a way other Americans don’t. Convince me it’s not that simple, or that this knowledge is not specific to black Americans, and I’ll try to engage.
When I say “Tactile knowledge” I’m referring to knowledge so ingrained inside of you that it’s just common sense. You struggle to explain the reasoning behind the knowledge, but you know it’s correct.
People play video games and can no longer explain why certain combos or builds are efficient to someone with no concept or an infantile concept of the game. It may be difficult for you to explain why walking works, or why you walk the way you do, you just rely on the fact others have the same tactile knowledge of walking you do. Same with social interactions. These things are so engrained in your mind, anyone that doesn’t understand looks dumb to you.
I was an ATC trainee. passed through Oklahoma, but for reasons that had nothing to do with my ability I was fired. My manager suggested I file an EEOC complaint over it, but it took a while for me to actualize what my issue was because it was obvious to me, but not to anyone in the facility to that wasn’t also black.
Onto ATC, they slam complicated concepts into you, and expect you to understand enough in like, 2-3 weeks. Followed by 1-2 months of practice in a simulated airspace. You need to memorize an entire map, a 52+ page booklet of procedures from which you make split second decisions. Actual facilities give you a more time (3-6 months) but exponentially more material in an exponentially more complicated, real life airspace where you will train for longer (2-3 years)
I’ve spoken to seniors doing this for like, 15-36 years, they’re all helpful, but some were blunt, said they’ve reached the common sense stage of the procedures I was concerned with (Coordination), instead teaching trainees ahead of me more advanced aspects which they’d help me with when I got there.
I’m no expert, but during my time there me and other trainees were able to quickly analyze flight plans, strips, call signs, and whatever else to quickly determine whatever that plane “Needed” or what another sector “Wanted” some simply did not get it, it was so intuitive to me that I felt like I was getting dumber trying to help them. I couldn’t imagine how a certified controller felt speaking to my comparatively dumbass.
The ability for a controller to explain what they view as common sense to someone with an infantile concept is a skill in an of itself, which is why OJTI’s are paid extra. This is also why I feel teachers in any profession deserve to be paid more.
A lot of jobs and talents could be broken down like this. Your job, most likely. By the same vein, the USA is a country built on the backs of black slaves, laws were put in place to justify and maintain a system of slavery. Even after the civil war, Jim Crow laws and black codes were put in place to create excuses to criminalize the existence of black people, hinder their success, deny their legal rights, and justify everything done to steal it from them.
the average black American understands that anti-black racism is a problem we endure. We understand the common excuses, idioms, dog whistles, etc etc. but it’s so engrained into our minds that some of us can’t explain it to someone who doesn’t understand already.
In today’s political climate, it’s easy to commit the fallacy fallacy, assuming that someone is lying solely because they cannot argue or substantiate their claims. A racist person with good argumentative skills can get a neutral person on their side.
This is what Angela Davis means when she talks about Anti-Racism. But her issue is assuming the average white person has the same tactile knowledge that we do. Like most jobs and talents, this knowledge must be taught. We are not the only people to suffer in this country, so all sorts of bias (Sexism, Homophobia, Islamophobia etc etc) need to be taught in schools, and especially to people in positions of power so that they can be challenged, or challenge eachother on these things.
There have been times I strongly suspected a person in my life or on the news to be racist, or a certain conviction to be racially motivated over a “Gut feeling”. I’ve learned not to point fingers and scream “Racism!” Because (A) I am not always right and (B) I am not good at arguing my own feelings. But I’ve been vindicated time and time again.
It’s tiring, and I’ve spent a lot of time last year trying to pull myself out of that mindset because it’s self defeating. Only for the same issues to materialize yet again and affect my recent job.
Other black people, co-workers, and supervisors in my life had to re-indoctrinate me on this. I’m being vague on purpose, but there were things I could have said or done to make this easier for myself had I held on to this knowledge instead of trying to forget about it.