r/changemyview • • 9h ago

Delta(s) from OP - Switch-It-Up Saturday CMV: The Allstate Mayhem Commercials Are Easily The Best Comedic Advertisement Campaign For Insurance

14 Upvotes

There's really no competition. The advertisements are consistently enjoyable with a clever shtick that effectively communicates the purpose of what is being advertised. Dean Winters (just looked up who that is) does a great job in the role, portraying exactly the sort of scumbag jackass a chance occurrence that caused you to get into a car accident would be if it were a person.

Other work in the space doesn't hold a candle to this advertising campaign:

- Flo from Progressive (and whoever the dude is who makes an appearance sometimes): She's quirky.... I guess? Who cares.

- Doug from Liberty Mutual (and frequent appearances from limu the emu): Initially, I actively disliked this one, but somehow, the persistence made it grow on me a bit. It's hit-or-miss, but the character is kind of likeable, and the gags are occasionally amusing. It's no Allstate mayhem, though—the gags themselves aren't narratives that actually communicate something specific to what's being sold. The whole shtick is just Doug being an annoying sales rep who is weirdly obsessed with what he's selling. Nothing about the gag is specific to what the product is.

- The "liberty biberty" Liberty Mutual guy: Horrible. No further comment warranted.

- Jake from State Farm: Milquetoast. Completely unremarkable.

- The Geico Gecko: It's a 3-d animated lizard with a British accent that is humorously awkward sometimes. It's fine. It might induce a bit of polite, tempered laughter that is to regular laughter what snapping during live poetry readings is to normal applause.

It's pretty clear: Allstate mayhem reigns supreme as the best comedic insurance advertisement campaign. CMV.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Hardcore Christian nationalism(a possible successor to MAGA) is probably going to fail in America

60 Upvotes

After the 2026 midterms, you had news about a certain 'Christ is King: America after Trump' conference, which features people like Nick Fuentes, Joel Webbon, etc.

First of all, the fact that they are incorporating white nationalism and Christian nationalism is probably shaving away a huge segment of support. A lot of the really religious Christians in America are non-white(Latinos, Vietnamese, Filipinos, etc.), and a lot of the extreme white nationalist types are explicitly anti-Christian, as they see it as a Jewish religion imported from the Middle Eastern deserts.

Secondly, religion keeps on declining in America, so whereas soft Christian nationalism of the Reagan, W. Bush, and Trump sort may succeed, it's unlikely a movement that wishes to make the state so explicitly Christian would succeed. Even Trump could attract a not insignificant portion of atheist,agnostic and areligious people which they will fail to do.

Thirdly, America has a long-rooted tradition of secularism. After all, Denmark, which is far more irreligious than America on the societal level(Church attendance, personal belief in God), still has a state church, whereas America has always had separation of Church and State since the late 1700s. Even the anti-Catholic Know-Nothings of the 1850s or the KKK in the 1920s emphasized their commitment to separation of Church and State.

Lastly, I think the movement is way too extreme, with proposals including ending abortion access, contraception, women's right to vote, criminalization of adultery, etc. It's nearly impossible for it to succeed in any Western country.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

CMV: Humans probably won't live in space on a meaningful scale

77 Upvotes

The most time anyone has been in space continuously is barely over a year. There are proven effects caused by microgravity resulting in continuous loss of muscle and bone density, headaches, and permanent vision loss. Lunar and Martian gravity still aren't enough to prevent changes from slow to fast twitch muscle and certain changes in gene expression. There has never been a mammal born in space or anything past the embyro stage.

There are also other practical issues like the extremely abrasive surface on the Moon (and Mars to a lesser extent) that will destroy equipment, and duststorms on Mars along with the fact that Martian soil is toxic for plants.

Even if you solve the practical issues. Living in space would be like living in a "cushy" prison, like in Norway. You are not going to be able to go outside without a suit, you will not have social interaction with Earth which is where 99% of people will live, you are probably stuck with only a few thousand people at best. Not many people will want to live there and future generations would want to leave.

The only real reason to go to space is if you had no more usable resources on Earth but by the time that is true particle accelerators (or nuclear reactors) will become efficient enough at creating mass and/or space mining will be done by robots.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: The summit that just happened in China is not Yalta 2.0. And Russia is in no way a superpower either

206 Upvotes

I keep hearing people refer to this summit that just happened in Shenzhen, China between Putin, Trump and Xi Jinping as "Yalta 2.0".  

Referring to it as such is breathtakingly ahistorical.  I'm tempted to use that tired Redditism "I have no words", but I'm about to use a whole bunch of words to explain why I think that the Shenzhen Summit is nothing like Yalta so...here we go. 

To start with, Putin really has no place at a superpower summit of any sort.  You might say the same thing about Trump of course because of his astonishing stupidity and incompetence but, the United States does remain the world's most formidable military, economic, technological and cultural force.  And it will remain so, when Trump leaves office in just two years. 

Putin on the other hand is the leader of a country that has spend almost five years fighting a country that he was expected to walk over in a week.  And, in case anyone wants to compare this to American misadventures in Afghanistan or Iraq or even Vietnam, consider this - Russia has lost about450,000 soldiers since the start of the war according to its own leaked data. That's about eight times more than the U.S. lost in Vietnam - America's most costly war since World War II. 

And the Russians have nothing to show for it. They do not even control one oblast capital since that they didn't already have prior to the start of the fighting.  And that's despite Kharkiv being about a marathon runner's distance from the border. Think about that.  My old fat ass can move farther in four hours than the Russian Army can in five years. Pathetic. 

All of this makes me wonder why anyone gives Putin any respect at all anymore.  Why are the Europeans such cowards?

Let's just imagine this. Let's say a joint Polish, German and French task force of just 25,000 (give or take) moved to the front lines in Ukraine (I'm sure the Ukrainians would not protest) and they said, "Vladimir Vladimirovich, if any of these men get so much as a sprained ankle...you just started World War III". What do you think would happen?

He would back down. His forces are shit and he knows it. The only thing he has is nukes and is he really about to kill himself and the whole world over Kherson?  

Moreover, it would send a clear message to the whole world that it's not 1945, World War II is not happening, Putin is not Stalin, Donny Tantrums is not Roosevelt, Xi Jinping sure as shit is not Churchill (comparisons to Winnie the Poo notwithstanding, 2026 China is a way better strategic position than 1945 Britain), and the rest of the world is not in ruins.  

They don't just have to sit there and take shit from the so called "great powers". They have agency. 

Change my view 


r/changemyview • • 2h ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: I can control others or the results of my actions. If I don't succeed, win, or achieve something, then it is completely my fault and my incapability.

0 Upvotes

Anything is possible. There is a way to control others and if you can't, then it is your fault.

I just can't separate my tasks and other person's tasks. I can't distinguish between what is in my control and what is not. I believe everything is in my control.

The wisdoms which say that others are not in your control and results are not in your control are useless.

If you lose you lose. Accept that you are incapable if we you are. There's no reason to justify your loss.

I just imagine myself accepting that things are not in my control. This also makes me derive my self worth from the results I get. Many times it makes me unhappy, but I am not able to change my belief. I don't have any logical explanation for it.


r/changemyview • • 19h ago

Switch-It-Up Saturday CMV: we need an online identity

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this for a while. A lot of the posts I see on Reddit are AI generated. A lot of the stuff that gets to the front page is AI generated content fine tuned to get the maximum amount of engagement. I really don’t see a scenario where the internet as a whole comes out of this unscathed given where it’s headed. I think we are heading to a point where we need to have an online identity. A decentralized ledger that maintains and records activity for a verified user. Various websites have forms of this, with the blue checkmark or whatever but I could see it being a standard check to even use the internet.


r/changemyview • • 18h ago

Delta(s) from OP - Switch-It-Up Saturday CMV: The average black American has a tactile understanding of racism that other Americans don’t.

0 Upvotes

Edit: Made a mistake and published with a bad title. I’m basically arguing black Americans understand anti-black racism in a way no one else can, this could be applied to any other ethnic group, but because this knowledge is tactile, it’s hard for other groups to understand. But because I failed to catch my mistake you are free to attack my post at either angle.

My arguments come from personal experience as a black person, a recent job, and a bit of history.

I will accept arguments that poke significant holes in the idea that “Racism” is something a black American uniquely understands in a way other Americans don’t. Convince me it’s not that simple, or that this knowledge is not specific to black Americans, and I’ll try to engage.

When I say “Tactile knowledge” I’m referring to knowledge so ingrained inside of you that it’s just common sense. You struggle to explain the reasoning behind the knowledge, but you know it’s correct.

People play video games and can no longer explain why certain combos or builds are efficient to someone with no concept or an infantile concept of the game. It may be difficult for you to explain why walking works, or why you walk the way you do, you just rely on the fact others have the same tactile knowledge of walking you do. Same with social interactions. These things are so engrained in your mind, anyone that doesn’t understand looks dumb to you.

I was an ATC trainee. passed through Oklahoma, but for reasons that had nothing to do with my ability I was fired. My manager suggested I file an EEOC complaint over it, but it took a while for me to actualize what my issue was because it was obvious to me, but not to anyone in the facility to that wasn’t also black.

Onto ATC, they slam complicated concepts into you, and expect you to understand enough in like, 2-3 weeks. Followed by 1-2 months of practice in a simulated airspace. You need to memorize an entire map, a 52+ page booklet of procedures from which you make split second decisions. Actual facilities give you a more time (3-6 months) but exponentially more material in an exponentially more complicated, real life airspace where you will train for longer (2-3 years)

I’ve spoken to seniors doing this for like, 15-36 years, they’re all helpful, but some were blunt, said they’ve reached the common sense stage of the procedures I was concerned with (Coordination), instead teaching trainees ahead of me more advanced aspects which they’d help me with when I got there.

I’m no expert, but during my time there me and other trainees were able to quickly analyze flight plans, strips, call signs, and whatever else to quickly determine whatever that plane “Needed” or what another sector “Wanted” some simply did not get it, it was so intuitive to me that I felt like I was getting dumber trying to help them. I couldn’t imagine how a certified controller felt speaking to my comparatively dumbass.

The ability for a controller to explain what they view as common sense to someone with an infantile concept is a skill in an of itself, which is why OJTI’s are paid extra. This is also why I feel teachers in any profession deserve to be paid more.

A lot of jobs and talents could be broken down like this. Your job, most likely. By the same vein, the USA is a country built on the backs of black slaves, laws were put in place to justify and maintain a system of slavery. Even after the civil war, Jim Crow laws and black codes were put in place to create excuses to criminalize the existence of black people, hinder their success, deny their legal rights, and justify everything done to steal it from them.

the average black American understands that anti-black racism is a problem we endure. We understand the common excuses, idioms, dog whistles, etc etc. but it’s so engrained into our minds that some of us can’t explain it to someone who doesn’t understand already.

In today’s political climate, it’s easy to commit the fallacy fallacy, assuming that someone is lying solely because they cannot argue or substantiate their claims. A racist person with good argumentative skills can get a neutral person on their side.

This is what Angela Davis means when she talks about Anti-Racism. But her issue is assuming the average white person has the same tactile knowledge that we do. Like most jobs and talents, this knowledge must be taught. We are not the only people to suffer in this country, so all sorts of bias (Sexism, Homophobia, Islamophobia etc etc) need to be taught in schools, and especially to people in positions of power so that they can be challenged, or challenge eachother on these things.

There have been times I strongly suspected a person in my life or on the news to be racist, or a certain conviction to be racially motivated over a “Gut feeling”. I’ve learned not to point fingers and scream “Racism!” Because (A) I am not always right and (B) I am not good at arguing my own feelings. But I’ve been vindicated time and time again.

It’s tiring, and I’ve spent a lot of time last year trying to pull myself out of that mindset because it’s self defeating. Only for the same issues to materialize yet again and affect my recent job.

Other black people, co-workers, and supervisors in my life had to re-indoctrinate me on this. I’m being vague on purpose, but there were things I could have said or done to make this easier for myself had I held on to this knowledge instead of trying to forget about it.


r/changemyview • • 2d ago

CMV: Tiffany Woods is not a good comparison for Russell Brand

17 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing a social media posts en mass on my personal instagram feed about Russell Brand in comparison to Tiffany Woods. To quote it:

‘Men are actually out here crying that Russell Brand’s 10.5 year prison sentence for R@PE is too long. Meanwhile, Tiffany Woods got life without parole for feeding her son cow milk out of desperation during Hurricane Katrina. But sure, let’s talk about injustice.’

Many women I love and respect have posted the screenshot of the tweet, and it’s so wrong it makes me upset. I’ll never tell any of them, because I don’t want to start an argument that I could be wrong about, so you people can deal with it / ignore it instead.

  1. Tiffany Woods did not give her child cows milk DURING hurricane Katrina. She gave it to her months after Katrina, and they were living in a rental house 300 miles away.
  2. Her child was 5lbs, 6oz when discharged from NICU. At death, the child had gained about 7oz in nearly 4 months. The kid was starving to death.

2.1) now, some people might say that she gave the cows milk BECAUSE the kid wasn’t taking to formula. Which might make sense if you know nothing about babies. It’s poison to their tiny bodies. You don’t cut cows milk with water, you take them to the doctor. Any doctor, any hospital. Anything.

3) which leads me to the charges. She’s wasn’t charged because she gave cows milk to a baby during Katrina. She was charged and convicted because months after Katrina she had a starving child that she didn’t seek medical care for, and then that emaciated child died. Has she sought any medical care, and then the child died, it would have just been a very sad story.

4) her boyfriend was also convicted. Good. At conception he was 17 and she was 25. A big age gap that some might call predatory. Apparently it was his initial idea to do the cows milk - shocking that your teenage boyfriend had a shitty idea. She had 3+ kids at the time. As a mother myself, after the 3rd one you should really know what to do and not do.

5) Russell brand sucks. He’s a bad person who did heinous things. He should have gotten more time in my book. But please, please, please do not compare the sentencing of a woman who starved and then neglected her child to Russell Brand. It’s nonsensical.

TLDR; post on social circulating pointing out Tiffany Woods got life in prison, lie that it was during Katrina, and men r crying that Russell Brand got 10 years. They think this is a gotcha. Tiffany Woods neglected her starving child and deserves every day behind bars, so stop comparing her. You can just say you wish Russell Brand got more time. That’s fine.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: It's hypocritical for the government to limit sports gambling

0 Upvotes

I've seen numerous government leaders express concern about the rise of sports gambling apps. While some governments have embraced them, many states in the U.S. (and many of their policymakers) point to its harms. They drive addiction, create problem gamblers, increase bankruptcies, etc.

I always thought that made sense, until I learned that state-run gambling (the lottery, scratch-offs, etc.) target a lower-income population (sports gambling is younger, affluent, men while the lottery is older, blue collar workers), creates more problem gamblers, and makes more money (aka costs the people it targets more money).

Any state that wants to block the development of new sports gambling apps is acting hypocritically unless it firsts shuts down its taxpayer funded scheme its pushing that does the same thing but worse.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

CMV: Your current relationship doesn't have to be your best one

0 Upvotes

I believe there is a widespread yet disingenuous belief that the current partner you are dating or with needs to be the best you've had, and that if they aren't, then you are doing them a disservice and should leave them. I believe that this belief doesn't hold ground, and that not only is it ok to date someone knowing they aren't your best relationship, but it is actually very common.

First off, I think the significant majority of people do not hold themselves to this standard. To say that the current person you are dating is your best (and to have held that believe in all prior relationships), the implication is that there is basically a linear line of improvement with each relationship, and that if you were to rank all of your relationships then it it would be 1:1 new-old, worst-best.

Second, I don't see any issue with having your current partner not be your best. For instance, I have eaten at a gourmet burger restaurant once and it was the best burger I've had. This doesn't mean that I can never thoroughly enjoy burgers from other places though. Not everyone can get everything they want, and you are gonna have to compromise in some places of life, relationships included.

I personally just find this idea that your current partner has to be the best a little disingenuous, and I don't think it's a reasonable expectation to put on someone. I feel like settling for someone is extremely common within relationships, but people don't really want to say the quiet part out loud and want to beat around the bush instead of admitting that it's not reasonable to expect every relationship you enter to be the next best thing otherwise you have to break up.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

CMV: Everyday, "average" people are just as responsible for the dystopian hellscape we're in as the elites

0 Upvotes

Whenever people bring up how much of a shitshow the world currently is right now, fingers are always pointed at rich people or the politicians currently running our governments. They are absolutely guilty and making the world a worse place, but no one seems to want to acknowledge that the average joe demographic is probably just as responsible for the world being as fucked as it is.

Like, think about it. Would these rich people have as much money as they do if we didn't keep buying all their products? Jeffery Bezos is rich because everyone uses Amazon. Mark Zuckerberg is rich because people can't stop using Instagram. Sam Altman is rich because, no matter how much internet natives shout about how much they hate ChatGPT, your average coworker most definitely uses it. And why is Donald Trump in power? Because most of the people in the US voted for him, even after after already having him as president. The majority of people looked at his first four years and thought "yes, we want this to happen again", and put him back into power. Hell, the majority of our children are mentally stunted now because the average person thinks giving your baby an automatic device funneling miles of slop and exploitative trash into its brains is a fine thing to do and don't see any problems with it. It gets to a point where you have to realize that society is fucked because your average human being just can't stop consuming unquestionably and making horrible decisions that'll have dire consequences in the future because no one can think more than two steps ahead.

People use to say that the internet was making us more empathetic and informed, but I've never been able to agree with that. Your average person isn't using social media to stay politically conscious or connect with people across the world. They're using to watch funny videos. Funny videos that rot their brain and numb them enough to keep them from ever having to think about anything for too long. Videos that probably aren't even made by human beings anymore. If we're going to analyze how the internet came to the state it is now, we have to accept that the average person is mainly responsible for it. They love automation. They love convenience. And they love empty distractions. TikTok and AI is immensely profitable for a reason, and it's because no matter how much we recognize how harmful and vile they are to the human soul, normal people love them.

I don't know. I'm just tired of "optimists" trying to insist that everyone's just innocently manipulated into the life or it's just rich people forcing us into this lifestyle. I'm very sure that's part of it and I'm not denying it, but I wish someone would finally acknowledge that most of the people who aren't chronically online probably has very little issue with the way the world is right now. Everything's built exactly for them, and they like it that way.

I'd love to be proven wrong and I'll admit that I make myself miserable, so please. Change my view.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago Bravo

Delta(s) from OP CMV: The process of learning social skills is a taboo topic,the average person does not want it to be taught to those who lack it, and missing it out on formative years will leave permanent damage to one's social life

375 Upvotes

This is an observation ive had for years. If one lacks social skills, to acquire them it will be a pain in the ass, thats obvious. However ive noticed that, more recently, people having been dodging the subject and trying to keep solutions out of reach for those who struggle it. I do not know if i'm going crazy but, from personal experience in life and watching online communities, this seems to be it.

If you're awkard, for example, nobody wants you to *stop* being awkward, even if you shown interest on trying to stop being. You'll be told to just be yourself, to not listen to others and be happy, even if you are completely disgusted at your own social awkwardness and crave to fit in. If you insist, they'll say you're weird for being obsessed with that, and it goes on and on.

Every suggestion to standardize teaching social skills is rejected (like a class of sorts at a young age to avoid children falling behind in those skills), and most methods proposed online barely work. Mentioning gets you told to suck it up and touch grass, to try harder, or to be yourself.

My theory? This has to do with evolutionary reasons. Social skills is something you learn during your formative years, you're only going to fully fit in if you learn during your late childhood and teenagehood, otherwise, you will never develop them as normal people do. If you, for example, end up being considered the weird, rejected kid and isolate yourself, you'll likely fall on a self fulfilling spiral that will make them get worse and worse.

A decent margin of those people (which i'm a part of) will never lean how to socialize, since when you're older you have less neuroplasticity and, mainly, it will be a humiliating experience: To go out, look like a manchild who speaks slowly and knows weird things, feeling intimidated and judged, is something few can overcome the discomfort and force through to learn them. And even then, those who do will never be as good as someone who developed them normally as a child and teen, and will inevitably fall in the social uncanny valley. Its like learning a second language, if you dont learn one as a child, you'll struggle a lot to learn by yours 30s and never get to the level you would if you were taught at 4 years old or soo.

One like this could, at the knowledge gaps they have, mess up a negotiation in the group they're a part of and consequently cause horrible things depending on how bad everything went. Soo, to keep the tribe safe, people have a built in rejection to the idea of teaching those things.

Furthermore, this also is an evolutionary "self cleaning mechanism", since those who lack social skills are generally neurodivergent, and those are seem as unpredictable and, deep down in human instinct, unpredictability is dangerous, thus best to avoid. Not saying ND people are bad, i myself unfortunately have adhd, and it is likely the reason i have no true friendships and never had a partner in life, but i do not judge normal people for having those feelings.

To keep someone without those skills, showing their traits, is subconsciously "best" for the average functional person because it keeps a red flag high on that person's head, screaming that they're potentially dangerous, thus avoiding the risk of dealing with someone who, at the darkest hour, might mess up things or plain up just do something horrible.

edit: I want to see counter arguments to this. Part of me wants to hope that overcoming such lack of skills is possible. But i struggle to see how, since most people react with utter disgust when someone is learning those, and reject any proposals to help it.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Ripping Pokemon cards or any other TCG is gateway gambling for children

72 Upvotes

How is this any different from slots or roulette?

I believe this for the following:

  1. Most packs what you get in the pack is referred to as "bulk" which is a euphemism for losing.
  2. Your wins are called hits, how is this different from hitting something on the slot machine?
  3. There is no skill element. Poker is gambling but you can make the argument that it is different in that you are using psychology and statistics to place your bets. If you play among friends there is no house cut so you could argue poker ISN'T gambling.

The rush of opening a Pokemon pack, or any trading card game for that manner is the unknown of getting a card of value. This is no different from pushing that button on the slot machine, how many packs you purchase is the same as how many dollars you place on the spin, or how many spins you do. The feeling of always wanting more is present. The biggest difference is Pokemon cards aren't as available as gambling where the house is always open and you aren't cut off. If scalpers weren't a thing it would be so much worse. Giving you a token of inconsequential value just circumvents the legality.

I personally believe TCGs such as Pokemon, Hearthstone etc... should be age restricted and educated about. The only winner is the company that prints the cards. There is nothing wrong with having fun, but this needs to be an age restricted activity.

Please change my view, I loved Pokemon as a child but I only played the games and watched the shows, my parents wouldn't let me buy cards and I now see why.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

CMV: The medical industrys lack of medical research on womens biology affects women everyday and we need to start focusing on women more in studies.

116 Upvotes

women regularly get delayed treatment and diagnosis, this leaves an entire group of human beings at risk everyday of catching medical issues to late.

when it comes to diagnosing patients with medical conditions, most of the knowledge used to decide the criteria for a diagnosis comes from research on men’s symptoms leaving women left out when science shows female symptoms can be significantly different than men’s for the same condition

because there is a lack of knowledge on women’s bodies due to women not being included in testing and often being left out of health and anatomy books. Doctors are often severely misinformed about the anatomy of women, leaving every female, born patient at risk of incorrect medical treatment.

For example, many women receive late in life, diagnosis of ADHD due to the traditional symptoms being described as hyperactivity and outwardly expressed these symptoms are based off male experiences study show that most women experience inattentive subtypes

I strongly believe that the medical field has failed when focusing on women’s biology and I am open to hearing opposing arguments on this issue.

Edit: thank you all for replying to this I need counter arguments for a current paper I am writing and needed real world opinions all of you have helped me out greatly!!!


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Playing chess is boring.

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

To make it as plain and simple as possible : I’m playing chess for about ten years. I’m an ordinary low level internet player : I used to play intuitively, then I read a basic book about tactics, then thought I knew it all, so I read opening books thinking it was the key to victory, realized it wasn’t, read strategy books because I was amazed how stronger players could dominate the board with ’’simple’’ moves, etc. My best speed game is correspondence (between 3 and 7 days a move), I’ve reached 2200+ on lichess (I don’t like or know other websites), I used to play a lot at that speed but now I’m done with it. Nowadays I’m playing bullet to rapid games, and I’m 1600+ on rapid.

So… why do I find chess boring ? Because as a beginner, what I wanted was to play better, that’s why I read these books. However, whatever I’ve learned from them was unuseful because at the low level I was playing, everything was about blunder : the player who blunders the first (or the most) gives his opponent the opportunity to win. And guess what : I used to blunder a lot. So I decided to just focus on that : are my pieces safe ? Are his pieces safe ? And nothing else. That made me win a lot of games and improve my level but hell, it was so boring ! It was boring to be constantly vigilant, on every move, on every piece ! I remember forcing myself to meditate before playing, and repeting in my head while playing : « his blunders… my blunders… » ! Then, after weeks or months like this, I became better at it, but then new challenges appeared, which were checking tactical combinations : forks distances, alignment, locked pieces, overloaded pieces, etc. This shit never ends, or should I say the boring tasks never end.

Sure, I could play chess just like some guys play dices or darts at the pub, just for fun, but I see chess as something different, you know : the king of games. Darts have never been a Cold War issue. Dices have never been a challenge for IA. In my opinion, when you play chess, you MUST play your A-game, that’s what it’s made for. If you don’t play it that way, don’t even play it, and playing your A-game at chess is EXTREMELY BORING. You know, when you see documentaries or youtube videos about Karpov-Kasparov championship, about Bobby Fischer, about Magnus Carlsen, it sounds like an incredible adventure : « they were doing this in such a situation, but all of the sudden his opponent did that, which completely turned the tables ! », but when you try it… all you do is boring things : checking each piece safety ; checking alignments, etc. It’s the same thing as the success stories about companies in TV shows or movies like « the social network » : we’ve identified an opportunity in the market, we’re gonna conqueer the world, become rich and all that stuff, but most of your REAL JOB is : making your accountancy, respecting safety standards, dealing with insurance companies, and all the daily BORING TASKS. Same shit. That’s what I’m thinking sometimes about chess : I enjoy this game but… it’s like enjoying making accountancy on your spare time, while you could play darts at the pub with your friends.


r/changemyview • • 4d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Physician assisted suicide should be legal for competent adults who no longer wish to live, not just those with terminal illnesses

557 Upvotes

Okay i know this might sound controversial, and to be clear, i am not advocating for suicide or encouraging anyone to harm themselves. i am currently working on a school assignment about physician-assisted suicide, and in the US, it is strictly reserved for patients with terminal illnesses.

My view is that if a competent adult genuinely does not want to live anymore, whether due to severe chronic physical pain, treatment-resistant mental suffering, a permanent loss of quality of life, etc. and they are truly set on it, they will eventually find a way to end their life on their own. Wouldn't it be more compassionate and ethical to allow them to leave with dignity in a safe and painless way rather than forcing them into isolated, violent, or traumatic methods on their own?

To clarify a few boundaries on my view, this would apply strictly to legal adults as i don’t believe minors have the developmental capacity or decision making ability to make a permanent choice of thsi magnitude. I also believe there should still be strict regulations in place and steps taken before the ultimate choice (such as psychiatric evaluations) to ensure that the person is mentally competent and not acting on a temporary and treatable impulse. And of course, participation by doctors should always be completely voluntary and the doctors can opt out of providing this end of life care if it is not within their ethical boundaries.

So yeah, CMV.


r/changemyview • • 2d ago

CMV: Changing your pension and bank has the biggest effect on climate change...it isn't that hard either

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this constantly as I was the news from COP 31 and I'm convinced that I'm right about this.

Admittedly, the effect isn't immediate though.

Rather than waiting for governments to sort our future, I move any money I had away from fossil fuels.

This meant choosing an ethical bank, who doesn't invest in petrochemicals, oil and gas, as well as arms. I moved my main account and a small savings pot, which took less than two weeks.

Then I did my pensions through another firm, choosing their climate plan. It wasn't even that hard, just a bit of paperwork, and I'm no longer funding a future I don't want.

Admittedly, I'm a drop in the ocean but imagine if more people did this. We'd soon see global on a massive scale and actual change.

Even if fifty percent of the population did this, it would be huge as fossil fuels firms would be forced to reinvest in greener alternatives or face bankruptcy.

They also wouldn't have the sway within politics that they currently do, with limitations on monetary kickbacks as firms would struggle to pay for the wages of employees (especially the board).

More oil and gas would stay in the ground, so I could have an actual liveable future.

Plus you are more likely to see your money grow steadily, as more people invest in green tech.

I will never understand why more environmentalists don't promote this, like The Guardian did back in the day.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: "Eugenics" is often misused, but even if we go by what people mean, eugenics isnt always bad

0 Upvotes

This was from another post i have made

If i said that i hope putin never reproduces, thats not eugenics. And even if it was, what is wrong with hoping certain people dont reproduce. Key word is hoping.

If we said, i hope that serial killer gets locked up, we are, in a consequence, preventing them from reprodicing.

If i said i hope all assaulters never reproduce what is wront with that.

However to the core issue i have is that i believe that poor people on welfare should not willingly have kids. It is irresponsible. The most common argument i hear is that the poverty people are in is the fault of power hungry rich etc. It is not the fault of the rich that one who cant feed themsleves decide to add to their own financial burden

However, lets suppose someone is not in poverty. They have wages that can cover their rent or mortgage and enough so they never go hungry. However, they do not have enough money to feed an extra mouth, but they chose to have one anyways. How is this not irresponsible and if my wish they not have kids is labelled eugenics, what is the problem with this "eugenic" wish. Its based on action not genes. Its no better than someone being a shopoholic and buying and spending beyond their means.

the government should no more cover your debt incured by the child you had nor the frivolous spending you had. and yes, even if we let compassion win, I don't see any right to let the progenitors to raise the kid when they clearly knowingly created the child they knew they could not raise

To change my view one can demonstrate people who willingly have kids are not irresponsible but rather making a sound decision or that they are in fact, not responsible for the action at all, which would hardly make sense as I said this scenario is for willing participants.

If it is sound, demonstrate how having a kid is not being selfish in asking welfare to fund their lifestyle in having a kid.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

CMV: The assassination attempt on Donald Trump in Butler was not staged

0 Upvotes

Right off the bat I want to specify that I'm not arguing about whether or not Trump was actually shot or not. I personally think he was, but if people believe he was struck by falling glass or shrapnel or whatever else then I could believe that too.

The purpose of this post is to truly understand the arguments that people have for believing the entire thing was staged. Whenever I see a post on reddit that even tangentially relates to the shooting a large portion of the comments invariably mention that the whole thing was obviously faked.

For the record I am as left-wing as they come, and I despise Trump.

I've seen that people point out:

- That it was 'too convenient'

- That, if Trump truly was in danger that he wouldn't have gotten up and pumped his fists, and that secret service wouldn't have allowed it

- That if it was real, Trump would be talking about it way more often

In my view all of these can be explained pretty reasonably. Most importantly, however, these theories really are at odds with the fact that:

- One bystander died at the scene, one bystander died years later from their injuries, and 6 others were severely injured.

- The shooter himself was shot and killed at the scene.

- Police were moments away from interfering; in fact, the shooter began the assassination attempt when he did because 40 seconds prior the police had attempted to scale onto the roof and were dissuaded away by the shooter's rifle.

- There are images taken of the bullet that struck him as it was travelling mid-air towards Trump.

- For a scheme like this to be successful there would have needed to be many people in on it, all of whom would not only need to keep their mouths shut but also all be confident that no one else would ever snitch about this happening too. They would also all need to agree to a plan that risked people in the crowd being killed, and then for no one to snitch once people actually were killed.

- That there has been nothing that has come out since that provides evidence of such a scheme occurring, such as leaks bad actors receiving payment or emails/texts detailing the plan.

I just don't see how people can be so confident that this whole thing was staged when the events don't really line up with many other conspiracy theories that end up being true. It genuinely does come across like this was real.


r/changemyview • • 5d ago Bravo

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Religion is one of society's greatest evils

339 Upvotes

It will be hard to change my opinion on this topic. I will openly admit this. And I also say these things as a theist.

So to begin religion, or precisely a particular brand of theism common in modern evangelical belief, is a because force of erosion. It erodes human agency. It erodes competence. It erodes social order. And most crucially it erodes liberty.

To begin with agency religion attributes good to a benevolent God or gods and evil to some Satan or malevolent god(s). When we experience good fortune we attribute it to the will of the divine and likewise when we experience misfortune. This erodes the importance of human action and shifts the attribution away from behavior and towards devotion. This erosion in turn acts as a disincentive to human action. Though most problematic in monotheistic religions, particularly Christianity, because "thy will be done" and therefore your action is meaningless and if you were meant to take action a god would make you. If something bad happens because of your inaction it was divine will.

Rather than accepting observed reality and developing an understanding of how cause begets effect, religion introduces an external locus of causal authority which one is subordinate to. This is an erosion of human agency and erodes the foundation for moral responsibility and deludes one into thinking their failures are punishment and their successes rewards.

Next is the erosion of competence wherein religion introduces a competing standard of truth in the way of divine revelation and scripture and religious doctrine. This directly destroys competence, as competence is the successful application of knowledge to a desired end. This means that competence, at its highest levels, is predicated on the recognition that reality is objective and that observation and reason is the primary source of knowledge.

The problem isn’t simply that religious claims are frequently unverifiable. It is that religious epistemology can encourage individuals to accept propositions without requiring the same evidentiary standards they would ordinarily apply to claims about the material world.

The doctrine becomes the truth and cannot be false. Competence requires we accept that we may be false. That we may be in error. And that we correct or misinformed or underdeveloped observations and assumptions to better account for reality as observed.

Thirdly is the erosion of social order. Not much will be said here for this is not a singular effect but the symptom of the others. It is the case, in my view, that social order is the first victim when agency, competence, and liberty are eroded. What will be said here is that religious dogmatism incentivizes cult behavior in which one proclaims loudly and fervently specific utterances designed to mark themselves as a member of the in group. We can look at Pete Hegseth and his adulation of Doug Wilson (a man who has claimed slavery was an institution of love) and the prolific utterances of the Christian nationalist movement on the erosion of church and state. It is discord seeking, chaotic governance that erodes social cohesion and the belief that we do not require shared beliefs to co-exist as a liberal society.

Lastly is the erosion of personal sovereignty. Religion, like monarchy, subordinates the individual to the divine. a worldview that places ultimate moral authority in an omnipotent supernatural being is a worldview that demands, the subordination of individual liberty to an allegedly higher authority.

Thus it is my view that religion, due to its erosion of society and human flourishing, is one of the greatest modern evils to exist.


r/changemyview • • 5d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Consent does not have to be enthusiastic

395 Upvotes

I’m on the ace spectrum. Most of the time, I only desire to have sex in response to my partner’s desire, so I often agree before my own desire kicks in. Sometimes, sex is just another activity I could engage in, no different than say reading or taking a walk, and if propositioned, I feel like “yeah, why not” rather than “hell yes”. I’d say I consented to all these encounters and had overall good experiences. The sex I have is not somehow lesser, or make me a victim, because it’s not aligned with norms.

Or take some other scenarios. Two parents trying for a baby, having sex after timing cycles to boost fertility. It could be that neither are particularly excited—it’s more of a mechanical task at this point—but you wouldn’t say they somehow didn’t consent, right? Or take sex workers where such work is legal and regulated. I doubt they’re enthusiastic about every client, but work is work.

From the FRIES acronym, I think the rest make a good framework for clearly defining consent: Freely given, Reversible, Informed, Specific. The E is a bonus, not a requirement.

What won’t CMV: if “enthusiastic” is used as a proxy for other criteria. Then just use those criteria directly! For example, enthusiasm implies that you’re not being coerced, but “freely given” is already part of many definitions of consent.

So Reddit, CMV.

ETA: To reduce confusion on what I mean by enthusiastic, the dictionary (and colloquial) definition is "feeling or showing intense excitement, interest, or approval toward someone or something." I'm not aware of any convincing alternate definitions. While being reluctant fails to meet this criterion, the strictest antonym to "enthusiastic" is in fact "apathetic" or "indifferent". In other words, my view is that consent can be indifferent.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: If Israel's goal were really just security and anti-terrorism like China's, its results would look like Kashgar, not rubble and new settlements

0 Upvotes

So both countries say they're doing the same thing, right? Fighting extremism. Keeping people safe. Totally the same goal. Let's just compare how it's going.

China:

Two decades of attacks in Xinjiang. Urumqi riots in 2009, the car attack at Tiananmen in 2013, the Kunming station stabbings in 2014, thousands of Uyghur militants off fighting in Syria. China's answer was a massive crackdown. Mass detention, re-education, religion restricted hard. Yeah, lots of innocent people got caught up in it, and that sucked.

Results: most people went home. Their towns got roads, jobs, and investment. Uyghur culture got UNESCO status. Kashgar is full of tourists now, and western influencers are literally moving there and marrying locals. Attacks basically stopped.

Israel:

Also "fighting extremism." Same goal, remember.

Results: tens of thousands dead in Gaza, a huge share of them kids. Most of the strip turned to rubble. Meanwhile in the West Bank, settlers keep moving into Palestinian homes and new settlements keep popping up.

Weird. You'd think if the goal was just security, you'd end up with fewer enemies and more stability. Instead somehow you end up with more land. Must be a coincidence. China apparently forgot to make the counterterrorism plan include taking anyone's house.

And honestly, ask any Palestinian parent with zero connection to Hamas. Would you rather get detained for a while and come home to a job and new roads, or watch your family get pulled out of the rubble? Detention ends. Dead is dead. Kids can't have a future if they don't live long enough to see it.

But sure, the west called the first one genocide and kept shipping bombs to the second. Very consistent.

Not saying China was perfect, it absolutely wasn't. I'm saying one campaign left people something to come home to, and the other one keeps leaving the land empty and filling it with someone else.


r/changemyview • • 4d ago

CMV: It is no more immoral for a celebrity to do an ad for a gambling app than it is for them to do an ad for alcohol

0 Upvotes

Celebrities like Danny McBride and Timothy Chalamet are in Kalshi ads. Kalshi is a gambling application where you can bet on pretty much anything. I've see people upset at them for making money from an ad for a product that causes and encourages bad behavior and gambling addiction. I do not see the same level of distaste for celebrities that do beer ads or liquor ads or even create their own liquors. I think it's selective outrage and a double standard to find doing an ad for Kalshi immoral but not an ad for a beer or liquor company. If we look at the numbers, alcoholism is extremely more prevalent in the United States than gambling addiction. I understand Kalshi could make it more prevalent and more wide spread, but I find it ridiculous to be up in arms about the potential harm of gambling ads, while being fine with the current harm of alcohol that is ten times the amount of gambling addiction.

The only exception I have is if you've personally been horribly effected by gambling addiction and not alcoholism. Personal feelings like that can be difficult to trump even when faced with the numbers.

I'm leaving the Sidney Sweeney thing out of this. Her ads controversy seemed to be more about her sexuality that it being a gambling ad itself.

For the record, I do not gamble, but I do like to drink.


r/changemyview • • 6d ago

CMV: Romeo and Juliet laws are fine, but an overall staggered age of consent for age gap relationships is completely insane.

360 Upvotes

In the wake of the recent conviction of Russel Brand, and the allegations levelled against David Walliams, there has been much discussion of changes to age of consent laws in the UK.

For the record, I believe keeping the age at 16 is relatively reasonable, with the condition that certain positions of trust are not abused (e.g teachers/doctors) and that fame ought to probably be added into these laws (as famous people have been shown to have levels of access and manipulation akin to other figures like coaches, teachers, priests etc.

I think that there is a reasonable argument to ensure 16/17 year olds can only consent to sex with similar aged persons, not 30/40 year olds an upwards. While some would keep the legal age gaps around 1-2 years up or down, I would personally opt to have everything between 16-21 legally fine.

This is mostly just a vibe, based on the fact that that age bracket are likely to somewhat socialise together, go the same events, clubs, festivals etc, or have siblings in those age groups (and thus a fair amount of normal contact with people of those ages)

I think it would be extremely unfortunate if a 20 year old happened to hook up with a 17 year old after a night out, and potentially be saddled with a criminal conviction, placed on the sex offenders register and generally have their life possibly ruined, by a pretty ordinary event/ or even mistake,.

Some have added to the conversation, that the concept of staggered ages of consent should be codified in law, even further.

This for me is complete madness. Government overreach to the absolute max. I can see no justification for the government intervening in a relationship between a 22 year old and a 44 year old, for instance.

While there may be a power imbalance between those individuals, I don't think that rules out a loving or positive relationship, necessarily.

On top of that, power imbalances can come from levels of income, levels of education, identity, physical and mental health, and various other factors.

Surely, most would find it completely absurd if the government forbade relationships between an ultra rich, and working class person? Or a person with a PHD vs someone who dropped out of High School. Or a wheelchair user and a able bodied person.

Why then would the government legislate against age gaps, but not other forms of power imbalance?

Anyway, that's my view. I am interested to hear arguments in favour of stricter age of consent laws, that may go to even higher ages - and examples of how this could work and what successes it may bring. Thanks


r/changemyview • • 6d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Psychological suffering is not a pre requirement for extraordinary achievements in life and we should stop romanticizing it completely.

121 Upvotes

I believe that people nowadays have developed a tendency to associate extraordinary intellectual achievements with extreme suffering. I got this idea while reading about historical accounts of certain scientists. For example let's take Srinivasa Ramanujan who was a brilliant mathematician but suffered from financial hardships and serious health problems. Also madam curie overcame poverty, gender discrimination, difficult working conditions and still managed to be extraordinary. People often tell or write about them and their greatness through the lens of struggle. But I seriously think we are overlooking something important.Achieving something because of suffering is not the same as achieving something despite suffering.I don't deny that adversity can sometimes develop resilience, change our perspective or encourage personal growth. Nor am I suggesting that extraordinary achievements come without discipline, sacrifice, persistence or intellectual struggle. But I will surely argue that psychological suffering itself is not necessary for exceptional creativity or intellectual development. In fact, prolonged distress and exhaustion can interfere with concentration, motivation and the ability to perform. I also connect this thought with modern hustle culture where people are always expected to stay productive, sacrifice comfort, and treat exhaustion as a sign of dedication. Rest is considered laziness. In all this glorifying we actually are undermining the values of effort, curiosity and supportive environment.

So is there any convincing scientific evidence that psychological suffering contributes to exceptional creativity or intellectual achievement? Also does prolonged adversity provide advantages that cannot be developed through intellectual challenges, education, curiosity and a supportive environment? Or am I overlooking something important about the relationship between suffering, resilience and achievement?