r/RocketLeague • u/TinyTimothy22 Grand Champion • Apr 25 '17
r/RocketLeague, we'd like to take a minute to talk with you about Reddit and CSS
In January’s assessment of the year to come, /u/spez rolled out a number of goals for the coming year in regards to the direction Reddit will be moving. Much of it was built around building a more welcoming community for all users, building more integration of mod tools, and enhancements to their perceived outdated design tools. Of note, he wrote the following:
One project I would like to preview is a rewrite of the desktop website. It is a long time coming. The desktop website has not meaningfully changed in many years; it is not particularly welcoming to new users (or old for that matter); and still runs code from the earliest days of Reddit over ten years ago. We know there are implications for community styles and various browser extensions.
One of the concerns from this announcement was that CSS customization might go away, and now we are learning that this will become reality, as announced Friday.
We’re designing a new set of tools to address the challenges with CSS but continue to allow communities to express their identities. These tools will allow moderators to select customization options for key areas of their subreddit across platforms. For example, header images and flair colors will be rendered correctly on desktop and mobile.
While they demonstrate an act of good faith with that statement, what is not at all clear in the post, and what has not been made clear in replies is what is truly meant when they said they will, “continue to allow communities to express their identities.”
However, what has been made abundantly clear is that this change is being driven because reddit users are increasingly coming into the site on a mobile platform. And on all mobile platforms (especially app-driven experiences, as opposed to browser-driven experiences), CSS is not seen as being important to the user experience. The app and mobile experience delivers all of the thread and comment content of reddit, yet it does not allow for for the individual enhancements that not only give subreddits their identity but also a more robust functionality.
For those of us who still come to reddit on our laptops or desktops, the CSS of many subreddits is not only important, but *vital* to their design and functionality.
Think of the subreddits you browse on a daily basis. Look at the small bits and pieces of each that you like and use, like the post filters on /r/squaredcircle and r/overwatch or the menu of helpful links on /r/music. Think of one of your longest and loudest requests, flairs. From small touches to /r/baseball like the nightmode sun or the mods with custom flair, to fully rendered sidebars for each team sub that updates scores, ranking and statistics on the fly.
All of that is done right now with CSS. All of it.
We here at Rocket League take a great deal of pride in the work that our mod team has put into the look and feel of this sub. Our whole development team has put in a lot of work and are still in the process of updating it in response to many user complaints, while has been done entirely with CSS.
We know that this change is going to come. The driving factors for this change are too important to the Reddit admins to be stopped. The reasoning behind the changes—faster performance, scalability, security, etc.—are all good and valid reasons to want to redesign the site.
Across reddit, all we ask is that when that change comes, we are allowed to keep the identities and individuality that essentially define the Reddit communities you know and love. We want to avoid a homogenization of reddit that offers only colored headers and a sidebar full of pre-made widgets that tested well with mobile app users.
We also want to make it clear that, in general, we try as best as we can to make sure that the drama that sometimes engulfs reddit as a whole does not impair the user experience in r/RocketLeague. We are, and always have been, a subreddit that focuses on the game and the community around it. But these changes can and will substantially impact our collective experience and your engagement with those of us who frequent this forum. For that reason, the mod team feels it important to make this statement on these proposed changes.
Our modteam will do our best to make sure that this subreddit is able to retain it's individuality, be it by continuing to discuss with the admins the importance of CSS or by getting involved with the alpha testing of this new desktop redesign. We have teamed up with lots of other moderators in /r/ProCSS and are working to ensure that our subreddits retain as much creativity as possible.
If you'd like to support /r/ProCSS, please read this post.
- The r/RocketLeague Mod Team
* cough huge thanks to r/NFL and r/FinalFantasy
3
u/IamAlso_u_grahvity Apr 27 '17
Jesus, what a gorgeous theme you guys made here. I only discovered you because of a comment in r/modnews. I can't hold a candle to the talent of the people involved in this theme but I do understand the effort and love it it takes and satisfaction it brings having spent hundreds of hours teaching myself CSS and trying to spiffy up my subs. (And I still suck)
Anyway, I just wanted to share my admiration for what you've done here. Cheers!
117
u/AnindoorcatBot STS-107 Apr 25 '17
Reddit takes another step into obscurity.
2 hops this time!!
49
u/burger_fourohfive Season 2 Champion Apr 25 '17
my condolences to all the programmers.
rest in peppermint
124
u/Hash_S :rldiscord: #s - Rocket League Discord (Administrator) Apr 25 '17
The current theme is too good to go away like this. I know how much work was put into making the css, and I hope that the people at reddit will change their minds about removing css.
38
u/minimalist_reply :gc: Grand Champion Apr 25 '17
Reddit Admins making dumb moves for the sake of business decisions that ultimately won't even pay off.
20
u/Dragonslayer314 KBM Forever Apr 25 '17
Without CSS, what'll happen to /r/Ooer and /r/ooerintensifies? I really like the current RL CSS theme, and I'll be sad to see CSS go.
25
u/FlyingRyan87 Apr 25 '17
I support rocket league! And psyonix!
10
u/powersnake Champion I Apr 25 '17
I read an article about this on theverge.com about 10 minutes ago and immediately thought of this sub's new style and how much work was put into it. Hopefully they'll cancel their plans or perhaps allow for grandfathering of existing styles or something.
2
u/tylerhockey12 Diamond II Apr 25 '17
are you like the only mod?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
Thanks Timothy for the detailed post and the work you've been putting in on the subreddit, it shows!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
Looks like anyone who wants to discuss for the change is being downvoted. Niiiiiiice
1
u/roknir Champion III May 26 '17
The expandos currently cover most of the upvote and downvote icons. Any fixes coming for that?
3
u/TotesMessenger Apr 25 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/Soundteq Apr 26 '17
I'm going to wait and see what those new tools are before passing judgement. He has some good points against CSS and I think you're overstating when you say CSS is vital to the function of some subs. It can make things a little more convenient on desktop but I've never visited a sub from my phone that wasn't functional.
But if over 50% of your users are on mobile platform and that number is going up it makes sense to shift more support towards that platform.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
Fuck Reddit lately. They're doing all kinds of stupid shit.
2
u/XKaniberX ♫ I tried so hard, and ranked so high ♫ Apr 26 '17
Aw yiss, my second fav sub after /r/dankmemes supports CSS, good shit.
3
u/BurritoCon Champion II Apr 26 '17
While I don't like the new style... this is still tragic for the people that put in all the work to make it
1
u/NeedHelpWithExcel Season 3 Super Champion Apr 25 '17
I always turn off CSS anyways :<
1
u/-_galaxy_- Apr 26 '17
Can't they use useragent or something to filter CSS on mobile? Weird.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
I want to say that the CSS on mobile is great too.
A lot of subs cause problems for mobile but your works fine! (Though voting might be a little dark on the lowest brightness) But the filler was the best use of a filter ever. It is actually now easy to use!
1
u/CodyCus Take 3 Apr 26 '17
Your top bar that is supposed to show messages and links back to reddit is not working. It just shows my name, rank, and that's it.
1
u/baldurs_mate Apr 26 '17
We come to Reddit on desktop browsers cause it's not a fucking rss feed...That being said, perhaps the "new tools" will eventually allow for full styling...
Have they revealed any of the purported new tools yet? And where if so? Sorry I am late to this
1
u/YuzToChihiro Champion II Apr 26 '17
Having CSS off by default but having a little tickbox on each sub saying 'use css' seems like a good compromise. That way each sub would be forced to go through reddit's new customisation tools to appeal to new users, so mobile users get the benefits, and then the people who really liked CSS can still use it
1
u/chuckthetruck64 I know how to put ball in goal Apr 26 '17
So dumb but alas I doubt Reddit is going to reverse course.
CSS is so simple to learn the basics and the stuff that can be done with it are absolutely amazing. There is a reason it has been a standard for websites for a long while. Seriously just make a subreddit watch some tutorials and have fun messing with shit on this site while you can. Hopefully the replacement is just as easy and has enough possibilities but I am not holding my breath.
1
u/seaishriver Apr 27 '17
Okay, people are really misunderstanding what's going on. CSS was not built for what it is used for on reddit. It was made for styling existing content, so it doesn't handle changes to the site at all. CSS is meant to be the finishing touches on a site. When you add content with CSS, it is always preferable, given the power, to add the same content with HTML.
What reddit wants to do is change the layout a lot. This breaks at least some and probably most things in almost all of the custom CSS subreddits. And while having custom, user-made CSS is neat, no other large website does that, so taking it out isn't that radical.
Reddit could keep custom CSS, and have everyone rewrite their CSS for the new layout, but that only means the problem today (outdated site) will happen again in the future. If reddit wants to be able to update their site as needed, then custom CSS is not an option.
There are ways to allow custom styling, though. Tumblr and WordPress have custom pages while every page still serves the same type of content (blog posts). This is what reddit should do. It's a little harder to implement, though, since the site has to make sure you don't put unwanted code into it. CSS doesn't have this problem since CSS is limited to styling.
I'm kinda late but I hope this clears things up.
1
u/s0lv3 Champion III May 03 '17
Trash Reddit people ruining the fun
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
It really isn't a big deal. Site continuity over individual styles every day of the week.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
[removed] — view removed comment