r/AskHistorians • • 9h ago

Digest Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | November 22, 2026

8 Upvotes

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.


r/AskHistorians • • 4d ago

SASQ Short Answers to Simple Questions | November 18, 2026

12 Upvotes

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are preferred. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

r/AskHistorians • • 44m ago

In the bible, Jesus gave out loaves and fishes. Ignoring the religious etc aspects: What fish(es) would be available in that location (NW shore of the Sea of Galilee) and how would a person in that time and place have prepared a fish to eat if just given one?

52 Upvotes

As above. Who was the average person and how did they do a fish dinner?


r/AskHistorians • • 5h ago

AMA I’m Andrew Yamato, co-founder and leader of "The Greek Phalanx" reenactment group, and on Sunday, November 22 at 3pm EST I’ll be here to talk about the many ways authentic historical reenactment is contributing to our understanding of Ancient Greek warfare.

98 Upvotes

In the five years since our formation in 2021, The Greek Phalanx has been at the forefront of a major expansion of Ancient Greek reenactment on both sides of the Atlantic. In addition to our stateside events, we’re helping build on the success of the 2022 and 2024 “Battle of Plataea” reenactments in Greece by planning another large international event on the Peloponnesian War battlefields of Pylos and Sphakteria.

Although first and foremost a fun hobby, serious Ancient Greek reenactment affords real insights to both casual observers and open-minded scholars by offering:

  • authentic reconstructions of armor, weapons, and clothing
  • experimental recreations of various combat styles and tactical models
  • interpretative performances of attested but unpreserved rituals like Pyrrhic dances and battle paeans
  • cultural contexts of foodways, religion, and recreation
  • immersive experiences on location at ancient battlefields

Perhaps most of all, the hobby nurtures a growing global community of experts and enthusiasts from various backgrounds who share information and often act as informal peer-reviewers of new theories and reconstructions. With so little accurate portrayal of Ancient Greek warfare in the mass media, and with so many unknowns even in our scholarly understanding of it, reenactors have both a responsibility and an opportunity to make a real contribution to history.

I’m looking forward to answering your questions.


r/AskHistorians • • 12h ago

In 1918, Transylvania was united with the Kingdom of Romania: two predominantly Romanian-speaking territories with very different political histories, separated by one of Europe's largest mountain ranges. How did this play out, and are the differences between the two regions still visible today?

304 Upvotes

My very shallow understanding is that Wallachia and Moldavia, east of the Carpathians, have a great deal of shared history, having existed since the 1300's and having been periodically independent and vassal states of the Ottoman Empire.

Transylvania, west of the Carpathians, was part of Hungary since 1002 CE, and was a part of the Kingdom of Hungary during it's time within the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and the territory became part of the Kingdom of Romania after the end of WWI in 1918.

Was there a lot of interaction between Romanian populations on either side of the Carpathians before the unification? Were there a lot of differences between these populations? What were the general attitudes toward unification in the two territories? And are there still a lot of cultural or economic differences between these two parts of Romania today as a result of their very different histories?


r/AskHistorians • • 3h ago

Why didn't water-tube steam boilers see any adoption in railroad locomotives of the 20th century, even though they became the standard design for maritime and stationary boilers?

34 Upvotes

It seems like fire-tube boilers were the standard in railroad applications right up until steam locomotives were phased out entirely.


r/AskHistorians • • 5h ago

Was Chinggis Khan a "Mongol," and is there a continuous Mongol people from the 13th century to today?

42 Upvotes

I recently came across a news story that a Mongolian philosopher named Molor-Erdene was detained by Mongolian authorities on September 2 after making public remarks about Mongolian national identity and history. Apparently, his remarks attracted considerable controversy because they challenged some ideas about Mongolian identity and whether Chinggis Khan should even be considered "Mongol".

To the best of my knowledge, he questioned whether a distinct "Mongol" people has existed as a continuous, clearly definable group throughout history. His view is that “Mongol” is a label or nickname rather than the name of a historically coherent people. He also questions the conventional understanding of Chinggis Khan as ethnically Mongol. More broadly, he appears to argue that modern Mongolian national identity relies too heavily on a particular interpretation of the Mongol Empire and its legacy, and that the connection between the medieval empire and contemporary Mongolia is not as straightforward as popular narratives suggest.

Now this is obviously a pretty provocative view, but I was wondering whether his arguments have historical merit to them or are mostly unsupported. In particular, what did 'Mongol' originally refer to, in what sense was Chinggis Khan one, and how continuous is the identity from the empire to the modern state?


r/AskHistorians • • 8h ago

At what point in American history would it have started to become standard for most households to be able to purchase a turkey for the Thanksgiving holiday?

61 Upvotes

In modern times there is a carefully managed supply chain that leads to a ton of turkeys being available in supermarkets in the weeks leading up to Thanksgiving. Most American households eat turkey in some form or another, and certainly the supply is such that every household in the country could probably acquire a packaged whole bird if they wanted one. I'm curious culturally, logistically, and economically when this started to become a possibility.


r/AskHistorians • • 4h ago

Do we know what Charles Darwin thought of Social Darwinism?

26 Upvotes

I'm aware that his cousin is who came up with eugenics, but did Darwin himself ever voice his opinion on it?


r/AskHistorians • • 9h ago

“Some historians have noted that Soviet propaganda during this time (1934) began to depict homosexuality as a sign of fascism”, how prevalent was this? What are some examples?

38 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 2h ago

Why did the liberators do such a bad job of taking over after Caesar’s assasination?

10 Upvotes

Listening to the History of Rome, Duncan seems to put forward the theory that the senators were so focused on Ceasar they didn't kill Mark Anthony or create a plan for taking over and so sheltered that they didn't realize killing Caesar would be pretty unpopular. Is there another theory?


r/AskHistorians • • 14h ago

Do we see much evidence of psychopaths in communal and/or indigenous societies?

89 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 12h ago

The Ancient Egyptian work 'Tale of the Shipwrecked Sailor' sees (in my Toby Wilkinson translation) a character refer to a capital G singular 'God'. What would this have meant to an Egyptian of the period?

55 Upvotes

Hi all, I've recently been reading 'Writings from Ancient Egypt', a collection of texts, translated by Egyptologist Toby Wilkinson. The following quotes caught my eye (context is that the eponymous sailor has suffered the eponymous shipwreck and has washed ashore on an island where he is taken in by a huge but surprisingly friendly snake.

'Do not fear, do not fear, little man. Do not blanch. For you have reached me. See, God has caused you to live. He has brought you to this island of the spirit where there is nothing that isn't here'

And (speaker is now the sailor, addressing the snake):

'Everything that has happened to me shall be told and all that I have seen through your power. God will be praised for you in the city, in the presence of the councils of the whole land.'

I found this interesting because the story (I believe) dates from the First Intermediate Period, in which the traditional Egyptian polytheistic pantheon was in full swing. I can't read the original work alas so I'm curious as to what word is being translated as God? Is it just the singular word for deity which could equally be applied to Ra, Osiris, Isis etc or is it referring to a more vague sense of...'Cosmic Justice'? Many thanks in advance for your thoughts and time!


r/AskHistorians • • 1h ago

When young men in the late 1700s chose to dress up like the main character in Goethe's novel, "The Sorrow of Young Werther", how did that trend fit into the larger history of cosplay?

6 Upvotes

My question is inspired by this article from History Today. In particular, I was struck by the passage that reads:

Followers of Werther also copied the fashion of their tragic hero. Groups of young men took to wearing yellow trousers in combination with a blue tailcoat and high boots in imitation of Werther’s appearance.

I was curious how this compares to modern cosplay where fans dress up as their favorite characters from fiction, and how Goethe fans imitating Werther fits into the broader history of that practice.


r/AskHistorians • • 9h ago

Why has western Europe maintained such a steady balance of power for 500 years?

21 Upvotes

Comparing the map of western Europe in the year 1500 to now gives a remarkable sense of continuity. There's Portugal with almost the same borders as today, Denmark with similar borders, and France occupying roughly the same place. Castle and Aragon merged into Spain, Scotland and England merged into the UK, and Ireland gained independence, but otherwise the British Isles and Iberia are close to identical.

Germany and Italy have transformed far more, but the thing is that's similar to or even less change than the rest of the world. Nothing in the Americas has any continuity with polities there before the European conquest, and Africa and Oceania are pretty similar. MENA and India were packed with states in 1500, none of which has anything close to the continuity that Henry VII's England has with Charles III's UK. The only place that comes close to western Europe is east Asia, where modern Japan still has the same dynasty as 1500 years ago, and Korea where the Kingdom turned Empire persisted under Japanese rule for 50 years as the Governor-Generalship before regaining independence, albeit with the loss of the north.

Obviously European colonialism destroyed historic polities, but it's not sufficient. Many in India and Uganda survived subjugation by the UK only to be destroyed by more locally ruled regimes. Iran, Afghanistan and most of China have never been ruled from Europe, yet all have seen repeated regime turnover as outsider and splinter polities conquered them.

Western Europe has seen repeated internal conflicts and wars between great powers, yet the political situation almost always snaps back to close to where it was beforehand in a few years or decades, as with the Napoleonic Wars and World War 2 to name just two. Is there something about the types of administration in western Europe in 1500, or the institutions that the states there relied on, that have given the polities incredible resilience? Is it just coincidence that western Europe's remained so static for half a millennium, unlike Iran and China?


r/AskHistorians • • 7h ago

How professional was the Achaemenid army?

16 Upvotes

Now I understand they were not full time professional soldiers, but they also seem to have been able to leave forces in the field for a while, notably Mardonius being left with a sizable force after Xerxes departure, which is usually only something armies with some level of professionalism can do.


r/AskHistorians • • 7h ago

What were fragrances (perfumes and colognes) like in Victorian England?

14 Upvotes

I’m just really interested in what people must have smelled like!!!

How did they change over the era? I’m assuming different classes had different scents that were popular and/or available? What were the differences for men and women? Etc.

I’m particularly interested in men’s fragrances, as most of what I’ve found online is about women’s. Thanks!


r/AskHistorians • • 12h ago

Is the Saarland Offensive doomed to fail?

30 Upvotes

From my very basic understanding, the French planned to send a few divisions East to invade German territory and hope to relieve Polish forces by forcing the Wehrmacht to transfer a few divisions back.

Essentially their goal is to reach Berlin and capture it. Isn't Berlin like a mini Moscow, how did the French plan to fight and occupy against a huge urban city in the scale of Stalingrad?

Is the Saarland Offensive ever viable?


r/AskHistorians • • 7h ago

What was President Lincoln's relationship with VP Andrew Johnson like?

9 Upvotes

I know Johnson was added to the Lincoln ticket as a concession to Southern interests, and he was impeached as President for resisting Republican efforts post-Civil War. But how did Lincoln and Johnson get along during the Lincoln presidency?

Did they differ on policies, or military actions? Where did Johnson stand on things like Indian policy, the Homestead Act, land grant universities, or other things the Lincoln administration is known for other than the war?


r/AskHistorians • • 20h ago

When AK and HI were admitted in 1959, how was it decided which classes their senatorial seats would be?

107 Upvotes

Also, did they have elections before statehood, so the senators would be ready on signing day, or did they just go without for a bit?


r/AskHistorians • • 4h ago

Why did some states fracture after the invention of gunpowder?

5 Upvotes

I know the slightly teleogical view that castles allowed the fragmentation of the medieval period by giving huge defensive benefit for relatively little, so a central sovereign would struggle to rein in his vassals militarily, and that gunpowder flipped this because it was expensive but was the trump card against castles, and to build a castle that cannons couldn't breach was so expensive only centralising states could really afford to. It makes a degree of sense to me.

But there are places like Egypt, the Ottoman empire, China, and even the HRE in Europe where despite having cannons and gunpowder, states experience a kind of fracturing and emergence of the kinds of warlords we'd translate to semi-independent dukes and the like under a kingdom if we were talking about the medieval era. Why did they defy that trend? Or is it just that the simple explanation is completely wrong and centralisation had other drivers?


r/AskHistorians • • 5h ago

What were the dynamics between grandparents-(parents)-grandchildren in Ancient Greece?

5 Upvotes

My question is inspired by a "AI slop" video on Ancient Greece (brought up on the YT Wired channel) in which you see an old man at the market with a young girl; he seems a tad too old to be her father. It reminded me of how my grandfather used to take me out to buy sweets.

So I'm curious about grandparents-grandchildren dynamics in Ancient Greece, as well as the parents (I'm curious about this in the Ancient World in general, but to keep it focused I'm going with Ancient Greece)

Were grandparents known to be doting towards their grandchildren, compared to how strict they were towards their own children (certainly the case for my grandpa)? Are there any records of them giving, for example, unsolicited gifts to their grandchildren, which the parents rolled their eyes at, like nowadays? Did they have any say in the raising of the grandkids? Did grandparents often live together with the families or were they just frequent visitors? Would a grandfather in Ancient Greece even pay attention to a granddaughter, given the gender dynamics and, I assume, importance of male heirs?


r/AskHistorians • • 17h ago

Did more people make a living as entertainers (actors, musicians, storytellers) before mass media, or now?

42 Upvotes

By this, I mean did a higher percentage of people make it as entertainers then?


r/AskHistorians • • 1d ago

Why is War and Peace considered THE long book?

280 Upvotes

"It's not War and Peace" is a phrase I've heard in many contexts regarding length so I'm curious how that reputation developed over the years. It is a massively long book and certainly well-known, but why is it the massively long book?