r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Nov 07 '21
Meta Meta Thread - Month of November 07, 2021
A monthly thread to talk about meta topics, i.e. /r/anime itself and its rules. Keep it friendly and relevant to the subreddit.
Posts here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Rule Changes
- We're using Reddit's native spoiler tags now! You still need to provide context for the spoiler with [ ] before the spoiler tag. More details in the announcement thread last month.
Also a new written/video essay contest just started but isn't open long, only accepting entries until December 4th.
12
u/baquea Nov 08 '21
Would it be reasonable to have a rule as to how many clips (maybe like 5) from a particular series can be posted per month or something?
It feels like I am constantly seeing the same handful of series (Kobayashi-san, Gintama, etc.) on the front page, and given people are limited to two clip posts a month it means that any clip posted from one of these is reducing the amount of clips from other series that can get posted, whereas I feel it would be better to spotlight a wide range of anime, especially since such posts are often used for general discussions about the series or for encouraging people to watch it. It would be easy enough for people to check beforehand how many had been posted recently since they are are all flaired and have the series name in the title, and clips already have so many restrictions that it is unlikely to cause any further difficulties for people who post them.
22
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Nov 07 '21
Some of you might have noticed that for a couple of weeks last month, it was possible to vote and comment on older posts that were formerly archived 6 months after their creation, a change that was recently enabled by admins.
That change is the new default across Reddit, but subreddits could opt out and return to archiving posts. We had a brief discussion and a vote before the change was made, with mixed opinions overall but ending with an agreement to allow the change and make use of the new AutoModerator check to report any comments made on formerly archived posts. With the help of that, we could monitor how often people were commenting on old posts, what kinds of comments were being made, and potentially catch any abuse that might otherwise go unreported. So we quietly let the admins turn the feature on and watched.
The comments came in, and what we saw wasn't encouraging. Comments largely ranged from irrelevant due to age at best to targeted harassment at worst. On top of that, the majority of new comments on old posts were from users that weren't otherwise commenting/posting on /r/anime recently, likely coming from searches outside Reddit. While it's nice that these people are finding our subreddit, they're less likely to be familiar with our current rules. The context the original post was made in no longer exists and we feel that it's better to encourage people to use more recent threads instead.
We left things alone for a week to monitor them, then a couple days after that held a second vote which swung the other direction. Overall we think the handful of situations where there was a good comment made don't outweigh the drawbacks of dealing with comments that range from being hostile in reviving long-dead arguments to planting "speculation" in old episode discussion threads that are thinly-veiled spoilers — and yes, one comment did say they were considering that. Are there comments made on posts 1-5 months old that also fall into the same category of being a problem that we aren't noticing? Possibly, but that's a smaller range of threads and the context of the discussion likely hasn't shifted as much yet.
For some number crunching, people were able to comment on old threads for 16 days, from roughly 2021-10-15 to 2021-10-31 (midnight UTC both dates). In that time:
8
u/Lovro26 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lovro26 Nov 13 '21 edited Nov 13 '21
Hey I'm just wondering why all MT Key Visual posts are being put on mod approval for the last 2 or so hours
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/qszr06/mushoku_tensei_jobless_reincarnation_cour_2_new/
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/qt0bu2/mushoku_tensei_jobless_reincarnation_cour_2_new/
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/qt1c0e/mushoku_tensei_new_key_visual/
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/qt1nn4/mushoku_tensei_jobless_reincarnation_2nd_cour_new/
7
u/Al-Pharazon Nov 07 '21
As a suggestion it would help a lot if the mod message for a temporal ban for breaking X rule gave some recommendations about how to avoid it.
For example, for spoilers the automod currently leaves information outlining how to properly tag spoilers for the current ruleset.
In my personal experience having a mod give me recommendations such as using links to comments in the source corner has helped me a lot to adapt. So I think it would be better both for the users and mods if these kind of recommendations where more automatic as it already is with the spoiler tag
24
u/DutchPeasant https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotJames Nov 07 '21
I feel these anime and manga side by side videos are a cheap way to circumfent the clip rule.
6
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Nov 07 '21
May I ask what caused this comment to initially get caught by some filter? I'm kinda curious why, if only so I don't accidentally hit it again in the future.
6
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Nov 09 '21
If the current Writing Contest isn’t going to be consistently pinned, then I feel like it should be given a poster on the sidebar, especially since we only have the WT!otM one up right now anyway
6
u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Nov 16 '21
Can you do something about the user that always links to this website? https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/qv7q1z/mushoku_tenseis_latest_episode_will_be_more/
They are shitty machine translated articles that just steal from other proper sources, and it always seems to the same person posting.
6
u/LegendaryRQA Nov 20 '21 edited Nov 20 '21
It's a little late since it expires in 6 days, but can we make an exception to the no crowdfunding rule for the Animator Dormitory Project? Perhaps pin it since there's one every year? People always ask how they can support the Anime industry and we can't talk about the most direct way of doing it.
6
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Nov 28 '21
I assume this is already in the works but you may want to try and get the writing contest thread stickied as much as possible this week given the entry rate looks to have been low (I promise I'm writing mine now!), the side banner only appears on desktop, and it is a week till the deadline.
6
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Nov 29 '21 edited Nov 30 '21
We hit 3 million subscribers!
We'll have a post just for that in the next day but for now: yay!Here's the thread about it.1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Dec 06 '21
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
5
u/Vaadwaur :I1::I2::I3: Nov 13 '21
Hey, doing this intentionally late as I don't feel a huge need for non-mod attention, but I am actually going to do an Interspecies Reviewers rewatch(announcing Monday most likely) but I want to ask if you guys have any particular feedback/things you want me to keep in mind? If any of you are unfamiliar, the show is ecchi to a few hentai scenes in the uncensored version BUT everyone is shown to be of age and virtually all of the sex is sexwork and thus consensual. Anywho, I am not actually starting until Dec 13th so if you have any input, let me know.
Also, totally go back tor/allfor the first day so we can have a flashback to the bad old days5
u/Lovro26 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lovro26 Nov 14 '21
Hey again it seems that the same issue from yesterday is happening again today
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/qtn3er/attack_on_titan_the_final_season_part_2_new_key/
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/qtq6kj/attack_on_titan_new_key_visual_for_season_4_part_2/
•
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Nov 07 '21 edited Nov 08 '21
Last month's thread for reference.
Hi y'all! It's been a somewhat busy month for activity, but not that many votes.
October Mod Report
October by the Numbers
5 of the 6 admin-removed posts were taken down by DMCA requests relating to a specific anime and all of those were made 4+ years ago.
4
u/TheBlessedBoy99 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Amiibo Nov 07 '21
I would like to know the subs' policies when it comes to arc names as spoilers. I think it was a month or two ago where I brought up the [Land of the Lustrous manga arc name] Invasion arc in a comment and had it removed. How should I decide what arc names are and aren't spoilers, and is it more strict for arcs that have not yet been adapted (i.e. I'd argue that saying [Attack on Titan arc name] Marley Arc spoils more than saying the name of that Land of the Lustrous arc).
4
u/piruuu https://anilist.co/user/dvj Nov 08 '21
There’s a small thing I’d like to have clarification on.
According to rules „all leaks and rumours posts are banned” but what happens when a reliable news site/blog reports on those leaks/rumours? I’m asking because few days ago ANN reported on the leak of „The Vampire Dies in No Time” getting new season and the thread about that leak wasn’t touched by the mods. Is it considered as news then rather than rumour?
12
u/Ssalari Nov 07 '21
I think we should bring back Mushoku Tensei bot, i'm not on any side of those discussions, but they are literal war zones. Ppl where slaughtering each other in that clip's comment section, full of toxicity and personal attack.
6
u/PREM___ https://anilist.co/user/ReincarnatedGoat Nov 13 '21
author:aslivertintedrose
author:superalloyberserker
At this point if this isn't just loop holing around clip's rules and posting low/mid- effort content idk what it is
3
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '21
If we think a mod is abusing their power, where do we report it?
3
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Dec 02 '21
[I messed up a spoiler]<!but the bot was fine with it!<
I've noticed something really annoying for who knows how long, a year even: the comment faces are moving, bouncing. A few people with the same version of Firefox, another didn't. It seems few people notice it, and it was a firefox rendering problem, so I resigned myself to it.
Somebody recently reminded me that the comment faces aren't animated gifs, they're snatched out of a giant collage, right?
So what I think is happening is there's something about Firefox's integer / fp javascript math, so that the coordinates of subsequent frames are offset. Some sort of frame number * (height / full height) * full height sort of thing where not everything is an integer.
If the CSS / JS experts could confirm / fix this, I'd be gratified. It makes animated comment faces not fun. (also a lot of static faces have acquired a line at the top or bottom, too. These were all fixed after dark mode was added, but now they are back).
12
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Nov 07 '21 edited Nov 08 '21
Is it time to re ban Mushoku Tensei "pedophilia" debate thread?
They are back in full force with the new season and turn into a shit show every time.
Edit : even talking about the drama strat more drama below...
5
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Nov 07 '21
Is it possible to get more details or information on the warning or strike system the mods use for transparency sake?
For example how long does a ban/warnings stay on someone? How does someone's posting ratio matter? When to give warnings vs permas?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '21
Is there a way to make all Clip posts automatically marked as a spoiler? I feel like there's a lot of them posted that aren't marked as spoiler until someone points it out to OP or a mod does it.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '21
I especially filtered the "Clip" flair to not see those short "<CHARACTER> DOES <THING>" and now people started posting them under the "Video" flair.
What the fuck?
6
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Nov 07 '21
Can we do something about is x anime good posts? I've been seeing these posts a lot lately.
Not banning them or anything. But having them be specific on what they like or dislike would help us decide if x thing would be worth them watching it.
Too often the x thing being asked is x worth it? Is a popular anime, so the majority of people are obviously going to be saying yes.
So if people give specifics on what they like/dislike that'd help a lot more being able to give them a more proper answer.
2
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Nov 25 '21
The HotD Writinc Club picture in the sidebar (of old Reddit) links to last month's writing club
5
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '21
I'd personally be in favour of banning 'does this get better' posts.
4
u/RehgarEarthfury Nov 08 '21
Apologies if there has been a recent discussion on this that I have missed - I vaguely remember reading one a very long time ago, but the details I can't recall any more.
I am wondering what the reason is for using Japanese names in discussion thread titles. For me personally, and I would guess many others too, an anime's episode discussion title threa is one of the only places I ever see its full Japanese title. The other main one is MyAnimeList, but there when I search for an anime using its English title the correct result will almost always be on top, whereas reddit search is far less consistent. I often resort to using the full discussion archive link and searching the English name there if looking for past threads.
If there are shortenings like "Rikekoi" I may be exposed to that, but sometimes it can be difficult to tell what a full title is based on just a shortening when scanning the front page for discussion threads, and they may not show up when searched. Some official English titles have shortenings in them already, such as Tonikawa, which can be the best of both worlds.
English anime titles are very prolific now. Streaming services will promote, announce and display shows on their sites and social media feeds using only localized English titles. I see clips on the subreddit front page tagged with English names rather than Japanese ones - though, obviously this may depend on a show-by-show basis. Therefore, I believe that it would be more inclusive to newcomers and more casual watchers alike for English names to be the norm rather than Japanese.
Perhaps this is a bold assumption, but people who prefer Japanese names should probably be familiar with a series' English name (especially if watching anime through legal means). However, the same can't be said for the opposite. When I first came to the subreddit after watching the first episode of "Banished from the Hero's Party, I Decided to Live a Quiet Life in the Countryside", the only way I could tell between that thread and the "The World's Finest Assassin Gets Reincarnated in Another World as an Aristocrat" thread is the fact that the former happened to have "Slow Life" in English in its Japanese title.
I know this may just be a minor annoyance (and I know that I could just click on these threads to get their English titles to show up at the top), but I still thought I'd bring it up - it has slightly annoyed me for long enough to ask about it instead of my usual lurking, so I would like to know the subreddit's thoughts on the matter :)
2
u/PreludeToHell Nov 07 '21 edited Nov 07 '21
I was wondering where to find the discussion that led to 'Weekly/Seasonal ranking infographics must be submitted by site staff/OC' rule. I think I saw a mod say it was to promote OC but I'm not sure if there was a specific meta thread that had more discussion surrounding this decision. If a mod could link it I'd appreciate it.
Personally I think it's just an unnecessary hurdle.
e: eh, guess I'm in the minority that enjoyed seeing them but I understand why people thought it was too spammy. nvm.
2
u/Royal_Heritage Nov 21 '21
Any reason why this clip hasn't been taken down since it breaks the rule of no reposts on the top 75 clips in the sub?
2
u/Hambaloni Nov 29 '21
Change rule to be able to post aingle pictures as it is a dumb rule. Pictures posted can be a catalyst for discussion, esspecially for important scenes of captures in certain anime episodes. Things that can be spoiler free as well as intruiging
1
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment