r/3d6 • u/rpssycsnd • 5h ago
D&D 5e Revised/2024 Which would fit my character better: Eldritch Knight vs. Zealot Barbarian?
Hey everyone,
I will soon be jumping into a new campaign and I have decided to be a frontline martial. The two options I'm eyeing at the moment are eldritch knight fighter and zealot barbarian.
Disclaimer: we are mostly using the 5.5 system with some spells modified to their 2014 version.
The backstory in short: my character is a dragonborn (born as silver) who was raised in a community dedicated to Bahamut. His clan was attacked and kidnapped by the Cult of the Dragon when he was a child, a branch that specifically worships Tiamat. He was subjected to numerous painful experiments throughout the years that made him shed his silver scales and later transformed him into a black dragonborn. He was taught the arts of war during his upbringing (with some magic, if I'm going with the eldritch knight route) and he became a physical powerhouse. During a sacrificial ritual, something went terribly wrong and he seized the opportunity to kill his captors and escape (if going the zealot route, during the ritual something awoke inside him and granted him insane powers which helped him in achieving all this). He now hunts the remaining cells of the cult.
Sorry if it is too edgy, never mind it.
I've spoken with the DM about changing his element from acid to fire, because I thought that it would be cool to have him represent the opposite element of his original ancestry, which is cold. Since silver dragonborns are cold-based.
If the choice lands on eldritch knight, I would definitely make a build that integrates fire into his damage (green-flame build, flame tongue, hot streak feat from the new wow book, etc.) as he is slowly embracing his new element.
The reason I am asking for your help is I want to be absolved of this dilemma of choosing between the two variants, so I would like to give this choice into your hands. I don't know which one would be cooler, more fun to play. I want him to be strong and tanky, I always imagined him as muscular and badass-looking. Also I would like to add that I will go against the sword/axe-stereotype and he will wield glaives/halberds/pikes. The build will both have great weapon master and polearm master as feats.
Which one do you guys think is better, in terms of both roleplay and mechanics, based on the above?
Disclaimer #2: the party will consist of two other people, a moon druid and a bard who is yet to decide which subclass she will take.
Thank you for coming to my ADHD breakdown