First : So we pretty much define the primary 4 functions of the 4 term contingency with EATS : Escape/Avoid , Access, Tangible ( even if it is for an activity), Sensory automatic. I think Most of us agree on that.
Second: I think We all Agree that Behaviors can be multiply maintained weather it is consecutively or concurrently e.g. motivations can shift and or multiple variables can impact behavior all at once. And sometimes functions compete with each other.
The most common example I see is Escape and Attention Maintained Behavior.
I put an example below of a core component of a BIP I wrote for a child who often engages in Behaviors that start as Avoidance/Escape and have an Attention Component ( BCAF also indicates that oftentimes there is a tangible component as well)
I will do my best to describe the "Control" aspect of the intervention here:
Imagine that an instruction has been placed and the child moves away from the instructor, says " Noooo", maybe yells or whines a bit, and fiddles with a toy. Behavior clusters similar to this are common. In the scheme of "maladptive behaviors" I would classify it as "Mild" compared to the other topographies of inappropriate delay and denial I've seen before. I do not program for "non-compliance" and I recognize the behavior cluster example is a double edge sword as it contains both positive skills, such as verbal communication, and less desirable behaviors.
....anyway
After an instruction is placed and the child engages in Escape/Avoid Behavior: When Attention is at all a component ( even if the behavior begins as escape ) while the child is still in view but not necessarily right near you so you can monitor ( Proximity is a form of attention) , it's ok to accept their denial of the instruction/activity instead of pushing harder or coercing ( provided safety or hygiene is not a concern).
To influence outcomes of participation in the task you requested, after accepting the child's denial, redirect your attention by beginning Modeling instead. Do this by Engaging in the instruction/activity yourself with other kids, an available adult or, if no one else is around, act it out with some available toys/tools.
This allows you toĀ a) model the behavior without expectation to engage b) DRAĀ any attention component of the initial avoidance behavior c) still honor the child's refusal (E.g. momentarily reinforce the delay by letting it happen) d) demonstrate that his behavior does not impact your choices to engage in XYZ Behavior (e.g. control component) d) If he does choose to engage in the activity, this provides opportunity for you Provide more natural socially mediated positive reinforcement for changing his mind, demonstrating flexibility and making the choice to follow your initial instruction to engage in the behavior. ( no token board or external reward such as an edible treat needed)Ā
When we implement this intervention we consistently get results where this particular child chooses to set aside the item he is playing with ( or he brings it with him but it's not a distraction any longer), and asks to join, or just joins in on the instructed activity without further maladptive behaviors.
( Aspect of Control Component) Less frequently, we get results where the child has an increase in Attention Maintained behavior ( particularly Screaming) which we then provide FCT with minimal attention for child to appropriately gain attention and after a max of 3 unsuccessful prompts where the client shows clear behavioral signs of rejecting the prompts provided through their assent withdrawal behavior/continuation of the maladptive behavior yelling, we then put it on extinction by going back to the task ourselves. We provide FCT again and move closer in proximity once the Client meets the definition and criteria of calm. ( sometimes the client moves closer in proximity to us so moving is not necessary)
- For this example, What I labeled up above as (control component) seems to me to be what most people would call "setting a boundary" or something like not sending mixed messages to the child by basically doing what you said you were going to do with your body, your attention and your words.
Please keep in mind I am not doing a "my way" program for this kid, nor am we using visuals for this ( no boss hat, bracelet or token board). We are only using the naturally occuring body language and proximity that is explained in the intervention ( the actual BIP is a bit more specific so please forgive me if it feels incomplete. Even though the child is young, he does not display unsafe behavior therefore does not always have to be within arms reach - I recommend typically 5-10 feet away as the situation and room allows)
My Questions: Would control be defined as "Shifting functions" or " the existence of multiple, possibly competing, functions"?
Lastly, Please understand I am not arguing or making the case that "control" is a function. Currently, with my level of understanding ( and I'm sorry if that level of understanding is ignorant ) I am in the camp that Control is either 1) not a function on its own (e.g. it is either what we call shifting functions or multiple functions) or 2) "control" is actually how we commonly label a certain subset of consequences that are tied to multiple functions.
I would love to have a discussion on this and read any articles you have to recommend regarding "control"