I’m a 40F Canadian living in Mexico. My best friend, who we’ll call Carl (39M), lives in Canada. His boyfriend, Mike (35M), lives in Mexico City, where I also live.
Carl and Mike met in Mexico City about a year and a half ago and have been in a long-distance relationship ever since. I’ve gotten to know Mike pretty well because we live in the same city. He’s genuinely a lovely guy, and I really like him.
For context, Carl is a great friend. He’s fun, generous, and someone I’ve known since university. However, he’s historically had pretty toxic relationship dynamics. He’s also the more avoidant partner in relationships, and I’ve watched this particular relationship follow a similar pattern.
Mike seems much more invested. He’s described this as his first love, wants a committed partnership, and genuinely wants them to figure out how to close the distance and potentially live in the same country.
Carl, on the other hand, seems to enjoy the relationship but keeps Mike at arm’s length. Whenever the conversation turns to commitment or making actual plans for their future, there’s always a reason why he can’t make a decision or isn’t ready. There’s a new house, Christmas, timing, pressure, etc. Meanwhile, Mike seems to keep waiting for him to come around.
Here’s where I might be the asshole.
I’m spending November and December in Tulum, and Carl and I were texting while I was planning the trip. He mentioned that he wanted to come visit for two weeks just after Christmas, so we booked his flights.
At one point, I asked whether he was planning to invite Mike. Carl said something along the lines of, “I don’t want to have to do everything with Mike. Why do I always have to spend my vacation with Mike? I’m just going to book this on my own.”
Fine. Not my relationship, not my business.
However, I did mention a couple of times that if he was going to invite Mike, it would be nice to tell him sooner rather than later. Flights around Christmas get expensive, and I also needed to know who was coming so I could plan accordingly.
Almost TWO MONTHS after booking his own flights, Carl finally told Mike about the trip and said he could come for part of it.
I found this pretty shitty, honestly. They’re in a two-year relationship, and I think it’s reasonable to expect that you’d at least discuss your holiday plans with your partner before booking a vacation that falls over Christmas and then casually offering them the opportunity to join after everything is already arranged.
I told Carl that if I were Mike, I’d be pretty upset. I also told him that, honestly, I find it embarrassing that Mike hasn’t broken up with him yet.
I said I love him, but I wouldn’t want to date him. I don’t think he’s being a particularly good boyfriend, and I think he’s stringing Mike along while Mike is trying to build an actual partnership.
Carl got really upset and told me I was being brutal to him.
Here’s my perspective:
I wasn’t proactively inserting myself into their relationship. He brought the situation up with me.
I wasn’t criticizing him for wanting a vacation without his boyfriend. That’s completely reasonable. I’m happily single myself and understand wanting independence.
My issue is the lack of communication and consideration. If you’re in a two-year relationship, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect your partner to be included in conversations about holiday plans, even if the ultimate decision is to travel separately.
I don’t think being someone’s best friend means you have to validate all of their behaviour or tell them what they want to hear.
I genuinely don’t enjoy being in the middle of relationship drama. I like both of them, and because I live in Mexico City, I naturally have a friendship with Mike independently of Carl.
But I also don’t feel like I should have to sugarcoat my opinion when my best friend brings something to me and asks me about it.
So, AITA for calling my best friend out and telling him he’s being a shitty boyfriend, or should I have just kept my opinions to myself?