Spoilers for Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney.
Apollo Justice has an identity that I find incredibly compelling. There is something distinctly unsettling about its world. The atmosphere feels darker, grittier, more mature and at times there is a feeling of something genuinely sinister at play, we've definitely had a lot of dark moments in the series but this feeling of something "sinister" feels very exclusive to Apollo Justice. It feels different from the original trilogy, and I wouldn't categorize that as criticism. It is a deeply ambitous title that got so much right for me but also left me completely devasatated with the way it handled certain other things. This is the reason for my conflict and the reason I find my feelings so hard to articulate on this game.
1. Phoenix Wright
I was a lot younger when I finished the orignal trilogy, and I was devastated that the trilogy was over, I was so much in love with the world, the characters that I just wanted more of it so I pretty much instantly downloaded an emulator and started my playthrough of Apollo Justice.
In hindsight I now understand why so many people take issue with this version of him. Trials and Tribulations leaves Phoenix at such a defining high point for the character and then immediately witnessing the version he becomes in the very next game can feel very extreme and even I at that point of time could not accept that version of him.
A few years later however I returned to the series after the later trilogy got remastered, I jumped back in and this time I decided to merely use the orignal trilogy as context not a constant benchmark I am judging the later games against. This is when Apollo Justice truly became a very special entry for me.
7 years is a long time, I understood how losing a career in an extremely disgraceful manner, raising a daughter, spending years plotting on trying to take someone down can deeply change a person to their core.
Phoenix Wright in this game almost functions as a Nihlist. It was an extremely bold and brave writing decision to have him forge evidence to win a verdict. I also initally took this as an extremely out of character moment for him, something that would be totally unaccepatbale to the earlier version of him that is until you learn what he is going up against.
Phoenix knows the way Kristoph functions. The murder of Shadi Smith is essentially a very rare slip up by Kristoph, An oppurtunity like this to put him away will very likely not show up again. The forged ace is a sign of extreme desperation to finally bring Kristoph to Justice no matter the cost. The forged ace not only signifies how far we have come from the Phoenix of old but it amplifies the danger Kristoph presents that our former moral bound protagonist would stoop to such a low to win a verdict against him.
Turnabout Trump is an absolute masterpeice of an opener, a peak the game unfortunately does not reach again.The game introduces some genuinely fascinating narrative possibilities, but it often feels as though it rushes past them before allowing them to reach their full potential.
And nowhere is this more apparent to me than with the Gavin brothers.
2. Klavier Gavin
This is perhaps my biggest character related disappointment. Almost everytime the favorite part of an ace attorney game for me is the prosecutor, there motivations, backstory, beliefs. Almost every major prosecutor we encounter has some sort of personal journey.
We see characters transition from injustice to justice, from rage to acceptance, from being manipulated or brainwashed to finally finding clarity. Their confrontations with Phoenix aren't simply courtroom battles. They're ideological conflicts, personal struggles and often the culmination of their respective character arcs.
Then we meet Klavier Gavin.
And here's the thing Klavier is already a man who already prioritises the truth above everything else. From practically our first encounter with him, he makes it abundantly clear that prosecutorial victories, professional status and authority aren't what matter to him. He values the truth above all else.
This contrast is something I absolutely LOVE about him but it also leaves me with a question.
Why?
What made Klavier this way? What experiences shaped his philosophy? How did he arrive at a position so fundamentally different from the people around him? We have two brothers, two completely different philosophies, and an incredibly compelling opportunity to explore their relationship. I understand that just because they are brothers dosen't mean they have to function similarly but time and time again we have seen in this series of how deeply influenced characters get by the people who hold some form of authority over them, I find it hard to believe that Kristoph did not attempt to have some form of influence on his younger brother and for the first time in the series we have someone who not only resisted this influence but landed on complete opposite end of the moral spectrum to his brother. It feels deliberate almost as if Klavier is conciously trying to be the complete opposite of his brother, everything Kristoph values fame, image, power, perfection are completely meaningless to Klavier. But then again it is never mentioned if Klavier recignized what his brother truly was much earlier.
Klavier is the one who probably suffers the most loss in this game. His brother and best friend get incarcarated, his musical career comes to a very abrupt end however it never really affects him, it never tests his resolve or his code he just brushes past them quite casually.
Like I said Klavier is introduced as someone who has already reached the destination that so many other prosecutors spend entire games trying to reach. But we never really get to experience his unique journey.
And that is such a shame because I genuinely think the Gavin brothers could have formed the emotional backbone of an incredible Ace Attorney story.
3. Kristoph Gavin
We experience various different types of villians in media. They embed a sense of hatred, fear, motivation within us due to their actions, intimidating nature or goals. I myself have experienced a plethora of villians across media and Kristoph felt different. if I were to define the way Kritoph made me feel it would be
Dread
For the first time I geniunely had no idea of what I was going up against, his design, his sprites the way he speaks and with how masterfully subtly he is built across the duration of the game makes him really stand out to me.
Their were a few instances that really stood out to me.
During Turnabout Serenade their is a moment when Klavier points out a contradiction in Apollo's line of thought, and Apollo has no answer for it, and Klavier goes into his element, he is air guitaring, trash talking, his theme comes on he basically has Apollo on the ropes. That's when he gets interrupted by Ema doing an impression of Kristoph, Klavier not realizing it's Ema messing with him does not breakdown or start sweating, he just simply freezes as if he has completely forgotten what he was doing before he was interrupted. The mere impression of his brother's voice left him frozen.
This specific instance could be me making an ocean out of a puddle but it is the way I interpreted it.
but Kristoph merely being mentioned having a deep psychological impact on the rest of the cast seems like a recurring theme.
Of how Spark Brushel explains of how everyone related to the Magnifi Gramarye murder case had a feeling of being watched, stalked, you as the player really begin to feel the dread Kristoph enstills in the characters around him.
And it all comes together when Vera Misham takes the stand.
Vera taking the stand is particularly powerful. She's a deeply frightened, vulnerable person who has spent much of her life isolated from the outside world. Being in that courtroom, surrounded by strangers and subjected to scrutiny, is an ordeal in itself.
When Vera finally begins discussing the forged evidence, Klavier starts connecting the dots. The evidence that destroyed Phoenix's career seven years ago was forged by Vera herself. The courtroom starts closing in on her. For the first time in the entire game Klavier completely loses his composure and almost turns downrigtht agressive towards vera while questioning her about the diary page, she is essentially being screamed at from all corners of the courtroom given the context to this scene, that this is happening to a person who has had almost no social contact with the outside world, and also just lost her father and is left up the stand alone to deal with something she is afraid of the most makes this scene particularly disturbing.
And eventually, she answers with just two words:
"The Devil."
And then she collapses.
I think what makes this moment so effective is the sheer contrast between the significance of the revelation and the vulnerability of the person delivering it. We're finally getting an answer to one of the biggest mysteries surrounding Phoenix's disbarment, and the person who holds that answer is quite literally collapsing in front of everyone. Vera isn't some criminal mastermind who has finally been cornered. She's a young girl who has spent her life sheltered from the outside world, who was manipulated into participating in something she didn't fully understand, and who has now become another victim of the very person she trusted.
The courtroom gets its revelation, but at an absolutely devastating cost.
Coming back to the title of "The Devil." Had it been any other game it would have come off as a pretty corny way to define your primary antagonist. But here it is done so well and immediately after when its revealed that she got poisoned herself as well that to me is the most chilling moment in the entire series.
A sprite which Kristoph has where he is holding his glasses and you can't see his eyes and how its shown that he is staring right at you when Apollo "perceives" paired with the the scar on his hand, funnily enough, and I'm not joking when I say this I would have fully bought it had the game gone the route that Kristoph Gavin was someone who was actually demonically possesed. That is the impact he had on me.
Conflict and Conclusion
I really dislike the way the game concludes the final confrontation with Kristoph does not match the build up the game does for him. I understand what Takumi was going for, Kristoph essentially cannot be taken down with the Law as it stands, but the answer it hands the player to that problem to me is simply not a satisfying one. Ace Attorney has always been a game with huge emotional pay offs, the way Kristoph is taken down in the end feels relatively easy almost compared to the impossible to beat villian he is built up as.
I have geniune critiques of how inconsistent certain characters are, especially Zak Gramarye and how Kristoph's motivations can be defined as honestly quite petty, I geniunely believe this should have been a 5 case game and its very devastatting to me that this tone, setting, world and cast of characters will never be explored again.
I hopefully was able to potray the turmoil this game caused for me, especially in regarding to Kristoph. Like I said it's hard to articulate. For me the first half of Turnabout Succession is the absolute best this series has ever been but it dosen't materialize into much.
I'm not disappointed because I couldn't find anything to love about it. I'm disappointed because I found so much to love, and I feel like the game never quite realised what it had in its hands. I really wish it fleshed out the relationship between the brothers. IT has my absolute favorite soundtrack, mechanics etc in the series but it leaves so much unexplored and unaccounted for.
I would love to hear your opinions or if you interpreted certain things similarly to me.