UPDATE — 11/21 1:00PM ET
After systematically testing our dual-fuel HVAC system (winter here, so heating), I've isolated the PM2.5 spikes to heat-pump operation. I tested each mode separately while monitoring air quality:
- Fan only: No significant PM2.5 increase.
- Gas furnace (emergency heat): No significant PM2.5 increase.
- Heat pump: PM2.5 spiked almost immediately in multiple areas (e.g., from 2 to 70+ within two minutes), despite producing heat normally (~90°F at the vents).
I've been running gas heat only, with our whole-house bypass humidifier (tap water drips through a panel in the HVAC duct) turned on, and no air quality issues for the past 18 hours.
As for the visible fog, it hasn't returned since November 19. The second HVAC technician witnessed it during testing after the fire department left, but after shutting down the system for an extended period, we haven't seen any fog since, even after restarting it. Haven't been running it fully in the way we did previously though. It's unclear whether the fog and PM2.5 spikes are related.
A more experienced HVAC technician is coming Monday to investigate the heat pump. Still no definitive explanation, but I've narrowed down the air quality issue a little bit.
As for the fog, I'm waiting on the HVAC operating logs to see what was running around 9 AM Thursday, when we actually watched the fog appear out of nowhere.
___________________________________________________
UPDATE — 11/19, 9:45 PM ET
The heat pump and whole-house humidifier have been running for an hour. House is warm, no visible fog, and PM2.5 readings have dropped to around 60 (still high but trending down from the higher levels earlier today).
Tomorrow's to-do list (no particular order):
- HVAC: Inquire if tested for refrigerant and compressor oil leak.
- Air quality expert: Find an industrial hygienist to identify the source of the haze.
- Thermostat: Obtain operating logs to compare against PM2.5 spikes.
- Fog sample: If fog reappears, grab some with a jar and see if it condenses.
- HEPA room air filter: Run with a fresh filter during an episode and inspect what it captures.
Super appreciate everyone's input and questions!!
ORIGINAL POST BELOW
________________________________________________________________
We're experiencing intermittent, visible, odorless fog/haze inside our house, primarily in the kitchen, dining room and living room. Two HVAC companies and the fire department have investigated, but nobody can identify the cause.
Timeline:
- Sept 14: Installers cut into our quartz countertop to install a new cooktop, releasing significant silica dust throughout the house (not sure if this is related but might be worth noting). I shut off HVAC as soon as I saw the dust. Cleaners deep cleaned afterwards.
- Late September: Woke up to visible, odorless fog inside. Turned off HVAC, aired out the house, replaced filters, and the fog dissipated.
- Oct 9: Routine HVAC fall tune-up. Technician had no explanation for the earlier fog/haze incident, but had not reoccurred at that point.
- Nov 17: Fog returned in the evening, again with no odor. Was a thick haze. CO2 monitor had no reading.
- Nov 18: Called emergency HVAC technician visit - he witnessed the fog, inspected the system, and ruled out obvious issues with the heat pump and gas furnace. Recommended disabling our whole-house humidifier (normally set to 40%). Fully aired out house, and no fog overnight.
- Nov 19, 9 AM: Fog returned despite humidifier being off. Called fire department, checked CO and oxygen levels, and found no abnormalities, fire, or source of smoke.
- Nov 19, noon: A second HVAC company performed a thorough inspection and also couldn't identify the cause.
Additional details:
- Home built in 2008 in Northern Virginia.
- Dual-fuel HVAC (heat pump + gas furnace).
- Thermostat typically set to 76°F.
- Indoor PM2.5 monitor registered over 1,100 µg/m³ during the haze.
- No noticeable odor during any incident.
My questions:
- Has anyone experienced anything like this?
- Could this be HVAC-related, condensation, or somehow connected to the quartz dust from September? The dust seems unlikely because the heat was on for several weeks without any fog incidents.
- What could cause such extreme PM2.5 readings and visible haze? How reliable are the numbers from this Ring air quality reader? The number seems super high.
- What kind of expert can actually identify the source, rather than just perform general air-quality testing?