I'm not a horror gamer. I get scared pretty easily. I was able to get through Dead Space Remake and RE2 remake. Couple of folks said if I could play through those games, than Alan Wake 2 wouldn't be a problem in terms of horror....
but I just got done with chapter 5 and, wow, this game is creepy. Gives me a sense of dread and unease like watching the Shining. There were probably only a max of 2 encounters in nursing home and wellness area but I was creeped out that entire section. Especially the basement part where literally nothing happened and yet I never wanted to rush through an area so fast in my life.
It made me think that if the game had as many combat encounters as Dead Space Remake, I feel like this game would be way less scary. Dead Space Remake was rough in the beginning for me, but I feel like I got desensitized to the horror elements as each encounter kind of felt the same and the overall environment was very similar. Necromorphs just ended up being like annoying pests towards the mid to late game.
The environmental storytelling in this game is top notch and unlike anything else I've played. I'm always on my toes and on full alert waiting for something to attack me but most of the time, nothing attacks me... and that just makes things way worse. It makes me pay attention the environment more closely which results in me being more creeped out at what i'm seeing.