I know no one asked, but in my opinion, DS2 is the best Dark Souls. But personally, I just love the powerstancing. I don’t get why people complain about ADP, because it just allows you to make the game easier by levelling it to like 50–60 for a lot of i-frames. Also, the Illusory Rings you get for beating the game deathless and without bonfires are just a nice small reward for people who want an extra challenge. Sure, the hitboxes are not the best, but the ones from DS1 also weren’t the best, to be honest. And DS3, in my opinion, is just overpolished. It just feels too perfect. Like, I still love the bosses and world, but I personally like the more janky stuff of DS1 and 2. Also, I personally think that DS2 has the biggest replay value out of all the FromSoftware games, except maybe for Elden Ring, just because of the sheer amount of build variety in these games.
So now I would like to ask: What are your opinions on DS2?
P.S. I don’t want to invalidate anyone’s opinion about these games. This is just my opinion.