r/AncestryDNA • u/Electronic-Employ928 • 11h ago
Discussion Population genetics makes the social concept of "mixed race" completely hilarious
I’ve been falling down a population genetics rabbit hole lately, to me it’s wild how inconsistent society’s idea of being "mixed race" is compared to actual human DNA. Basically, what we call a "race" is usually just an ancient mixed population whose recipe stabilized long enough ago that society forgot the ingredients.
1. High Social Contrast, Tiny Genetic Distance (The West Eurasian Loop)
I’ve noticed particularly half Middle Eastern/North Africa/West Asian are in this very complex loop regarding whether they are not White as society is very selective with this mix particularly.
The Hadids and Kardashians (half European, half Levantine/Armenian) are widely seen as mixed (sometimes other times they’re seen as white models). Yet Europeans, Levantines, and Caucasus groups all sit on the West Eurasian branch of the human tree, sharing massive deep ancestry from early Anatolian farmers. A Dutch person and a Palestinian are genetically very close on a global scale.
Meanwhile, other 50/50 European + MENA/Caucasus figures like Steve Jobs (half Syrian), Cher (half Armenian), Jerry Seinfeld (half Syrian-Jewish), and Andy Serkis (half Iraqi-Armenian) etc are almost universally coded as just "white", far more so than Kim Kardashisn is while Jessica Alba (who is actually more European than Cher or Seinfeld) gets coded as mixed/Latina. Even Ashkenazi Jews (~50% Levantine / ~50% European) are socially read as white today, whereas Romani (~70% West Eurasian / ~30% South Asian) and Sámi (~75% European / ~25% Siberian) are heavily racialized as "mixed" or non-European.
2. Massive Genetic Diversity Treated as "Monoracial"
Look at Nipsey Hussle and Tiffany Haddish (both half Eritrean, half African-American). Socially, they’re seen as monoracial Black. Genetically, they are far more admixed across deep human lineages than any half-European, half-Middle Eastern person. I’ll break it down in bullet points to paint a vivid picture.
- Nilotic/East Africans and West Africans split ~18,000–28,000 years ago (roughly as old as the European/MENA split, without the massive Neolithic re-mixing that west Eurasians had.)
- On top of that, Eritreans/Ethiopians are ~45%–50% ancient West Eurasian + ~50%–55% indigenous East African, and African-Americans are 75-80% West/Central African (NigerCongo) + ~15-25%European (and very small 1-5 African hunter gatherer and indigenous American give or take)
- That makes Nipsey and Tiffany a blend of at least four distinct deep populations, yet society doesn't register them as mixed at all. Similarly, a child of West African (or even more so A Centrap African Pgmy group or a Khoi/San group) and an Indigenous Australian/Papuan/Melanessian represents the widest genetic distance between any two living populations on Earth (West Africans are actually closer to Europeans than to Indigenous Australians), yet outsiders often lump both under "Black."
3. "Genetic Twins" With Opposite Racial Labels
(Here is where the definition of who is or isn’t mixed gets a bit stretched for me.)
- Kikuyus vs. Mexicans: Kenya’s Kikuyu (and many Kenyan/Tanzanian ethnic groups) are roughly 50% Bantu + 30% Cushitic (ancient West Eurasian + East African) + 20% Nilotic. That puts their genetic distance from West Africans (like the Igbo) in the exact same ballpark as Mestizo Mexicans (~50% European + ~45% Indigenous + ~5% African) are from Spaniards. Yet Mexicans are treated as the global poster child for "mixed/non-white," while Kikuyus and Igbos are lumped into a single racial box.
- Mexicans vs. Central Asians: Mestizo Mexicans (~50% West Eurasian / ~50% East-North Eurasian) have almost the exact same macro-continental ratio as Uzbeks or Uyghurs (~50% Iranian/Steppe West Eurasian / ~50% Turkic/Mongolic East Eurasian) and South Asians are essentially the "original Latinos" of Eurasia (ancient Iranian Neolithic farmer and Indo European speppe West Eurasian ancestry + deeply diverged East Eurasian AASI, genetically South Asians aren’t “dark skin MENA” people western media like Aladdin tries to depict them as but instead they’re far more complex ethnically and are genetically more similar to Latinos and central Asians for this reason. Same broadly for Turkish people who are a quarter east Eurasian/East Asian like ancestry and plenty of Afghanistan ethnic groups.
- Argentinians vs. Somalis: Average Argentinians are ~65%–70% European / ~30% Indigenous, while Somalis are ~60% indigenous East African / ~40% ancient West Eurasian. Yet Argentinians get rounded up to "100% white" while Somalis constantly get their "Blackness" questioned.
4. Even "Homogeneous" Groups Are Ancient Hybrids
- Japanese: Seen as the ultimate homogeneous population, yet mainland Japanese are a mix of ~75%–80% Korean like ancestry and a dinstinct 15%–20% Jōmon ancestry an isolated Paleolithic lineage that split from mainland East Asians ~25,000–38,000 years ago (further apart than both Europeans and Middle Easterners and West African and Nilotic people).
- Polynesians: Roughly 75% Austronesian (East Asian) + 25% Papuan/Melanesian (a ~45,000-year split). Are they a quarter black? interestingly groups like the Māori are largely mixed today with Europeans today as are indigenous Australian with some being mostly European and none islander ancestry continues to increase. is a Pacific Islander and Asian mix even considers mixed considering they and native Americans all descend from east/South east Asia.
- Southern Africans: Southern African Bantu-speaking groups like the Xhosa, Sotho, Tswana and Zulu carry ~20%–30% Khoisan ancestry, is . The oldest living human lineage on Earth and what’s even crazier is that a Khoi and San living on opposite sides of the kalahari desert have more genetic diversity/distance amongst each other than a European and East Asian do… is a Khoi Khoi and San child considerd mixed race?
what is race? it’s social and cultural.
Perception is more important than blood quantum’s in everyday social treatment. Anthony Joshua is very Nigerian genetically, he has 3 Nigerian (Yoruba) grandparents (and 1 Irish not English grandparent) Anthony even went to a Nigerian boarding school briefly In his youth. He looks phenotypically like fellow Nigerians boxer Richard Riakphore and Afrobeat pioneer Fela Kuti, along with Igbo actors Chitwel Efroj and Nnamdi Asomugha.
Yet when boxing achievements are made he’s quickly claimed as being “english” ethnically By Europeans And others despite him barely being much genetically different from northern Nigerians. on the other hand Tyler the creator has a Nigerian father and a biracial Black/white American mother (putting him closer to ~30% European), yet his Blackness is never questioned and he’s rarely coded as mixed. Same can be said about The "3/4 White" Double Standard: Nico Parker (from How to Train Your Dragon) and Halsey are both roughly 3/4 European and 1/4 Black yet Nico is almost always coded as mixed/non-white while Halsey is mostly coded as white. The exact same thing happens with Jessica Alba vs. Cole Palmer and Demi Lovato, where nearly identical European/Indigenous and or none European ratios get cast into completely different racial boxes based purely on styling and features
To me I think it’s more important to call out general colourisim/featurisim then get bogged down by blood quantum’s socially. As race is a social construct not a biological one. I also think things like blackness are more of a shared experienc/social denominator of global perseverance against imperialsim typically for those of African descent than a genetic hardline.
But what do you guys think? Habe you noticed these hypocrisie? is there any I’m missing?
Bibliography
- Bryc, K. et al., 2015. The genetic ancestry of African Americans, Latinos, and European Americans across the United States. The American Journal of Human Genetics, 96(1), pp.37–53.
- Cooke, N.P. et al., 2021. Ancient genomics reveals tripartite origins of Japanese populations. Science Advances, 7(38), eabh2419.
- Fan, S. et al., 2019. African evolutionary history inferred from whole genome sequence data of 44 indigenous African populations. Genome Biology, 20(1), 82.
- Homburger, J.R. et al., 2015. Genomic insights into the ancestry and demographic history of South America. PLoS Genetics, 11(12), e1005602.
- Jeong, C. et al., 2019. The genetic history of admixture across inner Eurasia. Nature Ecology & Evolution, 3(6), pp.966–976.
- Lazaridis, I. et al., 2016. Genomic insights into the origin of farming in the ancient Near East. Nature, 536(7617), pp.419–424.
- Malaspinas, A.-S. et al., 2016. A genomic history of Aboriginal Australia. Nature, 538(7624), pp.207–214.
- Moorjani, P. et al., 2013. Reconstructing Roma history from genome-wide data. PLoS ONE, 8(3), e58633.
- Moreno-Estrada, A. et al., 2014. The genetics of Mexico recapitulates Native American substructure and affects biomedical traits. Science, 344(6189), pp.1280–1285.
- Narasimhan, V.M. et al., 2019. The formation of human populations in South and Central Asia. Science, 365(6457), eaat7487.
- Pagani, L. et al., 2012. Ethiopian genetic diversity reveals linguistic stratification and complex influences on the Ethiopian gene pool. The American Journal of Human Genetics, 91(1), pp.83–96.
- Schlebusch, C.M. et al., 2012. Genomic variation in seven Khoe-San groups reveals adaptation and complex African history. Science, 338(6105), pp.374–379.
- Skoglund, P. et al., 2016. Genomic insights into the peopling of the Southwest Pacific. Nature, 538(7626), pp.510–513.
- Tambets, K. et al., 2018. Genes reveal traces of common recent demographic history for most of the Uralic-speaking populations. Genome Biology, 19(1), 139.
- Tishkoff, S.A. et al., 2009. The genetic structure and history of Africans and African Americans. Science, 324(5930), pp.1035–1044.
- Xue, J. et al., 2017. The time and place of European admixture in Ashkenazi Jewish history. PLoS Genetics, 13(4), e1006644.