r/AndrewGosden • • Jan 11 '22

Rules Reminder in light of recent developments: Please do not post private or personal information (dox)

190 Upvotes

Hello!

I trust everyone is aware of the latest developments, as two men have been arrested for kidnap in relation to the Gosden case.

I want to take this opportunity to remind everybody reddit strictly does not allow the posting of personal and private information.

Do not post personal information concerning individuals you suspect may be Andrew, or concerning individuals you plausibly believe may be, or become, suspects in the case, including names or addresses or social media handles or contact information; you will be warned and/or potentially banned.

If you feel you have pertinent information, please report it to the Missing People charity here or contact South Yorkshire Police directly here.

As per reddit's Content Policy:

Is posting someone's private or personal information okay?

No. Reddit is quite open and pro-free speech, but it is not okay to post someone's personal information or post links to personal information. This includes links to public Facebook pages and screenshots of Facebook pages with the names still legible.

Posting someone's personal information will get you banned. When posting screenshots, be sure to edit out any personally identifiable information to avoid running afoul of this rule.

Public figures can be an exception to this rule, such as posting professional links to contact a congressman or the CEO of a company. But don't post anything inviting harassment, don't harass, and don't cheer on or upvote obvious vigilantism.

Not only does posting dox violate reddit's site-wide rules, it could potentially threaten an ongoing investigation. Please be mindful not only of that, but of the Gosden family's privacy.

If you want to report information

To reiterate: If you do have anything you consider worth sharing with the authorities, you can anonymously report it to the Missing People charity here. You can contact South Yorkshire Police directly here or by calling 111 if you live in the UK.


Thank you and please feel free to let us know if you have any questions or concerns or feedback at all.

Cheers.


r/AndrewGosden • • 2d ago

Please Bring Me Home website

9 Upvotes

Would there be any interest in adding the case to https://pleasebringmehome.com/ ? Volunteers there "conducts interviews, undertakes background research, and mobilizes trained people for grid searching to pursue a positive end to each case. Our partnerships with canine, underwater and ground penetrating radar search firms allow a great range of professional search options."


r/AndrewGosden • • 3d ago

Did Andrew's single ticket really mean he wasn't coming back?

12 Upvotes

The one-way ticket is probably one of the most interpreted details in Andrew's case. He bought a single to London. The clerk told him a return would cost less than £1 more. He still wanted the single. It sounds deliberate. Perhaps it was.

What I'm much less convinced about is the next step people often make: that this tells us Andrew knew he wasn't coming back. The railway system he was dealing with in September 2007 was quite different from the simplified version that usually gets repeated.

What did the tickets actually cost?

There is some unusually good historical research on this. The National Railway Museum's catalogue of National Fares Manuals confirms that Manual No. 97 covered 9 September 2007 to 1 January 2008. It was the manual in force when Andrew travelled, just five days after it came into effect.

In December 2020, a Reddit user researching Andrew's case described contacting the museum and obtaining a scan of the relevant fares. With help from someone familiar with railway ticketing, they identified an adult off-peak single from Doncaster to London at £62.80. Andrew was 14, so the half-price child fare was £31.40.

The same research identified an off-peak return at £31.90. The difference really does appear to have been 50p. They also identified an Anytime Return at £76.50, a rather different proposition if you were trying to travel during restricted hours.

The South Yorkshire Police appeal doesn't give the fare, but says the ticket seller recalled offering Andrew a return for less than £1 extra. He declined it. An earlier 2008 Guardian interview with his mother, Glenys, gives a little more colour. Glenys said the clerk remembered Andrew because he seemed unusually small to be going to London alone and recalled him insisting on a one-way ticket.

I've never seen the clerk's original statement. Did Andrew walk up and ask specifically for a single, or did he simply ask for a ticket? Was the return mentioned once or discussed further? More importantly, was anything said about when he could use it? The published accounts don't tell us.

The 50p return wasn't just for that Friday

The 2020 fares research says the £31.90 return could be used within the following 30 days, subject to off-peak restrictions. That sounded surprising enough that I wanted to check whether it fitted the railway rules at the time. It does.

GNER's 2005 East Coast franchise agreement describes the protected return fare which replaced the old Saver Return. Where a Saver Return had existed, the replacement had to be valid for at least a month, including all-day travel on Saturdays and Sundays.

This changes one common interpretation of Andrew's ticket quite substantially. If he intended to spend Friday night in London, the cheap return could still have covered him. If he planned to stay for the weekend, the same applied. Even if he didn't know whether he'd be coming back on Friday, Saturday or a week later, having a return portion in his pocket would have given him more options, not fewer.

So the suggestion that he refused it because he was staying overnight doesn't really work on its own. He could have stayed overnight and still used the ticket.

There was, though, a catch.

Friday afternoon was potentially awkward

The return wasn't necessarily valid on every train. That same GNER agreement allowed Saver-type returns to exclude weekday journeys leaving London between 3pm and 7pm. And there is evidence that GNER actually used those restrictions.

A Guardian guide to rail fares from 2005 says a GNER Standard Saver between London and York couldn't be used northbound from King's Cross between 14:59 and 18:59 on weekdays.

Then, in May 2006, a passenger complained after being charged extra to board GNER's 3pm departure. The correspondence reproduced on Digital Spy includes a response attributed to GNER Customer Care saying its Saver restrictions had been unchanged since June 2002. It specifically confirmed that the 15:00 was barred to Saver tickets, while the 19:00 wasn't.

I haven't found the September 2007 restriction code for the precise Doncaster fare Andrew was offered. The agreement tells us what GNER was allowed to restrict and the York example shows what it was doing on at least one route. Neither establishes the exact conditions of his £31.90 ticket. But it gives us a reason to question the assumption that he could have used that return on any train he liked.

Suppose Andrew expected to be home around dinner. He arrived at King's Cross at 11:20am and his journey down from Doncaster had taken one hour and 44 minutes. The journey back would take a comparable amount of time, before you add getting back to King's Cross and then from Doncaster station to Balby.

If the cheap return couldn't be used on trains leaving London between 3pm and 7pm, he'd have had an awkward choice: leave London much earlier than he might have wanted, or stay until the evening and get home late. Travelling back in the afternoon peak could have meant buying a more expensive ticket.

That makes the 50p offer less straightforward than it sounds. It doesn't, by itself, explain why he declined it. Even a restricted return might have been worth another 50p as a fallback. For the restrictions to explain his decision, Andrew would have needed to know about them and have some reason to think they would interfere with his plans.

And that's where the conversation with the clerk becomes interesting. Being extremely good at maths doesn't give somebody an instinctive understanding of Britain's 2007 railway fare system. Plenty of adults, myself included, find it baffling.

"Would you like a return? It's only 50p more" tells us something quite different from "This return is valid for a month, but you can't use it on certain trains out of London this afternoon."

We don't know which, if either, is closer to what Andrew was told.

There's another detail I think belongs in this discussion. Andrew was deaf in his left ear and South Yorkshire Police has noted that he struggled to tell where sounds were coming from. At a ticket counter in a railway station, he could have missed part of what the clerk said. Even if he heard that a return was only 50p more, that doesn't tell us whether he understood what the ticket covered.

One of his teachers also described him as shy. I can imagine a fourteen-year-old who'd gone to the counter with 'single to London' in his head sticking with that rather than asking a stranger to explain the different fares. Perhaps he assumed a return meant coming back that evening. Perhaps he didn't quite hear or understand the offer and didn't want to ask again. What the clerk remembered as a firm refusal needn't mean Andrew had carefully weighed up the alternative.

Could he realistically have got home the same day?

I've been trying to establish what trains Andrew could actually have caught back to Doncaster on Friday 14 September. The Summer 2007 GNER timetable survives and Timetable World has the May 2007 National Rail Timetable, the last printed national edition before the move to electronic timetables that December.

GNER had introduced a half-hourly London-Leeds service in May, alongside Newcastle and Edinburgh services, many of which also stopped at Doncaster. There were opportunities to travel north that day. What I haven't yet done is check the complete Table 26 for that Friday, the precise departures and any alterations affecting the service. I particularly want to pin down the last practical train home and which departures the cheaper return would have covered.

One version of events I've wanted to test is that Andrew went to London, did whatever he intended to do and hoped to get back before his family realised he'd missed school.

We know he left King's Cross at 11:25am. Allow close to two hours on the train back, time to reach the station from wherever he'd been in London and another journey from Doncaster station to Balby. There isn't much room left for an afternoon in London if he wanted to be home around the usual dinner time. A possible 3pm to 7pm ticket restriction would tighten that window further, unless he paid to travel during it.

For an evening event, such as a concert, the question changes. Then the last train matters far more than getting home unnoticed. And of course "back in Doncaster" still isn't "back home". Andrew lived in Balby. He'd still have needed to get there from the station, whether on foot, by local transport or some other way.

I don't think the journey can be reduced to "he could have been home for 50p more" until we know which trains that ticket would actually have covered.

What did £200 actually give him?

The police chronology records Andrew withdrawing £200 at 9:08am. Kevin later told VICE that there had been about £214 in the account and that Andrew left roughly £100 in birthday money at home.

One possibility worth considering is that the cashpoint dispensed £20 notes. If it did, £200 was simply the largest amount he could withdraw from a balance of around £214. We don't know what notes the machine stocked, but the withdrawal needn't represent a carefully calculated £200 budget.

After paying £31.40 for his outward ticket, he would have had £168.60 left, excluding any other cash he might already have been carrying. That was a substantial amount for a fourteen-year-old in 2007: roughly £298 in October 2026 money using the ONS Consumer Prices Index. For context, London fares in January 2007 included £4 for a cash Zone 1 Tube journey and £2 for a cash bus fare.

He could afford food, local transport and ordinary spending in London. He could also have bought another rail ticket. If a second £31.40 off-peak single had been available for the journey home, for example, he would have had £137.20 left from his withdrawal before his other spending. That's an illustration rather than a confirmed return fare; a ticket allowing travel during the peak might have cost more.

By comparison, buying the £31.90 return in Doncaster would have left him £168.10, with the return journey covered within the permitted times. The extra 50p was clearly good value if he expected to use it. But buying a single didn't leave him stranded in London or unable to pay his own way back.

And what about the PSP?

The £200 has also been linked to the launch of the PSP Slim & Lite, which reached UK shops on 14 September 2007, the day Andrew disappeared, at around £129.99.

The arithmetic is interesting. After spending £31.40 on the train and £129.99 on a PSP, he'd have had £38.61. Another hypothetical £31.40 single would leave just £7.21 for food and local travel. If he needed a dearer peak-time ticket, the numbers would be tighter still.

But there isn't evidence that Andrew wanted to buy one. He already owned a PSP and took it with him. The Slim & Lite was largely a smaller, lighter version of the original, rather than a new console with an entirely different set of games. Ars Technica's contemporary coverage described the changes as relatively modest. It was a national launch, too, not something he needed to go to London to buy.

What interests me more is the money he didn't take. He withdrew almost everything from his bank account but left the birthday cash at home. Those are two different decisions. I don't think the round £200 figure, on its own, tells us he was shopping for something at that price.

What if he wasn't planning to return by train?

Andrew wasn't travelling to a city where he knew nobody. He had family connections in and around London, including his grandmother and his parents had offered to let him travel down alone to stay with her during the summer. That offer wasn't taken up and none of the family was reportedly expecting him on 14 September.

I wonder whether those connections made London feel less daunting. Even without a mobile phone, he may have imagined he could use a payphone, borrow a phone or make his way to a relative if he got stuck. That isn't the same as having arranged somewhere to stay, but it might have affected how much he worried about a contingency plan.

He could also have expected a lift, intended to travel by coach, or planned to buy another train ticket later. None of those possibilities is established. Nor can we rule out that he didn't expect to come back. The point is that the rail ticket can't distinguish between them.

What do we actually learn from the ticket?

I still think that the clerk's recollection points to Andrew deliberately chose the single. But having looked at the actual fares and the rules around them, I'm much less convinced that his choice tells us what he intended to do after arriving in London.

The cheap return appears to have covered much more than a same-day visit, which makes the usual overnight explanation difficult to square with it. On the other hand, weekday restrictions may have made it less useful for an afternoon journey home. He had enough cash to buy another ticket and we don't know what, if anything, the clerk explained about the cheaper return.

I'd most like to know more about that clerk's original statement and the September 2007 Doncaster fare restrictions. The conversation at the ticket counter may tell us rather more than the extra 50p does.


r/AndrewGosden • • 2d ago

[Theory] The "Grey-Market PSP-2000 Trade-In" Lure: Connecting the Sept 14 Release Date, Custom Firmware, the Left-Behind Charger, and the One-Way Ticket

0 Upvotes

I’ve been doing a deep dive into the timeline, technical context, and behavioral clues surrounding Andrew’s disappearance on Friday, September 14, 2007. While the "PSP Release Day" idea has been mentioned before, I want to propose a more specific, cohesive scenario that connects every single anomaly in Andrew’s behavior that morning without relying on internet grooming (which digital forensics ruled out).

My core hypothesis is that Andrew was lured to London by an offline acquaintance or older peer with the promise of a grey-market trade-in/modding deal for the brand-new PSP-2000, combined with an offer of a ride back home to Doncaster later that evening.

Here is how every piece of evidence fits into this single framework:

  1. The Exact Date: UK Launch of the PSP-2000 (Sept 14, 2007)

September 14, 2007, wasn’t just a random Friday - it was the official UK and European release date of the Sony PSP-2000 (PSP Slim & Lite).

  • For a 14-year-old tech-savvy gamer, getting the newly redesigned console on Day One was huge.
  • However, official retail stores (like GAME or HMV) wouldn't offer a favorable cash trade-in for a used PSP-1000 on launch day, nor would they sell pre-modded units.
  1. Why London? The "Underground" Modding & Grey-Market Scene

A common counterargument to the PSP theory is: "Why travel 160 miles to London when he could buy a PSP in Doncaster?"

  • In September 2007, the biggest thing in the PSP scene was Custom Firmware (CFW) (e.g., Dark_AleX’s firmware), which allowed users to run homebrew, emulators, and ISO backups from a Memory Stick.
  • In a smaller town like Doncaster, finding someone to downgrade/mod a brand-new PSP-2000 on Day One was nearly impossible. In contrast, London - specifically informal electronics shops, market stalls, and independent gaming outlets around Tottenham Court Road, Soho, or Camden - was the hub for grey-market imports, instant modding/chipping, and off-the-books trade-ins.
  • An older acquaintance (someone from school, a local gaming/music circle, or the summer gifted program) could have easily pitched this to Andrew: "I know a guy/an underground shop in London doing launch-day swaps - your old PSP-1000 plus £150 cash for a modded PSP-2000. Let's go Friday morning before they run out."
  1. The Financial Math (£200 Withdrawn vs. £100 Left at Home)

Andrew’s financial decisions that morning were hyper-rational, not impulsive:

  • He withdrew £200 (the maximum allowed by the ATM given his £214 balance) and spent £31.40 on his train ticket, leaving him with £168.60.
  • If the agreed trade-in price was around £140–£150 cash + his old console, £168.60 covered the exact cost of the swap plus food/tube fare for the day.
  • He intentionally left his £100 birthday cash hidden at home because he didn't need it for the deal, and a cautious kid wouldn't carry his entire life savings into central London if £150 was the exact agreed price.
  1. Why He Took the PSP, Left the Charger, and Packed No Overnight Gear
  • The Charger Compatibility: The original PSP-1000 and the new PSP-2000 used the exact same proprietary yellow-tipped 5V DC power adapter (plus the PSP-2000 added Mini-USB charging). If Andrew was going to swap just the handheld unit ("console-only trade-in") at a grey-market shop, he didn't need to bring his charger—his existing charger at home would work perfectly with the new Slim model. Meanwhile, taking the console itself was essential both to play on the 2-hour train ride and to hand over for the trade.
  • No Coat, No Passport, No Spare Clothes: Everything about his packing screams a same-day round trip.
  1. Hiding It From His Parents & Staging the Uniform
  • Why skip school and hide the trip from his parents? Because strict or cautious parents would never approve of skipping school to travel to London to hand over £150 in cash at a shady/unofficial electronics stall for a modified console.
  • By putting his school uniform in the washing machine and hanging his blazer on his chair, Andrew was trying to make it look like he had come home from school normally—hoping to slip back into the house that evening with his new PSP before anyone realized he had skipped classes, or figuring it would be "easier to ask forgiveness than permission" once he was already back.
  1. The One-Way Ticket & The 11:25 AM King’s Cross CCTV Footage
  • Refusing the 50p Return Ticket: For a mathematically minded teenager, refusing a return ticket that costs only 50 pence more makes zero sense unless he was 100% certain he had a free ride home. If the person who set up the London connection promised: "Take the morning train down, I’ll meet you there, we’ll hit the shop, and I’m driving back north tonight so I’ll drop you right off in Doncaster," buying a return ticket would seem completely redundant.
  • The CCTV Expression at King’s Cross: Look closely at the famous 11:25 AM still frame of Andrew exiting the main concourse. Unlike the earlier footage on the walkway where he looks calm and focused, at the exit his posture shifts - he looks slightly bewildered, scanning the crowd as if expecting to spot a familiar face (or suddenly realizing the person waiting for him isn't who he expected, or brought someone else along).
  • No Digital Footprint: Because Sony confirmed his PSP never connected to DNAS/PSN and school/library PCs were clean, this lure almost certainly happened offline - a face-to-face conversation with an older peer or someone in his wider real-world network who exploited his interest in tech/gaming to get him to London alone with cash.

Questions for the Community:

  1. Does anyone know if the initial police investigation in 2007 ever canvassed independent/grey-market electronics and console-modding shops around Tottenham Court Road or central London?
  2. Could the "older acquaintance" angle connect to anyone Andrew met during his summer gifted youth program (Lancaster University) or through local Doncaster gaming/music circles who wasn't on his immediate friends list?

I’d love to hear your thoughts—especially from anyone who was active in the UK PSP modding/import scene back in September 2007.


r/AndrewGosden • • 2d ago

CrimeBase.org

0 Upvotes

Would there be any interest in adding the case to https://crimebase.org/about ? It uses AI to regularly reorganise knowledge on cases including missing persons.


r/AndrewGosden • • 3d ago

Andrew’s supposed lack of online activity doesn’t seem to be an established fact

47 Upvotes

Every time I look back at the Andrew Gosden case, I try to remind myself that we're not examining an incomplete yet otherwise robust record of the police investigation. (Think of the Madeleine McCann case, where extensive investigative material became publicly accessible, including witness statements, interview transcripts, and official documentation.)

Here, we're working with a separately constructed public narrative, shaped largely by media coverage and the accounts of Andrew's family, who have been the primary narrators of Andrew's life and disappearance throughout. I admire the Gosdens' efforts to keep their son's disappearance in the public eye. I really do. But I'm cautious about how certain claims have come to be treated as established facts.

Because the family's accounts are inevitably influenced by what investigators have chosen to share with them, how they understood that information, and potentially their emotional relationship to its implications. The possibility that Andrew was secretly communicating with an online predator, for instance, carries a very different emotional weight for his parents than it does for those of us examining the case from the outside, and could naturally impact how they respond to it when asked about it by interviewers.

That brings me to the frequently repeated assertion that police examined computers Andrew might have used at school or at the public library and found nothing significant. As far as I'm aware, we don't have a publicly available statement from investigators themselves explaining what was examined, what information was recovered, or what conclusions they reached. What we have instead are accounts from the family relaying what they understood the police had told them.

But that doesn't necessarily mean every investigative lead was exhausted or every potentially relevant piece of information was ruled out. It means that no significant online activity attributable to Andrew has been established and/or conveyed to the public. That's very different from determining, for instance, whether a seemingly innocuous search for a concert taking place in London on September 14, 2007, was made by Andrew or by somebody else using the same shared computer. Even if such a search appeared in the browser history, investigators might have had no reliable way of establishing who made it, or whether it had anything to do with his disappearance.

“Nothing significant was found”—a relatively cautious formulation compared with more sensationalized claims such as “no trace of Andrew was found on those computers”—is not interchangeable with “every potentially relevant possibility was investigated and excluded.” The arrests made in December 2021 illustrate just how little we may know about what investigators have actually been pursuing, including lines of inquiry that were never publicly disclosed.

Two men were arrested on suspicion of kidnapping and human trafficking, with one additionally suspected of possessing indecent images of children. Police seized numerous electronic devices, spent MANY months examining them, and eventually eliminated both men from the inquiry in September 2023. We still don't know for sure what information prompted that line of investigation, although an anonymous tip-off was reportedly involved. Interestingly, Kevin Gosden himself acknowledged at the time that the family had no factual information beyond what the police had publicly disclosed.

This is precisely why I'm reluctant to treat the family's descriptions of earlier investigative findings as definitive. If the family wasn't fully informed of the evidence behind a major development in 2021, why should we assume that their public accounts provide an exhaustive picture of what investigators established in 2007?

If police were still pursuing possible kidnapping and exploitation scenarios fourteen years later, and primarily seizing and conducting extensive forensic examinations of electronic devices at this stage of the investigation, we certainly shouldn't assume that every possibility involving an unknown online contact back in 2007 has been thoroughly investigated and ruled out.


r/AndrewGosden • • 3d ago

I Wish We Knew...

12 Upvotes

The information The police have.


r/AndrewGosden • • 4d ago

The school and library computers were checked. What could they actually reveal, and how else could you access the internet in Doncaster in 2007?

14 Upvotes

The phrase "the school and library computers were checked" comes up so often in accounts of Andrew's disappearance that it can sound as though the internet question was settled. But we don't know from the public reporting which machines were examined, what records were available or how much could be connected to Andrew personally.

I wanted to look at what internet access was actually available in Doncaster in 2007, beyond the computers usually mentioned, and then at what investigators and service providers might realistically have been able to establish. That includes public terminals, internet cafés, Wi-Fi hotspots and the different kinds of records which might have existed at the time.

Part of my professional work involves analysing telephone, internet and communications data, which makes me cautious about treating an unsuccessful enquiry as proof that something never happened. I haven't seen the original police or forensic reports, and I don't know the full extent of the enquiries undertaken, so I'm not suggesting anything was overlooked. The question is how much the public descriptions of those enquiries actually allow us to conclude.

"The school and library computers were checked"

This is a phrase which sounds much more comprehensive than it necessarily is.

The VICE interview says police took computers from Andrew's school and Doncaster Library and found nothing. Of course we don't have the forensic reports.

McAuley's historical Ofsted material shows that it had established IT provision well before 2007 but I haven't found is anything describing the actual September 2007 network setup. Did every pupil have an individual Windows or network login? Were the machines using shared accounts? Was internet traffic passing through a central proxy or web-filtering system? Were logs retained against usernames, computers, IP addresses or not at all? Could pupils use external Hotmail, MSN, forums or other services? How long did local browser histories survive on heavily used school computers? The public information doesn't answer any of that.

And "the computers were taken" makes me particularly interested in whether this meant individual workstations or whether server-side material was also examined. If Andrew used a particular machine under an identifiable personal account and police examined it quickly then a negative result would carry substantial weight. If dozens or hundreds of pupils used shared terminals and the relevant information lived in short-lived proxy logs somewhere else, it is a very different enquiry.

The Doncaster Library has the same problem. Public libraries could have booking systems, membership-linked sessions, shared public accounts, browser histories, central filtering or some mixture of those things. Again I haven't found Doncaster's 2007 configuration. A booking record saying Andrew used a terminal wouldn't tell us what websites he visited. A web address found on a shared terminal wouldn't tell us Andrew was the person who visited it.

There were also other libraries in Doncaster besides the central one at Waterdale. Cantley Library was on Goodison Boulevard near McAuley's two school sites and Balby had its own branch. In the minutes of a Doncaster Council meeting held on 25 February 2008, the mayor specifically referred to free internet access at the borough's public libraries. A later 2014 council report also discussed continuing free computer and internet access at Cantley. The first is particularly close to the period we're looking at, although neither establishes what equipment each branch had in September 2007, how sessions were booked or what records were retained.

I'm curious about what "Doncaster Library" actually meant in the original enquiry. Was it the central library, a particular branch, several branches or records held by the library service centrally? An examination of computers at one branch wouldn't automatically tell us about activity at another. Equally the public descriptions might simply be shorthand for a more extensive enquiry. Without the original reports we simply can't tell.

None of this means the police examination was inadequate. There simply isn't enough public information about its scope to judge how much "nothing was found" actually excludes. Which machines were examined, when, what accounts were searched, what date range was covered, whether network or proxy logs existed and what applications or websites investigators were actually looking for.

There were other places to get online in Doncaster

I went looking for internet cafés in Doncaster around 2007 and ended up finding something I hadn't expected: a network of public email terminals which didn't require someone to go to a conventional internet café at all. The best evidence is a German visitor's diary from July 2006. The writer was spending a few weeks on a placement in Doncaster and on 3 July actually used one of the terminals to send a video greeting. The automatically generated message identified 'iPlus Point on Everingham Road, Cantley, provided by Cityspace Ltd'. So now we have a contemporary account of somebody using a public communication facility in the area.

His entry the following day is quite informative about what the machines could do. You could send emails, electronic postcards and recorded video messages, find bus connections, print route maps and use a limited web-search function. But he also wrote that ordinary browsing was heavily restricted so I wouldn't treat the Everingham Road terminal as the equivalent of a normal PC with free access to Hotmail, MSN Messenger or any forum you chose. Even so sending an email from a public terminal was demonstrably possible in Cantley in July 2006 without having to own a computer or visit the central library.

The council's own Corporate Asset Management Plan, in its 2008/09 revision, recorded 35 public information kiosks across the borough. They offered free email, council and transport information, job opportunities and other services. Some stood outdoors on council land while others were housed in buildings. The 2006 visitor also mentioned public terminals in libraries and at The Dome.

There were other internet possibilities as well. On 25 June 2007 in a Sheffield Forum discussion about internet gaming cafés a commenter recommended somewhere called UPLOAD in Doncaster to a person looking for a place to play World of Warcraft. I haven't established UPLOAD's address, what else it offered or whether it was still trading in September. But it's a very specific dated reference from only a few months before Andrew disappeared.

Another business was LANlounge at 59 Silver Street, an internet café which can be found in a surviving business directory. A London Gazette notice published on 4 October 2007 describes someone as having 'lately' carried on business under the name LANlounge at that address, with a bankruptcy order dated 1 October. That establishes the business operated at the relevant time.

I also found two planning applications, one for an internet café at 31 Kingsgate and another for a cybercafé at Danum House on Cleveland Street. Both received permission in 2004. The limitation is that we obviously cannot confirm whether Andrew visited any of these locations.

There's a Websleuths comment from September 2020 claiming that police examined computers at a local internet café as well as the school and library. The contributor didn't identify the café or cite an original police or family source. I haven't found one either so I wouldn't treat that statement as confirmed but it would be equally unjustified to say that police definitely didn't check any commercial premises just because their public statements don't mention them.

What interests me here is that different facilities might have generated very different records. A library computer, a commercial gaming café and a council kiosk capable of sending outgoing emails wouldn't necessarily have had the same accounts, access rules, histories or logs. The iPlus Point also shouldn't be confused with a public Wi-Fi hotspot. I've found nothing establishing that it provided a wireless connection for somebody else's device, such as a PSP. Even if a premises had computers, we would still need to know what could be attributed to an individual user and how long any records survived.

None of this places Andrew at an internet café, library branch or kiosk. But it does make the phrase "the school and library computers were checked" feel rather incomplete without knowing which facilities were considered and what the original examinations actually covered.

The question of Wi-Fi

There's a separate question about public Wi-Fi, because somebody with a PSP didn't necessarily need to use one of those terminals or café computers. I had assumed it would be difficult to establish where wireless hotspots actually existed in Doncaster in 2007 but there are a few useful surviving records.

The earliest specific one I've found is a BT Openzone hotspot directory dated 16 November 2004. Its Doncaster entries include PC World at Unit 2, Danum Retail Park on York Road, a McDonald's at Junction 38 of the A1(M) by Redhouse Interchange and another McDonald's simply recorded as 'Doncaster' with no street address. That's quite a bit earlier than September 2007 so I think it is fair to say there were likely more than three hotspots operating when Andrew disappeared as wireless access points were being advertised at identifiable Doncaster businesses almost three years beforehand.

They weren't necessarily free. BT Openzone generally worked through payment, subscriptions or other access arrangements. There was also a later change at McDonald's which could easily confuse the dates as it announced in October 2007 that it was rolling out unlimited free Wi-Fi in the UK, after Andrew disappeared.

Wetherspoon is probably the most interesting example I've found of wireless internet being offered without a separate internet-access charge before that date. A MoneySavingExpert discussion started on 16 March 2007 describes customers buying food or a drink and asking at the bar for a voucher giving them 30 minutes online. A June 2007 blog post reproduces Wetherspoon's own promotional wording which said the offer applied to Wetherspoon pubs and Lloyds No. 1 bars. Wetherspoon's own company history also dates free Wi-Fi to 2006. People were still discussing the same scheme in August 2007, only a month before Andrew disappeared. So the relevant offer really did predate his disappearance.

There were at least two longstanding Wetherspoon pubs in central Doncaster. The Gate House on Priory Walk and the Red Lion at 37-38 Market Place. A local newspaper report from 27 August 2007 also refers to the Gate House as a Wetherspoon pub at the time. The contemporary customer accounts make the arrangement sound less straightforward than the advertising. One poster in March 2007 described a small blue scratch-card with a username and password, supplied for The Cloud network. And there is a more obvious difficulty in applying this to Andrew: he was fourteen. Section 145 of the Licensing Act 2003 restricted unaccompanied under-16s in premises used primarily for selling alcohol for consumption there. A Wetherspoon premises licence originally dated August 2005 also records an adult-accompaniment requirement. I don't think we can assume Andrew could have gone into either on his own, bought a soft drink and got a voucher.

Other Doncaster pub listings identify The Cloud as the wireless provider at the Black Bull on Market Place, the White Bear on Hall Gate and the Goose on Wood Street. There's also a free-hotspot directory entry for the Grand St Leger Hotel on Bennetthorpe.

There were also other possible Wi-Fi opportunities. Someone with a valid subscriber account or voucher could use certain paid hotspots without paying for each individual visit. Schemes such as Fon let members use participating residential connections. Independent cafés, shops, libraries or other organisations might simply have offered open Wi-Fi. An unsecured private router would of course raise another opportunity.

The surviving records establish some real local wireless infrastructure and a plausible means of getting access, not an actual connection by Andrew.

A website in the browsing history wouldn't establish an account

Even if investigators had recovered a history showing MySpace, Bebo or Facebook on a machine Andrew used, what exactly would that have told them? Someone might have opened a public profile or followed a link without signing in. A visit could have been made by another pupil on the same computer. And a browser history entry wouldn't automatically tell investigators what username, if any, was used on the website.

There are of course stronger local traces than an ordinary browsing entry. A saved username, session cookie, cached account page, contact list or locally saved chat history could narrow it down. A June 2007 digital-forensics paper on Windows Live Messenger 8.0 identified user settings, contacts and other recoverable traces on Windows XP machines, sometimes even after deletion. It didn't find that every conversation would necessarily be recoverable. I would be interested in whether the school's forensic work included those application-specific files, individual Windows user profiles and any shared network records rather than just browser histories.

A school or library's public IP address could also represent dozens of computers. A website showing a login from that IP address at 4pm would not identify the person at the keyboard without other records. Investigators would need to account for different time zones and link the activity to a particular terminal or user.

A Wi-Fi hotspot could have been another possible source of records. Depending on the operator's systems, a commercial provider might have recorded a voucher or subscriber login, the time and location of a session, an assigned IP address or a device's wireless MAC address. But I haven't found The Cloud's or BT Openzone's actual 2007 retention policies so I wouldn't assume any of those records were routinely kept for long enough to help. Even a successful hotspot login wouldn't necessarily identify the person using the device or show which websites they visited. I also haven't found a public account of whether investigators approached any wireless hotspot provider, which is different from evidence that they didn't.

And a site might possess an account registration without knowing the user's real identity. Many services relied on names and email addresses supplied by users themselves. An account registered under a nickname or an unrelated email address wouldn't necessarily turn up just because somebody searched or asked for data for Andrew Gosden or a known email address or username. There may have been alternative names, usernames or email addresses unknown to family or investigators.

Could police have obtained his records from the websites themselves?

This part I think gets lost when people say the school computers were checked and nothing turned up. Even if a computer examination had identified a particular website, the police would still have needed to work out whether Andrew had an account there, how to identify it, what the company had kept and whether it could lawfully disclose the information. An account could exist without a locally saved history. And finding a website in the history wouldn't automatically tell them which account to ask about.

There's an earlier problem too: which websites would investigators even know to approach? If a service wasn't mentioned by Andrew's family, friends or school, and left no identifiable trace on a computer police examined, it might never have been recognised as a line of enquiry. The Lancaster research illustrates this quite well. Knowing he attended NAGTY wouldn't necessarily tell somebody about Lancaster's LUVLE, Warwick's separate study groups or other associated online communities, each potentially holding its own records. Investigators could identify services by other means, including institutional enquiries or leads from IP addresses, but they still needed something to point them in the right direction. We don't know which of those enquiries were actually made. And even where a provider was approached, an unknown username or email address could leave them unable to find an account.

There is good documentation from around the time. A Microsoft law-enforcement retention summary from July 2006 gives 60 days for Hotmail/MSN email IP logs and certain MSN Groups and Spaces connection logs. For Windows Live Messenger conversation contents, the entry is simply 'None'. Microsoft's March 2008 handbook explains that its servers authenticated Messenger users but didn't centrally log what they said. It might retain account information and some connections, but without a transcript. It also says an account could not be identified from a Messenger screen name alone - this means that investigators would actually need the full account name, including its domain. A Windows Live ID didn't even necessarily have to come with a Hotmail mailbox. So a check for Hotmail addresses, a check for Messenger accounts and a check for Xbox Live were different enquiries which would not automatically rule out one another.

Other providers kept completely different things. MySpace's law-enforcement guide, last updated 1 November 2007, says login IP records were available for about a year, but sent private messages were kept for only 14 days unless deleted sooner. Inbox messages lasted until the user deleted them, and the company said it couldn't recover deleted private messages. It advised investigators to look on the person's own computer for MySpace Messenger logs, cookies and cached material. So police might have been able to establish when an identified profile logged in without being able to retrieve the conversation. MySpace also preferred its numerical FriendID, rather than a vague description of an account.

Facebook's surviving 2007 law-enforcement guidance is interesting for a different reason. It describes searching website logs by a known account or an IP address, with entries identifying the active account, operation, IP and time. But it gives normal IP-log retention as approximately 30 days, subject to variation. A February 2008 version gives a different, longer figure of around 90 days. I can't establish precisely which arrangement applied on 14 September and the earlier document itself has an awkward mix of version dates. Still, a sufficiently precise school or library IP address and time could sometimes have provided a route to identifying a Facebook account, assuming the logs still existed. That wouldn't identify the child using the computer.

Bebo's privacy policy reproduced in an Ofcom submission dated November 2007 says it collected registration details and technical information including IP addresses and cookies. It also had invitations, which means an email address could appear in its records merely because someone else had invited that person. On 29 April 2008 its safety officer told Parliament that Bebo had a dedicated team trained to handle requests under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act and was accustomed to working with British police over information such as IP addresses and timestamps. I haven't found a reliable guide giving Bebo's exact September 2007 log-retention period.

A surviving Yahoo law-enforcement compliance guide describes Messenger contact and login information which could include the IDs of people an account had communicated with during roughly the previous 45-60 days, without centrally storing the downloadable client's conversation contents. Yahoo's own guide says it generally needed a Yahoo ID and a narrow date range to search those records. This version of the guide is from after Andrew disappeared, so its retention figures aren't proof of Yahoo's exact 2007 practice, but it demonstrates how a provider might identify contacts yet have no conversation to produce. A local Messenger archive could tell a different story.

There is also a difference between internet service provider records and a website's own account records. An ISP might identify the subscriber using a public IP address at a given time, or have some network traffic data, but that didn't give it a universal record of every person who logged into a forum. Nor did the October 2007 telephone-data retention regulations require Facebook or MySpace to keep twelve months of their users' messages. In a 2009 Lords debate the government expressly confirmed that the later internet communications retention rules did not apply to social networking sites. In September 2007 there were voluntary UK retention arrangements for some communications providers, but not a blanket requirement for every website to record all activity.

Then there was the legal and practical process of getting the data. RIPA legislation provided routes for British authorities to seek certain communications data, subject to the applicable powers, necessity and proportionality. But it didn't turn every stored private message into disclosable communications data. The Data Protection Act 1998 also didn't provide a general power to compel a company to hand over whatever the police requested. And the biggest services weren't necessarily holding their records in Britain. Microsoft's March 2008 handbook says overseas criminal-law requests for its online-service customer records had to go through Microsoft in the United States where it stored those records. MySpace's 2007 guide likewise distinguishes subscriber information, login records and message contents under American law. Where formal US legal process was required a British request alone couldn't simply substitute for it. Emergency or voluntary disclosures might have been possible in particular circumstances, but that wasn't an automatic right to obtain everything in a missing-person enquiry.

There were ways to ask a US provider to preserve records while the proper process was arranged. Under 18 USC 2703(f) the statutory preservation period was initially 90 days, renewable for another 90 days. Preservation still required an identifiable target and could only protect information the provider actually held. It couldn't recreate an already deleted message or a login log that had expired. Whether an overseas request could be acted upon directly, or needed US law-enforcement involvement, depended on the applicable procedure and provider.

The dates of police enquiries are therefore important. A September Messenger contact log available in October might have expired by December, while a MySpace login record could outlast its messages. A provider might also have records but require a different identifier or legal process. An unsuccessful enquiry therefore could mean several different things.

The later 'Andyroo' lead gives a particularly relevant example, although it tells us nothing about Andrew's actual internet use in 2007. In Kevin's 2018 VICE interview he described police approaching the operators of a website following a 2017 report about somebody using that name and claiming to have left home at 14. According to Kevin a change to the site's systems meant the administrators couldn't supply the user information being sought. The lead wasn't established as Andrew, but it shows how even a known website and apparent username may not lead to retrievable records.

We don't have a public list of the sites police approached in 2007, the usernames or IP addresses they gave them, whether they made preservation requests, the dates of any approaches or what the replies actually said. A response saying 'no account matches this email address' is very different from 'the account exists but the messages aren't retained' or 'we cannot identify the user without more information'. And that's assuming they were asked. Without the original correspondence, I don't think it's possible to say what each negative result genuinely excluded.

So what do the negative digital findings actually leave us with?

For school and library computers, "nothing found" becomes more useful the more we know about the machines, user accounts, central logging and date range examined. The same applies to the other public-access facilities in Doncaster. We have evidence of working email kiosks in 2006 and contemporary references to commercial internet gaming, but no evidence Andrew used either and no original account telling us which of those facilities the police considered.

The wireless research adds one more distinction. There were documented commercial hotspots in Doncaster before September 2007, but we have nothing showing Andrew actually did so. We also have nothing showing he didn't.

There's still no positive evidence that Andrew used any of these public facilities to communicate with someone. But the descriptions of the school and library enquiries aren't detailed enough to establish what happened across every possible service or connection.

The better question is which specific channels were examined, using which identifiers, at what date, and what the negative result from each check was capable of excluding.


r/AndrewGosden • • 3d ago

A day-trip to London to purchase the new PSP leading to a crime of opportunity is the most plausible explanation to whatever happened to Andrew

0 Upvotes

Picture it: a 14-year-old boy from Doncaster who lives and breathes for his PSP has saved up just enough money to buy the new version of the console. He doesn't tell his parents about his plans. They might object to him spending so much money on another gaming device, particularly when they're already struggling to get this self-professed couch potato out of his bedroom.

Altogether, the boy has saved up £130, which is precisely what the game went for. One afternoon, he decides to browse his local gaming stores. Let's say it's September 5, precisely the date the new console was originally expected to be released nationwide, although a later date would also work for our theory.

Unfortunately, the launch has been delayed. Gamers are confused about the new release date, and even those actively exchanging information on online discussion boards are encountering conflicting reports from retailers. The boy visits a shop or two, discovers that the console isn't available, and returns home empty-handed.

Now picture him arriving home later than usual, only to find his father there. Dad has happened to return from work earlier than expected and assumed his son was already upstairs, as usual. Asked why he's only just getting home, the boy explains that he decided to walk instead of taking the school bus. He fancied a bit of fresh air, I suppose. But let's not be too hard on him: it's a harmless white lie to conceal his attempt to buy the new PSP.

Anyway, September 14 arrives. It's a Friday, and the new advertised release date. Having already encountered unreliable information about availability in Doncaster, the boy decides that London might offer his best chance of finding the console. He has family there, has visited many times, and knows enough about the city to feel comfortable navigating it independently.

From King's Cross, he can reach Oxford Street by following major roads, where several flagship gaming and entertainment retailers are concentrated within walking distance of one another. In his mind, these shops might be more likely to have the console in stock, perhaps even with better bundles than those offered locally.

And why London rather than Leeds or Sheffield? For starters, because familiarity can matter more than distance, particularly when you're fourteen and traveling without a smartphone or GPS. The boy knows London. He has some idea of where he needs to go and how to get there. A geographically closer city he doesn't know nearly as well might actually feel more difficult to navigate.

Then comes the question of money. He has £130 saved up for the console, but traveling to London will cost considerably more than walking into a shop in Doncaster. Suppose he takes £30 from his cash savings, leaves the remaining £100 in his bedroom, and withdraws £200 from his bank account. That gives him £230 for the day: approximately £130 for the new PSP, with another £100 available for train fares, food, and any other expenses.

(How do we know he had that extra £30? We don't. But we don't know that the £100 left behind was all the cash he had at home, either. We only know how much money was reportedly found in his bedroom after his disappearance, not how much he'd had in the first place or how much he might have taken with him. In other words, there's no reason to assume that the £200 he withdrew from the ATM represented his entire budget for the trip.)

Anyway, the boy spends £31.40 on the outward ticket. That leaves him almost £70 for the journey home and perhaps a snack or two, assuming he spends approximately £130 on the new PSP. The ticket seller offers him a return for just 50p more, but he declines. Why? Well, either because he didn’t understand the offer or because, being the smart boy that he was, he knew that discounted return tickets came with restrictions on when they could be used. The 50p increase would prevent him from returning on any train departuring from London during the Friday afternoon peak, between 3 p.m. and 7 p.m. He could not have been back home in time for dinner or before his parents noticed his absence in the first place.

And then, this boy arrives in London. His parents believe he's at school, as usual. Whatever concerns he might have had about the school contacting his family to report his absence have, at least for the time being, proved unnecessary: his parents haven't been alerted. According to subsequent accounts from the school, they only had the family's landline number and, with both parents away at work, royally messed up the attempt to contact them by calling the wrong number and leaving a message on someone else's answering machine.

Now the boy is heading towards or walking around Oxford Street. He's fourteen, alone in London on a Friday morning when he should be at school, and possibly carrying enough cash to buy an expensive new gaming console. All it takes is one person with criminal intentions noticing him, striking up a conversation, noticing his accent, and establishing that he's visiting from out of town.

Perhaps the stranger offers to show him another shop where the new PSP is available, or where he can find a better deal. Perhaps the boy follows him somewhere less crowded, expecting nothing more than a chance to buy the console he's traveled all this way to find. And perhaps what begins as an attempted robbery escalates into something far more serious, especially if the boy tries to react or shouts to get someone else's attention. Or it was really a sex predator jumping into a window of opportunity all along.

No human trafficking ring required. No elaborate runaway plan. No online grooming of a boy that didn't have access to a home computer and that left no trace whatsoever in the PCs he could have used in school or at the public library. No intention to commit suicide and somehow remain undiscovered in one of the largest cities in the world. Just a teenager pursuing an ordinary interest, making a series of decisions that seem perfectly reasonable to him, and encountering the wrong person at the wrong time.

That, to me, is by far the most plausible scenario for whatever happened to Andrew Gosden: foul play resulting from a crime of opportunity against a boy who had a perfectly valid reason - to him - to deviate so drastically from his routine that day.


r/AndrewGosden • • 5d ago

My thoughts and theories about Andrew Gosden’s disappearance

16 Upvotes

1. The Slipknot T-shirt
I’ve been following Andrew’s case, and I have a few theories I’d really like to discuss.
First of all, I find it hard to believe that Andrew wearing that particular Slipknot T-shirt was just a random choice. Maybe he had told some friends in his neighbourhood why he bought it in the first place. Perhaps there was a concert, maybe he wanted to meet someone from a particular band or get an autograph, or maybe there was some kind of gathering of people who shared his interest in rock music. It doesn’t necessarily have to be a concert happening that day. It could have been some private gathering or a meeting that wasn’t publicly advertised.
Honestly, I find it strange that after all these years, nobody seems to have come forward with any information about his plans or intentions. Does anyone here know somebody who knew Andrew personally, perhaps a neighbour, a schoolmate, or someone from his close circle of friends?
2. The £200 and the school uniform
I don’t really believe that someone who intended to disappear forever would only take £200. He could have withdrawn more money if that was genuinely his intention.
And one detail I find particularly important is that he put his school uniform in the washing machine after returning home. Why would someone planning to disappear permanently bother doing that? It seems to me that he was trying to prevent his mother from discovering that he had returned home instead of going to school. That makes me think he wasn’t necessarily planning to leave his family forever.
3. Meeting the wrong people in London
My strongest suspicion is that he simply met the wrong people at the wrong time. He was very young, and perhaps he got involved in something he didn’t fully understand.
I keep imagining that he travelled to London for a particular reason, possibly to attend some kind of gathering or meet someone, but ended up somewhere he shouldn’t have been. Maybe he even went to the wrong address and found himself in a dangerous environment, surrounded by people involved in drugs or other criminal activities.
I just can’t come up with another convincing explanation for what happened to him.
4. What was going through his mind that morning?
More than anything, I wish I could know what was going through his mind that morning. To me, the biggest keys to this case are still that Slipknot T-shirt and his closest friends.
If his entire circle of friends was thoroughly investigated and absolutely nothing suspicious was found, then I would lean even more towards the possibility that something unexpected happened to him in London, involving people he didn’t know.
What do you guys think?


r/AndrewGosden • • 5d ago

Andrew Gosden: il viaggio misterioso verso Londra | La scomparsa

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/AndrewGosden • • 8d ago

NAGTY video

22 Upvotes

I found this particular NAGTY video on YouTube interesting https://youtu.be/DyKUABNmFic?is=E1I_5niEtOUvTiSC

It mentions that there was a September meetup, and then we see pictures. Because the segment that follows it is about February 2008 stuff, the meetup was presumably in 2007.

There's nothing I can see in that video that connects that particular Nagty meetup to Andrew, but the fact that September was a meetup for Nagty members strikes a cord seeing as Andrew disappeared in September and was a NAGTY member.


r/AndrewGosden • • 9d ago

Andrew Gosden – Could something have happened to him around King's Cross that has simply been overlooked?

30 Upvotes

I've been thinking about Andrew Gosden's disappearance and wanted to put a few thoughts out there. This isn't a claim that I've discovered anything, and I don't have any inside information. It's more a collection of questions and possibilities that have been playing on my mind, particularly when I think about King's Cross and what the area was like back in September 2007.

I think sometimes we concentrate so much on the fact that Andrew travelled to London that we perhaps don't spend enough time thinking about what those hours might actually have looked like for a 14-year-old boy on his own.

What did he do after leaving King's Cross station? Where did he go? Who might he have spoken to? Did he spend most of the day simply walking around, looking at things, getting something to eat and enjoying being away from home?

The possibility that he was simply spending time in London

One thought I keep returning to is that Andrew may not initially have intended anything particularly dramatic.

He was 14. He had travelled to a city he may have been curious about, and perhaps he just wanted a day away from his normal routine.

I can imagine him walking around, visiting places, stopping somewhere to eat and generally taking in the surroundings. There have been reported sightings around London, including a possible sighting at Pizza Hut, although these should not be confused with confirmed sightings.

I also wonder whether he stayed out as the day turned into evening.

King's Cross is a busy area, with people constantly moving through it. A teenager on his own might not necessarily attract much attention, particularly in a place where young people and travellers are a common sight.

And this brings me to something else.

Could someone have approached him?

I've wondered whether Andrew might have encountered somebody during the day or evening who offered him help, food, company or simply somewhere to go.

I'm not suggesting that this definitely happened, or that any particular person was involved.

But when you consider how young people interact with strangers, sometimes an encounter can appear completely ordinary at the time.

Someone might offer assistance, strike up a conversation or make a young person feel comfortable enough to accompany them somewhere.

I've also wondered about the possibility of outreach workers encountering Andrew.

There are people who work with vulnerable and homeless young people around King's Cross. Someone working in that environment might have spoken to a boy matching Andrew's description without having any idea who he was.

If that person didn't recognise him at the time, they might never have connected the encounter with his disappearance.

And after nearly two decades, an ordinary conversation with a teenager could easily have faded from someone's memory.

I wonder whether former outreach workers, including people who worked with the Salvation Army in the area, have ever been asked to think back to that particular date.

King's Cross in 2007 was a very different place

This is probably the part of the case that interests me most.

Anyone familiar with King's Cross will know how much the area has changed.

There was substantial redevelopment around the railway lands, old industrial buildings, railway structures, construction sites and areas that were being transformed.

When I think about Andrew disappearing in 2007, I wonder whether enough attention has been given to the physical environment as it existed at that time.

What buildings were standing? Which areas were accessible? Which places were abandoned, empty or awaiting redevelopment?

And what has happened to those locations since?

Could an area that was accessible in 2007 now be completely unrecognisable?

Could a site have been redeveloped, with the original structures and surrounding land effectively disappearing beneath new buildings?

I'm not saying Andrew was necessarily involved in any such situation. It's simply something I think is worth considering when investigating a disappearance that happened in an area undergoing so much change.

What about the old underground infrastructure?

Another possibility I've thought about is the older underground railway infrastructure around King's Cross.

The area has a long Victorian railway history, and there are disused or altered railway structures associated with its development.

I wonder whether historical records of these places have been considered in the context of Andrew's disappearance.

Could there have been spaces or structures that were subsequently sealed, altered or incorporated into later development?

Again, I have no evidence that Andrew entered any such place. I'm not suggesting anyone should attempt to explore abandoned infrastructure. These are questions for investigators and people with access to historical railway and building records.

Have we lost potential witnesses simply because nobody knew what to look for?

This is perhaps my biggest question.

When somebody disappears, we understandably focus on CCTV, confirmed sightings, family appeals and the evidence available at the time.

But what about all the ordinary interactions that might have taken place?

A shop worker, an outreach volunteer, someone working on a building site, a local resident or somebody who simply passed Andrew in the street.

They might have seen him, spoken to him or offered him assistance without realising anything was unusual.

They might not have remembered the encounter until years later, if they ever heard about the case again.

I wonder whether there are people who worked around King's Cross in September 2007 who have never been approached about their recollections.

I'm interested in hearing from people who knew the area

I'd particularly like to hear from:

- Anyone who lived or worked around King's Cross in 2007.

- Former Salvation Army or other outreach workers.

- People who worked on construction and redevelopment projects in the area.

- Former railway staff who knew the older infrastructure.

- Anyone who remembers the atmosphere around King's Cross during that period.

Do you remember particular buildings, empty sites or parts of the area that have since disappeared?

Are there historical maps or redevelopment records that might help establish what was accessible at the time?

And has anyone ever looked into whether there were overlooked witness accounts from people who worked with young people in the area?

I appreciate that some of these thoughts are speculative, and I don't want to present assumptions as facts.

I'm not trying to create another elaborate theory or point fingers at anyone.

I just find myself wondering whether the answer could involve something very ordinary that happened to Andrew during those hours in London, something that nobody realised was important at the time.

After all these years, his family still deserves answers.

What do people think? Is there an aspect of King's Cross in 2007, particularly its outreach services, redevelopment or older railway infrastructure, that deserves another look?


r/AndrewGosden • • 10d ago

What do we make of the later sightings?

23 Upvotes

This is a somewhat pointless post I get that, as if none of them are confirmed then what's the point discussing them?

But if even one of them happens to be genuine, it leads me to think it's more likely that he just ran away and didn't really have a solid plan at all. Particularly if the park sighting was real in southwark.

Now the pizza hut sighting, if it could have been confirmed, doesn't really tell us much. I mean whatever he was doing in London getting food to me isn't a significant clue unless someone can enlighten me.

A number of sightings are just in different areas of London so was he just wandering about?

And the Covent garden sighting, the denying being Andrew also tells me nothing, in fact, I'd expect him to deny being Andrew if he indeed was.

Some places he was seen are quite odd and dont make sense. Like why would he be in Wales or Plymouth. I reckon these sightings are false. The Brighton one I'm less sure about.

I actually personally think at least one of them (not including pizza hut) may be genuine. If so it seems like he was just wandering about, bought some more appropriate clothes and just tried to wing it.

But then the more sinister theory I had was that he just got into a car at kings cross and then... well 😐.

What do people here think of these sightings? Is there a chance they're all just misunderstandings?

Sometimes people say they "I'm 100% sure it was them" but from what I can find there's not much information on each sighting or the witnesses confidence in the sighting.

If I saw him and noticed his distinctive features like his ear, I'd be speaking loud and stressing that I really do think it was genuine and point the smaller features in noticed.

I know its not really right, but I half wished one pf these people took a photo of the person they thought was him to show the police, facial recognition these days must be way more sophisticated then it was back then.

All potential drivel from me, but when cases have a number of sightings I tend to think a lot about them.

Edit: fair play to the godammitletmesleep who last posted on here giving a deep dive into Andrew's possible communications. Really interesting stuff.


r/AndrewGosden • • 11d ago Bravo

Andrew's PSP could access MSN Messenger in 2007. What did Sony's reported check actually establish?

63 Upvotes

The digital side of Andrew's case is usually summarised very neatly.

"He didn't have a phone. He didn't have an email address. Sony checked his PSP. There was no online account on his Xbox."

From there it often becomes "Andrew had essentially no internet presence, so an online friendship or arrangement can more or less be ruled out".

I'm no longer comfortable with that last step because once you separate what the technology could actually do in 2007 from what Andrew is known to have used, and then separate both of those from what the publicly described police checks could realistically exclude, the picture becomes much less tidy.

This follows on from my previous post about Andrew's 2006 Lancaster summer school and its online side. Looking into the different NAGTY and Lancaster online systems made me wonder how much of a young person's internet activity would actually have been identifiable to investigators in 2007, particularly if nobody close to them knew which sites or services they were using.

For full disclosure: Part of my professional work involves analysing telephone, internet and communications data and it's made me particularly cautious about what can be concluded when an enquiry produces no results. So much depends on what investigators knew to look for, what was actually checked, when those enquiries were made and what information was available or could realistically be obtained. That's especially important in a case from 2007 when online services and the ways people communicated were developing rapidly, data retention practices varied considerably and even thorough enquiries had their limitations.

I haven't seen the original police reports and I don't know the full extent of the enquiries undertaken or the responses investigators received, so I'm not suggesting that anything was overlooked or handled incorrectly. But I do wonder whether some of the public descriptions of the enquiries into Andrew's internet use (including findings attributed to police) may have conveyed more certainty than the underlying evidence could support, particularly given the technology available at the time, what service providers could actually establish and the limitations of the data they held. Equally it's possible that subsequent reporting has made those statements sound more definitive than they originally were. Once something has been repeated as an established fact for nearly twenty years, it's easy to lose sight of precisely what was established in the first place.

There's also the issue of time. If certain lines of enquiry weren't identified or pursued when Andrew first disappeared then potentially relevant records may never have been requested or preserved. Depending on the provider, some of that information could have been deleted within weeks or months under routine retention policies. That doesn't mean there was necessarily anything to find, but it does mean some questions may no longer be answerable.

I'm not suggesting that Andrew definitely used the internet or was secretly communicating with anyone. My point is that there's an important difference between finding no evidence of something and establishing that it never happened. Without knowing exactly what was investigated, what information was available and what those enquiries were capable of ruling out, I don't think we can confidently make that leap.

The phones Andrew apparently lost

The clearest account I can find of Andrew's mobile phones comes from Kevin's 2018 VICE interview.

Kevin said Andrew had "a couple" of phones between roughly the ages of ten and twelve, managed to lose them, hardly used them anyway and asked for an Xbox when his parents offered another replacement. Andrew turned twelve in July 2005. But an October 2007 Times report, also reproduced here, says Andrew was given a mobile for his twelfth birthday and later lost it. It doesn't say when. And in a March 2020 Reddit post reproducing what was said to be a direct reply from Kevin, he reportedly described Andrew losing his mobile "months before going missing". I can't independently authenticate that exchange, but it complicates the idea that Andrew had lost both phones years earlier. Kevin's reference to his ages in the VICE interview doesn't necessarily tell us when the last phone was lost.

I haven't found a reliable source giving either handset model, network, telephone number, SIM details, IMEI (handset identifier) or a date of last use. That leaves quite a large gap between "the family believed Andrew had lost two phones" and the technical question of what happened to those devices or numbers afterwards. A lost handset and an inactive handset aren't necessarily the same thing. A lost handset and a concealed handset definitely aren't.

A pay-as-you-go (PAYG) phone in 2007 wasn't tied neatly to a verified identity. In Parliament on 16 July 2007, the government confirmed that compulsory proof-of-identity registration for PAYG mobile phones had been considered and rejected. Someone could therefore buy another PAYG SIM without the sort of mandatory ID check people may now imagine, and that means that checks with network providers wouldn't tie the owners name with that SIM card.

Now that didn't make a phone technically invisible. Networks could still hold things such as the telephone number, SIM identity, handset identifier, call and text records, cell site location data, customer notes and cell-site information depending on the event and their systems. Police already had routes for obtaining this kind of communications data. Orange later told a Parliamentary committee that it supplied subscriber, billing and other communications data under RIPA and could provide real-time location information in urgent life-at-risk cases.

But the retention position in September 2007 was different from the one people sometimes project backwards from later years. The Data Retention Regulations 2007, which imposed a twelve-month requirement for specified fixed and mobile telephone data, didn't come into force until 1 October 2007, seventeen days after Andrew disappeared. Internet-access, internet-telephony and email retention requirements came later still.

The 2003 voluntary retention framework was already in place, and evidence submitted to Parliament in 2005-06 by mobile-phone forensic specialist Daren Greener gives a useful picture of what providers actually held. He described historical call records being retained for up to twelve months, with records of text-message exchanges sometimes kept for six months or less depending on the network and account type. The contents of old texts weren't ordinarily available. So the fact that the new regulations hadn't yet started doesn't mean relevant mobile records couldn't have been obtained if investigators knew which number or handset to ask about.

Providers obviously retained some information before those regulations (usually as a wase by-product of daily business rather than for a specific purpose) but the point is that there wasn't one uniform statutory twelve-month archive covering every possible communications service when Andrew disappeared.

Timing would have mattered enormously. If police knew a number, SIM or handset identifier early enough then a useful enquiry may have been possible. Enquiries could have been made with network providers. On the flip side, if a relevant handset, account or number was never identified at all, there was nothing obvious to ask or search for.

The truth is that we have no idea if Andrew secretly had acquired another phone, or if a 'lost' phone was actually concealed. Kevin's recollection is that Andrew showed very little interest in phones even when his parents offered him replacements but we can't be sure that reflected his full feelings.

And we also have no idea what police checks were - or weren't - done around the phone. If family reported that there wasn't one because they weren't aware of one then it isn't beyond the realm of possibilities that these checks weren't seen as necessary.

The PSP oversimplification

Andrew took his PSP with him to London and therefore the hardware itself is worth dating properly.

Sony launched the original PSP in Europe in September 2005. The slimmer PSP-2000 generation only reached the UK market around September 2007, with contemporary trade reporting putting its retail launch on 14 September itself.

The new device was primarily a redesign of the original PSP rather than a significant technological upgrade. It was slightly lighter and slimmer, but played the same games and offered the same core functionality. Contemporary reporting by Ars Technica in August 2007 described the changes as relatively modest.

Andrew already owned his console before that morning. So unless there was some very unusual pre-release/import situation, his PSP was from the original PSP-1000 generation and that machine absolutely had wireless internet capability.

Sony's browser supplier 'ACCESS' announced in September 2005 that its NetFront browser had been incorporated into PSP system software version 2.00. European PSPs launched with that software. The PSP had built-in 802.11b Wi-Fi and could connect through wireless access points to browse normal websites. That is quite different from some of the later PSP communication features people sometimes mention.

It was still a basic browser. What worked would have depended on the particular website, its security requirements and the firmware installed. The fact that some browser-based communication services worked on the PSP doesn't mean every website or messaging service would have - they wouldn't have.

Sony's own August 2005 announcement also explicitly advertised access to internet-based email accounts through the browser. It said the firmware could be downloaded to a PC and transferred to the PSP by USB, too. So even having the browser installed wouldn't by itself establish that the PSP had ever connected to Sony's servers.

Sony announced Go!Messenger in August 2007, but explicitly said it was due for release in January 2008. Likewise, Skype support wasn't announced until January 2008. So Andrew couldn't have been using integrated PSP Skype or Go!Messenger in September 2007.

But he could technically use the ordinary web browser. We don't know if Andrew's family was aware of this functionality. I don't think I'm overstepping when I say that a lot of parents aren't fully aware of what their kids' devices are capable of, especially with new technology (and I think with the technological advancements of today we sometimes forget that this very much was completely new at the time!)

There are some useful figures from the period that really emphasise that fact. Ofcom's evidence to Parliament which drew on research from 2007 reported that 61% of parents of 12-17-year-olds thought their children were more skilled at using the internet than they were, while around one in five parents didn't know whether their child had a social network profile. It also found that parents tended to underestimate some of the things their children did online, particularly gaming, watching videos and using social networking sites. Among 12-15-year-olds average weekly internet use had risen from 7.1 hours in 2005 to 13.8 in 2007. The internet itself wasn't new, but the range of ways teenagers could access it and communicate through it was changing quickly. None of that tells us what Andrew's parents knew about his PSP, but it does make me wary of assuming they would necessarily have known about every feature of it.

To be clear: websites, forums and browser-based email services worked with the relatively basic NetFront browser on the PSP. It had Wi-Fi capability. If the family had Wi-Fi but believed Andrew was not connected to it, passwords were written on the back or routers or often visible on other family devices which were connected (for example, Charlotte's laptop) so it was not difficult to work out. Equally, even if there was not Wi-Fi at home or the PSP was not connected to it, it still had the capability to connect to publicly available Wi-Fi networks.

I haven't found anything establishing how the family's home Wi-Fi, if they had it, was actually configured or whether a password would have been accessible to Andrew in that way. The only inference I can draw is that Charlotte had a laptop and that, from Kevin's accounts, it seems it may have had internet connectivity.

One thing I hadn't appreciated until I started looking at the old Wi-Fi services is that commercial hotspot operators were already building services specifically for PSP owners. On 3 January 2007, Pocket Gamer reported that The Cloud had partnered with Channel 4 Radio to offer PSP users access to 4Radio podcasts through its roughly 7,500 UK hotspots. A user opening the PSP's ordinary internet browser within a participating hotspot would be directed to a landing page linking to a PSP-optimised version of the service. That's a contemporary example of a UK Wi-Fi provider expecting people to use the standard PSP browser on its network, months before Andrew disappeared. The complimentary access was only to the radio content during a two-month trial, not unrestricted internet browsing and Engadget's report from 5 January 2007 explicitly says that visiting other websites still required payment. But it does show that some public Wi-Fi hotspots could accommodate the PSP - we do not know which ones Andrew had access to.

There is actually a Pocket Gamer guide from 17 August 2006 explaining how to use MSN Messenger on an ordinary PSP. It walks through opening the browser, visiting the mobile version of E-Messenger, entering an existing MSN email address and password, and selecting a contact to chat with. No modified console or special Sony messaging software was needed. TechCrunch was also reporting in May 2007 that eBuddy supported browser-based access to MSN, Yahoo and other messaging networks, including on the PSP. Its basic service didn't even require a separate eBuddy registration.

That challenges the idea that Andrew couldn't have used instant messaging because Go!Messenger and Skype weren't available yet. An existing account could be used through a third-party webpage. Whether it worked reliably on his particular firmware, and whether he ever tried it, are separate questions. Sony wouldn't ordinarily have recorded the conversation simply because the PSP browser carried it. Any traces could instead have been on the Memory Stick or with the messaging providers.

And this is where I think the wording of the Sony check becomes really important. VICE's 2018 interview says simply that Sony confirmed Andrew "didn't have an online account on his PSP". But PlayStation Network had only launched in the UK in March 2007, initially through the PS3, and the PC-based PlayStation Store for PSP owners didn't arrive until November 2007, two months after Andrew disappeared. So the absence of an account isn't particularly surprising and certainly doesn't establish that he never used the PSP's ordinary internet browser to visit other websites, log into accounts on forums, email services or other online platforms. Direct access to the PlayStation Store from a PSP itself wasn't introduced until October 2008.

An even stronger version was already being reported by May 2018, before the VICE interview. In a Reddit post from that month somebody said they'd emailed Kevin about the PSP and been told that police had spent a considerable amount of time corresponding with Sony. According to that poster, Sony found no account associated with Andrew's PSP serial number and said this meant he couldn't have been communicating with anybody on it. I can't verify that private exchange, or establish whether the last part was Sony's wording, Kevin's interpretation or the poster's. Other accounts say Sony established the PSP had never connected to the internet at all. I haven't found the original police request or Sony's response, so I can't establish how any of those stronger claims were reached.

However Sony's own description of DNAS (the Dynamic Network Authentication System built into PSP) describes it as an authentication system which could retrieve hardware and software information for things such as authentication, copy protection, account blocking and game management. But crucially I haven't found anything in Sony's documentation saying DNAS maintained a complete central log of every ordinary website visited through NetFront. So we don't actually know whether Sony held any records of ordinary PSP browser activity, whether it had the technical ability to establish if Andrew had used the browser, or whether its enquiries extended beyond checking for a registered PlayStation account.

The original British PSP-1003 instruction manual also describes up to ten wireless network connections being saved on the console itself. It separately identifies the device's wireless MAC address, which some access points required for connection. That isn't the same identifier as the PSP serial number mentioned in the 2018 Reddit account. The saved settings could have shown which networks had been configured if the device had been recovered, although not necessarily whether it had successfully connected to them. I haven't found anything establishing that Sony could retrieve those settings remotely or use a serial number to reconstruct every ordinary Wi-Fi connection.

That doesn't mean Sony's actual check was useless. It means I want to know what Sony was asked and exactly what it checked before "no Sony or PSP account" turned into "the PSP had never been online or accessed any accounts, including those for third-party websites or unaffiliated chat functions". Those aren't interchangeable statements. The distinction becomes more apparent when you look at the device itself.

A 2009 digital-forensics paper on the PSP found that browser evidence could be stored locally on the Memory Stick. The researchers identified files containing manually typed web addresses and pages which had actually been visited, as well as bookmarks and RSS information.

But there was an awkward wrinkle: some browser-history files were only written properly when the browser closed normally. Turning the PSP off, removing the Memory Stick or leaving the browser without closing it could mean browsing activity never made it into the saved history. They also showed that some deleted material could remain recoverable depending on what had happened to the card afterwards.

That study wasn't carried out on Andrew's PSP, it was published in 2009 and its practical testing used a Slim & Lite model. But it shows the sort of evidence the PSP browser generated locally on the device itself. The paper also examines a separate internet-search feature introduced with firmware in June 2008, which obviously wasn't available when Andrew disappeared, but it's the findings about ordinary browser-history files that are relevant here.

Sony's own browser documentation says that visited-page history was saved on Memory Stick media or, depending on the model, system storage. There's also a November 2009 account by a British forensic examiner describing a case in which a web server recorded a visit from a PSP browser. After examining a physical original-series PSP-1001 the examiner found bookmarks and visited-page history on its Memory Stick. The web server's browser-identification string didn't identify a unique PSP serial number. That examination involved later firmware than Andrew's, but it's a practical example of the difference between records held by an external website, local browser evidence and Sony's own account records.

Andrew's PSP disappeared with him and has never been recovered. I haven't found a reliable account establishing whether a Memory Stick was in it, or whether he owned other cards which were left at home. If the browser data were on a card taken with the console, that potentially useful source was never available for forensic examination. And even if it had been recovered an empty or incomplete browser history wouldn't necessarily mean he hadn't used it. So unless Sony had some other way of establishing his browser activity, which I haven't seen evidence of, we simply cannot rule out that he used the PSP to access websites, communicate with people or use online accounts.

That makes the original Sony response particularly important. It is my suspicion that it may have been overstated in the public accounts, but without seeing it we only have a limited picture.

Could he have used it on the train?

Technically, yes.

By October 2006 GNER had installed Wi-Fi across all 41 of its trains. First-class passengers got it free. Standard-class access started at £2.95 for thirty minutes. Andrew's PSP could connect to Wi-Fi, but that doesn't mean he did.

A standard-class user still had to get through the train's connection and payment process using a fairly clumsy handheld browser and on-screen text entry. We have no evidence Andrew bought access, opened the browser or communicated with anybody.

The passenger who remembered him using the PSP described him playing a game. That doesn't tell us whether the wireless connection was on.

I wouldn't build a theory around train Wi-Fi but once again it's another example of the difference between "technically impossible" and "there is no evidence he actually did it".

The Xbox question

The Xbox gets flattened in a similar way. Some modern retellings say Andrew's Xbox lacked online capability but the Xbox consoles absolutely had online capability in 2007. Again we don't actually know if Andrew's family was aware of this functionality or if it was used.

A specific example is Casefile's October 2023 episode about Andrew which says his Xbox "didn't have online capabilities". It also describes the PSP's text, voice and video chat features as though they were all available at the time and required an online account and email address. Those descriptions don't properly distinguish what the devices could actually do in September 2007. I don't know what source Casefile relied on for its description of Andrew's particular console.

Microsoft launched Xbox Live for the original Xbox in 2002. Users had gamertags and friends lists and could talk to other players using voice communication during compatible games. The Xbox 360 was a different system. It launched in Europe on 2 December 2005.

By May 2007 Microsoft had added Windows Live Messenger to Xbox 360, allowing text chat with Messenger contacts on Xbox, Windows PCs and Windows Mobile devices. Xbox Live already supported voice and other communications.

There was an age restriction. On 30 November 2007 Microsoft announced that an upcoming dashboard update would allow Xbox Live members under eighteen to use Messenger on the 360. So it existed in September, but wasn't then available to an account registered as belonging to a fourteen-year-old. That doesn't rule out use through an adult account. It also doesn't rule out an account with a fabricated DOB. And it doesn't affect the original Xbox's online voice communication.

What I haven't been able to establish is which Xbox Andrew actually owned and Kevin's phone story isn't precise enough to solve that. If the Xbox was bought when Andrew first declined a replacement phone before December 2005, it would have to have been the original model. If the purchase happened later while Andrew was still twelve a 360 is possible.

There is a clue pointing towards the original model in the reported 2020 exchange with Kevin. He was said to have described Andrew wanting to save for the "next X-Box". If he meant the next generation of console, that would fit with Andrew already having the original Xbox and hoping to get a 360. But it's not a conclusive identification, and the date the family discussed replacing a phone doesn't establish when any Xbox was actually purchased.

There was a practical difference between the models too. A Microsoft Knowledge Base article updated in April 2007 says an original Xbox Live subscription required a credit card for validation, even when using a starter kit. That would have been an additional hurdle for a fourteen-year-old, although not an insurmountable one if an adult helped. The Xbox 360 had different registration arrangements.

Online accounts say Andrew had no online account associated with the Xbox, but contemporary family material only says he wasn't allowed to play games online. That of course may not be the whole story. It is not uncommon for teenagers do things they aren't allowed to. Equally there is the possibility of an account associated with an email address or username which was unknown to the family.

I'd like to know the model, whether police actually examined the physical console, whether there was an Ethernet connection, what user profiles existed and whether Microsoft was asked to search an account or gamertag.

Microsoft's own March 2008 criminal-compliance handbook says Xbox Live registration and IP connection histories were then retained for the lifetime of a gamertag account. It also describes searches using details such as a gamertag, associated email address or, where the console had been registered online, its serial number or console ID. That's later documentation so I can't definitively say the policy was identical in September 2007. But it means an identifiable Xbox Live account could potentially have left more than a simple registration entry. Equally if Andrew's Xbox really had never been connected or registered, there might have been no relevant central record to retrieve. A negative Xbox Live search would also tell us nothing about a separate Messenger or webmail account.

What websites were British teenagers actually using?

I also think it's worth looking at the internet of 2007. A BBC-commissioned report published in December 2007 using found 50% of British internet users aged 12-17 used Bebo, 27% used MySpace and 12% used Facebook.

Ofcom's from October to December 2007 found that with boys aged 12-15 who used the internet at home 52% said they'd never created a social-networking profile, 30% had created one and 18% had created two or more. Among the boys who had created a profile 68% used Bebo, 33% MySpace, 20% Piczo and 20% Facebook. We can't assume Andrew must have been on one (plenty of boys his age didn't) but if we're discussing what online accounts might have existed, Bebo probably deserves more attention than Facebook.

Bebo was used for profiles, messages and keeping in touch with friends. Piczo was particularly popular among younger teenagers and let people make their own webpages, with photos, guestbooks and other content. TechCrunch reported in January 2007 that Britain was Piczo's largest market and its users generally needed someone's actual page address to find them. You couldn't necessarily find an account by searching somebody's name. In fact, an investigator searching a known email address or a full name wouldn't necessarily find every webpage someone had created on any of these services. If they didn't know the email address or name used at the point of registration, it would be even harder.

MySpace is also interesting given Andrew's musical interests. In July 2007 the Guardian reported that eight of the ten most popular UK MySpace profiles were associated with bands or artists including Bullet for My Valentine.

There were other sorts of communities as well. Windows Live Spaces and MSN Groups were around alongside Messenger and Hotmail. Yahoo had Messenger, Groups, email and personal webpages, with different records held for each. Last.fm connected people around music. RuneScape had registered players and social features. Habbo Hotel and Club Penguin offered other kinds of social interaction, although their desktop browser requirements were not the same as browsing a simple webpage on a PSP. YouTube was hugely popular, but watching a public video was another activity that didn't necessarily require logging in, and the PSP's browser couldn't be assumed to play its Flash video content.

These figures tell us where accounts could have existed, not whether Andrew had any. And that doesn't mean police should have approached every popular website without a particular lead, but how thoroughly was each of these avenues considered?

The online route with the clearest connection to Andrew's real life isn't gaming

My recent Lancaster/NAGTY research changes this part of the discussion as well. We know that Andrew participated in the 2006 Lancaster residential program.

NAGTY had a national discussion forum and subject-based online study groups. Those forums were moderated, but gave an avenue for people to stay in contact. Notably, the age range of those allowed to participate is shown as 11-19 on many archived web pages.

Since my last post about Lancaster and NAGTY, I came across an April 2007 paper where a Warwick researcher describes a thread about heavy-metal music within NAGTY's eforums. Nineteen members contributed. They talked about the bands and different styles of metal they liked, whether their friends shared their tastes and what the music meant to them. The paper doesn't date the thread precisely, I can't tell whether it ran before or after Andrew attended Lancaster but it had taken place by March 2007.

A Telegraph report from 22 March 2007 says the bands discussed included Slipknot, System of a Down, Tool, DragonForce, In Flames and Forward Russia. South Yorkshire Police confirm that Andrew was wearing a Slipknot T-shirt on the day he disappeared. Slipknot was a popular band and this doesn't establish that Andrew read the discussion, let alone took part in it. But it's a rather specific overlap between one of his documented interests and something young people were discussing on NAGTY's own forums.

There's still no evidence that Andrew was ever a part of these forums, but I do wonder whether NAGTY's own account and forum records were ever available to investigators, and whether enquiries into Andrew's internet use included them.

We know many pupils continued to interact with one another online. The Warwick follow-up study of the 2005 summer schools found that 95.6% of responding pupils had kept in touch with at least one summer-school friend. An earlier NAGTY evaluation specifically records pupils using text messages, mobile phones, MSN Messenger and the NAGTY forum to maintain those friendships.

Lancaster had its own LUVLE system too. The surviving 2006 maths report says staff made good use of LUVLE and then refers to a pupil making comments about the course leader "after the SS", apparently meaning after the summer school had finished. That gives us at least one documented example of post-residential pupil activity in a Lancaster online environment.

The educational systems weren't necessarily all administered together either. A contemporary Open University account of NAGTY online study groups describes robotics and web-design groups delivered through FirstClass with a customised web interface. That doesn't place Andrew in those groups, but it does show that a central NAGTY membership or forum search wouldn't automatically cover every single participating institution's system as they were split up across multiple.

There was also a change of management at an awkward time for anyone trying to reconstruct old accounts. The Guardian reported on 28 August 2007 that Warwick's NAGTY contract was ending and CfBT was taking over. CfBT's later published programme timeline records a transition from May to August 2007 and the new Young, Gifted and Talented website launching in September. I haven't established which historical databases, usernames, posts or server logs moved between the organisations but that is exactly what I would want to establish before treating a negative search by one organisation as covering Lancaster, Warwick and every associated online community associated with it.

We still don't know Andrew's course, whether he had a LUVLE account or whether he used the NAGTY forum but these routes are attached to something Andrew actually participated in. That puts them in a different category from saying he might theoretically have joined some random internet forum. An old 2008 "biology group" message is also relevant here. A later Reddit user reports finding an August 2008 Facebook message saying: "i really hope you find andy soon, i know the biology group from NAGTY '06 is thinking about him". It's notable that web archived material shows that NAGTY also had a separate Biology Online Study Group hosted through Warwick.

Schome and IGGY are also relevant. Schome Park was a real restricted Teen Second Life environment used by selected NAGTY pupils in 2007. IGGY's website was live by early September 2007. Schome Park's virtual world used the Teen Second Life application. It also has an associated wiki and discussion forum.

For the old mobile phones the public evidence establishes that the family believed Andrew had lost two handsets and didn't want another one, although the date the last phone was lost is less certain than some accounts suggest. But without the original handset identifiers, SIM details or network enquiries, we can't say whether either device was ever shown to be permanently inactive. A clean negative enquiry against those two known phones would still say nothing about a different SIM, borrowed handset or a new device.

For the PSP, the reported Sony check is meaningful evidence against an identified Sony account or Sony-controlled online activity, depending on what was actually searched. But I don't think the public wording is strong enough to say that ordinary browser use was technically excluded.

The physical PSP, where browser history might have existed, has never been recovered.

For the Xbox, the result depends almost entirely on the model, connection and account-search scope. If it was genuinely offline and had no account, that closes a sensible route. But we don't yet have public knowledge of that examination.

For NAGTY and LUVLE, there is no Andrew-specific online record, but there is a meaningful real-life connection to the communities.

And none of these digital checks can exclude a friendship which moved between channels.

Someone met at Lancaster could have communicated through NAGTY, then MSN, then text messages, or simply met Andrew again in person. A conversation at school, on a bus, at Lancaster or anywhere else leaves no internet account to find.

I don't think the evidence currently supports saying Andrew definitely was communicating secretly online. There is still no positive digital trace showing that. But I also don't think "no internet use" is a very precise description of what has actually been established.


r/AndrewGosden • • 11d ago

The disappearance of Michael Martin

Thumbnail gmp.police.uk
13 Upvotes

Apologies if posts like this aren’t allowed but reading this recent appeal from GMP about a missing person who vanished with no further trace made me think of Andrew. I hope this family gets closure and thought id share the appeal here for visibility


r/AndrewGosden • • 10d ago

What do we think about corruption in this case

0 Upvotes

In the disappearance of Amy Fitzpatrick it’s stated she reported to the police that her step dad was abisvive and they didn’t do nothing
In nearly everyone of these cases the police always fumbles something.
What’s the chances these fumbles for example “we couldn’t find Andrew on the cctv for almost 2 weeks until the Doncaster police found him” what’s the chances they actually did see him.
Are we underestimating evil
Do we trust the police too much
Could Andrew have been kidnapped by a group of police officers.
Who would assumed a police officers murder Sarah everard
Then u do more research and find out loads of officers knew he was weirdo.
I think he didn’t kill himself and someone with immense power in any industry knows something this was also when Jeffery Epstein was on the prow
It’s also a stated fact that British pedophiles target white British children the most ik it’s a stupid stat but I just wanted to put it out ther e


r/AndrewGosden • • 11d ago

Andrew’s memory is fading from the public consciousness

60 Upvotes

What a damn shame. Everywhere I look online, every video, article, or documentary covering the case came out years ago, and any current coverage is either a reposting, or AI. It seems as if Andrew’s case is losing steam day-by-day now. Even here, seemingly the last bastion of active discussion, is slowing down too. Posts are more sparse than they used to be, and even then, most are just low-effort speculation or opinion pieces. Finding a resourced post is like a diamond in the rough.

I don’t want to be saying this, but it seems as if it’s going that way. I hope the police can soon release more information. If nothing else then to reignite awareness of Andrews case.


r/AndrewGosden • • 11d ago

Off the wall theory

0 Upvotes

Ive seen countless theories about Andrew, I’ve heard the story loads of times, I jsut can’t wrap my ahead around why he wasn’t found and what has happened to him. I know it is out there, but could it be possible that Andrew has blipped out of reality? That he has completely vanished like some kind of glitch? In my opinion he 100% planned on coming home…unless the Croydon sightings were fake which I’ve heeds nothing more about so thanks for getting my hopes up guys…what is something supernatural happened and he literally vanished


r/AndrewGosden • • 15d ago

The Xbox 360 Andrew never bought

Post image
55 Upvotes

(Still from a BBC documentary about missing people , broadcast on the 21st April 2008. The image shows Kevin sitting in the cellar where Andrew kept his Xbox)

I briefly mentioned this in a comment a few weeks ago, but I wanted to make a separate post because there’s something about Andrew and the Xbox 360 that I’ve been thinking about recently. I’ve never seen it discussed on this sub: Andrew was saving up for an Xbox 360, but by September 2007, he had enough money between his bank account and birthday money to buy one, even the most expensive version, yet he hadn’t.

We know Andrew had an original Xbox, and Kevin spoke about how he would use it every night. Gaming was clearly something he enjoyed. Andrew had owned a couple of mobile phones when he was younger, but he rarely used them and lost them. When his parents offered to replace them, he showed little interest in getting another phone and said he would prefer a new Xbox instead. Kevin recalled him asking, “Can I have an Xbox instead?”

Considering he already had an original Xbox, it makes sense that he would have been interested in the Xbox 360, which was a significant upgrade. Gaming was something he clearly enjoyed, whereas he seemed to have little interest in having another phone. However, we don’t know exactly how long he’d been saving for the 360 or whether he was still interested in getting one by September 2007. His priorities could have changed in the time between that conversation and his disappearance.

The timing is something else I’ve been thinking about. The Xbox 360 launched in the UK in December 2005, when Andrew was 12. Kevin’s recollections place the phone situation somewhere around the ages of 10–12, so it’s possible Andrew had the 360 in mind from around the time it launched and spent some of the following period saving towards one. If so, he could have had quite a long time to build up his savings before he disappeared. We don’t know exactly when the conversation about his phone took place, when he started saving, or how much of his bank balance had accumulated over time. We also can’t establish whether he was saving specifically for the 360 throughout that period.

By September 2007, the Xbox 360 had been available in the UK for almost two years, and the Elite model had launched the month before. There were three main versions available: the Core at £179.99, the Premium at £249.99 and the Elite at £299.99.

Andrew had around £214 in his bank account. He also had £100 in birthday money that he’d left in his bedroom. His birthday was in July, although we don’t know exactly when he received that money or how long he’d been building up his bank balance.

His bank balance alone was enough to buy the cheapest Xbox 360. With his birthday money included, he had £314 in total — enough to afford even the most expensive Elite model, with £14 left over.

£314 was a considerable amount of money for a 14-year-old to have available. Although we can’t know how much of it, if any, had been saved specifically for the Xbox 360, it’s interesting that he had enough to buy even the Elite model by September 2007.

This is the part I find interesting: by September, Andrew could afford the Xbox 360 he’d been saving for, even the most expensive model, yet he hadn’t bought one. There’s also no known account of him mentioning to his parents that he was planning to buy one, or of them saying he was still interested in getting one around that time. Why hadn’t he got one?

Perhaps he simply changed his mind. He might have lost interest, decided to keep saving his money, or planned to buy one later. Maybe he just hadn’t got around to it. We don’t know whether buying an Xbox was even something he still wanted by that point.

I’m not suggesting that Andrew not buying an Xbox means anything sinister, or that it tells us anything about why he went to London on 14 September. I don’t think the trip was necessarily connected to the Xbox at all. I just find it interesting that something he’d previously wanted enough to ask for instead of a replacement phone was within his reach by September, but he hadn’t bought one.

I’m curious whether anyone else has thought about this, or knows anything more about how long Andrew had been saving for the 360, or whether there’s any information about how his interest in getting one changed over time?

Thank you for reading!


r/AndrewGosden • • 16d ago

What happened?

25 Upvotes

im new to this case and im wondering what happened to that account from a few years ago going by the name “andyroo” claiming to be gay and ran away when he was 14. Did the police ever investigate it? or was it proven a different way?


r/AndrewGosden • • 18d ago Bravo

Andrew's 2006 summer school had an online side that's rarely discussed. Who could he have met, and how might they have stayed in touch?

132 Upvotes

The more I looked at Lancaster, the less useful the usual description of it became.

"Andrew went to a gifted-and-talented summer school in 2006, enjoyed it, came home unusually enthusiastic, perhaps met somebody there".

All of that is broadly true. But it leaves out most of what the programme actually was.

Kevin has directly confirmed that Andrew attended a NAGTY summer school at Lancaster University in 2006. Lancaster's contemporary report says more than a hundred pupils aged 11 to 16 spent two weeks there taking university courses in subjects ranging from music to maths. Another Lancaster notice published before the course gives the dates as 6 to 19 August 2006. The surviving example mathematics certificate gives the same dates.

Kevin later remembered Andrew coming home unusually animated and enthusiastic about the experience.

What I still can't establish is what Andrew actually studied. His ability in maths seems to have gradually turned into an assumption that Lancaster was a "maths camp" for him. NAGTY didn't work like that. Its archived summer-school information says pupils chose a single academic course.

Lancaster's own August 2006 report describes a forensic-science exercise being run through Biological Sciences, involving a staged crime scene and DNA work. There were clearly other options besides mathematics.

So Andrew's course is still an open question. And once you start looking at how the summer school actually worked, the course turns out to be only one part of the contact network anyway.

The 2020 FOI

A 2020 WhatDoTheyKnow request originally asked Lancaster for any information it held about NAGTY between June and September 2006. Lancaster did an initial search and responded saying that the search had produced "a considerable number of files and data" relating to the 2006 summer school. It asked the requester to be more specific about what they wanted. The requester then narrowed the request to the mathematics courses.

Lancaster's final response, FOI-4317, dated 17 August 2020, says the material was already outside the university's six-year retention period. The staff who ran the 2006 summer school were no longer at Lancaster and the Department for Continuing Education, which had organised it, no longer existed. It then says the attached documents were the only data Lancaster still held on the mathematics course.

Those five attachments were produced after the request had been narrowed to mathematics, but they aren't evidence that Lancaster searched its entire surviving 2006 archive and found only five documents. In fact the university had already said its broader initial search had returned a considerable amount of material.

We don't know what all of that was. Some may have been duplicate material, records which didn't answer the request, or information which couldn't be disclosed. I also wouldn't assume everything Lancaster could locate in 2020 still survives now.

One of the attachments itself also raises questions. The "Mathematics Outline and Selection Criteria" supplied in response to the 2006 request is actually headed 'Lancaster 2005'. The course title matches the 2006 example certificate, so it may have been reused.

And of course, there has never acually been any confirmation it was in fact the Mathematics course which Andrew was enrolled on to.

The people Andrew could have met weren't just his classmates

One of the documents returned in the FOI is the 2006 social timetable. This is probably the document that changed my picture of Lancaster the most. This was not two weeks of pupils going to their chosen subject and then returning to rooms with the same group.

Outside the academic programme there were sports, swimming, badminton, squash, trampoline, salsa, dance, martial arts, African drumming, playwriting, drama, open-mic nights, film-making, debating, talent shows and other residential-assistant-led activities. Internet access appears repeatedly in the chill-out programme.

There was a disco on the first Saturday, a talent show later in the second week, and a banquet and disco on the final Friday.

The Sunday program offered day trips including Sandcastle waterpark, Dalton-in-Furness Zoo and religious services.

So even if Andrew's academic course is eventually identified, that only gives us one set of people who met and interacted with him. There was also his residential corridor, whatever group he ate and moved around campus with, people he met in the social activities, excursion groups and general friendships formed over the fortnight.

The surviving maths report gives a sense of how much mixing could occur even within one course. Maths pupils were divided into small groups and the staff changed those groups around until they found combinations that worked. They used the PC labs regularly for research and report writing.

The report also tells us something about supervision. Each academic course team was supposed to contain an academic leader, a school teacher and one or more teaching assistants.

The residential side seems to have been separate.

There is also a fairly detailed Reddit account from somebody who says they attended the same Lancaster summer school in 2006. The poster says they were 13, studied art and did not know Andrew.

They remembered residential groups being mixed across academic subjects. In their case there were roughly eight to ten children on a corridor with one or two residential assistants, who they remembered as Lancaster students. The RAs shepherded them between meals, classes, activities and the accommodation, and free time was fairly structured.

I can't independently prove that poster attended, so I wouldn't use their memory to assign Andrew to a particular hall or corridor. But parts of it fit the official material very well. The 2006 timetable itself repeatedly refers to RA-led activities, and the whole social program is obviously structured around organised zones, events and trips.

The useful point is that "Andrew's Lancaster group" probably wasn't one group. His academic classmates and his residential friends could have been largely different people.

Keeping in touch afterwards was normal

I think this deserves much more attention. A University of Warwick follow-up study of the 2005 NAGTY summer schools looked at what happened after pupils went home.

Among the 590 pupils who answered the follow-up questionnaire, 99.7% said they had made at least one good friend and 95.6% said they had kept in contact with at least one summer-school friend.

They reported visits, reunions, text messaging, telephone calls and web-based messaging. There is even a parent in the report describing their child arranging to meet eight summer-school friends in London, despite living about 230 miles away.

That obviously isn't evidence about Andrew. It was a different year's cohort and these were questionnaire respondents rather than every child who attended.

But it tells us something about the camp which is directly relevant when people ask whether Andrew could still have known someone from Lancaster thirteen months later. Long-distance contact after NAGTY wasn't unusual.

An earlier NAGTY evaluation is even more specific about the technology being used. It records pupils staying in touch through texts, mobile phones, MSN Messenger and the NAGTY internet forum, as well as meeting up again around the country. One parent reported that their child's MSN list eventually contained 50 NAGTY contacts.

Again, this is not specific to Andrew but the idea that a thirteen-year-old could leave one of these summer schools with contacts scattered around the country and continue talking to them online is historically completely ordinary.

That changes how I'd frame the Lancaster question. The problem isn't finding a hypothetical way Andrew could have remained in contact. The problem is finding any Andrew-specific evidence that he actually did, who with and how.

LUVLE was a post-course communication route, at least for maths

Lancaster had another online system of its own called LUVLE, the Lancaster University Virtual Learning Environment. It had existed for years before Andrew's summer school. Lancaster staff material from December 2005 advertises training specifically on "Groupwork and LUVLE" and "Multimedia and LUVLE". Later university material says the system had been developing since 1996 using Lotus Notes and Domino.

The 2006 maths report also supports this and says the maths staff made good use of the LUVLE site. In the same passage it also records "some name calling about the Course leader after the SS by one of the pupils". "After the SS" appears to mean after the summer school.

I wouldn't stretch that sentence further than it goes. The report doesn't tell us what LUVLE feature was used, who could see the comment, whether pupils could privately message each other or how long their accounts survived. But it does appear to establish that at least one pupil was interacting with the maths course's LUVLE environment after leaving Lancaster. So LUVLE wasn't necessarily something summer-school pupils could only use while sitting in a university PC lab.

If the old system records ever survived, potentially relevant categories would include account creation, course membership and whatever posts or comments were stored in the relevant course area. There may once also have been technical access records, although I haven't found a historical retention schedule showing what Lancaster logged or how long it kept it.

But the questions are still the same. We don't know that Andrew took maths. We don't know that his course used LUVLE. And I haven't found an account, username, post, interview or anything else showing Andrew personally used it.

There was, however, another online environment which we know was aimed at NAGTY members generally.

NAGTY itself had an online community

An archived NAGTY page from September 2006 describes national discussion forums for registered members. Its online-learning directory lists subject-based study groups in areas including biology, chemistry, ethics and philosophy, creative writing and reading.

This was separate from Lancaster's LUVLE.

The surviving material describes the forums as moderated message boards. Members had usernames and passwords, posts were moderated, and there were rules restricting personal information and attempts to arrange outside contact.

I wouldn't describe this as an unmoderated chatroom where an unknown adult could simply privately approach children without oversight but it was an online place where NAGTY members from around the country interacted.

A 2006 Warwick evaluation gives a particularly direct example. One pupil said the reason they used the NAGTY student forum was "through summer school really to get in contact with people I've met".

The 2008 "biology group" message

In the 2024 Reddit thread from the person claiming to have attended Lancaster in 2006, another user says they searched the Missing Andrew Gosden Facebook page for "NAGTY" and found an old post from August 2008.

They report the wording as: "i really hope you find andy soon, i know the biology group from NAGTY '06 is thinking about him". The thread also mentions a photograph captioned "bio group".

Interestingly, NAGTY also had a separate Biology Online Study Group hosted through Warwick.

What happened to NAGTY in 2007?

The timing gets a bit messy because Andrew disappeared during the handover from the old NAGTY scheme to its replacement.

Warwick's government contract was ending in summer 2007 and CfBT Education Trust had won the contract to run the new Young, Gifted and Talented programme. Evidence CfBT later gave to Parliament sets out the transition fairly precisely.

CfBT received the contract in March 2007 and began managing the programme in April. The formal transition from NAGTY ran between May and August. There was a soft launch in August and the new Young, Gifted and Talented website launched in September.

Welcome letters to former NAGTY members were sent in October, after Andrew disappeared.

The online catalogue of extracurricular opportunities followed in November. CfBT later said that another 107,000 former NAGTY members had been transferred into its Learner Academy. That tells us there was a transfer of former membership records at some level.

The replacement system eventually had fifteen online study groups, ten moderated discussion forums and fifteen "faculty cafés", but those figures describe the programme over its later operation. I wouldn't assume all of that infrastructure was available to Andrew in the first half of September 2007.

Schome and IGGY

Schome Park is also worth mentioning. A Guardian report from April 2007 describes NAGTY pupils aged 13 to 17 using an enclosed educational area in Teen Second Life named Schome Park. Open University research on the project gives the initial pilot group as 149 pupils.

This wasn't an online environment automatically available to every NAGTY member. Pupils had been selected for the project. Andrew was a NAGTY member and was in the right age range but that is currently the extent of the connection.

We don't have any Schome participant list, a username, an avatar or any other indication he took part whilst Schome is relevant, it remains theoretical access.

IGGY is slightly different. The Guardian reported Warwick's plans for the International Gateway for Gifted Youth (IGGY) in August 2007. At that point Warwick was talking about selecting around 1,000 young people for a pilot beginning in 2008. Then on 11 September 2007, three days before Andrew disappeared, the Guardian reported that the IGGY website had gone live the previous week.

I haven't found is any evidence Andrew had joined it, been invited into a pilot, received login details or had access to member-to-member communication through it. But that doesn't necessarily mean that he didn't.

What is actually Andrew-specific?

The firm part of this remains surprisingly small. Andrew attended Lancaster from 6 to 19 August 2006 and apparently enjoyed it enormously. That's established.

We don't know what academic course he was enrolled on. We don't know his residential corridor.

We don't know his friends. We don't know the specific social activities and trips he attended.

There was scheduled internet access during the summer school. We don't know whether he used it.

LUVLE was being used by the maths course and there appears to have been pupil activity after the residential. We don't know whether he was even in that course.

The national NAGTY forum and online study groups existed during the period he was a member. Schome and IGGY both existed in some form. We don't know if he used them.

That is why I think the most valuable Lancaster evidence would actually be very mundane records. His course allocation would immediately identify a much smaller academic group, his residential allocation would identify a second, probably different, group.

If the 2024 attendee's recollection of eight to ten children sharing a corridor with RAs is broadly right, that could turn a vague pool of more than a hundred pupils into a fairly small set of people who actually lived alongside Andrew for two weeks. And then the question becomes whether any of those relationships continued.

If there were texts, calls, MSN contact, LUVLE activity, NAGTY forum interaction or later meetings with a Lancaster friend, a prearranged meeting in London becomes more plausible as an explanation for the journey. It still wouldn't mean that person caused Andrew's disappearance but someone could be relevant to why he went to London and completely unrelated to what happened afterwards.

NOTE: I'm aware of the widely repeated claim that Andrew didn't use the internet on his devices and I haven't overlooked it. However based on my own research and professional experience working with communications and digital data, I think there's reason to examine just how firmly that conclusion was established. I'll be looking at this in more detail in a separate upcoming post, particularly the distinction between what was actually ruled out, how statements have been interpreted, technical capabilities and what has simply come to be accepted as fact.


r/AndrewGosden • • 19d ago

Have Anthony Marsh and Lee Davis ever been discussed on this sub?

7 Upvotes

r/AndrewGosden • • 20d ago

Some concerning/interesting comments (please read below)

Post image
189 Upvotes

For the last few days I have been trawling through thousands of comments left under various Youtube videos and documentaries that cover Andrews disappearance. Out of those thousands, I have collected a list of comments that I believe may be of some interest to fellow users of this sub. I am unable to include them all here, so have included a Google drive link below. Some of these allege sightings of Andrew, and others are more speculative, but I considered them worthwhile inclusions.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1j0MaJ-sx-Qw2S1GI4A4_frj0HKP988Ot?usp=sharing


r/AndrewGosden • • 19d ago

Andrews case has been overcomplicated and the reason why

27 Upvotes

Ive been aware of Andrews case for many years. I remember seeing his picture on my Iceland milk carton in the family fridge well over a decade ago.

I have also been fascinated with missing person cases for a long time and have done deep dives into them, inadvertently learning missing person handling.

Something that stands out to me about Andrews case is that in terms of handling, seemingly everything that could have went wrong did.

The famous "48 hour rule" was butchered, and the lack of CCTV obtained and witness statements not followed up on promptly is a horrendous mix. Stuff of nightmares.

As a result of the disheartening lack of clarity, we are forced to focus on the only thing we have access too, his immediate movements shortly before his trail was lost, leading to mere speculation about intentions etc

I think this is a "simple" foul play case.

Here me out. I say this in the sense that the only fact we have access too, which is concretely objective, is that Andrews existence has been a complete silence since 2007. I feel other theories such as suicide fill in alot of gaps.

Call me closed minded or even illogical, but that is a fact too conclusion for me.

I believe with the CCTV and better handling, or maybe with some luck, this would have been a straight forward case to us, where we would focus only on the evidence and the outcome rather than theories of what happened before, that would be something for the family mainly to think about and come too terms with.

I actually believe that the case will be solved, but it may take a while. I mentioned foul play. We all die, including those that take lives. I believe if the purp has access to remains, that would be discovered after they pass and their property is searched, and the remains could be discovered in nature and identified.

Of course I could be wrong, I don`t care. I just hope this damn case gets solved...