So to begin this... Ramble I want to share with you lot a pervasive worry I, and possibly some others, had as a teenager in middle school; that I was dumber than my bullies. This was something that hurt me for a very long time and it's still something I struggle with. As a rather inathletic, asocial lunk of a lad I felt I had not a single actual skill worth note except my "scholarly ability" as it were. I got good grades in math, English, Dutch, geography, sociology, biology, and I always enjoyed it when our art teacher or woodworking teacher or (in the later years) cooking teacher complimented me on my ability to apply myself. If they gave me some wood or some scrap paper I could have fun and make something just idiosyncratic enough that they would be impressed enough. Of course I never quite got the hang of perspective or electrical wiring, so again, I felt I had no true skill except the more theoretical subjects of ours. This I felt while my fellow students were athletic, likeable, skilled, more generally better in ways I was sure I could never achieve myself. So when I noticed other students were in any way closing in, for it did feel like an exhausting foot race, I panicked. 2020 was the best year of my young life because of this, since for once I hadn't anyone to fear at all. It was me and the books I thought I understood. I did weeks work of assignments in days and loved every moment of it.
And now I'm an adult, and it hardly matters if I got a 10 in math in middle school because I either don't use it or the maths involved are still beyond me. All this fear for... Nothing at all, and it's still there because there are still peers around me everywhere who exceed me while I can't see anything about me that I'm good at. But there's no grades, no teachers to impress, there's nothing but that fear.
This was the kind of thinking that haunted me throughout this novel because Heldenarr Fall, the Godeater's Son and Red King and supreme warlord of Bodshe, is also a man afraid. A man who thinks he had it all and hated it until the moment he met someone better than him in one way. And from there he wants to keep it, clutch it to the maw in his chest, because otherwise what does he even have? But, unlike yours truly, he finds his answer and can live with it. Can die with it. And then live with it again.
Blood of the Godeater is not just on par with Godeater's Son. It's not just good. It's a novel that stands heads and shoulders over anything else I've read of warhammer (and anything else) for years. It's not just a novel, you can treat it as a philosophical treatise on meaning itself. On rulership and pain and family and trauma and more. I will not pretend to say this book is on par with true works of philosophy, I'm not here to do that. But several times in this book I had to sit back and think, wrack my dry little brain on a single paragraph I just read. Maybe a page or a chapter if I was lucky. The mad ramblings of Talman that seemed almost sane, the mental and physical merging in one as Held duels a bloodthirster to a standstill, Helds on crumbling mind. It is a novel deliberately written to cram as much into as few pages as possible and which wants to confuse you.
The timeline is magically altered, even going beyond that this is a story told in first person by Held himself. Held has to ruminate on ideas even as he tells us. Some things you're just not meant to understand even.
Thats not even mentioning the sheer bulk of world building that's done and then done away with at the end. Houses and sub cultures, lords and wastrels, geography. All of it is scoured at the end of the story but none of it feels meaningless. By the third act you even get a grip on who's who and who's meant to be where, helped by the ever narrowing scope admittedly, but it takes its time to elaborate where needed. As well because it is a sequel if you've read Godeater's Son before a lot of this will already be expounded on there.
Speaking of this book is almost beat for beat an inversion of the previous novel, but ends very similarly with Held being stabbed through the heart by a peer he sees himself in. Valique, a character with all of one and a half chapters of pagetime, is as deep as Stormsworn ever was and the sheer grief that's put into his every word means that like Held you can't help but feel for the guy. He and Hammerhal and Lumnos and Hag Narr and every other city that sent even a single steelhelm have every damned right to hate Held for everything he represents and Held does too so you never feel like it's unjust. Even with the horrible crimes the Se Royes and Candip committed the book never pretends that Carnd-Ep was better or even it's equal. This is not a book about how there are no true better people or how both revolutionary and revolutionised are equally horrid. No, the chaos kingdom of Carnd-Ep is vile and evil and wrong because Held was willing to sacrifice everything and anything to make it.
And there we come to the books greatest lesson, that Held was the one making these calls every agonising step of the way. His excuses that as a king he has to be tough, that he must placate Khorne to maintain power, that he's making a better world and that should be enough all of that falls away by the end. Because Held is alive and kicking and so he has the power, in his own calloused hands, to make things better. They're the surest blades, he never needed anything else. But that doesn't mean he never needed anyone else of course. That's the rump of it all really, Held could do nothing alone. Not even Talman, the Uberkhornate, could do anything alone. Kadarrar did not want to be alone anymore. Valique could never raise Carnd-Ep alone. All these great heroes of myth stand on the shoulders of millions of slaves, citizens, warriors, and family. Without Held's subjects Talman would be a lone madman awaiting the end of the world. Without his brother Valique would have starved on the streets of Hammerhal. Without Kadarrar Held would've likely killed his adopted children in frustration and apathy. And Velekkhah, wherever she goes, will need her mother as much as she always did. As she always needed her father, in so many ways Held never thought he could want to be needed.
Now, on the topic of the welps I was excited to get this book quickly because of the prospect of khornate family time. Then I heard it involved drama and angst and I was even more hooked. I am a squeaker, I like books where I kick up my legs and go "ohh he said it it's so cute!" or "Oh nooo, he's so saaad" that's my nature and that will never change and this book provides. I wanted Kadarrar the mamá bear, I got it. I wanted a distant love where both sides just don't know what to do but they know they want it, and I got it. I wanted Plako and Vel to stab Held for every insult he threw their way and by the muses I got it. When Plako finally turned on held I just... Oh that was satisfying.
I wanted Held to kill Talman, and he did in a moment of such climatic relief after a books worth of Talmans rambling and even Talman thought it was time. This book makes you want and want and want and it gives but it does not do it easily. By the end of the book you don't want to see Carnd-Ep saved, and it isn't. Why don't you want it? Let me illustrate.
Over the course of twenty years at least half a million slaves were used to dig a tunnel from Carnd-Ep proper to Bharat at the bottom of the realm (by the way sorry Sage it seems Bharat is literally at the bottom of the realm rather than in a flame world). This took countless lives to create a trade route to a butchery where no doubt many more were slaughtered to a man to feed the dark city. Yknow what the sigmarites did in the course of a few months? They built drills. And I know Held couldn't understand the tech but like... He has friends with the Kharadron, he could've had the same thing done but he didn't care. He had a household of slave orphans from the people he killed whomst he didn't give a fuck about. He let freed slaves, which hey them being freed is a bit of a good thing, live in the cramped and ashen tunnel of the Great way in abject poverty. He is a madman and he is a tyrant... And even he knew it. So he got rid of it all. He made the world better by finally accepting that the horrors he wrought or which were wrought in his name were not worth it. The sunk cost Fallacy fell to the perimeter of the realm alongside Mount Ashrashra. And it was good...
Now before I get to why this book made me love Khorne yet more and to bring up what's relevant about my entry remarks Im gonna say this book was so well timed. With the Fyreslayers being put away with the Khazalites this is the last piece of true Fyreslayer depiction that we got before that change. And yknow what, they're not gone but this is a damn good eulogy. In two chapters, barely really, we get a great picture of a warrior culture that's so starkly rich and vibrant compared to Khorne it's insane. They sing in battle, they laugh, they boast, they goof, they are dedicated, they're a little racist, and they are capable. Forty fyreslayers were worth hundreds of blood reavers. And don't get me wrong I don't want to come across like I want my guys to beat up other guys, especially since I do really like the Bloodbound. No. But when you read abort the sheer impact a Fyreslayer lodge can have and have read their stories as I have you can sometimes feel like they're a little overhyped? Yknow they're cool and capable but they're among such demigods that it can sort of fall away. And then a book like this makes you jump up and cheer when you read Haroomf because it means flames are gonna roll. Them singing in battle is also just such a fun detail, it reminds me of the sisters of battle. Also also, them being racist to the local sand duardin is neat. Of course they'd be, they're a prideful lot of warrior monks dealing with merchants known for double crossing you, of course they'd call them "sand rats". It's not right but it gives a realistic edge where a lot of the time species in warhammer can seem sort of... Monophilic. Like how many times in 40k do you have imperials actually being hateful to another imperial not cause they're a mutant but because their culture is just weird to them? Not many I've read, honestly. I wanna see more of this. Where are my Ionracheneth calling Nautilar filthy travellers while being called effete back? Get on it, GW. Anyway this was awesome.
Now onto why I hate Talman and have to respect him. Between this book and the recent battletome for 4e all I can think is that... Yeah. Good hell, I see why people turn to Khorne now. Yet I don't. Yet I do. It's like looking through a red stained mirror with a red ballon on the other side. You see the shadow of the balloon, where the light barely casts over it. But is it a red balloon? You can't know. You barely know it's there. But it taunts you. That's khornate religion right there. You can see the imprint of values and reasons why someone would fall. You can see an outline of an ideal but you just can't make it out. The battletome spells it out: it's ultimate selfish freedom, but this and Talman go beyond that. What is the value of a life, you wonder, what is the value of a death? One zealout hero says it's all the things youve done and all the things you haven't but then why the slaughter? Talman says Khorne loves him but that he won't pity him, so why praise him? Talman says it's all about doing what you want to do but where does the cruelty come in? Is the value of life what Held concludes it is, that living let's you fix your mistakes and be in control but then where does the slaughter come in?!
I am not smart enough for this book. And that's a painful thing to think about honestly. Because I want to be, I want to understand and grasp at that balloon but it's just too far for me. I'm thinking and wracking my brain about it and I know the answer is there somewhere in the silence but I can't hear it. I just can't. And any book, especially a warhammer book, that makes you think all these things deserves your time. This was like how I felt when I read Starseers Ruin and stewed in the depression it left me with but there there was an answer I could come up with. About trying to save the world one day, one second sooner even if it means damning an innocent soul. About catharsis and absolution. Here I can't, because it doesn't give you an answer like Ruin did. It wants you to sit down and listen to the silence, even Talman couldn't answer his own questions and wanted to know the answer even if someone he hated told him.
I don't know the meaning of a life. A bloodtsained, scar covered monster has outwitted me. And I wouldn't want it any other way.
10/10, it has fun fantasy names for stuff like Lavamander, read it and weep.