r/AriAster • u/Legitimate_Crew6735 • 1d ago
Beau is Afraid...who gets it....[Spoiler]...Jewish mommy guilt Spoiler
Generally, other people have told me the movie was too long and had too much sustained intensity for them to enjoy it. The reviews were mixed as well.
When I've read people's critiques of Beau Is Afraid they mention that they think that the film, and Aster's work in general, isn't 'about' anything. It just brings up themes....
I just don't understand what that means to be honest. Don't all movies just bring up themes, and the best of them don't reveal an obvious point?
I saw the movie with my two siblings and we found ourselves laughing and enjoying it quite a bit. I felt a bit deranged to be laughing to be honest, while other movie goers seemed to be counting down the minutes to leave. It was perplexing to have such a different reaction to the material from them.
[SPOILER]
almost died of laughter watching the first bit with the homeless people infiltrating Beau's apartment. While Beau just watches on like a helpless sock puppet. But the absolute funniest part for me was the fact that his mother was PRETENDING to be dead! The entire fucking time! He goes on this odyssey and she was just testing him the whole time !!! And it's Patti LuPone...the queen of all jewish neurotic mothers.
Like he executed this surreal odyssey about Jewish Mommy guilt while using comedy in a way I've never seen before. Like an elevated Tim and Eric sketch.
I'm jewish and so are my siblings. I asked my friends what they thought about the film. Overwhelmingly, the people who really liked the film were also Jewish.
Of course people with different backgrounds experience this guilt to certain degree. So I don't mean to invalidate them lmao. But there's just something so specifically jewish about this film. Like the first scene he's talking to a therapist LOL....
I guess I'm just rambling ... but yeah I think that it's a masterpiece. I think part of the public's ambivalence towards the movie is due to different cultural perspectives but also a reaction to the general strangeness of the movie.