It’s no secret that the kpop industry, despite being antiblack, takes so much from black music and culture without truly acknowledging the black foundation of their image.
However, looking back at summer 2024, when popstars like Tate McRae, Sabrina Carpenter, and Chappell Roan, all white women, were getting big, I couldn’t help but focus on the double standards of white vs Asian musicians taking from black music. You see, all these white women’s image were built on black music and image. Tate McRae’s production and sound are built from black producers like Timbaland, Danja, The Neptunes, and the Yin Yang Twins. Sabrina Carpenter’s breakout song Espresso has the Say So by Doja Cat’s fingerprints all over. Sabrina’s dance-pop disco sound is built from black musicians. Chappell Roan’s drag image and dance-pop disco is built on black queer culture.
Yet, when you look at their songwriting and producing credits, barely any black people appear on their songs.
So why does the kpop industry and many big white musicians, despite taking so much from black musicians and culture without truly acknowledging the black side of their image, the kpop industry gets punished for it, while the white musicians get to be held off easily
I know Tate, Sabrina, and Chappell have all had some sort of hate, but the hate isn’t because they’re using black culture and music despite not properly acknowledging them.
“But they [T,S,C] have performed with black people!” This isn’t a proper acknowledgment. Celebrity Interaction isn’t activism. By that logic, kpop groups with racism controversies, like BTS and Blackpink, performing with black artists would be considered anti racist activism. By truly acknowledging, I mean not slapping a black musician’s name on your song. I mean going into research and the contextualization of what you’re inspired by.
“But they [T,S,C] have more creative control!” Most of you guys, including me, aren’t the music industry, so we don’t know how much creative control musicians have.
(PS: This isn’t a Kpop exclusive problem. Artists like Denise Julia (Filipina) and Karlee Girl (Japanese-Korean, but not Kpop) have been accused of appropriating black culture without acknowledging the black people)
This isn’t me defending anyone’s antiblackness, but a question for the culture on how Asians taking from black culture without true acknowledgement get punished, while white musicians who do the same thing get let off.