r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

AskALiberal Biweekly General Chat

2 Upvotes

This Friday weekly thread is for general chat, whether you want to talk politics or not, anything goes. Also feel free to ask the mods questions below. As usual, please follow the rules.


r/AskALiberal • • 5d ago

Israel and Palestine Megathread Israel and Palestine Megathread

1 Upvotes

This thread is for a discussion of the ongoing situation in Israel and Palestine. All discussion of the subject is limited to this thread. Participation here requires that you be a regular member of the sub in good standing.


r/AskALiberal • • 1h ago

What if Trump passes Trumpcare?

13 Upvotes

Famously, before taking office - Abdul El-Sayed posted about Trump guaranteeing health care for all americans, but putting his name on it. That has actually gained some serious traction, it's looking like it's actually possible. Improbable, but possible.

Obviously I want free healthcare, I also don't want the name of an Epstein-affiliated rapist to be on my insurance card.Though it would be a nice change of pace to finally see that the sack of shit do something good.

Would you be in support of a trump branded free healthcare system? Would you want the name to be changed after he dies?


r/AskALiberal • • 2h ago

Do you think conservatives use an Islam ban intentionally as a dog that won’t catch the car for decades? If ever at all?

3 Upvotes

I feel like Republicans do this thing where they talk about the importance of a complete and total ban on Islam with essentially 0 plan of how to do it.

I feel like Texas is a great example; Abbott has been essentially spending what will be the last year of his decade plus reign handwringing about the need to end the practice of Islam but he has never given a plan on how. He talks about banning the Sharia but the institution of any religious law is already banned.

I wonder if this is the new “dog that has little chance of catching the car.”

They came within a single vote on birthright citizenship and even that is likely to be a multi decade project for them to remove, if they ever do so at all.

A state or federal ban on the practice of Islam would likely lose 8-1 or worse, and it being struck down by even this current court with at least 5 votes is a near guarantee.

My theory is that Republicans are essentially going to continue virtue signaling about the need to ban Islam for decades with no plan on how to do it so they can keep their base energized.

They’re also going to be very excited if France ends up banning Islam under Le Pen and virtue signal about how it needs to be done here, while also ignoring the fact we have a very difficult legal framework from France.

On top of that, when you combine the fact Muslim citizens have largely lived here with no issues, I think the idea that Muslims have been committing crimes disproportionately has lost. It’s literally going to be fear mongering about Muslims believe this or that.

The one thing to watch for would be a Muslim country travel ban enshrined into law so Democrat presidents can’t undo it. I do think if they passed it, a Democrat trifecta would not remove it, but no point in considering that until either party kills the filibuster anyways.

My overall point is it’s a very sturdy car for the dog not to catch for decades, if ever at all, compared to other things like abortion. And it will be used as such electorally.


r/AskALiberal • • 17h ago

Why is it only mamdani was able to realize how to get things from the president?

26 Upvotes

Trump just reposted Abdul El-Sayed’s proposal for universal healthcare, complete with a gold “Trumpcare” card and the promise of healthcare for every American from cradle to grave.

My question is: Why didn't Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi try this approach during Trump's first term? They knew how much Trump cared about branding, recognition, and getting credit for major accomplishments. Why not use that to push for universal healthcare and let him call it Trumpcare?

Was this a massive missed opportunity, or were they simply too focused on fighting Trump to recognize a potential opening?


r/AskALiberal • • 1h ago

In 2026 can a person be left wing but racist?

0 Upvotes

Obviously Charles Dickens for example had racist views. But that was a long time ago, with different standards.

Many leftists vote left, but when it comes to forming friendships there's an assumption that they won't have much in common with a minority person. If a non-White has interests that don't align with racial stereotypes, it's a surprise. For example, if they read different books, listen to different music or have different ways of engaging in life than their stereotype suggests. White is the default, and even amongst leftists, to be White means to be judged as an individual, with the Whiteness barely being considered in the overall judgement of the person.

Most women who state themselves as liberal or left wing also tend to consciously racist against men of color. This is seen in dating app statistics, which demonstrate that men of color have an extra bar to clear to cancel out the effects that being non-White has on how they're perceived.

It's similar to how studies show workplaces discriminate against non-White applicants at the pre-interview stage, but are more likely to view them as compatible if the non-White is able to signal competency in the interview (and cancel out assumptions like that they might not speak English, might not be culturally similar enough to fit in, might not be well-read or well-spoken) - so the recruiters are not completely racist, but they are racist enough that when judging superficially, non-Whites fare significantly worse. These recruiters may well be ok with a non-White neighbour and vote left, but on a personal level they still hold superficial biases (part of what makes up White privilege is freedom from needing to counteract those biases, although White folk deal with presumptions against them at times too).


r/AskALiberal • • 20h ago

Why did universal healthcare fail in Vermont?

19 Upvotes

Also why could Colorado and California not get it to work?


r/AskALiberal • • 11h ago

Where do you think the line between an involuntary moment of social awkwardness and actual transphobia?

0 Upvotes

Imagine a routine, close contact situation like going to get a haircut and randomly after sitting in the chair you realize the person cutting your hair is trans, and you feel a brief, caught off guard moment of awkwardness or discomfort around someone with masculine traits handling your hair.

Since people take in physical cues and expectations before they even have time to sort through them, is that initial, internal "jolt" of discomfort a form of implicit bias transphobia in itself? Is an instinctive split-second awkwardness due to gender expectations or physical proximity bigoted?

Where do you draw the line between a passive micro-reaction and actual transphobia in everyday social interactions?


r/AskALiberal • • 12h ago

Am I a conservative Democrat?

0 Upvotes

I've been trying to figure out where I fit within the Democratic Party and would appreciate some outside perspectives.

Economically, I'd describe myself as leaning toward left, with views rooted in New Deal and New Frontier liberalism. I support regulated capitalism, strong labor protections, universal healthcare, progressive taxation, public investment, raising minimum wage, and a robust social safety net. However, I'm also strongly pro-growth and pro-development. I believe economic growth, private investment, and entrepreneurship are essential to prosperity. I'm particularly supportive of building more housing, reducing unnecessary zoning and regulatory barriers, streamlining development, and making it easier to build the infrastructure and businesses communities need. I favor a government that facilitates growth rather than unnecessarily getting in its way, while maintaining reasonable safeguards and protections. I want the fiscal policy to be where the outcome and what is being seeked justifies its cost, but don't oppose deficits for good investments. Less unnecessary bureaucracy. Also significant gov investment and the opportunity to combat poverty.

I am pro-life (with exceptions and other qualifiers), support LGBTQ+ rights but have reservations about certain transgender-related policies, and generally favor a live-and-let-live approach. I'm also pro-Second Amendment and believe the right to keep and bear arms is important, though I support some gun regulations. I favor drug decriminalization alongside treatment and rehabilitation, as well as strong borders and strong qualifications for coming in, more accessible legal immigration. I am generally skeptical of huge cultural change and prefer more gradual cultural change. I am also very indifferent to identity politics and generally think it is a waste.

I value effective government over ideological purity. My biggest influences are JFK, FDR, Obama, Eisenhower, and John Bel Edwards.

I see some overlap with Conservadems and Blue Dogs, particularly on social issues and fiscal pragmatism, but I consider myself more economically liberal than many of them.

edit: Have all of you forgot about rule 5? Jesus.

Let me clarify my pro-life position. Abortion shouldn't just be outright illegal, but it should always be the last resort and there should be emphasis placed on that. We should have more education and birth control. Make our foster care and adoption system better so that if the mother were the carry the baby to term, there would be little risk or harm to the child. As well as expand benefits that help new mothers.

I am also more in favor of certain abortion restrictions, such as partial birth abortion bans, assuming they aren't dentrimental to life of mother. I do think women whos lives are in detriment by carrying a baby to terms should be able to get an abortion.

Abortion is still an option, but limit it and make sure the alternatives are well understood. And I would like taxpayer funds to go towards those who genuinely need it and can't afford it.

That's what I mean by pro-life, so quite distinct from the modern day GOP definition.

You guys need to grow up and learn to accept others opinions, not everyone is gonna agree with you on everything, try opening your mind to other positions instead of just saying what you believe is correct because you believe it.


r/AskALiberal • • 3h ago

What do you think Woke 2 should be?

0 Upvotes

The issues that DEI meant to address are still largely there, and in many ways worse. Politicians are distancing themselves from that era, labeling it Woke 1 and calling it, as AOC said "Woke 1 was crazy."

So how do we make power structures and workplaces more representative of the general population in a way that's not perceived as crazy and won't generate the backlash that we're living through now?


r/AskALiberal • • 21h ago

Is the Ballroom a lost cause?

5 Upvotes

Looking at photos of the ballroom, there is every reason to believe it will be completed by 2028. I believe that every tactic to delay its completion should be taken so that DJT does not get to enjoy it for a single day in office. But then what?

Tearing it down and rebuilding the East Wing would cost millions more in taxpayer dollars that are best spent elsewhere. Holding him accountable, when the Supreme Court has ruled that he can do whatever he wants so long as it's an "official act," is likely impossible. So what can a democratic Congress or President even do at this point?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Those who followed US politics before Trump, what was the Republican Party like?

12 Upvotes

I’m a non-American Gen Z who’s interested in US politics. I was too young to follow American politics before Trump, so almost all my exposure has been during the MAGA era.

I’m genuinely curious as to what the Republican Party was like before Trump and the MAGA movement became so influential. What were its priorities, and how different were things back then?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

For those of you who are big proponents of the Abundance Agenda, how are you feeling about Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA)?

5 Upvotes

I'm reading through an AI summary of the bill and it seems like it would largely be a wet dream for the Kleins and Iglesias-es of the world.

Any thoughts?


r/AskALiberal • • 21h ago

Would you prefer to work for a promising startup or a stable company with a union workforce?

1 Upvotes

A big portion of your compensation from the startup is equity. Startup company does offer a solid healthplan though. If the startup has a successful IPO one day, you become a decamillionaire. However, nothing is guaranteed, there is a real risk that the Startup fails to execute and goes under.

The union job initially, has better pay and benefits, no equity, no compensation increase (outside of the already agreed to labor contract) until the contract is up for renegotiation. Corporation is stable with a sustainable rate of growth.


r/AskALiberal • • 23h ago

Why should college be free?

0 Upvotes

Or not?


r/AskALiberal • • 23h ago

When are violent revolutions justified?

0 Upvotes

Throughout history violent, deadly revolutions usher in a new era. Just look at our own American Revolution. In all cases, there was an injustice that needed a violent upheaval. Polite persuasions wasn't going to cut it. In 2026 there is such great wealth inequality (just look at the recent Anthropic IPO) and it doesn't feel like anything will actually game unless there is another revolution. But I'm guessing most will not support such revolution. But at some point don't the injustices of society justify such revolution?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Everyone seems to be talking about what Democrats should do at the federal level in 2027, but what about at the state level gains?

10 Upvotes

Multiple states saw Democrats win new trifectas or break Republican supermajorities. What should each of these respective Democratic governments or divided governments at the state level try to accomplish while they have power?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Do you consider yourself good at risk assessment?

3 Upvotes

For the dangers that present in the world do you feel like you have a good handle on how likely they are to impact you, and what mitigations you should or shouldn't take based on that risk?

Keeping it open as not to frame the dialog, but an example would be air safety and do you avoid flying because there are stories in the news a few times a year of planes of all sizes crashing…

…but please don't use this as your example. Or do. Do whatever you want. Just know you'll irk me. Maybe that's a positive. We will see.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

What do you make of the Danish left wing Prime Minister talking about the Great Replacement Theory?

15 Upvotes

“I am not in favour of a multicultural society where one equates cultures,” Frederiksen said.

“I am European, Danish and from Aalborg. And I am also not in favour of a large population replacement. I believe there needs to be a strong majority culture"

Do you agree?

Source:

https://brusselssignal.eu/2026/11/denmarks-social-democrat-pm-rejects-large-population-replacement-and-wants-strong-majority-culture/


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

If the choice came down to a highly erratic, deeply-flawed, and unstable Democratic version of Trump and a sane and rational Republican candidate would you vote for 4 years of stability over party loyalty?

0 Upvotes

I asked the same of conservatives and am now interested in hearing the left's perspective. The question essentially boils down to are you willing to put your policy objectives on hold for 4 years to avoid the constant instability of someone like Trump?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Is capitalism in crisis? Will it end and will our generation be the last to live in it?

0 Upvotes

Do you believe that the capitalist system is entering (or has already entered) its final crisis, and that our generation will be the last to live under it?

Will future generations witness the rise of socialism?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

How is consenting to sex not consenting to pregnancy?

0 Upvotes

I have a hard time grasping this concept

To me this is equivalent to jumping from a cliff and saying you don’t consent to falling or throwing a rock off a bridge and saying you don’t consent to the rock killing anyone.

Take all the precautions you want… ultimately gravity is gravity.

PS: I’m pro-choice. I just dont grok this specific pro-choice argument that is often wheeled out.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

I would consider Trump to be a fundamental betrayal of Conservative values. What is the Democratic equivalent of Trump in this regard according to Liberals?

0 Upvotes

See title.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

How do you feel about the concept of "fairness" towards the tax payer(s) of your country?

0 Upvotes

I notice that with the left, they don't seem to see tax revenue as public funds based on their actions and rhetoric. I say this because I don't wanna assume that they know that already and simply don't care as that would be uncharitable. They really support the government providing more than half a percent of our budget on foreign humanitarian aid, helping illegal immigrants, weakening the effectiveness of our systems(police, public transit, criminal justice system, school system, etc), etc.

For example, in NYC, there was a pilot program where migrants were put into free or discounted housing and given prepaid debit cards, and hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of free legal council. I see stuff like this and go "huh?!". People who have not paid into the system, and some of them who are illegal, and they are given access to our public funds. This is not fair to the tax payer if it isn't part of an "opt-in" system before funds can be appropriated like this. This seems completely inappropriate.

Another: letting prisoners out of jail repeatedly. We have laws on the books, ww have an apparatus that can enforce them, and it fails to occur.

I feel it would be more fair for us to be able to opt into or out of charity and welfare systems and be able to donate as much money as we want. You can have those who like their resourcea being siphoned off by people from 3rd world countries, and unproductive people buy into that system, and those who don't reject it.

But what do you think about it?


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

What do you think is the motivation of pro-life supports?

10 Upvotes

Why do they support pro-life?

Edit: meant to say “supporters.”