r/AskAcademia • • 4h ago

Humanities Do humanities students have to be extraordinary with talents?

2 Upvotes

Someone said to me that arts students are extraordinary among other fields, they enjoy, are well spoken and have talents!

But I don't fit in that category as I am just very ordinary with no talents... It made me doubt myself so much.

What do you guys think?


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

Interpersonal Issues Is it too much to ask a course instructor for a meeting for a reference letter?

3 Upvotes

I am finishing up my science undergrad and applying to a healthcare professional program that requires an academic reference. I am in a tough spot because I have not really formed relationships with any professors.

I do beleive I am a good applicant for the program nonethless because I have good grades and good work expereince. I just havnt been too involved in academia as I have always been interested in applied work over research.

There is one course instructor that seems to be my best option for academic reference because I have done 3 classes with him and gotten good grades. I went to office hours, and answered questions in class discussions.

The thing is, he has hundreds and hundreds of students every year. Theres no way he knows who I am unless he sees my face to jog his memory. Even then, he might barely remember me.

My hope is to have a meeting with him to remind him that I went to office hours, participated in class discussions, and got good grades. In the meeting I would also want to explain other reasons I think I am a good candidate for the program such as my work experience.

I am afraid that if I send an email requesting a meeting it will come across as too demanding. He is very busy, and might think "Why is this student expecting me to go out of my way to write a good reference for them, when I don't even know who they are?"

What should I do? What should I write in my initial email to him to maximize the chance that he takes a second to learn about me and write me a good reference? Is it better for me to just explain all of the stuff I want to discuss in a meeting over email?

Thank you for any input!

TLDR: How to email a prof who barely knows you and end up getting a good reference?


r/AskAcademia • • 1h ago

Humanities Phd admission w/o attendance requirement.

0 Upvotes

Is there any college in lucknow or nearby where I would not need to attend regular classes while pursuing phd. I have jrf but i am preparing for civil services.


r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

Professional Fields - Law, Business, etc. Seeking advice on a tenure-track faculty application rejection

0 Upvotes

I'm currently a tenure-track Assistant Professor of Data Science at a public university. I recently applied for a tenure-track position in Business Analytics and Applied AI within a College of Business at a teaching-focused university.

I hold a Ph.D. in Data Science and have several years of independent university teaching experience, including teaching Business Analytics. I also have peer-reviewed publications in applied AI and machine learning.

The position required a Ph.D. in Business Analytics, AI, Computer Science, Information Systems, or a closely related field.

However, I received a rejection stating that I did not meet one or more of the required qualifications. I fully respect the search committee's decision, but I was somewhat surprised, as I believed my academic background and experience aligned with the advertised requirements.

Could having a Ph.D. in Data Science or holding a faculty appointment outside a College of Business be a reason for not meeting the minimum qualifications? Alternatively, is this common rejection language used in faculty hiring?

I'd sincerely appreciate any insights, particularly from those who have served on business school faculty search committees. Thank you!


r/AskAcademia • • 2h ago

Professional Fields - Law, Business, etc. What subjects are best for business?

0 Upvotes

I would like to know which subjects are best for owning a business.


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Interpersonal Issues Non-academic reasons for rejecting job candidates?

190 Upvotes

I think a committee I was on got a candidate nixed from consideration because several committee members felt the candidate was rude to staff and impatient over tech problems.

What kinds of non-academic issues have you all seen people get eliminated for?

Grad students and new faculty: be kind to everyone during an interview! You are being assessed from all angles!


r/AskAcademia • • 12h ago

Interpersonal Issues How can I find a postdoc position in Europe/Gulf with a background in Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) and Lattice Boltzmann Method (LBM)?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm looking for advice from people who have experience finding postdoctoral positions, particularly in Europe/gulf.

My academic background is in fluid mechanics and computational fluid dynamics. My PhD research focuses on the numerical study of complex flows using the Lattice Boltzmann Method (LBM), particularly its application to pathological blood vessels and non-Newtonian blood-flow modeling.

I have experience with 2D single-relaxation-time LBM (SRT-LBM) and MATLAB. I have also published five research articles in Q1 and Q2 journals, covering topics related to my research field.

I'm now interested in pursuing a postdoc, preferably in Europe (France, Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, Switzerland, or other countries)/gulf.

However, I'm not necessarily looking to continue working exclusively on blood-flow simulations. I'd also be interested in exploring other research areas where my numerical modeling and CFD background could be useful, such as:

Multiphase and complex fluid flows

Microfluidics

Porous media flows

Fluid-structure interaction

Turbulence modeling

Thermal and environmental fluid dynamics

Advanced numerical methods and HPC

My main questions are:

How did you find your first postdoctoral position? Did you apply to advertised vacancies, contact professors directly, or use academic networks?

Is it realistic to find a postdoc in Europe with an LBM/CFD background without having previous experience in the specific application area?

Which websites, research groups, or platforms would you recommend for finding postdoc opportunities?

How important are publications compared with technical skills and research experience when applying for postdocs?

Would you recommend contacting potential supervisors directly with a CV and a short research proposal?

I'd particularly appreciate advice from researchers who obtained postdoctoral positions in Europe, especially those who came from outside Europe.

I'm trying to develop an effective strategy rather than simply sending hundreds of applications.

Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences!


r/AskAcademia • • 6h ago

Meta Any Suggestions on Gifts for my Professor and Lecturers

0 Upvotes

Hello guys. I am going to have my convocation ceremony shortly (end of this year, December) and am planning to buy gifts to appreciate my professor and other lecturers.

I have bought a self customized notebook for my Professor for her birthday gifts therefore I have really no idea on what else I should buy. And is it appropriate to give other lecturers a customized notebook as well?

Hope to hear from you guys :)


r/AskAcademia • • 13h ago

Social Science How do you properly credit someone in this scenario?

0 Upvotes

I am getting ready to send in my grad school applications and am not sure how to credit a classmate on my writing submission. The writing is completely new and I added a fair bit that we didn't have before - I didn't even copy sentences from the poster that only I wrote - but I based the essay off of a research poster we made together for a class. I used sources that we found together for our poster and the initial topic idea was hers. We didn't write a paper together for the poster, otherwise I would have submitted that and just had us both as authors. She gave me permission to do this, but I don't want to come across as plagiarizing her work. Should I add in the acknowledgements that she helped with the initial research and idea?


r/AskAcademia • • 15h ago

STEM From Wet lab to Dry lab : how realistic is a hybrid profile?

0 Upvotes

For those who've made the transition from wet lab to computational work, how did you do it, and how long did it take before you felt competent?

is a true hybrid profile (comfortable generating and analyzing your own data) actually realistic, or do most people end up leaning one way?

Any advice on where to start would also be welcome.


r/AskAcademia • • 16h ago

STEM idk

0 Upvotes

its a simple post. im just too concerned about whether i should go for grad school or not
(im a finalyear chemistry bachlor student. im interested in flow chemistry, organic syntheses of functional materials (currently working on fluorogen synthesis), f*** idk, material science maybe?? i had a review project on nanotech but bachelors project dont teach you things)

im in a state right now where i dont know whether i should go for a PHD or Masters. PhD has its own problems and risk factors like research commitment, motivations, and ability to carry out the research thoroughly unlike bachelors. also phd acceptance for me is also an issue like im hardworking but im not exeptional in any way that i can get into direct phd. also phd scholarships are not a 100% guaranteed. i do not know a case where a phd fellow can carry out its work without proper funding.

similarly masters has its own problems. first is financial which is a biggest one out there outside of my homecountry. a lot of money is spent on the degree and sometimes ROI is not met. it is not guaranteed that one will receive proper PI for their reserach degree masters/phd any. then it is also not guaranteed that the projects one will receive will be of their interest throughout the program.

jobs are another issues. after masters i havent heard about getting jobs that easily even if one does it from a foreign university.

also if im pursuing general phd/mtech in chemistry or chemical engineering, im not sure what will be the value of that degree and what flexibility will it offer to me. also its not as versatile in reserach fields as materials science. i dont know what should i do..

like people can anyone knock sense into me. any kind of help will be appreciated.


r/AskAcademia • • 10h ago

Social Science Не зміг написати магістерську, бо науковий керівник дотошний підарас

0 Upvotes

Мені тупо нав'язали цю кончу, яка не хоче перевіряти мою роботу. Бо йому не подобається текст, і це при тому, що він сам казав, що не проти використання ші. Я коректував роботу як міг і йому всеодно не те. Хтось знає скільки коштує поновлення, і так щоб вибрати нову тему і керівника? Я з КНЕУ якщо що, ЕКОНОМІЧНА КІБЕРНЕТИКА ТА ДАТА САЄНС. Це мені треба рік чекати чи як? Хто як взагалі писав магістерську? Хочу зробити напевно по аналогії, бо моя тема надто складна для мене.


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Professional Misconduct in Research Unethical to pay someone to edit/polish paper?

4 Upvotes

I'm in a master's program. I was waiting for one of my professors before office hours and I overheard him tell another professor that 20 years ago some faculty would pay to have someone edit and polish a paper before submitting it to a journal, but that "you couldn't get away with it nowadays" as it'd be unethical.

  1. Is this something that faculty did commonly 20 years ago?
  2. If so, what would change to make it unethical now but not then?

For context: I wasn't eavesdropping. They were talking in the hallway and saw me waiting.


r/AskAcademia • • 17h ago

STEM Click to reveal a hidden 3D object and tell us what it is — university research on visual attention

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm a university student working on a research project about which parts of a 3D object people look at.

In the study, you see a 3D object from three sides, but it's completely covered. You click to reveal small circles, then answer one short question (what the object is, describe it, or rate how nice it looks). There are 8 objects, and a counter shows your progress.

⏱ About 5-10 minutes · 🙈 Anonymous, no sign-up · 💻 Works in your browser

🔗 https://mesh-saliency-study.vercel.app/

Thank you so much for helping! Happy to answer any questions in the comments.


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM How much does PhD institution ranking matter for TT hiring?

27 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm planning to apply for TT faculty positions in engineering, and I'd love some advice from those with experience on either side of the hiring process. I’m wondering how much weight search committees put on the ranking of candidate's PhD school in US when hiring for TT positions in engineering.

A bit about my background: I’m a permanent resident, so I don’t need visa sponsorship. My publications are mostly in well-known IEEE journals and top AI conferences, and I’m currently a postdoc at a QS top-5 university. Any insights or personal experiences would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks for sharing your perspective!


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM Experiences in leadership/director roles at research institutes

4 Upvotes

Hi all. I’ve recently accepted a role at a top 30 R1 university. The role is Assistant Director of an early-stage research institute that focuses on my speciality, with a portion of FTE to develop my research programme (NTT, no teaching load, 2 years of modest start up funding for the research component). The Director has a much smaller time allocation to the Institute than me, so it’ll be my job to organise the nuts and bolts of growing the Institute.

I did a post doc at the same university, but have since spent 7 years in non-profit leadership/programme management.

I’m wondering if anyone could share their experience in a similar type of more admin/leadership role in the university system? What sorts of unexpected pressures are there that aren’t present in a normal faculty role?


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM In person interview - specific questions on attire, dining, etc.

10 Upvotes

You all have provided such great advice both in questions that I’ve asked and in other threads so I’m hoping you’ll come through again. This is a Midwest SLAC and I’m in STEM.

  1. I fly in mid afternoon and then my schedule states there will be a campus tour and then dinner. Should I be dressed in business casual or is smart casual ok? I plan to change once i arrive at the airport before I am picked up so I’m not wrinkly or smelly. I was thinking a blazer, dark wash jeans, and heels. I’m fine walking around campus in heels.
  2. I plan to bring a tote bag instead of a backpack. That’s ok right? Backpacks kinda kill the vibe of an outfit lol
  3. For said dinner ^, it’s with the committee. Anything i should be aware of besides normal dining etiquette when you’re the guest (e.g. never ordering the most expensive meal, don’t order alcohol unless the person paying does, etc.)?
  4. I have a meeting with the provost. What general questions should I expect to be asked? What questions should I bring for the provost?

Feel free to share any other advice or things you think would be helpful. I’m so grateful for this sub!


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM Priority claim and an unresponsive journal

2 Upvotes

I submitted a manuscript in April in a reputable STEM journal. About two months ago, I became concerned about the results I achieved, since I never posted a preprint. I contacted the journal to ask if I could post the preprint now, since I didn't know what the rules are, since my submission itself was anonymous. Two months passed, and I never got a response. Recently I discovered that another group has reached the same result in a very similar fashion and posted a preprint. It's the same thing just achieved six months after me. This is quite bad, so I immediately contacted the journal editors and the authors of the said preprint to establish the timeline. Only, it's been a week and the journal hasn't responded to my email, and neither did the authors of the paper. What exactly should I do?


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Professional Fields - Law, Business, etc. Integrated PhD for Aspiring Lecturer, is it worth it?

2 Upvotes

I completed my Bachelor's degree in Management around 10 years ago and have been working ever since. Long story short, I grew interest in HR and I have finally made my move transitioning to become an HR professional.

After moving I realized, while I enjoy the topic, being a practitioner may not be my long term goal. I have always been curious about becoming a lecturer as I enjoy teaching and I find it quite meaningful but want to do it in a more formal setting.

Question is: Is it worthwhile to pursue an Integrated PhD program (Master and PhD) to allow me to pursue a career as a lecturer? I am looking into such programs with specialization in HR.

Thank you for your inputs!


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Admissions - please post in /r/gradadmissions, not here Digital Product Passports - the future of luxury resale?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm currently conducting a research for my MA in Fashion and Luxury Brand Management about how Digital Product Passports (DPPs) may influence consumer trust and participation in the resale market, for European luxury handbags and leather goods.

If you have 5 mins could you help me completing this survey? It's completely anonymous, thank you so much!

https://forms.gle/xPNysaNB6mhmCfF98


r/AskAcademia • • 2d ago

Humanities Upcoming Zoom Interview for TT position (humanities) at an R1

33 Upvotes

Hello! I am an ABD at an R1. I’ve been invited to a zoom interview for a TT position (in humanities) at an R1. This is absolutely my dream position and dream school, and I really want to at least get to the campus visit stage.

Last year I did three zoom interviews (one r1, two slacs) and while none translated to a campus visit, all theee places said that I was next on the finalist list (not sure if they say this to everyone.) I had a good time at those interviews but I did go in with a grad student energy and answered questions like it was a defense.

People who have interviewed or been on search committees, please give me the essential checklist of advice and things to prepare for! I will be forevermore grateful!


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM Broader Impacts of Experimental Physics Questions

1 Upvotes

I'm a new grad student in material engineering and I'm still trying to understand academia in the U.S. I'm considering applying for the NSF fellowship. I'm not too sure about the broader impacts listed in the NSF fellowship especially pertaining to my PI's area of study which is about superconductor hybrid devices. The NSF fellowship lists broader impacts as

-Increase participation in STEM.

-Improve STEM education in schools through outreach and mentoring.

-Increase public scientific literacy and public engagement with STEM through community outreach.

-Increase collaboration among academia, industry, and other types of organizations.

-Improve education and educator development — at any level — in STEM.

-Improve the well-being of individuals in society.

-Develop a globally competitive STEM workforce.

-Improve national security.

-Increase the economic competitiveness of the U.S.

-Enhance infrastructure for research and education.

I heard from a senior in the lab that our research has little real-world application and is mostly for proving physics theories, but he's from a theoretical background. Is the senior wrong? Because the lab gets military funding. If it's only for supporting theories, I don't feel as though it has much direct broader impact to the field, at least personally. Especially compared to my goal of wanting to make contributions in semiconductor devices and having an effect on the electronics everyone uses which could improve the well-being of individuals in society, improve national security, etc.

Should I be doing more research in looking for ways to apply the research to what I'm interest in? Or is my understanding of academia broader impacts lacking in some way about proving theories, and if so, what?


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Social Science When interview results in Econ Job market EU?

0 Upvotes

Hi I am fairly new to the Econ JM in EU and I was wondering if Universities let you know the outcome of your applications regardless of whether you failed or are shortlisted for the interview phase and, in case, when this happens usually on avg (late november? beginning of december?)

Thanks


r/AskAcademia • • 2d ago

STEM End of the postdoctoral position

91 Upvotes

When I came to US in 2016, my postdoc salary in STEM was 65k and the rent of a nice 2BD townhouse was 1.6k. I barely survived being a 3 person family.
Today, the same postdoc is 70k and the rent of a 2BD is 2.4k.
65k inflation adjusted should be 91k.

It's basically the end of the postdoctoral position.

Edit: end of the postdoctoral position as a viable path for talent to get into research or academia.

Edit 2: All in all, with current salaries, I would not be able to take the offer and come to US. I would have stayed in Europe. So, more and more, the path to US research/academia will be paved with students/postdocs from poorer countries or lower talent unable to find better positions in their home country.

Edit 3: I agree is perfectly possible that, for a local recent single PhD graduate with some savings and local family to help, to survive with 70k and rent 1BD or stay at parents home. But not when you (as a professor) want to bring someone from overseas to do research on a specific topic. Also, it is a comparative post. Of course, conditions can continue declining, and you can always find some candidates (though one may doubt their quality).

Edit 4: This is a fact from https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsf25336 Across all fields, 34% of 2023 U.S. doctorate recipients held temporary visas (19,393 of 57,862), and China and India together accounted for 49% (9,414) of those temporary visa recipients.
Also, In studies tracking U.S. STEM postdocs on temporary visas, 58% come from South and East Asia, with China serving as the single largest source country alongside India, Japan, and South Korea. https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20240903161932652

Finally, anyone in academia long enough already saw with their own eyes the trend.