r/AskComputerScience • • 13h ago

How do researchers determine whether an idea is truly novel before investing months into it?

6 Upvotes

A real question I've never gotten a good answer to.

When a researcher picks a problem to work on, how do they check beforehand that it hasn't already been solved or isn't too close to existing work?

I get the literature review idea in principle, read papers, spot gaps. But in reality:

- How many papers do you have to read before you feel sure a gap is there?
- Do you just run keyword searches and hope nothing slipped past you?
- Is there an actual systematic method or tool that people use for this?

It feels like a genuine risk to sink 3 months into something and then discover a 2019 paper already did it. How is that risk handled in practice?


r/AskComputerScience • • 18h ago

Junior/senior: shape of knowledge

4 Upvotes

Hi, I am not from this domain but I am curious about learning and understanding in general.

​Would you say that after graduating you know a lot of math formula and tricks to solve academic problems, you also understand how they work. But being a junior your work don't offer you cases to use them. Years later, as a senior you are presented lot of case where those tricks might come usefull but you forget about how they work so you search the formula and see how you could apply them to solve your problem. So you rediscover their working and learned them a second time ?

An analogy would be as a junior you know the content of the books in the library but don't get the chance to use it. As a senior you forget years​ ago the content of the book but you know where to find the book that contain what will help you solve the problem.

If so would that mean understanding 100% how things work is a temporary state. Even knowing you gonna forget 99% that was still usefull as the 1% is the most important (where to find the book).

Somehow the more you know the more you can forget.

Don't hesitate to share other analogy, counter exemples