r/AskEconomics • • 7h ago

Weekly Roundup Weekly Answer Round Up: Quality and Overlooked Answers From the Last Week - November 22, 2026

3 Upvotes

We're going to shamelessly steal adapt from /r/AskHistorians the idea of a weekly thread to gather and recognize the good answers posted on the sub. Good answers take time to type and the mods can be slow to approve things which means that sometimes good content doesn't get seen by as many people as it should. This thread is meant to fix that gap.

Post answers that you enjoyed, felt were particularly high quality, or just didn't get the attention they deserved. This is a weekly recurring thread posted every Sunday morning.


r/AskEconomics • • May 04 '26

Meta Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

12 Upvotes

Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

What Are Quality Contributors?

By subreddit policy, comments are filtered and sent to the modqueue. However, we have a whitelist of commenters whose comments are automatically approved. These users also have the ability to approve or remove the comments of non-approved users.

Recently, we have seen an influx of short, low-quality comments. This is a major burden on our mod team, and it also delays the speed at which good answers can be approved. To address this issue, we are looking to bring on additional Quality Contributors.

How Do You Apply?

If you would like to be added as a Quality Contributor, please submit 3-5 comments below that reflect at least an undergraduate level understanding of economics. The comments do not have to be from r/AskEconomics. Things we look for include an understanding of economic theory, references to academic research (or other quality sources), and sufficient detail to adequately explain topics.

If anyone has any questions about the process, responsibilities, or requirements to become a QC, please feel free to ask below.


r/AskEconomics • • 15h ago

Approved Answers If I have a bagpipe, and my friend has a $100 bill. Can we hand them back and forth 10 billion times to create a trillion dollar bagpipe industry?

223 Upvotes

I’m trying to get a sense of how this isn’t a simplified version of Nvidia.


r/AskEconomics • • 1h ago

Is inflation truly "always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon"?

6 Upvotes

One of Javier Milei’s core talking points is Milton Friedman’s quote that inflation is strictly a monetary issue—meaning it happens when money supply outpaces money demand, and stopping the money printer is the only real cure (even if it takes up to two years to fully show in the numbers). On the other hand, many economists argue that costs, supply chains, utility rate adjustments, and market expectations play a massive role, and that treating it only as a monetary problem misses the bigger picture. Looking at both economic theory and real-world cases like Argentina, what’s your take? Is inflation purely monetary, or is that only half the story?


r/AskEconomics • • 19h ago

Approved Answers Is there any truth to the claim that IPOs are now treated more like exit liquidity for private investors than a chance for retail investors to invest?

113 Upvotes

I’ve heard this claim but I’ve heard it on online videos so I have no clue the credibility of the claim

Basically what I heard is that IPOs in the past tended to be more like a good way to get a lot of investment if your product was promising. Companies in the past grew massively from their IPO, so retail investors would gladly invest

Recently, IPOs have gone for insane valuations at IPO, then start dropping. Over long periods of time, they don’t grow as quickly

I’ve heard that a lot of the investment has turned private for better returns and that IPOs have shifted to being an exit liquidity strategy for early private investors, and that’s why this is happening

Any truth to it?


r/AskEconomics • • 3h ago

loophole:dollar will always go up?

2 Upvotes

i was just researching about the dollar getting stronger,gold falling and indian ruppes (foregin currency)also getting weaker because they buy gold in dollars
case 1: if dollar get stronger then obviously gold will fall and other currencies too

case2: (dollar falling but aparently got stronger)
now due to inflation, and no price hike for 3 years the dollar had to get weaken and fall but
instead of letting it weaken ,USA increased interest rates (which means other countries were
putting their money into USA,hence making it stronger and their currency weaker)

isnt this a loop like dollar will never stop falling until other countries stop trading dollars?


r/AskEconomics • • 10h ago

Approved Answers What are some good books about economics?

8 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 1m ago

Canada Telecom Concentration: What would you suggest?

1 Upvotes

With Quebecor’s offer to acquire Telus, it got me thinking again about competition in our telecom sector and the generally-poor value for money we get in Canada. The distribution of our population is sometimes blamed for oligopolies (in other sectors as well), though I’m not sure how true this is. The result of the oligopolies seems to be uncompetitive markets.

If Mark Carney asked you what to do to improve Canada’s telecom sector, what would you tell him? In the case of the proposed Telus acquisition, but more generally as well.


r/AskEconomics • • 20h ago

Approved Answers If repairing something uses fewer resources than making a new one, why is replacing it often cheaper?

29 Upvotes

I recently got quoted $180 to repair a small kitchen appliance that I could replace with a comparable new one for about $120.

The technician wasn't trying to rip me off. Between diagnosing the problem, ordering the part, labor, and the shop's overhead, the quote actually seemed reasonable.

But it made me wonder about something from an economics perspective.

Somewhere in the world, a factory can extract raw materials, manufacture dozens of components, assemble an appliance, package it, transport it across an ocean, distribute it to a retailer, and still sell it profitably for less than a local technician charges to replace one broken component.

Obviously mass production and cheaper labor explain part of this. But it still feels like a strange outcome: the process involving substantially more physical production can have the lower market price.

I started wondering whether this is an example of Baumol's cost disease. Manufacturing productivity keeps improving, while an individual technician still has to spend time diagnosing and fixing one appliance.

But I'm not sure whether that explains most of the price difference or whether other factors are more important.

For example, if repair is frequently uneconomical, shouldn't there be strong incentives for businesses to develop cheaper repair methods? Or does the relatively small and unpredictable demand for each particular repair prevent those economies of scale from developing?

I'm also curious whether economists distinguish between something being cheap in monetary terms and something being efficient in terms of the actual resources society uses.

Is there research on why the relative cost of repairing consumer goods has changed over time? And is this mainly a productivity story, or a market structure problem?


r/AskEconomics • • 12h ago

Does this study establish that nearby data centers don’t reduce home values?

5 Upvotes

This study https://cra.gmu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/NoVa_DataCenters.pdf is being used to justify rezoning for a mega data center in Stafford Virginia. To me it just seems to confirm that homes closer to urban areas, where most currently reside, cost more. It doesn’t seem to address things like changes in value and appreciation rates. But would like some expert feedback.


r/AskEconomics • • 1h ago

Approved Answers Why is economic growth such a dogmatic feature of modern society?

0 Upvotes

I’m a biologist, and in my field, most stable systems move towards homeostasis, meaning an equilibrium of things moving in and out of the system. I just don’t understand why we are so dependent on a constant disequilibrium, in which we always need more for our economies not to crash. Especially since as far as I know, there is not a single instance where economic growth was not directly tied to increased destruction of our natural resources, meaning that it is directly leading us to turning earth into a hellhole by destabilising the natural systems upon which we are so reliant for food and resources. I might not know much about economics, but boy can I tell you that by following this dogma we are really messing it up, and as far as I know the economists focusing on the cost of climate change agree.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

What should I consider before doing post grad economics study?

5 Upvotes

Some context: Based in Australia. I have been working as a swe for ~5 years now with a comp sci bachelors degree. Before undertaking that I had considered doing economics as my second option.

I've been considering doing post grad economics study. It's something I've always had an interest in (and got more interested in it in recent times), and keep up to date with different economic news, looking at various charts of data or reading policy papers.

I wanted to know what are the things to consider before going forward with this, and whether it's worth doing or not? Is it harder to do without an economics undergrad? And what impacts will AI have in the future in economics to consider as well?


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers How would lower taxes increase tax revenue?

0 Upvotes

Here in Florida we recently approved amendment 3, which increased property tax exemptions and lowered rate increases for future years. Its clear to me how this lowers tax revenue for the municipalities but now the governor has been claiming that it could actually increase tax revenue.

How could this be? If the tax revenue is the same why wouldn't the tax burden be the same (ie: what would benefit be of lowering taxes is the same amount is paid elsewhere)


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers Can someone explain to me what a stochastic lattice is in economics?

3 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers Why do economists treat 'labor hoarding' as an employer strategy but rarely discuss workers doing the inverse?

24 Upvotes

The concept of labor hoarding, firms keeping workers through downturns to avoid rehiring costs, shows up regularly in business cycle literature. What I have not seen is symmetrical analysis of workers staying in jobs below their skill level during tight markets, not from mismatch but as a risk buffer. Is there established terminology or empirical work on this? It seems distinct from underemployment or job lock because the mechanism is precautionary rather than contractual or search frictional, yet the aggregate effects on measured productivity and wage growth could be substantial.


r/AskEconomics • • 20h ago

Why can inflation fall even while prices keep rising?

0 Upvotes

How do economists distinguish a fall in the inflation rate from an actual fall in the overall price level? What would cause each?


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Should the Fed cut rates to save America from its $40T debt, or keep rates high to fight inflation ,even if markets crash?

0 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

Why does Kuwait have such a high government spend as a % of GDP compared to the other GCC countries?

30 Upvotes

imf.org/external/datamapper/exp@FPP/KWT/SAU/QAT/ARE/OMN/BHR

Government Spend (% GDP)GDP per Capita (USD)
Bahrain29.1%30,597
Kuwait50.4%32,312
Oman28.7%19,947
Qatar26.0%72,525
Saudi Arabia29.6%34,537
United Arab Emirates21.4%50,273

r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

Approved Answers Why is the U.S. engaging in trade wars when it heavily relies on foreign treasuries and investments to manage federal debt, what advantageous outcome could there be economically when it appears that there is mainly negative consequences?

6 Upvotes

A goal of the U.S. is to grow its economy, but debt typically increases relatively to the growing rate of the economy. How can the U.S. manage its debt and reduce it and what would happen if the U.S. defaulted on its debt? Would the U.S. have to merge its economy into an international entity like the European Union as an example to prevent utter economic decline and degradation?


r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

Approved Answers If grocery store loyalty cards are free, why do stores charge a higher price to people who don't use one?

23 Upvotes

I was grocery shopping yesterday and noticed something that's been bothering me more the longer I think about it.

A box of cereal was $5.49 at the regular price, or $3.49 with the store's loyalty card.

The loyalty card is completely free. You don't have to accumulate points or spend a certain amount to get the discount. You just sign up and scan it.

So the store is effectively offering two different prices for the exact same product, with the only difference being whether you're willing to register for a free account.

I understand why a store might reward frequent customers with discounts. But this doesn't seem to require any actual loyalty. Someone who has never visited the store before can sign up in two minutes and immediately get the lower price.

Which makes me wonder why the higher price exists at all.

Is the idea that some customers are too busy, uninformed, or unwilling to register, so the store can charge them more while still offering competitive prices to everyone else?

Or is the information collected through the loyalty program valuable enough to justify selling products at a lower price?

I'm also curious whether this affects how economists think about grocery prices. If the shelf says $5.49 but most customers actually pay $3.49, which price is economically meaningful?

It seems like the store has created a small inconvenience that customers have to overcome to avoid paying more.

Is there a specific economic explanation for why this is more profitable than simply pricing the cereal at $3.49 for everybody?

And is there research on whether loyalty-card pricing actually benefits consumers overall, compared with a system where everyone faces the same prices?


r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

Approved Answers If an economy spends more money every year just preventing fraud and theft, can GDP grow without people actually becoming better off?

5 Upvotes

I've been wondering about a category of economic activity that doesn't seem to make anyone's life better so much as prevent it from getting worse.

Think about online fraud. Banks hire entire teams to detect suspicious transactions. Businesses pay for identity verification software. Online stores invest in systems to stop fraudulent purchases. Meanwhile, criminals develop new methods, which forces everyone to spend even more on prevention.

All of this involves real jobs, salaries, software development and business revenue.

But suppose a country spends an additional $10 billion on fraud prevention this year, and the result is simply that the amount of fraud stays exactly where it was last year.

From the perspective of consumers, nothing has improved. They're just getting the same level of security at a higher cost.

My understanding is that the additional security services still contribute to measured economic output. But I might be misunderstanding how GDP accounting handles these expenses.

I'm not suggesting fraud prevention is useless. Obviously it's necessary when fraud exists. What interests me is the possibility of an economic arms race where both sides consume increasing amounts of resources just to maintain the same outcome.

Is there an established concept in economics for this kind of activity?

And more importantly, do economists have a way to distinguish growth that actually improves living standards from growth that merely reflects how expensive it has become to prevent things from getting worse?


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers Can community organizing be a way of solving poverty ?

0 Upvotes

Specifically mobilizing people at relevant local and if possible national or international levels to support a project of providing essential services to underserved areas or developing capacities and rapport to achieve shared goals without relying on money.

Is this possible ?


r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

How much US wealth transfer did ww2 result in?

5 Upvotes

Boomers vs zoomers is back in the media cycle again and I've been hatching an idea: what if boomers represented a generation raised in uniquely unusual wealth and economic prosperity from the post-war era and the increasing malaise of subsequent generations is actually a slow return to m economic status quo? My question is twofold. First as in the title, roughly what was the value redistributed by the US government as a result of the war? This would be soldier pay, things like discounted mortgages, and the value of any net increase in manufacturing spending. If this number can even be approximated, I'd like to know if it's unusual and how much of a windfall it actually represented for US families compared to other generations. Secondly, I assume this idea has been either studied or debunked so I'd alternatively like suggestions on books or articles to read about it either way. Thanks in advance!


r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

On the commonly debated issues of should we and how can we tax ultra high wealth individuals, could a new capital gains tax specifically targeting billionaires combined with estate/step up basis reform provide a more efficient alternative to a wealth tax?

8 Upvotes

There are many disadvantages that come with a wealth tax, so I’ve been trying to think of any reasonable alternatives that might be better. I’m not an economist, so I don’t think my answer is perfect but I’m curious about it. What if we passed a new capital gains tax, so only applies at realization, targeting only those with a billion dollars in wealth and did so while reforming the estate/step up bases laws for a higher but deferred payment tax on their death. Could this be a more efficient alternative? What are the advantages and disadvantages?