Ada unemployment questions
Unemployment question
Title: Question About ADA Accommodations, Previously Negotiated Part-Time Schedule, and Employer Changing My Work Schedule (Washington State)
Hello, and thank you for taking the time to read my question. I'm looking for advice regarding my employment situation, ADA accommodations, and my rights as an employee in Washington State.
I've worked for the same healthcare company for approximately 6–7 years total.
Over the past year, the work environment has become increasingly hostile and stressful. There has been very little consistency with scheduling. Work hours change frequently, schedules are sometimes released with less than seven days' notice, and overnight on-call assignments change from week to week. This has made maintaining a reasonable work-life balance extremely difficult.
Background and Original Work Arrangement
I previously left this company because the workload had become overwhelming. At that time, I was working four 10-hour shifts per week (4x10s) and was assigned approximately three overnight on-call shifts each week. I was regularly working 40–50 hours per week and had been doing this for more than two years.
I was often asked to work additional nights and received pushback when I declined. I was also expected to work national holidays and was not given the option to take those days off.
I repeatedly asked for a reduction in overnight responsibilities so I could have a better work-life balance, but I continually received pushback. Eventually, I felt like I was drowning in work and had no life outside of my job, so I left.
Approximately a year later, a previous supervisor contacted me to see if I would reconsider returning because the company was short-staffed. I initially had no intention of returning, but they asked what they could do to convince me to come back.
I negotiated a verbal agreement for a part-time schedule consisting of three 10-hour shifts per week (3x10), with two overnight on-call assignments associated with my scheduled workdays.
The understanding was that I would be responsible for my designated workdays and overnight responsibilities. Any coverage needed outside those days would be the manager's responsibility to arrange.
I specifically requested this part-time arrangement because I have several medical conditions and injuries related to my military service. I have ongoing medical appointments and physical limitations. Because of the physical demands of my job, I cannot consistently work a full-time schedule.
The verbal agreement was communicated to company HR, and I understood that I was grandfathered into this arrangement. I believed the agreement would remain in place for the duration of my employment unless I decided to leave the company.
I was able to maintain this arrangement for approximately a year and a half.
Change in Management and Scheduling Issues
A new supervisor eventually took over. From the beginning, she started pushing me to work a full-time schedule.
I had numerous conversations with management explaining that I had returned under a negotiated part-time arrangement and wanted to continue working the schedule I had maintained for approximately 18 months.
I asked whether there was still a part-time option. I was told there was not and that I needed to work full-time because of business needs.
Essentially, I felt forced to accept a full-time schedule because I was concerned about losing my job.
The company began changing my workdays, hours, and overnight on-call assignments every few weeks. This made it extremely difficult to schedule and attend medical appointments through the VA.
Some of my appointments require traveling outside my immediate area to different cities in Washington and Oregon. Having an unpredictable schedule made coordinating these appointments increasingly difficult.
Request for ADA Accommodation and Intermittent Leave
Because management was no longer honoring the previous scheduling arrangement, I submitted a formal ADA accommodation request and intermittent medical leave paperwork.
My physician completed the necessary documentation supporting my need for a consistent three-day work schedule consisting of three consecutive 10-hour shifts, followed by four consecutive days off.
The purpose of this arrangement is to allow me to attend necessary medical appointments and give my body sufficient time to recover from the physical demands of my job.
I waited more than a month for the company to process my ADA accommodation request. During that time, I contacted HR to ask about the delay because I was continuing to work a full-time schedule that I had never agreed to.
After I sent an email to the HR department questioning the delay and expressing my concerns about how long the ADA process was taking, the company suddenly expedited the request and came back with a proposed accommodation in less than a week.
I felt that I was being rushed into accepting the accommodation without having all of my concerns addressed.
Recent ADA Accommodation Approval and Additional Concerns
Eventually, the company came back with a proposed 3x10 schedule that they indicated would accommodate my ADA request.
An HR representative contacted me on Tuesday, late in the business day, to discuss the proposed arrangement. Before agreeing, I had additional questions that needed to be answered.
HR indicated that she would need to research my questions and get back to me.
I was out sick on Thursday and was not able to return her call until Friday. Because I was working when HR contacted me, I did not have an opportunity to fully review or understand the proposed schedule.
I am also a visual person, and I wanted to see the actual schedule and conditions in writing rather than trying to understand everything through conversations and text messages.
I felt like I was being rushed into accepting an arrangement before my questions had been properly answered. I was concerned that I would not have sufficient time to review the agreement, obtain clarification, and have my VA representative review it and provide feedback.
My Concerns About the Written ADA Accommodation
A third-party company that handles the ADA accommodation process subsequently approved or issued the accommodation with an effective date of the following week.
However, the finalized accommodation document did not include the specific details I had requested.
For example, it did not clearly identify:
\\- My specific three scheduled workdays.
\\- My actual 10-hour work shifts.
\\- Confirmation that I would receive four consecutive days off.
\\- Whether I could be assigned overnight on-call responsibilities outside my scheduled workdays.
\\- What procedures would apply if I needed to call out for medical reasons.
\\- Whether management could continue changing my schedule or assigning additional days outside the agreed arrangement.
\\- How time-off requests and absences would be handled, particularly because the proposed schedule included a weekend day.
The last point is particularly concerning because my supervisor has previously denied time-off requests submitted approximately three weeks in advance, stating that they did not meet business needs, even though I provided what I believed was appropriate advance notice.
The proposed accommodation also did not explain what would happen if I needed to call out or take medical leave on one of my scheduled workdays.
These are important details because I have previously had verbal agreements with management that I believed would protect my schedule, only to have those arrangements changed later.
I specifically asked HR to put the details in writing to prevent the same situation from happening again.
HR did send me a text message containing some partial information, but those details were not included in the finalized ADA accommodation document.
I also have not physically received a copy of the finalized accommodation letter by email, despite being told that it had been sent.
Request for Additional Time to Review the Accommodation
The company wanted the proposed accommodation to begin the following week, during the last week of November and over Thanksgiving weekend.
I had previously requested time off for that holiday weekend because I had already purchased an out-of-state plane ticket. My time-off request was denied, despite being submitted in advance.
As a result, I am now out the money I spent on the ticket and will miss my yearly opportunity to visit friends and family.
I requested December 1 as the start date for the proposed ADA accommodation. This would give me time to receive and review the complete written accommodation, have a VA representative review it, ask any additional questions, and make sure the terms accurately reflect my medical needs.
I explained to HR that I was not ready to agree to the proposed accommodation until I had an opportunity to review all the details in writing.
I am not refusing an accommodation. I am trying to make sure that the accommodation actually addresses the medical limitations documented by my physician.
What concerns me even more is what happened after I communicated that I was not ready to agree to the proposed accommodation.
After completing my shift, I returned to the workplace to turn in paperwork. When I checked my work mailbox, I found an updated work schedule for the following week. The schedule already reflected the changes outlined in the proposed ADA accommodation.
I had not agreed to the proposed arrangement, confirmed that I accepted its terms, or received answers to my outstanding questions. I had specifically asked for additional time to review everything and requested December 1 as the implementation date.
Despite this, management had apparently already prepared and distributed the new schedule as though the accommodation had been finalized and accepted.
At that point, I felt like I was being forced to agree to the new ADA accommodation because the company was already moving forward with the schedule before I had agreed to it.
I am concerned that management is treating the proposed accommodation as final without allowing me a reasonable opportunity to review the complete written terms and address the issues I raised.
Given my previous experience with verbal agreements and management subsequently changing my schedule, I do not feel comfortable relying on another verbal understanding.
My Questions
- Can an employer consider an ADA accommodation finalized and implement it when the employee has not received the complete written terms or had an opportunity to review the conditions?
- Can I request that the implementation date be postponed until I receive and review the complete accommodation in writing?
- If the employer approves a 3x10 schedule but does not specifically identify my workdays, four consecutive days off, or restrictions on additional overnight on-call assignments, does that actually constitute an effective accommodation?
- Can management continue assigning me additional workdays or overnight on-call responsibilities outside my approved schedule if those assignments interfere with my documented medical limitations?
- Does the fact that I previously maintained a negotiated 3x10 schedule for approximately 18 months have any significance when determining whether this is a reasonable accommodation?
- What protections do I have under the ADA and Washington State employment laws if management continues pressuring me to work outside my documented medical restrictions?
- If I decline the proposed ADA accommodation because there are so many unanswered questions and concerns, do I have the right to apply for unemployment benefits? Would I potentially qualify, or would I risk being denied benefits if I voluntarily decline the proposed accommodation or leave my employment?
- Can an employer put a proposed ADA accommodation into effect and change an employee's upcoming work schedule before the employee has agreed to the arrangement or had an opportunity to review the complete written terms? In my situation, I specifically told HR that I needed additional time and had not agreed to the proposed accommodation. However, after my shift, I found an updated schedule in my work mailbox showing the proposed changes for the following week. Is management allowed to do this, or should the employer continue the interactive process and address the employee's outstanding questions before treating the accommodation as finalized?
Final Thoughts
I want to continue working for the company. I'm not asking to be treated differently or to avoid my responsibilities. I'm simply trying to maintain a consistent part-time schedule that accommodates my medical conditions and allows me to continue doing my job.
I have tried working with management, previously negotiated a schedule that worked for approximately 18 months, and now gone through the formal ADA process with medical documentation from my physician.
I feel like I am continually having to fight to maintain a reasonable schedule that allows me to work while managing my medical conditions.
I would appreciate advice from anyone familiar with ADA accommodations, Washington employment law, unemployment eligibility, or similar workplace situations.
Thank you for taking the time to read my situation. Any advice or personal experiences would be appreciated.