r/AskHR • • Feb 02 '24

Career Development ASK YOUR CAREER QUESTIONS HERE!

73 Upvotes

How to get into HR, etc.


r/AskHR • • May 12 '26

AI posts will result in an instant ban.

55 Upvotes

Also, stop asking to post your research surveys.


r/AskHR • • 1h ago

[CAN-ON] Possible Outcomes?

0 Upvotes

Not my first time in this situation. I am being trained to take over an individual role. The woman training me has allegedly purchased a home and is retiring and moving two hours away.

She is a very bossy woman and she speaks to everyone there terribly. She tattles on EVERYTHING. It has taken time to quietly separate what is actually part of my role as front desk and what are rules she made up and management does not actually support.

One example is we do the employee mastercard statements. They send in their receipts and I match to statement. However, she is also training me to challenge and argue purchases with site managers. I do not believe it is my authority at all to question site managers on their buisness purchases. I also dont feel comfortable telling my VP and coworkers they arent allowed to work fom home, call in sick etc. It is not my job to track other departments attendance or procide disciplinary action. When I very politely express this, she gets very angry and says they will walk all over me.

As her last day comes closer, she is becoming reactive, critical and her already very controlling personality is smothering me. I feel she is becoming regretful of leaving this position. I worry she is going to complain and all of a sudden say I am a bad fit when I know I am a great fit.

Is there also any insight on how HR may view a complaint from her about me? And if ive been hired and onboarded but she wants the job back, am I possibly not secure?


r/AskHR • • 4h ago

Workplace Issues [IN] Final Warning…Gone Right?

1 Upvotes

[IN] In October, I was issued a final warning which in my org means you have 30 days to improve or else. Also a final warning cannot be reversed, restricts internal job transfer for 12 months and makes one ineligible for an annual raise. I truly think the final warning was a bunch of admin mistakes to mask her retaliation of me taking pto for my learning and development to learn skills for my role on my own. My manager has always discouraged me to do these extra learnings. Plus, this all started as a verbal warning that was rescinded then in two weeks she went to the extreme with the final warning. I mainly think this is about the warning because ever since the warning my manager hasn’t actually mentioned it at all. It’s like she completely moved on, isn’t concerned about the things she put into the warning, etc. She has treated me warm and kind in front of others and even privately in my 1:1s ever since. It’s now been about 15 days since the 30 day period should have ended and still no confirmation if I’m safe or not. I tried explaining this to my ER rep and she kept endlessly rescheduling our meeting to when I had conflicts. I also requested my HR business partner to be present in my 1:1s (to secretly get a witness to the warning never being acknowledged) and she routed me to ER. I’m just tossed back and forth. It’s bizarre as if this whole thing never happened even though the impact on my growth with in the org now is stunted. I definitely don’t feel psychologically safe to keep working here, and plan to leave, but just trying to make sense of it all. Any thoughts?


r/AskHR • • 5h ago

[CA] GF unexpectedly placed on PIP shortly before maternity leave after positive reviews and no previous warnings. How should she approach this?

0 Upvotes

My girlfriend works for a private company in California and is expecting our first child early next year.

She's been with the company for several years. Last year, she received a strong performance evaluation and a merit increase. Throughout this year, she says she continued receiving positive feedback and was never told that her performance was seriously deficient.

She's also been pursuing a promotion for roughly two years, without success.

Her annual performance review was delayed by several months (~4 months). There were legitimate management absences that help explain the delay, so we aren't assuming that the postponement itself was deliberate.

However, when the review finally happened, she was unexpectedly placed on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).

Management identified two broad categories of concern:

  1. Communication skills

They allege that her interactions can sometimes come across as dismissive or diminishing toward less experienced colleagues.

They haven't provided specific examples of what she allegedly said or did. They cited confidentiality concerns when asked about the feedback.

She respects the need to protect colleagues' identities but wants to understand which behaviors need to change.

2. Technical and work-related performance

Management cited some examples that she disputes. From her perspective, several involved ordinary requests for clarification rather than mistakes, missed deadlines, or deficient work.

She wants to understand what standards she allegedly failed to meet and what measurable improvement is expected.

The most confusing aspect is that these serious concerns were not raised during regular feedback conversations earlier in the year.

Her employer knows she is pregnant, and her previously approved, extended maternity leave is approaching soon. She has only a few scheduled workweeks remaining.

We want to handle this professionally and avoid unnecessary conflict during an already stressful time.

Questions for HR professionals and managers:

  1. Is it reasonable to request specific behavioral examples while respecting the confidentiality of colleagues who provided feedback?
  2. What level of detail and measurable criteria would you normally expect in a legitimate PIP?
  3. How should a PIP be handled when an employee has only a few working weeks remaining before previously approved maternity leave?
  4. How would you advise an employee to document disagreements with performance feedback without appearing defensive or uncooperative?
  5. Is it unusual to move directly to a PIP without earlier coaching, or does this sometimes happen for legitimate reasons?

We're also considering a consultation with a California employment attorney to understand the interaction between the PIP, pregnancy-related protections, and her leave.

I would particularly appreciate practical advice from people who have handled similar situations, whether as employees, managers, or HR professionals.

Thank you.


r/AskHR • • 6h ago

Resignation/Termination [NY] need advice on termination from firm

0 Upvotes

My boyfriend was recently terminated from a hedge fund after the company said coworkers had overheard some inappropriate joke he made at work. He had no prior warnings so it was random

He got a separation package that has salary continuation for a couple of months , a severance payment, and a waiver of his noncompete.

Problem is he just accepted an offer at another fund and was planning to give notice in January. He just submitted his background check for the new firm the day before he was terminated and asked that they don’t not contact his current employer until later.

  1. Should he proactively tell the new firm that his employment has ended so the November termination date doesn’t raise questions when the background check company eventually contacts his former employer? Or is it better to wait unless they ask, since his information was accurate when submitted?
  2. Since his noncompete has been waived, he’s now available to start much sooner than originally planned. Should he reach out to the firm to discuss moving up his start date? If so, should he mention that he’s no longer employed, or simply say his availability has changed? Im sure they’ll ask why - what should he say?

I think he should tell them because he can’t afford to wait til end of next year and can start now but worried they might rescind the offer


r/AskHR • • 6h ago

[WY] Already contacted HR, what else can I do?

0 Upvotes

Hi all, first time poster so forgive me if I don't know appropriate abbreviations or honestly whether this is even an HR issue, I think there are a few routes I need to pursue, please point me in the right direction(s) if you can.

This will also likely be a quite long winded post as well as I try to include all pertinent details, sorry in advance. 

----

I've worked at my current job in food service (at a college cafeteria, running the salad bar, training all new hires, and filling in elsewhere including caterings whenever needed) for a little over a year, the pay is decent for where I live, they offer benefits, and they are closed for a portion of the year (winter break for a month, and summer break for 2ish months) which to me is a plus, as I work on a lot of side projects in my off time and can collect unemployment that allows me to pay my bills while I'm out of work. 

The issue is that based on her behavior and management style, it seems that my boss isn't really qualified to be my boss (I'll elaborate why in a moment, I promise I'm not trying to be demeaning for no reason) and she still manages to nitpick and micromanage mine and my coworkers work almost daily, this is often due to unclear expectations / lack of signage / lack of verbal and written communication/ etc., in addition to seemingly holding grudges against certain employees that don't listen to her without question. 

Example: a coworker recently asked our boss for Thanksgiving week (a very slow week for us, few customers) off on short notice due to some recent personal developments, and after having already asked another coworker of similar skill level to cover her shifts, receiving an affirmative answer from said coworker. Our boss threw a fit and turned it into a lecture, and then left a copy of our attendance policy that referenced the two week's notice required to request vacation off. This has never happened before, and until maybe 2 weeks ago or so, she had been making the schedule a day or so before it would kick in. Very rarely would we get it a week in advance, and couldn't make plans of our own in advance as a result unless we specifically asked for it. This coworker has been targeted consistently about her attendance (tardies, not absences) in a way that others have not, and often butts heads with the boss for various valid reasons.

I was quickly asked to train new hires within about 2 months of being hired, and requested a raise if I were to do so, which I received, but only after about 2 months of doing so. I've gone above and beyond to make changes to the training procedures which were all but nonexistent; created updated, concise signage for new trainees to refer to in order to increase efficiency and prevent waste of product; and asked for hold standards to be posted for us to refer to in order to properly rotate product, as it was not available previously. Now looking back, this may have been a mistake on my part.  

As soon as I started working, I noticed the lack of reference material (storage standards, training manuals, deep clean lists / schedules, etc) that is typical of other food establishments. I also noticed the lack of consistent schedule and inability to accommodate employee schedule requests without making a fuss. There is no availability sheet filled out when new hires fill out paperwork. This is a first for me. 

Example: I have a fairly open schedule, I only ask that 1. my days off are consecutive, 2. if I work 12 hour shifts that I get an extra day off instead of my other work days being shorter, and 3. I once asked that my weekends off rotate every other week to match my husbands schedule which she immediately agreed to. She has repeatedly had to be reminded of these things and it has become exhausting, I offered the idea of an availability sheet and she shot it down, saying that she is running a business and ultimately has the last say in whether she will accommodate someone's schedule. She also often gives single parents grief for when they have to miss work due to lack of childcare. 

In the past year, I've learned a lot about the inner workings of our business and found some concerning blind spots that have been missed in previous years. Some of which include but are not limited to:

No clear expectation of specific job duties, a lot of "robbing Peter to pay Paul" so to speak.

Example:

Borrowing dish staff to perform foh duties / catering duties in addition to day to day operations due to lack of sufficient staffing. Expecting FOH people to keep up on BOH duties.

Deep fryers (that are used to fry both shellfish and gluten-containing foods in addition to regular fried fare, using high temp rated peanut oil) never having been boiled out in at least the last 4 years if not longer, instead they scraped off the blackened burnt on oil with a spatula and used hot soapy water. 

Management dismissing employee concerns (sometimes aggressively so) about cross contact issues in shared fryers in which would necessitate allergen documentation for consumers. Claiming that "the high heat kills/removes the allergens, and that's from my boss", I pushed back on this claim after having done my own research / refreshed my allergen training recently and was met with hostility. 

Boss encouraging new hires not to give previous jobs 2 weeks notice, as well as poaching new hires from other jobs on false pretenses / offering a schedule she doesn't actually plan to give them.

Rampant nepotism / favoritism.

Example:

Not holding employees clearly in violation of attendance policy (4-5 no call no shows) accountable, while harassing others for minor offenses. No regard at all for the point system whatsoever, I didn't even know it existed until a month ago. Threatens using it when it suits her. 

Disregard for the safety of those we serve

Example:

She plays poker with a group of folks, and sometimes she invites them in to eat. One of them that she brings in most frequently is a registered sex offender with a violent criminal record. We are open to the public and therefore anyone can reasonably come in and eat, but honestly our location is so far off the beaten path that almost no outside customers know we exist, the only reason he comes in is because of her. And yes, she is aware of his RSO status. She's brought him in and eaten with him at least 3 separate times. The students we feed are around the same age as the victim listed in the info on his offense. She claims she brought my concern surrounding this to HR, but they found no issue. I was not present for that conversation.

---

I asked for a meeting with HR to discuss these and other issues, and was told by HR to "stay in my lane", and that it sounded like I was too concerned with telling my boss how to do her job. 

My goal is not to tell her how to do her job or step unnecessarily on toes, my goal is to keep our food safe for consumers, provide a safe environment for our college students, and to get the turnover rate to a slightly less atrocious level, because it directly affects me (as well as their bottom line, training is expensive, and people previously would often train for a month) when I'm constantly training people and also expected to do my regular job. But ultimately she has been more concerned with finding small things to fixate on than the bigger issues, and creates a toxic work environment that engenders fear of retaliation and avoidance of conflict, and conversely, overt rebellion of certain expectations due to lack of respect, and hostility between coworkers and management.

When I mentioned all of this to my boss in a conversation not including HR, but instead our other manager, and explained that I didn't wish to step down but instead that I'd like to see some change in the way people are treated, I was told verbatim that "my concerns aren't real".

I know not much can be done unless my coworkers also go to HR and mention their experiences and therefore create a written record, but what other concrete actions can I take? I really don't want to just quit. I really like my coworkers and my job for the pay. 


r/AskHR • • 7h ago

Workplace Issues [IL] Direct report said I'm singling him out due fmla

0 Upvotes

have a team of five people; only one had FMLA and accommodations. The employee requested a full day off on one of our busiest days. I denied it. He called out on that day. I reported him for insubordination, and he told hr that the appointment was an FMLA absence. Now I know he'd had FMLA before this and approved those days without a problem. However, I needed a full team that day. Well HR came back and basically told me that next time have him write FMLA on the sheet. Well, he has since reported to the third-party website AGAIN stating that I am singling him out because he has FMLA.

I have had issues with this employee, but nothing outrageous. We really just don't like each other. He's a good worker otherwise. I'm looking to see if we can get him switched to another team but idk. In the meantime, Every time I asked if this is an FMLA approved absence, he would say he doesn't know if it applies and would keep in contact with HR regarding the matter. I don't have to track the absences or anything. I just want to make sure that if I'm denying an absence, I won't be in trouble.

I feel like hR has told me the wrong thing (after what I've found on the internet)? He attached an email I sent stating how he is different from anyone else on the team and so that's why he has to put FMLA on paper as proof of discrimination. Help me out with this one 😂


r/AskHR • • 8h ago

Recruitment & Talent Acquisition [KS] ghosted post interview x3

0 Upvotes

Can’t figure it out. We moved to this state so my wife can go to a certain school. In our original state I was a hot commodity, never had a crap interview and could always find a job. In my career field based on credentials and experience, on paper I am probably in the top 20%, maybe top 10% nationally in my career. I’m having interviews here in Kansas, they seem to go well. I am an older professional so I can normally see issues quickly. During the interviews all is well, great conversations and synergy, I literally can’t think of anything. I have senior people saying I really like you and can see you on the team. I’m excited and looking forward to a call. Heck, one of them told me that company orientation started three weeks after the interview. I thought I was just waiting for something official. All three interviews, I sent a follow up thank you email. After a couple weeks of no commo I called and left a voicemail. A week after that I sent a follow up to check in, ask about the orientation.
Nothing. No call. No text. No email. No snail mail. Nothing.
I am so damn confused. Makes no sense. Is it just coincidence? Is there some weird secret database I don’t know about with my name in it? Is there a service I can pay to basically act like a potential employer and call around for references and do research or digging?
The only thing online that would or could have any negative vibe is that like 15 years ago, I happened upon a man trying to unalive a lady and I intervened. There was security video that was released and out in the public. Guy was found guilty. So all of the online stuff talks about hero this or hero that, it’s all so old.
I’m at a loss. No clue what to do.
Should also probably add I am a combat veteran and I am considered 100% disabled by the government but like I’m good. I have scars here and there and things but I work. It shouldn’t be a thing.
Sigh


r/AskHR • • 8h ago

Employee Relations [IL]

0 Upvotes

I’ve been working for a corporate company for the last three months. I got called into my Managers office to discuss a workplace conversation that I had. They said that I was reported to HR regarding comments I made that weren’t true. After four different conversations with Direct managers and my HRBP, I am now being asked to give a written statement even though I was told this wouldn’t be the case. I’m concerned about providing one because my own words could be used against me. I really could use some advice on what I should do. If I refuse to make a written statement, am I going to be fired?


r/AskHR • • 15h ago

[MI] My employer makes me use 2 days of PTO before I can use my accrued Sick Time

0 Upvotes

Context: I am currently out of work with the flu. I called in on Thursday and Friday. My manager asked me if I would like to take my PTO hours for my time off. I told her that I had enough sick time available and would like to take that as I am sick. She stated that company policy was that I had to burn 2 days of PTO before I could use my earned sick time. Is this a violation of ESTA? Doesn't this make ESTA hard to use for the average employee.

We have 3 leave banks. PTO, EST (earned sick time) and ELB (extended leave bank). I work at a large business that isn't a collective bargaining unit.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Resignation/Termination False accusations [UK]

5 Upvotes

So i have just started work being an apprentice at a job a few months ago and once a month for a week all apprentices meet for classroom lessons.

Suddenly mid-week i call called and asked to leave the site as i have been saying racist and sexist comments to other students!

I was with another student at the time when they got a call saying can he confirm i have been saying hate speech towards his race and religion and then (the caller) named all these awful things like "your a dirty muslim" and "you wanna touch children" and the apprentice denied all these clames at the time but he seemed really suspicious and was rushing me to leave him alone.

Now the other person is a girl who i have been "sexist" too however im not even joking around here i have NEVER SPOKEN A WORD TO HER!! I barely knew she existed but now i have been told i have been saying she is "too weak" and "women should not be doing a trades course".

I feel like i am being bullied and target to get fired by these other students but i have no idea the motive?! I have known them for barely even a few weeks and have been very quiet and to myself during this time. All i can say is i have not said ANY of these awful words but it seems the other students have a freind group that all agree i said them?!

Im being bullied and nobody in the workplace believes me i feel like im going insane!

What can i possibly do to defend myself when its me against a group of bullies?


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

[PA] Inappropriate Personnel Sharing Consequences

32 Upvotes

Hi! Looking for some insight into this situation.

My husband got a second job at a large department store working overnights for some extra cash. His ex's husband is a supervisor at said store, but not in the same department as my husband. My husband reported the income to the child support office and they said he did not need to do anything further.

His ex then files for modification and specifically puts his start date of employment in the filing. My husband nor the child support office told her about the employment, yet she had specific dates. My husband works 2 shifts before needing to go on a medical leave and unsure of when he can return.

Today was the child support conference and his ex brings PRINT OUTS of my husband's personnel file with his wage, his availability, his clock ins and outs, his dates of work, etc. She openly admitted her husband retrieved these documents. Her own lawyer pulled her from the room and berated her so loud everyone could hear. My husband's attorney made sure all of it will be documented in their report. Additionally, she knew that he was on a leave but "not an official medical leave, it was a verbal agreement to be taken off the schedule" which is accurate.

My question is--from an employer standpoint, is this a fire-able offense? My husband no longer feels comfortable working at this place and won't return. He wants to report this once the child support conference report is available and I am just curious what could happen.


r/AskHR • • 15h ago

Workplace Issues Racist Coworker [CAN-ON]

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskHR • • 18h ago

Unemployment [WA] ADA ACCOMMODATION AND UNEMPLOYMENT

0 Upvotes

Ada unemployment questions

Unemployment question

Title: Question About ADA Accommodations, Previously Negotiated Part-Time Schedule, and Employer Changing My Work Schedule (Washington State)

Hello, and thank you for taking the time to read my question. I'm looking for advice regarding my employment situation, ADA accommodations, and my rights as an employee in Washington State.

I've worked for the same healthcare company for approximately 6–7 years total.

Over the past year, the work environment has become increasingly hostile and stressful. There has been very little consistency with scheduling. Work hours change frequently, schedules are sometimes released with less than seven days' notice, and overnight on-call assignments change from week to week. This has made maintaining a reasonable work-life balance extremely difficult.

Background and Original Work Arrangement

I previously left this company because the workload had become overwhelming. At that time, I was working four 10-hour shifts per week (4x10s) and was assigned approximately three overnight on-call shifts each week. I was regularly working 40–50 hours per week and had been doing this for more than two years.

I was often asked to work additional nights and received pushback when I declined. I was also expected to work national holidays and was not given the option to take those days off.

I repeatedly asked for a reduction in overnight responsibilities so I could have a better work-life balance, but I continually received pushback. Eventually, I felt like I was drowning in work and had no life outside of my job, so I left.

Approximately a year later, a previous supervisor contacted me to see if I would reconsider returning because the company was short-staffed. I initially had no intention of returning, but they asked what they could do to convince me to come back.

I negotiated a verbal agreement for a part-time schedule consisting of three 10-hour shifts per week (3x10), with two overnight on-call assignments associated with my scheduled workdays.

The understanding was that I would be responsible for my designated workdays and overnight responsibilities. Any coverage needed outside those days would be the manager's responsibility to arrange.

I specifically requested this part-time arrangement because I have several medical conditions and injuries related to my military service. I have ongoing medical appointments and physical limitations. Because of the physical demands of my job, I cannot consistently work a full-time schedule.

The verbal agreement was communicated to company HR, and I understood that I was grandfathered into this arrangement. I believed the agreement would remain in place for the duration of my employment unless I decided to leave the company.

I was able to maintain this arrangement for approximately a year and a half.

Change in Management and Scheduling Issues

A new supervisor eventually took over. From the beginning, she started pushing me to work a full-time schedule.

I had numerous conversations with management explaining that I had returned under a negotiated part-time arrangement and wanted to continue working the schedule I had maintained for approximately 18 months.

I asked whether there was still a part-time option. I was told there was not and that I needed to work full-time because of business needs.

Essentially, I felt forced to accept a full-time schedule because I was concerned about losing my job.

The company began changing my workdays, hours, and overnight on-call assignments every few weeks. This made it extremely difficult to schedule and attend medical appointments through the VA.

Some of my appointments require traveling outside my immediate area to different cities in Washington and Oregon. Having an unpredictable schedule made coordinating these appointments increasingly difficult.

Request for ADA Accommodation and Intermittent Leave

Because management was no longer honoring the previous scheduling arrangement, I submitted a formal ADA accommodation request and intermittent medical leave paperwork.

My physician completed the necessary documentation supporting my need for a consistent three-day work schedule consisting of three consecutive 10-hour shifts, followed by four consecutive days off.

The purpose of this arrangement is to allow me to attend necessary medical appointments and give my body sufficient time to recover from the physical demands of my job.

I waited more than a month for the company to process my ADA accommodation request. During that time, I contacted HR to ask about the delay because I was continuing to work a full-time schedule that I had never agreed to.

After I sent an email to the HR department questioning the delay and expressing my concerns about how long the ADA process was taking, the company suddenly expedited the request and came back with a proposed accommodation in less than a week.

I felt that I was being rushed into accepting the accommodation without having all of my concerns addressed.

Recent ADA Accommodation Approval and Additional Concerns

Eventually, the company came back with a proposed 3x10 schedule that they indicated would accommodate my ADA request.

An HR representative contacted me on Tuesday, late in the business day, to discuss the proposed arrangement. Before agreeing, I had additional questions that needed to be answered.

HR indicated that she would need to research my questions and get back to me.

I was out sick on Thursday and was not able to return her call until Friday. Because I was working when HR contacted me, I did not have an opportunity to fully review or understand the proposed schedule.

I am also a visual person, and I wanted to see the actual schedule and conditions in writing rather than trying to understand everything through conversations and text messages.

I felt like I was being rushed into accepting an arrangement before my questions had been properly answered. I was concerned that I would not have sufficient time to review the agreement, obtain clarification, and have my VA representative review it and provide feedback.

My Concerns About the Written ADA Accommodation

A third-party company that handles the ADA accommodation process subsequently approved or issued the accommodation with an effective date of the following week.

However, the finalized accommodation document did not include the specific details I had requested.

For example, it did not clearly identify:

\\- My specific three scheduled workdays.

\\- My actual 10-hour work shifts.

\\- Confirmation that I would receive four consecutive days off.

\\- Whether I could be assigned overnight on-call responsibilities outside my scheduled workdays.

\\- What procedures would apply if I needed to call out for medical reasons.

\\- Whether management could continue changing my schedule or assigning additional days outside the agreed arrangement.

\\- How time-off requests and absences would be handled, particularly because the proposed schedule included a weekend day.

The last point is particularly concerning because my supervisor has previously denied time-off requests submitted approximately three weeks in advance, stating that they did not meet business needs, even though I provided what I believed was appropriate advance notice.

The proposed accommodation also did not explain what would happen if I needed to call out or take medical leave on one of my scheduled workdays.

These are important details because I have previously had verbal agreements with management that I believed would protect my schedule, only to have those arrangements changed later.

I specifically asked HR to put the details in writing to prevent the same situation from happening again.

HR did send me a text message containing some partial information, but those details were not included in the finalized ADA accommodation document.

I also have not physically received a copy of the finalized accommodation letter by email, despite being told that it had been sent.

Request for Additional Time to Review the Accommodation

The company wanted the proposed accommodation to begin the following week, during the last week of November and over Thanksgiving weekend.

I had previously requested time off for that holiday weekend because I had already purchased an out-of-state plane ticket. My time-off request was denied, despite being submitted in advance.

As a result, I am now out the money I spent on the ticket and will miss my yearly opportunity to visit friends and family.

I requested December 1 as the start date for the proposed ADA accommodation. This would give me time to receive and review the complete written accommodation, have a VA representative review it, ask any additional questions, and make sure the terms accurately reflect my medical needs.

I explained to HR that I was not ready to agree to the proposed accommodation until I had an opportunity to review all the details in writing.

I am not refusing an accommodation. I am trying to make sure that the accommodation actually addresses the medical limitations documented by my physician.

What concerns me even more is what happened after I communicated that I was not ready to agree to the proposed accommodation.

After completing my shift, I returned to the workplace to turn in paperwork. When I checked my work mailbox, I found an updated work schedule for the following week. The schedule already reflected the changes outlined in the proposed ADA accommodation.

I had not agreed to the proposed arrangement, confirmed that I accepted its terms, or received answers to my outstanding questions. I had specifically asked for additional time to review everything and requested December 1 as the implementation date.

Despite this, management had apparently already prepared and distributed the new schedule as though the accommodation had been finalized and accepted.

At that point, I felt like I was being forced to agree to the new ADA accommodation because the company was already moving forward with the schedule before I had agreed to it.

I am concerned that management is treating the proposed accommodation as final without allowing me a reasonable opportunity to review the complete written terms and address the issues I raised.

Given my previous experience with verbal agreements and management subsequently changing my schedule, I do not feel comfortable relying on another verbal understanding.

My Questions

  1. Can an employer consider an ADA accommodation finalized and implement it when the employee has not received the complete written terms or had an opportunity to review the conditions?
  2. Can I request that the implementation date be postponed until I receive and review the complete accommodation in writing?
  3. If the employer approves a 3x10 schedule but does not specifically identify my workdays, four consecutive days off, or restrictions on additional overnight on-call assignments, does that actually constitute an effective accommodation?
  4. Can management continue assigning me additional workdays or overnight on-call responsibilities outside my approved schedule if those assignments interfere with my documented medical limitations?
  5. Does the fact that I previously maintained a negotiated 3x10 schedule for approximately 18 months have any significance when determining whether this is a reasonable accommodation?
  6. What protections do I have under the ADA and Washington State employment laws if management continues pressuring me to work outside my documented medical restrictions?
  7. If I decline the proposed ADA accommodation because there are so many unanswered questions and concerns, do I have the right to apply for unemployment benefits? Would I potentially qualify, or would I risk being denied benefits if I voluntarily decline the proposed accommodation or leave my employment?
  8. Can an employer put a proposed ADA accommodation into effect and change an employee's upcoming work schedule before the employee has agreed to the arrangement or had an opportunity to review the complete written terms? In my situation, I specifically told HR that I needed additional time and had not agreed to the proposed accommodation. However, after my shift, I found an updated schedule in my work mailbox showing the proposed changes for the following week. Is management allowed to do this, or should the employer continue the interactive process and address the employee's outstanding questions before treating the accommodation as finalized?

Final Thoughts

I want to continue working for the company. I'm not asking to be treated differently or to avoid my responsibilities. I'm simply trying to maintain a consistent part-time schedule that accommodates my medical conditions and allows me to continue doing my job.

I have tried working with management, previously negotiated a schedule that worked for approximately 18 months, and now gone through the formal ADA process with medical documentation from my physician.

I feel like I am continually having to fight to maintain a reasonable schedule that allows me to work while managing my medical conditions.

I would appreciate advice from anyone familiar with ADA accommodations, Washington employment law, unemployment eligibility, or similar workplace situations.

Thank you for taking the time to read my situation. Any advice or personal experiences would be appreciated.


r/AskHR • • 19h ago

United States Specific Doing the same work as senior colleagues without the title or compensation. Is HR worth involving, or should I just leave? [OH]

0 Upvotes

I’m on a team of seven, and over the past five years I’ve taken on increasingly complex responsibilities. At this point, I independently own the work for an entire business unit and do essentially the same work as the senior level ICs on my team. We have the same responsibilities, decision making authority, and level of ownership.

For the past year, I’ve repeatedly brought up the lack of distinction between my role and the senior positions. The difference isn't just the title or salary, either. Senior employees receive annual bonuses that I'm not eligible for. I also feel like my current title is holding me back when applying externally because it doesn't reflect the level of work I'm actually doing.

What's especially frustrating is that two former managers independently recommended me for promotion. The first recommended me after a previous reorganization, before the current VP joined the company. She later left, and I inherited her responsibilities. Her replacement also recommended me during the most recent review cycle but was subsequently laid off.

Since then, the new department head has continued pushing the conversation to future review cycles. We had one in September, but nothing happened. Now he's saying he wants to wait until a replacement director is hired and potentially revisit things in another year.

I'm honestly at my breaking point. I enjoy the actual work, but I'm starting to feel taken advantage of. It's becoming difficult to stay motivated when I'm expected to perform at the same level as senior colleagues without the recognition or compensation.

I've started pulling back from going above and beyond because I don't see the point anymore. I don't want to damage my reputation, but I also don't want to keep taking on senior level responsibilities indefinitely with no clear path forward.

Has anyone dealt with something similar? Would involving HR actually accomplish anything, or would I just be putting a target on my back? At this point, am I better off focusing entirely on finding another job?


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Employee Relations [TX] Manager shared personal information to customer

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

btw pp means pet parent at petsmart


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

[NY] PFL and NYS STD for pregnancy without FMLA protections

0 Upvotes

I'm a part time NYS employee (not NYC) who is scheduled for less than 20 hours a week (though I believe my actual average is 18-20 hours due to picking up extra coverage shifts). I have worked for 175+ actual working days for this same employer so I believe I'm covered for NYS PFL. I did not opt out of it NYS PFL and have always paid into it.

I'm currently 7.5 months pregnant and I've had a very difficult time getting any information from my employer/HR during the pregnancy. We work at a location an hour away from the admin offices/HR team so most of my communication is with my direct boss at my workplace. This direct boss recently requested to know what my plan is for leave, so I ended up sending an email and cc'ing HR. In my email, I said I tentatively planned on taking the 6-8 weeks of NYS STD and the 12 weeks of PFL. I acknowledged that all of this was dependent on what I qualify for. My employer hasn't provided a specific policy about maternity leave and I haven't found anything in our handbook, other than a seemingly outdated policy about general STD.

I don't want to give many details to protect anonymity, but due to my specific job responsibilities and scheduling, I may have to take leave towards the end of pregnancy (prior to delivery) because it will likely be unsafe for myself and others at the workplace if I go into labor/need to leave immediately while at work. I typically work alone. I have specifically asked if I could be scheduled with someone towards the end of pregnancy to prevent this issue and haven't gotten a direct response other than a suggestion that I could leave if I contacted someone close by for coverage, though I have concerns about legal liability if I leave my workplace unattended due to the nature of my work. I mostly work overnights so getting someone to answer a call in the middle of the night has proven difficult in the past.

The only response I got to my leave plans was an email from HR saying I don't qualify for FMLA (which I acknowledge is true) and that we can "reevaluate closer to my due date to see if I meet the hours required". There's 10 weeks until my due date. By my calculations, the only way I'd meet the FMLA requirement at this point is if I worked more than 40 hours a week until my due date, so that seems to be a moot point . I'm aware that I don't qualify for FMLA in terms of job protection, but I believe NYS PFL has job protection and I qualify for that, so I'm confused/concerned by this response. Am I completely misunderstanding the laws/protections in place?


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

[NY] Is a one-sided 90-day resignation notice requirement common?

0 Upvotes

I'm reviewing a healthcare employment agreement that requires employees to give 90 days' notice when resigning, but doesn't require the employer to provide any notice when terminating without cause.

The agreement also allows the employer to remove the employee from their duties at any point during the 90-day notice period, without explicitly guaranteeing continued pay.

I'm curious how HR professionals view arrangements like this.

  • Is this a common provision in healthcare employment contracts?
  • What's the rationale for requiring 90 days from employees without a corresponding obligation for the employer?
  • If an employee gives notice and the employer immediately removes them from the schedule, would they typically continue receiving pay?
  • What happens in practice if an employee resigns without giving the full 90 days?
  • Is this the kind of provision HR departments are generally willing to negotiate?

I'd be interested in hearing how organizations actually handle these situations, particularly from anyone who has administered or enforced similar agreements.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

[GA] Mismanaged Layoff and Continuation of Benefits

0 Upvotes

[GA] - I have unfortunately been laid off multiple times, however this last one has been a messy, horrible experience. While employed, the company was extremely cheap and that included available benefit plans. I have had to actively ASK for applications, addresses, etc. Even my severance and separation papers were late and/or incorrect. This has continued when it comes to COBRA servicing. To date, my health insurance has been cancelled and reinstated TWICE because my employer failed to submit records/payments. I STILL am trying to get a life insurance conversion, because the documents provided to me and the address for premiums was out of date. Even after working with the provider directly, they are still slow to process anything. Since June. Today, I became aware that the employer's open enrollment period has already ended and COBRA enrollees were never notified. I have reached out to HR and they have told me "oops" and blamed it on the carrier I selected last year. Which why would company X, have anything to do with providing me access to open enrollment options? After today's call they are claiming and open enrollment packet "should arrive in a few weeks." There's only six weeks left in the year.

Who do I complain to? I have made multiple calls and emails to my employer's benefits, the involved carriers, etc. They all point the finger back at each other. I did speak to yet another person on the life insurance front (this time directly with a VP at the insurer; probably because my last email mentioned making a complaint with the insurance commission) and not their third-party administrator, but I am apparently stuck with a very expensive medical plan and no way to change it, unless they come through on the promised packet. Which I don't trust, given my current experiences.

Any guidance would be greatly appreciated.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Resignation/Termination [WA] Why would an employer want you to sign an affidavit?

0 Upvotes

My boyfriend told me he was fired for phone use. I saw his manager had sent him a message to come in and sign an affidavit. I've never had to do this when leaving a job, is this normal? Is there something he might not be telling me? Something feels off


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Off Topic / Other [FL] I mistakenly listed client company rather than 3rd-party service on background check. Now I'm being asked to verify W2. Am I going to get my offer rescinded now?

0 Upvotes

So I accepted an offer from company X and currently in the background check stage. Last summer, I interned for company Y, but I was actually employed by company Z for payroll and tax purposes. When filling out the form, I didn't think much of it and just put company Y. Like 30 minutes later, I realized I messed up, but it was too late since I already submitted. I assumed they would just call company Y and verify that way. I got an email asking to verify employment for company Y. Now, there's going to be a mismatch since my W2 will say company Z.

I can prove 100% I interned for the company I said I interned for, but there's just a mismatch in employer name that I messed up. For example, I have an offer letter, letter from my supervisor saying when I interned for company Y. In addition, I can also probably produce verification letters from HRs of both company Y and Z if I ask them.

Am I going to get my offer rescinded now or what?


r/AskHR • • 2d ago

United States Specific What is considered a reasonable accommodation for a severe allergy? [WY]

48 Upvotes

Wyoming, USA

I (37f) have worked at my job for 8 years. I also have a well documented cinnamon and banana allergy. I can't even walk past cinnamon pinecone or scented candles, or be in a room with someone eating a banana, or something heavily cinnamon without having a reaction. Most of the time the in the air reaction isnt anaphylactic. Unless someone has heated something up in a microwave that is heavily cinnamon, and then I heat my food up in the same microwave after that will trigger anaphylaxis. Also something to note my work has know about my allergies and medical issues since I interviewed. My work does not have a break room for employees. I work at something similar to a recreation center with a pool and what not. I am the receptionist essentially. The other employees have a room off the pool for when they aren't lifegaurding ect. It is a very small room with barely any room for those on shift to sit, and one more body makes things cramped. While I could use that microwave, it is kinda far from the front desk, and I don't have good line of sight to the front desk. The concessions area is directly across from the desk, and I can stand in the doorway to concessions and see the desk at the same time. The only employees allowed in concessions is reception, supervisors, managers and concession workers. There is a refrigerator in the office directly behind the reception area. In the 8 years I have worked there i have never had an issue.

On to the issue! On Friday, November 13th, I took my meal into concessions, and I didnt notice anything different until after heating up my dinner. I started eating it and closed the door with a waft of air from the microwave hit me in the face. Full blast of cinnamon scented air. I had a minor panic because I had already started eating my dinner. Well with in 15 to 20 minutes I started exhibiting symptoms. I was able to go to the ER and be treated for anaphylaxis. I am ok now.

I know that allergies are covered under the ADA for reasonable accommodations. My question is would it be too much to ask if I ask to bring in a small microwave that has a note for no cinnamon or banana in microwave? There is room next to the refrigerator in the office directly behind the reception area. How far is a reasonable accommodation for an allergy?


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Employee Relations [TX] Manager shared personal information to customer

0 Upvotes

Ok, so today at work I just found out that after this one pet parent had been going back and forth with my SL about a bad service I did (I cleaned that dog so good, and it was my best clean to date), that my SL had told them that the reason I performed the service poorly was that I have autism. I have been thinking recently that I'm somewhere on the spectrum, but I have never taken a test or been diagnosed, nor have I said or submitted anything to the higher-ups. This means that not only is this an ADA violation, but she is also making up lies about her employees to get the angry pp off her back. On a personal level, this really rubs me the wrong way. Because I've been pondering about being on the spectrum; her just taking a look at me and labeling me as autistic is just so wrong on many levels. The employees at this store have had many o problems with this SL for a while now, and this is just my last straw with her. Luckily, the angry pet parent is a school teacher, so she knows it's wrong to release this information, so apparently she made a report about this. I am gonna make a report to HR soon and email her boss, but I'm wondering if there's anything else I can do about this. This incident was horrible, and I'm worried that they will just sweep my complaint under the rug.