r/AskJews • • Nov 14 '25

Welcome to r/AskJews!

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone, and welcome to r/AskJews!

Why does this subreddit exist when there are plenty of other Jewish spaces on the site? Well, we created this community as a space explicitly for curious people to ask questions and for Jews of all kinds to answer. Other Jewish spaces on Reddit are typically for Jews, not about Jews, which is an important distinction. As Jews are not a monolith, the answers you find here might not be representative of Jews at large, but rest assured they will be answered by people who have signed up to hear your questions, rather than people frustrated that you are coming into their space.

While we get the space set up, please leave us feedback! We'd love to hear your thoughts.


r/AskJews • • 15h ago

I (Catholic) had a strange interaction the other day and it made me curious.

3 Upvotes

I wanna start this post off with the obligatory ‘I come in peace’. I really don’t know much about you guys’ faith or culture, and I don’t want to say anything that comes off offensive or disrespectful.

The other day, I was out at a local pond fishing, and as I was walking around the little path around it, I passed by an older gentleman that had a Star of David pendant on, with a menorah over it. I wear my rosary around my neck, and under my shirt (we’re not supposed to wear the rosary over clothing or in any way that makes it an ‘accessory’). Anyway, I nodded and gave him a casual ‘hey how’s it going’, and he pointed out the beads around my neck, to which I told him it was my rosary. He returned something of a dirty look and just walked off.

I didn’t think much of it in the moment, but given the current political climate it did make me curious, is there somewhat of a reactionary rise in resentment towards Christians amongst the Jewish community? I know folks with a disdain towards Christians likely don’t represent the entirety of the Jewish community, but I’m not in these circles as I really don’t know any Jews personally, is this something you guys are seeing more commonly as of late? I know as a Christian there is a lot of propaganda floating around in certain circles of ‘the Jews did _____’ ‘it’s all the Jews’. This is nothing new but it’s definitely becoming more widespread, and seeing this personally I feel I’d be naive to believe that there’s no Jews seeing it and breeding their own disdain for Christians as a result.

This is a genuine question and I mean no offense to you guys, I just wanted to get some feedback from an actual Jewish community, rather than throwing the question to the wind in ‘regular’ social media circles where the propaganda is rampant.


r/AskJews • • 13h ago

Where did the Star of David originate?

2 Upvotes

r/AskJews • • 1d ago

My choir is performing a Hanukkah song at the holiday concert, and I have some questions.

4 Upvotes

I’m in the mid-level choir at my high school, and one of the songs we’re performing at our school’s holiday concert is Hanerot Halalu. There are three solos at the beginning, and I want to know if it would be appropriate for me, as an agnostic who celebrates Christmas, to audition for a solo. There are no other solos available, I’m not picking this song out of multiple options. Also, if I do audition and I get a solo, would it be appropriate to wear a Christmas necklace with red and green star and tree charms on it for the concert? I can’t take it off for the solo, either I wear it for the whole concert or I don’t wear it at all. Thank you!


r/AskJews • • 2d ago

Are there any special Jewish Thanksgiving customs?

0 Upvotes

This well be my first a Thanksgiving with my child's grandparents. I understand they a Jewish. Is there anything I should know about traditional Jewish Thanksgiving customs? Are there any weird foods involved?


r/AskJews • • 3d ago

B’nai Mitzvah etiquette

2 Upvotes

My daughter will be attending a joint mitzvah for twins (1 boy, 1 girl). She is friends through sports with the girl but has never met the boy. The invitation is referred to as B’nai Mitzvah for both, so it’s not 2 events happening at the same time, but one event. I assume she should bring a gift for both of them (2 gifts, not a joint gift just to be clear) but I just want to make sure that isn’t weird or something. Thank you for any advice.


r/AskJews • • 3d ago

would it be alright if I as a non Jewish person who has Jewish ancestors wear the star of David?

0 Upvotes

I am what I consider an agnostic pagan (getting less and less agnostic by the day) i plan on eventually working my way up to eclectic paganism where I'd practice aspects of both Judaism and Celtic paganism, i want to respect my Jewish ancestors and the best way I can think to do that is by respecting people who are currently Jewish so I thought best to ask before I do anything that might be disrespectful, would it be alright for me to wear a necklace with the star of David on it? if not is there a more acceptable symbol i can wear? and would it be alright for me to wear it side by side with a pagan symbol?


r/AskJews • • 4d ago

Do trans men need a bris?

8 Upvotes

Im Jewish myself, but I’ve never thought of this as I’m a cis woman. I go to a Conservative shul, if that matters. I was wondering if a Jewish trans man or a trans man who later converts needs anything resembling a bris if they have bottom surgery done? While this is purely theoretical, this feels like something that has probably come up in shuls, especially Reform and Conservative shuls, more than once. I’d love if someone more educated than me had any input into this.


r/AskJews • • 4d ago

How can I help my spouse with our child’s hewing upbringing?

4 Upvotes

First off, me and my husband are both men and we are both Israeli, but we live in the U.S. He’s jewish, and I’m from a Melkite catholic family. We are currently expecting a child, with help from an egg donor and our friend Yael. We are incredibly happy, and he have decided that we will raise him Jewish. I’m not Jewish, but I want to help contribute to our son’s religious formation. Does anyone have any advice or experience that could help? Thank you!


r/AskJews • • 5d ago

Can I still feel connected to the Jewish people despite not being fully Jewish?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’ve been thinking about something lately and wanted to hear your perspectives.
My father is Jewish, while my mother isn’t. I wasn’t really raised in a Jewish household, and Judaism wasn’t a particularly big part of my upbringing. Because of that, I sometimes feel a little disconnected from that side of my heritage.
At the same time, I have a surprisingly strong connection to my Jewish roots. A large part of my family is Jewish, and I feel that this is an important part of who I am, even though I haven’t necessarily grown up practising the religion or participating in Jewish traditions.
Sometimes I wonder whether it’s okay for me to feel like I’m part of the Jewish people, or whether I’m somehow claiming an identity that isn’t entirely mine.
I’m aware that according to traditional Jewish law, Jewish status is generally passed down through the mother. I’m not necessarily asking about religious status, though. I’m more interested in cultural identity, heritage and belonging.
I’d especially like to hear from people who might have a similar family background. How do you view someone with a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother who still feels a strong connection to the Jewish people?
I’d genuinely appreciate hearing your thoughts.


r/AskJews • • 7d ago

What made Chanukah magical for you growing up?

5 Upvotes

Hi Reddit!

I’ve been converting to Reform Judaism for about a year and a half. I grew up in a loosely Christian household—we celebrated the holidays but rarely went to church—and I identified as agnostic, although I’ve long felt drawn to Judaism. My conversion is almost complete!

Something I’ve been thinking about as the holidays approach in the U.S. is how to create that childhood sense of magic for myself and my future family, whether we have a Jewish or interfaith household.

Holidays growing up were really special to me. I wholeheartedly believed in Santa until the fifth grade!! That year, on the drive home from my uncle’s on Christmas Eve, my brother told me Santa wasn’t real. This was probably the third year in a row he’d told me this—but this time my parents didn’t correct him. It. Was. Heartbreaking. Beyond that, though, I loved helping my mom decorate the Christmas tree and hang lights, making reindeer food and spreading it on the front lawn, and setting out cookies and milk for Santa on Christmas Eve.

I’m also a natural host. I love inviting friends over for dinners, throwing baby showers, and finding any excuse for a party, complete with homemade meals, decorations, and likely a new outfit. I’m excited to bring that energy to a Jewish home, but I don’t have childhood Jewish traditions to draw from.

This is where my question comes in—if you grew up in a Jewish home, what made you love Chanukah?

I’m especially curious about Chanukah because of how present Christmas is in the U.S., but I’d love to hear about the whole Jewish year. I feel like I’ve found my footing with Shabbat, Yom Kippur, Rosh Hashanah, and Sukkot, but if you have any traditions you’d like to share, please do. Also, if you grew up somewhere with a very small Jewish population, as I did, did you feel left out around Christmas and Easter? Did your family do anything that helped you feel excited about your own traditions or proud to be Jewish?

I also have mixed feelings about things like “Mensch on a Bench.” It seems cute and reminds me of the kind of holiday fun I imagined creating with my future children, but I’m still figuring out how I feel about “borrowing” from Christmas traditions, even when the adaptation was created by someone Jewish—let me know your thoughts!

Part of this is reimagining what the holidays will look like for me moving forward, both on my own and with my future family. I had always pictured celebrating Christmas, and now I’m imagining celebrating an equally magical Chanukah and/or creating an interfaith holiday season. I’d love to hear what you treasured growing up, which traditions you’ve carried into your own home, and any new ones you’ve created.


r/AskJews • • 9d ago

Menorah Q from a non-Jew

9 Upvotes

Hi all!

I am not Jewish but was wondering whether it would be acceptable to light a menorah throughout this year’s Hanukkah. My grandparents are Jewish (though we aren’t technically related and so I have no Jewish ancestry, I consider them to be grandparent figures, especially my grandmother) and I’d like the connection with them. Though he died many years ago, my grandmother’s father was a Holocaust survivor and I still think of him quite a bit - it feels to me like a way to honor him, though I really only knew him as a child. I can’t remember the company that sponsors this, but I did print a menorah out last year and stuck it to my window, which I know touched my grandmother, but I thought making it more of a real moment this year could be nice.

With the rise in antisemitism, I thought it could additionally be a way of showing people in my neighborhood some support (as little as it might be) and that ours was a safe home.

I of course wouldn’t be reciting any prayers, just thinking of some loved ones.

If this is an inappropriate question, I deeply apologize.

May you all have wonderful celebrations!


r/AskJews • • 9d ago

how do you view soviet jewish people?

5 Upvotes

this is kind of a personal question i suppose, but how do jews from around the world view jews from the (former) soviet union, many of whom were atheists and/or disconnected from culturally jewish traditions?

i myself am from a family of soviet-raised jews. my family was not religious and didn't speak any yiddish. we never cooked traditional jewish food or anything like that. nonetheless, my family considers themselves russian jewish and it's a huge part of how they view themselves and their place in society. they made sure i knew i was jewish from a very young age.

what's interesting is how their jewishness actually manifested. my grandparents lived in a small town and all of their friends were either jews or ethnic germans. i guess it made sense for minorities, fifth columnists etc, to stick together. all the people in their circle were very educated and somewhat anti-government, so in their mind, and later in mine, being jewish became synonymous with being an intellectual and possibly a dissident. i guess i should also mention that my family members did face antisemitism through out their lives due to having very jewish names.

but now, as i get older, i'm starting to wonder what kind of right do i even have to call myself jewish, considering i know next to nothing of "real" jewish traditions, have no interest in israel, and very little ties to judaism. you could suggest i start learning about those traditions now, but the funny things is, none of those things are what "being jewish" means to me. to me it was always the way my soviet jewish grandparents understood it, which was, be dissident, stand up for other oppressed people and work twice as hard as everyone else because you are a minority. but now i'm wondering, was that an actual soviet jewish identity, or just the soviet intelligentsia identity in general? can those be separated?

I guess i'm interested in how other jewish people view people like us. do you consider soviet jewish diaspora to have their own unique cultural traditions, if those can be counted as such?


r/AskJews • • 9d ago

Question about hair and mourning

1 Upvotes

Hi Art student here! I’m doing some research about different cultures’ mourning traditions specifically in relation to hair. Suuuper random, I know. I was looking into Jewish mourning traditions and the restrictions that come with Sheloshim which to my understanding is a 30-day period of mourning where the cutting or shaving of hair is prohibited. (Also another source said that Certain sects of ancient Judaism used to shave their heads in association with mourning.) Please correct me if I am wrong + would love to know more about this tradition any fun facts would be awesome too!


r/AskJews • • 9d ago

What to get the girl I babysit for her Bat Mitzvah?

7 Upvotes

I’m going to my first Bat Mitzvah next weekend! I’m super excited, it’s for the older sister of the family I babysit. I’m technically “working”, as I’ll be with her little sister for the day and evening but of course I still want to get her something special. I want to give her something more meaningful than cash. I’m in NYC so any cute shop recommendations are greatly appreciated! Thank you :)


r/AskJews • • 11d ago

Dating when your goal is to be a rabbi

0 Upvotes

Hi there. I’m Reform and I plan to go to rabbinical school, obviously to become a rabbi. Now I’m trans masc, currently single and trying to date seriously. Would it be easier to date after I get ordained or before? Should I tell potential partners that I want to be a rabbi? How difficult would it be to date as a rabbi?


r/AskJews • • 11d ago

Who do you feel a connection with? Those with Jewish identity, those with Jewish maternal lineage, or anybody with Jewish ancestry?

4 Upvotes

I am Hungarian and I have some Jewish ancestry (from my father's side). I have often been asked by both Jews and non-Jews if I was Jewish because supposedly "I look kind of Jewish, but they are not sure". I also work as a doctor, which is common for profession for Jewish people here. However, my family is Christian and doesn't do anything Jewish. I also don't have any close relatives who practice Judaism, because as far as I was told, nearly all of the Jewish relatives were murdered in the Holocaust.

In my case, is there or should there any connection exist between myself and the Jewish people in your opinion?


r/AskJews • • 12d ago

Is it okay to wish Happy High Holiday's to my friends?

3 Upvotes

hello everyone! I'm a Christian. Is it okay to wish Happy High Holiday's to my friends? I have 4 Jewish friends. * means code names the first two are McKenzie* and Maxwell, they're twins. McKenzie told me that they're Jewish and told me her dad wears a kippah. Maxwell on the other hand, told me that they are Reform Jews and don't attend synagogue often. Maxwell doesn't wear a kippah. my friend Rory* told me she converted from Christianity to Judaism, I'm not sure if she had a Bat Mitzvah but she's apart her local BBYO and she wears the Star of David regularly and celebrates the High Holidays. lastly, my mutual Dahlia*. Dahlia* and I aren't close. she is in an organization I'm apart of, but we had only few conversations- she's very busy. I know she serves in a Jewish summer camp every summer, she had a Bat Mitzvah, and is very proud of being Jewish.


r/AskJews • • 12d ago

How do Jews view God?

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I hope this is the right place to ask this.

I have been reading about catholic guilt recently, and the way people who were raised catholic view God.

They way I understand it, among catholics there is this idea that God doesn't necessarily love you; he is just but cruel; that God let his son die for your sins, and since there's still sin in this world, it is your fault, and your resposibility to make it right. Basically God wants you to suffer precisely because he loves you, because you grow through suffering.

I wonder how jewish people see God. Is this perception similar to that of catholics?


r/AskJews • • 13d ago

Question from partner about ‘Sabbath Goys’

2 Upvotes

Hi all! I’ve got a question for everyone on behalf of my boyfriend. I (31 F) was raised going to a conservative synagogue but am less religious these days. He (30 M) was raised Catholic but is very intrigued by the differences between his upbringing and a Jewish one, so he’s been asking me a lot of questions, and I’ve got one that I’d like to ‘share with the class’.

Specifically, he was curious about Sabbath Goys. He asked me if I knew whether synagogues have designated people to handle things during the Sabbath. I’ve explained to him the concept of homes that have light covers or timers, and how more observant people might leave their oven on to avoid having to turn it on during the weekend. So he is now kind of excited about the thought of being able to volunteer for members of the community to be that person that can go help out someone keeping the Sabbath. And he specifically asked if synagogues have people designated in that role or if they look for volunteers to do that sort of thing at the synagogue itself in the event of maintenance or emergencies that happen that need to be handled, but it’s during the Sabbath.

So basically, I’m curious if anyone has heard of that because I don’t recall that being a thing at the synagogue I grew up at and while I’ve heard of people assisting the orthodox during the Sabbath I have not heard of a specific position that is advertised. So I was just kind of curious for additional perspectives…he does not plan on converting when we marry but is very supportive of us raising any children Jewish and would like to be an active member of the community in his way.

He’s very excited to read the responses and appreciates the insight! 🙌🏻


r/AskJews • • 12d ago

Am I Jewish or not?

0 Upvotes

for one, people are telling me that I’m Jewish, and others telling me I’m not, so im wondering if I am or aren’t.

My biological dad is a jewish jew of mixed Ashkenazi and Mizrahi descent, and my mom is an indigenous Christan of Jaffa. They never married and I’m pretty much an accident to sum it up.

I do not feel connected to judaism or my Jewish descent, I am a christian and my culture is the same of my mom.

am I or am I not? cause I know I’m not halakhaly Jewish but I’m looking for a clear answer.


r/AskJews • • 13d ago

Meeting my boyfriend's Jewish aunt?

5 Upvotes

So this Friday, I'm going to be meeting my boyfriend's aunt for the first time. She is a Jewish convert (she converted when he was very young I believe?) and observes a lot of the traditions like resting on the sabbath. She said she can receive visitors on Friday before sundown, so we're going to see her in the early afternoon this Friday.

My boyfriend is non-religious (as am I) and he doesn't know a ton about his aunt's religious practices, other than the dietary guidelines and observing the sabbath. Is there anything I should know before meeting her? I just want to be as respectful as possible and don't want to overstep or cause any sort of offense from my lack of knowledge of Jewish traditions/practices.

Thank you so much in advance! 💜


r/AskJews • • 14d ago

I am from Pakistan and want to learn

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am from Karachi, Pakistan. I have a lot of respect for Jewish people and I want to learn about Judaism from real Jewish people, not from Google. Can someone be my friend and answer my questions? Thank you.


r/AskJews • • 13d ago

Do you think Judaism has a problem with institutionalized sexism, particularly regarding the different expectations placed on men and women?

0 Upvotes

r/AskJews • • 14d ago

Is practicing Kabbalah wrong?

4 Upvotes

My partner is part of a somewhat eclectic and esoteric spirituality circle. They are in a discord and apparently one of the group members who joined originally practices his own version of Kabbalah and is trying to build a temple in his own area. He’s not super active but posts every once in a while to promote his temple.

This has been a huge point of contention as a few new people joined the group, found out he was in it, and then got really mad. There was a huge disagreement between everyone. They said it was cultural appropriation and the group basically said he was here to stay, take it or leave it. Then they left.

Now he’s mad at the founder and they’re no longer friends and I’m so relieved because I hated him too. He wasn’t terribly active anyway.

Since then, I have noticed a large degree of tolerance among non news practicing Kabbalah in a lot of spirituality or witch circles and it makes me extremely uncomfortable. I don’t know much about Judaism at all so I’m not sure if I’m just being weird or if it is cultural appropriation. It feels wrong to me but I also don’t know any practicing Jews to ask.