I'm 24M, and I've been thinking about this quite a bit lately. I'm curious to hear perspectives from both men and women, especially about how attraction works beyond conventional physical appearance.
Growing up, I was the typical academically focused kid. I had a crush in 10th standard, but never really made a move. Like most teenagers, I cared about my appearance, hairstyle, dressing neatly, looking good, etc. Back then, I had a pretty straightforward understanding of attraction: handsome guys have it easy. They're the ones girls notice, and if they make an effort, they can probably attract whoever they're interested in.
During pre-university, I got into a relationship through a friends-to-lovers situation. I didn't actively pursue her or do anything particularly impressive. She liked the way I cared about her, we got close, and eventually things developed naturally.
Then came university. For almost four years, I genuinely didn't care about dating. I wasn't actively looking for anyone, but nobody really approached me either. I didn't think too much about it because I always assumed that girls rarely make the first move, especially in India. Usually, guys approach girls, or relationships develop through friendships.
I also didn't consider myself unattractive. I'm reasonably tall (around 5'10"), had an average build, and thought I looked decent. I wasn't some exceptionally handsome guy, but I didn't think I was below average either. However, after university, I started noticing things that completely challenged my understanding of attraction.
First experience:
I had a close male friend during university. We were both academically and technically good, participated in competitions, had similar achievements, and were reasonably popular in our circles. After university, we attended an event together. There was a girl who seemed noticeably interested in him. She kept looking at him, eventually waved at him while leaving, and he followed up by connecting with her on LinkedIn. They're now in a relationship and have been together for around two years. What surprised me wasn't that he found someone. It was that someone had noticed him, shown interest, and initiated things. He wasn't particularly confident, wasn't exceptionally handsome, and had a pretty average build. In terms of achievements and social standing, we were quite similar. I remember wondering: we were both there, we had similar qualities, but someone noticed him that way. What was I missing?
Second experience:
I have another male friend who's relatively short, dark-skinned, and has an average/slim build. He isn't particularly muscular or conventionally what I'd consider the stereotypical handsome guy. Yet he's had multiple instances of women approaching him, texting him first, expressing interest, and initiating romantic interactions. Interestingly, he's not even particularly active on Instagram or other social media platforms. His personality isn't necessarily what you'd expect either. He's not always the soft, sweet, exceptionally considerate kind of guy. He can be egoistic, sometimes ghosts people, and has his flaws. Yet women have been interested in him, sometimes quite openly. This again challenged my assumption that women generally pursue only tall, fair, fit or exceptionally handsome men.
Third experience:
More recently, I had a conversation with a junior from college. He's around 5'7"-5'8", considerably overweight, and has a visible belly and chest fat. He's genuinely cute and reasonably handsome, but certainly doesn't fit the stereotypical image of a fit or conventionally attractive man. He shared several instances of women approaching him, expressing interest, and initiating conversations. He even showed me some of those interactions. And these weren't just one-off incidents. He had multiple stories. The interesting part is that we studied at the same college. So I couldn't help wondering how two people from the same environment could have such different experiences.
These experiences have made me question almost everything I believed growing up. I used to think that if a guy was reasonably handsome, tall, fit, well-dressed, successful, etc., women would naturally notice him and potentially approach him. Now I'm seeing examples of men who don't necessarily fit those conventional standards having women actively show interest in them.
Meanwhile, I'm someone who considers himself reasonably good-looking, funny, caring, socially comfortable, and reasonably accomplished. I have plenty of female friends who enjoy my company, but I've rarely experienced someone showing explicit romantic interest in me or making the first move.
I'm not saying this out of resentment, jealousy, or an expectation that women owe me attention. I'm genuinely trying to understand what I'm missing. I also wonder whether being passive about dating plays a bigger role than I realise. I've spent most of my adult life not actively pursuing anyone, so perhaps I haven't created enough opportunities either but to be honest, the guy in second experience I mentioned never really actively looked/looking to date anyone either.
Would love to hear some honest experiences and perspectives.