r/AskNetsec • • 15h ago

Architecture How much do you trust the cross-account roles your SaaS vendors ask for?

1 Upvotes

Some of the IAM templates SaaS vendors ask you to deploy are pretty generous.

i get why they do it. easier to support one template than deal with different permissions for every customer.

but if a monitoring tool only needs certain API calls, why give it access to so much else?

RCPs are interesting for restricting external access to resources, although you've still got to deal with what the vendor can do once it's assumed a role in your account.

Sonrai uses org-level policies to block unused privileged permissions. Act Security looks at what the identity can actually reach and which of those paths can be closed. my agency does work for Act, hence my interest in that side of it.

anyone managed to get a SaaS vendor to accept a more restrictive IAM policy than their default template?


r/AskNetsec • • 21h ago

Other Anyone compared CAASM tools for pulling asset data together and figuring out ownership?

2 Upvotes

We are looking at cyber asset attack surface management tools, or asset intelligence depending on the vendor. Mainly we want one place that pulls from EDR, cloud, AD and the CMDB, shows what’s missing coverage, and helps us figure out who owns things. From what I have read, axonius is strong on pulling those sources together, JupiterOne is more about graph queries and relationships, and Armis comes up a lot for IoT and OT, which isn’t really our problem. Has anyone used more than one? Mostly wondering how much cleanup each needed before the data was actually useful.


r/AskNetsec • • 2d ago

Analysis If an offline Raspberry Pi read data from another PC’s HDMI output, could that PC exploit it?

7 Upvotes

Hypothetical question. Say you connect a Raspberry Pi to another computer’s HDMI output (through a splitter and an HDMI capture board), and the Pi reads small blocks of data encoded in the pixels on screen.

Assume the PC is fully compromised, so the attacker controls every pixel the Pi sees. The Pi would have no network connection at all: no Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Ethernet or SSH.

  1. Could the PC attack or take over the Pi just through the video signal?
  2. Are there HDMI-level risks (EDID, HDCP, CEC, InfoFrames) or known bugs in HDMI capture chips or their drivers that would matter here?
  3. Could the PC tell the Pi is there, and would that help an attacker?
  4. What would you do to make the Pi side as safe as possible?

Just curious where this kind of setup would break.


r/AskNetsec • • 2d ago

Other Better ways to prevent customers from giving verification codes to phone scammers?

6 Upvotes

We've seen a number of incidents recently where customers have been handing over their one time passcodes to scammers, who are impersonating a bank representative over the phone. The calls usually involve scammers convincing someone that there has been activity on their account and that they need to secure their accounts.

It can be hard to catch them because some of these scammers are even spoofing our official phone numbers, so there's very little reason to doubt them. We've added more notices to our app, reminded people that our staff will never need your codes but people are still getting scammed.

I'm starting to wonder if SMS verification is becoming more trouble than it's worth. I've also heard of carrier based authentication and device bound passkeys but unsure how viable these solutions are. All the cases I've seen have been victims who truly believe they are working with our security team and the saddest thing is that most of them are older customers.

Do you guys think it makes sense to move away from verification codes? What do you think is the solution for this?


r/AskNetsec • • 3d ago Bravo

Analysis 40,000 failed logons overnight on one jump host and nothing alerted.

39 Upvotes

Our RDP jump host is only reachable through an IP allowlist and one of the ranges on it turned out to be stale. Overnight the box racked up about 40,000 failed logons (4625s) on Server 2019 and nobody knew until a user got locked out in the morning. No SOC here, it's two of us covering IT and security, so anything we alert on has to be quiet enough that we don't start muting it.

What thresholds are you actually using for failed logon bursts on a box like this, per account, per source IP, per minute? And what's doing the alerting, so it catches this without burying a small team?


r/AskNetsec • • 2d ago

Analysis Threat Hunting & Incident Response Workflows

3 Upvotes

How do people approach their IR and threat hunting workflows on a daily basis? Seems theres always a temptation for overload or losing focus!


r/AskNetsec • • 3d ago

Threats which kind of monitoring and alerting you have for threat detection for a homelab?

5 Upvotes

How do you know when a homelab has been compromised? What or which hardware/software do you use to collect logs, analyze behavior and alert on malicious activity?


r/AskNetsec • • 2d ago

Architecture What does your Patching Landscape look like?

0 Upvotes

I am  a CyberSecurity Student at Eastern Michigan University and I am trying to work through an issue that my organization has with patching. Right now we're looking through possible solutions and issues we have with our system and I wanted to understand what other people in the industry were doing.

Please note that if you feel like any of these questions are inappropriate to share with someone who does not work for your company please feel free to ignore them. I don't want anyone getting into trouble for this project.

 

Team Structure & Responsibilities: Which team(s) handle asset management and patch management in your organization (e.g., dedicated Security team, IT Operations, SysAdmins)?

 

Roughly how large is the team handling this?

 

Environment Scale & Scope: Approximately how many devices does the team manage (e.g., under 500, 1k–5k, 10k+)? Are these mostly centralized, or spread across multiple regional/global locations?

 

Tooling & Solutions: What platform(s) or toolsets do you currently rely on for asset management and patch distribution?

 

Overall System Efficacy: On a high level, how well would you say your current patching workflow meets your organization's compliance targets?

 

Success Factors: What is the single biggest factor (process, automation, policy, or culture) that helps your team maintain high patching compliance?

 

Pain Points & Wish List: If you could improve or fix one thing about your current patching setup, what would it be?

I'll start and reply below if that helps.


r/AskNetsec • • 4d ago

Architecture Looking to automate end-to-end PSIRT vulnerability report triage. Any suggestion

11 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm exploring ways to automate our PSIRT vulnerability intake and triage process. We currently receive vulnerability submissions from security researchers through email.

I'd like to build an end-to-end automation workflow covering:

  1. Email Intake: Automatically capture incoming vulnerability reports and extract relevant details.
  2. Report Validation: Identify missing information such as affected product/version, reproduction steps, PoC, impact, etc.
  3. Automated Responses: Acknowledge submissions and automatically draft/send emails requesting all missing details from researchers.
  4. Deduplication: Identify duplicate submissions by comparing vulnerability descriptions, affected components, endpoints, and PoCs.
  5. Initial Triage: Classify vulnerabilities using CWE, estimate CVSS severity, and identify potential false positives.
  6. Tracking: Generate unique report IDs and track submission status, researcher communication, and remediation progress.

I'm interested in automating as much of this process as possible using AI/LLMs, Python, n8n, Power Automate, Jira, or other tools.

A few questions:

- Has anyone implemented something similar?
- What tools or architecture would you recommend?
- How can we implement intelligent vulnerability deduplication?
- Are there existing solutions for automated report validation and researcher communication?
- Any recommendations for building this securely without exposing vulnerability details to external AI services?

Would appreciate practical suggestions, tools, and implementation experiences.

Thanks!


r/AskNetsec • • 3d ago

Work AI SOC tools vs SOAR, what actually makes analysts' jobs easier?

7 Upvotes

We've been looking at a few tools lately, including Tines, Mate, and Dropzone, to understand where AI SOC platforms actually fit compared to traditional SOAR.

I'm less interested in whether a tool calls itself AI-powered and more interested in whether it makes analysts' work easier. Better context, faster investigations, less manual triage, and fewer things slipping through the cracks.

One thing I'm curious about is how these platforms handle context spread across different systems. A lot of useful information lives in Slack conversations and ticketing systems, not just security alerts.

For those using any of these tools, what has actually made a difference in your day-to-day SOC workflow? And where do you still find yourself doing things manually?


r/AskNetsec • • 3d ago

Analysis how are you checking vulnerability scanning coverage against what actually exist??

2 Upvotes

what evidence you ask for when the vulnerability report says scanning coverage is good.

A completed scan job doesn’t tell you whether every host was included, or whether the credentials worked and the authenticated checks actually ran. That makes it hard to know what “95% coverage” really means.

If you’ve got Nucleus or Brinqa sitting over your scanners, how is your team checking that number against cloud inventory, EDR or the CMDB? mostly interested in what gives you confidence the report includes the blind spots, and what your team still has to verify by hand.


r/AskNetsec • • 5d ago

Concepts what vulnerability management metrics are actually worth opening???

17 Upvotes

our open count keeps jumping every time scan coverage grows, and closing a pile of easy lows makes the chart look great even when nothing important moved.

we moved everything into Nucleus earlier this year so pulling the numbers is the easy part now, it’s picking the right ones that’s hard. I’m leaning toward time to fix exploited vulns and how long things sit overdue on critical systems, with coverage reported separately.

what do you actually track, and what did you stop reporting because you had to explain it every time someone saw the chart?


r/AskNetsec • • 5d ago

Other I want suggestions on SOC automation stack

11 Upvotes

I am asked to design and setup an enterprise grade SOC automation stack for our security team.

Reason for agentic: No spare analyst time

Reason for vendor agnostic: Cost effective & feasible to have every component working on our existing tools without us replacing any of them

These are the components I choose:

Sentinel

Splunk

CrowdStrike

Okta

Jira

For this i am planning to use Mate or Dropzone for the triage and investigation layer

The project is still in design and POC stage. So I am open for suggestions and improvements.

Thanks in advance!


r/AskNetsec • • 6d ago

Other Would you spend your only pen test this year on staging?

6 Upvotes

Staging runs the same build as prod, but the login is different and the payment gateway is in sandbox mode. Those are two of the bits I’d most want someone to test. If you had the budget for one web app pen test, how would you split the time? I’m leaning towards doing most of it in staging and agreeing on a handful of checks in prod. For anyone who’s done that, what did you wish you’d put in scope before you signed the quote?


r/AskNetsec • • 6d ago

Concepts How do you manage recurring, known-benign alerts in Elastic Security?

2 Upvotes

I'm working with Elastic Security and have a recurring alert that triggers for the same user and behavior roughly once a week.

We've investigated it and currently consider the activity benign. However, I don't want to suppress the alert entirely, because I still want analysts to see every new occurrence and be able to track its history.

Keeping one case open indefinitely feels awkward, but closing each occurrence separately makes it difficult to maintain a continuous history.

How do you handle this in your SOC? Is there a common approach or feature in Elastic Security for tracking recurring activity while preserving visibility into every occurrence?


r/AskNetsec • • 7d ago

Analysis Your attack-surface scan may be quieter than it should be — OWASP Amass v5 silently skips two enumeration techniques

0 Upvotes

If you pinned v5 in a pipeline after the rewrite: -alts (name alterations) and -brute (wordlist brute force) are accepted by the CLI and ignored by the engine — exit 0, plugin "started," zero candidates. Wordlist brute force from v4 hasn't been ported at all (#1122). Passive sources still work fine.

Why this matters for blue/purple: a recon tool that reports success while skipping techniques you asked for makes your external asset map smaller than reality. Worth a re-run once the fix lands ([PR #1161]) or on v4 if you depended on those techniques.

Bonus silent failure: 48 possible API data sources, one YAML file, no feedback when a key is in the wrong shape — proposed a wizard for that [#1159], built here: github repo

Full technical write-up on medium


r/AskNetsec • • 7d ago

Threats LiteLLM's leaked key was deleted from the repo but never revoked, how fast do you kill a leaked key?

19 Upvotes

LiteLLMs root cause report has the bit worth reading twice. an admin key for their internal agent platform got committed to a public repo on may 27. the file was deleted a few hours later but the commit stayed in public history and the key was never revoked. in october though, it got used to pull a github token and ship a backdoored release and microsoft says attackers are now running agent tooling over github for exposed keys, one case reportedly went from scanning to pulling data out of key vault in about five minutes

so the order seems to be revoke at the provider first, clean history after. past that its short lived keys (sts, vault leases, hush security etc) and one key per app so killing it isnt an outage call


r/AskNetsec • • 7d ago

Analysis How can a tool accept your command-line flag and still have it "not arrive" where it's used? (real example from OWASP Amass v5)

0 Upvotes

Short version for anyone learning: modern Go tools are often split into two programs (CLI + engine) that talk over HTTP. The CLI turns your flags into a struct and sends it as JSON. The engine unmarshals it into a fresh struct. If a field is tagged json:"-" in Go, it means "never send, never receive" — the CLI set it to true, the engine received false, the plugin looked at false and did nothing. Program exits 0.

json:"-" is not a comment. It's a wire-protocol decision. Real-world example and fix: article on medium, PR: [#1161].


r/AskNetsec • • 7d ago

Architecture What's a good AI agent harness for cybersecurity work with multiple AI subscriptions?

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to set up something for pentesting. I already have multiple AI subscriptions (Claude, ChatGPT) and ideally want to use those for research work they wont refuse while having an uncensored api model as their orchestrator, managing them and prompt refusals.

I've looked into Pi and OpenCode but I'm not sure which one would be best for this or if there's something better, while having their plugins to use my codex and claude subscription usage.

Has anyone set up something similar?


r/AskNetsec • • 8d ago

Other AI agent runtime security: how to sanitize prompts of secrets before agents store/use it

10 Upvotes

I used Claude Code (Anthropic) at our org. And sometimes the agents/claude code use env tokens or stored secrets.

Is there a way where we can strip the prompts of the secrets/access keys before it reaches the agent. Something like prompt going into a lambda and getting sanitized before AI using it.

I know some repos on GitHub that help find leaked secrets in prompt logs but those are when the prompt logs are stored. I’m seriously thinking about setting up a Capsule or Prompt Security POC, but I want to know if there is a way where the llm/agent doesn’t even see the secret, if it goes into the prompt (by stripping it beforehand)


r/AskNetsec • • 9d ago

Architecture Palo Alto Networks alternatives for AI security?

14 Upvotes

Recently sat through a Palo Alto demo for Prisma AIRS and their AI access piece and it was impressive. We’re not a Palo Alto shop for anything else and a lot of the value seemed to come from already being on their platform. So before going any further I want to see what else is out there.

For context, we’re 500 people across 4 offices. We’re also covered on firewalls and EDR, so this is purely about AI security.

What are people using or evaluating for this?


r/AskNetsec • • 10d ago

Compliance How did you replace Veracode’s policy reporting for auditors?

7 Upvotes

We’re replacing veracode when the contract ends in march for around 120 apps, mostly java and .NET, audited every year for PCI and SOC 2. The POC is down to checkmarx and snyk and on the scanning side I’d be fine with either. Checkmarx found more in our older java code and snyk was easier for the devs.

Our auditors are used to Veracode’s reporting where every app has a policy, each scan passes or fails against it and the auditor gets a pdf per app plus the mitigation history showing who approved each one. They’ve seen that format three years running.

Things I have to keep

  • a pass or fail per app against a written policy
  • how long findings have been open against our SLA, by severity
  • who accepted a risk, when and until when
  • one page for the risk committee every quarter

How do you cover these for your auditors?


r/AskNetsec • • 10d ago

Other AI SOC tools for alert triage,, which one better at investigation? any experience?

4 Upvotes

company trying improve SOC triage, we evaluating mate and prophet, also looked at dropzone. main focus for us is alert triage, not so much the rest of soar stuff

what we care most is tool knowing what normal for us, like service account that always noisy, change that already approved, or alert someone already closed before. Speed also but more interested what happen after, when tool actually close or escalate it


r/AskNetsec • • 10d ago

Architecture CyberArk, Delinea or BeyondTrust for SSH and RDP access with session recording?

4 Upvotes

CyberArk, Delinea and BeyondTrust are the commercial options I'm comparing for controlled SSH and RDP access to servers with session recording. I also have JumpServer's GPL-3.0 Community Edition on the list after a quick test where it let me SSH to a host without ever seeing the target account's password. I haven't done a PoC with any of the three commercial ones yet.

For anyone who ran a PoC of two of these or runs one in production, what ended up being the deciding factor?