r/AskReddit • • 22h ago

What is the worst video game mechanic ever?

2.0k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

41

u/bpaps 22h ago

Motion blur.

21

u/ikantolol 22h ago

that's more like a graphic option rather than a mechanic.

4

u/DarlinInThePranxx 22h ago

This is true tho but I get your point too u/bpaps.

→ More replies (2)

3.5k

u/nickel47 21h ago

Defend this NPC. NPC proceeds to run in and fight everyone with a tree branch/ fists

1.0k

u/Paliampel 21h ago • Regret Bravo

In Divinity 2: Original Sin there is a mage NPC who will start the combat with a fire explosion spell. In an oil field. Usually resulting in his and your death. So the common tactic is to lure him into a tent and barricade it with some boxes for his own safety until the fight is over

→ More replies (13)

55

u/andbruno 19h ago

This is one reason Bioshock Infinite was great. You spend at least half of the game escorting Elizabeth, but they straight up tell you "Elizabeth can take care of herself, so don't worry." She keeps up with you, can't be killed, and even tosses you health or ammo when you're low on either.

141

u/illz569 20h ago

I would love, just one time, to have a mission where you're supposed to defend an NPC against a horde of enemies, and then the character in question proceeds to mow them all down like the Terminator while you just watch.

→ More replies (11)

72

u/IAMEPSIL0N 21h ago

NPC is slower than your run, faster than your walk, panics and pees their pants if you run ahead during sections you know are safe for them, will then run into combat unarmed when you hit the ambush sections. Only thing better is when on top of all of that they aren't considered an ally for targetting purposes on smart skills / spells that can normally AOE the mess of enemies while leaving allies unharmed so you also can't even use your banked panic ability to save them as it will hurt them too.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/SpoonsAreEvil 21h ago

Bonus points if at the end of the fight they have to first run back to their last location before the fight to pick the trail back up again.

31

u/Culbrelai 21h ago

God damn you Captain Keyes

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (28)

9.7k

u/texasinv 22h ago • Bravo

Unskippable cinematic before a boss fight that you have to replay after every death.

2.2k

u/Vore_Daddy 22h ago • Bravo

There's no way you're taking Kairi's heart!

→ More replies (55)

553

u/Salzberger 22h ago

Bonus points when there's a little 30 second playable bit before the cut scene too. Like if you have to enter an area or run a little bit first.

→ More replies (5)

36

u/captainmeusli 20h ago

"You'll never save Prince Horus" YOU'LL NEVER SAVE PRINCE HORUS!

68

u/__M-E-O-W__ 21h ago

Tales of Symphonia, while it is one of my favorite games, is one of the absolute worst offenders at this. There isn't just cutscenes, there can be long stretches of dialogue in between the cutscenes before a boss fight. Sometimes there's a boss fight, and then a cutscene, and then another boss fight.

→ More replies (3)

123

u/da_chicken 21h ago

That's not really a mechanic. That's just a shitty design.

28

u/kloiberin_time 18h ago

Its called Final Fantasy X because you're going to be mashing the X button to skip the cut scenes.

12

u/Lioreuz 21h ago

Lady Yuna, it is a pleasure~

→ More replies (42)

6.2k

u/Rosstin316 22h ago • Bravo

“Follow me.”

(person you follow walks too fast for your regular walking speed but too slow for your jogging speed)

1.8k

u/parthyell 22h ago

And then they stop walking the second you catch up.

→ More replies (5)

250

u/Nothos927 22h ago

Bioshock infinite being basically the only game that does it right

→ More replies (23)

58

u/tokke 22h ago

Been playing wow forever. Forgot how I hate this.

→ More replies (6)

82

u/ReanSuffering 22h ago

"If you design a quest where I have to follow an NPC and they move faster than my walking speed but slower than my running speed, you are banned from making video games for one year."

→ More replies (9)

91

u/da_chicken 21h ago

They do that intentionally. It's the easiest way to give the NPC a single speed without letting them go too fast for you to catch up with them.

→ More replies (11)

13

u/Soopercow 22h ago

And you get attacked all the time, the NPC is suicidal

→ More replies (1)

28

u/gurnard 20h ago

One thing I love about ARMA Reforger is that you can fine tune your walking/jogging speed with the mouse wheel. Playing with a group, it's so easy and intuitive to adjust speed to maintain formation as a squad.

Sometimes a game mechanic comes along and makes you wonder why it took so long for someone to think of it. Imagine if this had been normal, across many genres, for decades?

A hardcore military simulation is probably a bit niche to "leak" ideas into mainstream games, but I really hope this gets copied into 1st and 3rd-person action games of all ilks. There has not been one time I've ever preferred to use a mouse wheel to rotate through weapons, when hotkeys are right there.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (40)

599

u/nitram20 21h ago

Any where you have to escort someone through a pre scripted path. If they follow you it's ok, but when you have to follow them? Fuck off with that shit.

Same thing for trailing someone on a pre scripted path.

104

u/Ed_Trucks_Head 19h ago

Fucking idiot Natalia in Goldeneye. She would walk right in fr9nt of you and get herself shot in the head.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/HendrixChord12 20h ago

They’re always slower than your run speed and faster than the walk speed. Extra points if they die while accident running off.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

1.5k

u/Neat_Rare_5389 22h ago • Bravo

Far Cry 5 getting kidnapped whenever your progress bar fills up a certain amount.

For context, basically any activity will give you xp for this bar. And you get kidnapped 3 times per area boss, for a total of 9 times. The game punishes you for playing it.

And it’s narratively stupid as well, that’s 9 times the bad guys easily captured you, and you escape everytime. Because instead of killing you they put you in some convoluted death bunker or whatever that of course you shoot your way out of.

547

u/thrillho613 21h ago

I flew a helicopter a high as I could in the air to see if I could evade that shit but no, Faith Seed still somehow managed to drug me. Super annoying.

→ More replies (2)

175

u/DrMonkeyLove 21h ago

Oh hey, you're having a lot of fun doing what you're doing right now? Well not anymore!

Dumbest mechanic 

Far Cry 3 and 4 are both way better games.

→ More replies (5)

246

u/Oncemor-intothebeach 22h ago

When your flying the plane !! What the actual fuck

→ More replies (3)

106

u/ikantolol 22h ago

one of the stupidest mission design in FC series, and I really like FC5 too if not for that.

the previous design is working great: go to certain characters to start certain missions, some characters give side missions, main characters give story missions to progress

I'm not sure what they're thinking that they thought FC5 progress style is necessary. It's just hella annoying. I just play with mods that increase the xp necessary to advance to the next kidnapping.

53

u/tyrom22 22h ago

Agreed, it could have been cool once but 9 times was just stupid

42

u/Rizo1981 21h ago

Absolutely it stunted replayability for me. The idea of sitting through it time and again was a non-starter for me. Maybe that was Ubi's ill-conceived plan to get people to buy their next title instead of replaying an old one lol.

→ More replies (9)

1.2k

u/TobbeLQ 22h ago • This

Forced stealth in non-stealth games.

511

u/WraithCadmus 22h ago

The biggest offender in my memory is Stars Wars: Jedi Knight 2: Jedi Outcast. You're sneaking around, but if you're spotted an officer will run to alarm box. If successful then a cutscene plays where Kyle is held up by two stormtroopers and captured.

Excuse me? I am Kyle "Motherfucking" Katarn, veteran mercenary and Jedi Knight, two hundred stormtroopers would not be an insurmountable challenge.

→ More replies (7)

56

u/Superb_Doctor1965 20h ago

Black & white, a game where you play as an omniscient god, has a stealth section

→ More replies (1)

167

u/ikantolol 22h ago

the only exception for me is the "All Ghillied Up" mission in Call of Duty 4.

→ More replies (10)

25

u/cheat-master30 19h ago

Especially when the system is setup in such a way where merely being seen is instant failure for whatever reason. And where your super powerful, nigh indestructible god of a main character is stuck sneaking around enemies they could easily defeat in a fight.

Honestly, a lot of these sections would be a lot better if the game just gave us the option to run or fight back when caught, and someone who struggled with stealth could just blast their way through all guns blazing.

→ More replies (3)

124

u/Vordeo 21h ago

While we're at it - forced platforming in non-platformers.

Looking at you, Dark Souls series.

→ More replies (12)

75

u/thyrandomninja 21h ago

I heard HORROR stories about the MJ sections of insomniac’s Spider-Man, but I only recently played it myself. I don’t know if the PS5 remaster has changed those sections at all in response to the blowback, but if not, and that’s what they were like already, people were blowing that stuff WAAAAAY out of proportion

Honestly, I’d say some of them were actually a little boring because they know they aren’t making a stealth game, so everything is neatly laid out for you to have a very easy time of it

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (26)

1.4k

u/GOOCH_GANG900 20h ago

In RPGs, enemies always scaling to your level. What's the point of leveling up if you can never gain a numerical advantage against the enemies?

I do like coming across an area with way stronger enemies than I'm prepared for and then coming back 8 hours later and being on equal ground with them.

99

u/Mr__Random 19h ago

The draugr are training...

→ More replies (8)

410

u/RyudoKills 20h ago

I like a mixture. Give me some areas where the enemies level with me (like story critical stuff) so that I can't just over level and tear through a whole game, but I do want some areas to punish me for going somewhere I'm not ready for, and others to make me feel like a God when returning to them.

→ More replies (9)

133

u/WeekendBard 18h ago

I've seen a dumbass say that Elden Ring should have enemies scaling to your level, so certain areas won't be too easy if you end up getting there after getting too strong

→ More replies (5)

26

u/Electric_Feel9374 19h ago

I agree, I always wanted this.

It's one of the reasons I loved Elden Ring so much

→ More replies (4)

25

u/chillinwithmoes 19h ago

Agreed, enemy scaling annoys the shit out of me. I like to grind out levels/abilities/gear to get that extra sense of power and games that allow scaling completely ruin that

→ More replies (25)

489

u/Flareon_Enthusiast 21h ago edited 20h ago

Unskippable tutorials

I'm talking the kind of shit pokemon does with nearly every switch game having around a 1-3 hour long tutorial, i love pokemon but I KNOW HOW TO CATCH POKEMON, I KNOW HOW GYMS WORK, I KNOW HOW ENCOUNTERING POKEMON WORKS

99

u/AzureMiles 20h ago

At this point, they really just need to drop a quick 'Is this your first adventure?' question in the character creation menu. A truncated introductory section isn't gonna hurt the modern Pokémon experience.

→ More replies (4)

37

u/ironkb57 20h ago

"I'll show you how to catch a pokemon, and you have NO other choice.... Now follow me and let me waste your time"

→ More replies (1)

118

u/slaymaker1907 20h ago

Really, any tutorial which is obviously a tutorial is bad. Tutorials should have fun and engaging gameplay. As a programmer, I'm also somewhat a believer in the idea that programs should be intuitive and discoverable enough that they do not need any tutorial at all.

→ More replies (10)

71

u/shymon7 20h ago

Let me introduce you to the mart and Pokemon center then! ;)

→ More replies (4)

21

u/PresidentDSG 20h ago

On the other hand I've seen people skip or ignore tutorials, have no idea how to play the game, and then blame the game for it more times than I can count.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/mystical-mismagius 20h ago

The fact they haven’t implemented a way to skip or at least fast-track the same exact tutorial segment after 30 years is mind-boggling.

→ More replies (31)

746

u/ikantolol 22h ago

platforming in a game that's not built for it.

137

u/Jaffacakelover 21h ago

Alone in the Dark is one of the earliest survival horror games. It was released in 1992. It had fixed camera angles and shoddy controls. Three-quarters of the way though the game you reach a cave system, and a new verb appears in your Actions menu... Jump. You can guess how awful this was.

74

u/Topgunshotgun45 22h ago

The Elder Scrolls Online has some of the worst jumping mechanics I've ever seen, and a somewhat recent content update is riddled with them. You can spend an hour on one section that would take two/three minutes in almost any other games.

47

u/RumHamComesback 19h ago

There was this weird period in the 90s where FPS games tried to do platforming and it really didn't work. I love Half-Life 1 but the weakest parts of it were when you had to jump on platforms on some stages.

42

u/HoppersEcho 21h ago

I hate suprise platforming. I don't like platformers, the whole concept of "miss this jump and you'll have to redo the last 30 as well" has just never been fun to me.

87

u/diegolpzir 20h ago

Worst part of FromSoftware games

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)

146

u/earhere 21h ago

In JRPGs if the main character dies or is knocked out it's game over. You mean to tell me the other party members can't hit him with a revive spell?

116

u/FoxyBastard 20h ago • Bravo

Healer: "My job is to do what the boss says, and he ain't saying shit."

44

u/nWo1997 20h ago

Understandable in some games like SMT 5, where your partners are demons who contracted with you and aren't exactly loyal to the end. Happily avoided when it would've been understandable in SMT 4.

Egregious in those "power of friendship" games like Persona 5, especially when SMT 4 (another MegaTen game) doesn't do that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

1.8k

u/jonnythefoxx 22h ago • Bravo

Loot boxes.

311

u/MeNameIsDerp 21h ago

This and any other related gambling style mechanic needs to be banned and shoved up the CEOs behind for their greed.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

66

u/Callec254 22h ago

Paid loot boxes/pay to win mechanics.

→ More replies (1)

340

u/Lonewolf222222 22h ago

Micro transactions or pay to win

26

u/laurel_laureate 16h ago

* Gasp *

You mean to imply that you don't get a sense of pride and accomplishment from unlocking cosmetic/pay to win shit?

→ More replies (4)

119

u/mark5hs 22h ago

Stealth sections where you have to restart if you get spotted

→ More replies (2)

251

u/Double-Slowpoke 18h ago

In OG Oblivion, you leveled up by doing stuff that you picked as your “major” skills that you selected.  So if you picked Acrobatics you’d gain a level jumped around a bunch.  The enemies also scale with your level.

It was a bit unintuitive, but if you picked a bunch of major skills that you use a lot in normal combat, you would level up too quickly without gaining enough skill points.

It would create a situation where if you accidentally level up in an inefficient way, you would find yourself dying to regular enemies who were just massive damage sponges.   

101

u/WeekendBard 17h ago

Oblivion punished you for not metagaming, thanks Toddm

24

u/Electric999999 15h ago

The main issue with oblivion was the level scaling on enemies.
Morrowind had pretty much the same system, but a few bad level ups where you didn't raise the right stats weren't nearly as impactful because most enemies didn't scale.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/RelicRedux 16h ago

Getting flashbacks to getting repeatedly mauled by mountain lions after leveling up too fast just because I ran around too much...

23

u/DarthMaulATAT 16h ago

I thought it was kind of cool. Sometimes I just wanted to train a non-major skill without leveling up. But yeah it had its problems too. Pretty sure it's the only game that had that kind of leveling system though.

→ More replies (2)

334

u/ragnarok0424 21h ago

Missable trophy/achievements.

Specifically in older final fantasy games, the bestiary.

They'll be like 'oh you made it to the last act of the game. The world has changed permanently. You however are missing bestiary number 049 that only spawns in the middle act, and even then, you have to go so far out of your way into some random island that spawns a 5th variation of a common enemy that bares no significant exp or loot drop. Yeah thats the one you missed. So unless you have a saved file in that act of the game, good luck.'

31

u/WhiteLama 19h ago

Fucking Red Dead Redemption 2 and the camp mission achievement. What do you mean these conversations that might not even appear for me can also lock me out of my last achievement?

I adore the game, such a masterpiece, but I’m still missing that achievement because I refuse to replay so much for so little.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/mmss 20h ago

Classic X-COM (I think jt was Terror from the Deep) has a bug where if you research things out of order, certain items never show up in the research tree and you can’t finish the game. Can happen when you capture certain enemies early, orif you don’t research early items, late game enemies will no longer spawn with them (pistols etc).

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Crashman126 20h ago

Freakin Intangir who only spawns in that one island before the World of Ruin.

18

u/SheWolfe_ 20h ago

And then it only spawns at night after killing 20 other random unrelated mobs. FFXII with the hunts be like

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

636

u/WhyOhWhy60 22h ago

I really dislike games where checkpoint saves are the only saves. Let the player decide when to save.

Replaying a section is unproductive use of limited gaming time.

171

u/DrMonkeyLove 21h ago

Yes! I will not play games that are checkpoint only at this stage of my life. I don't have time to go back and replay the last 15 minutes. 

Shout out to Baldur's Gate 3, which has the single best save system of any game ever made. You can save during conversations even. Absolutely perfect.

→ More replies (3)

82

u/Trippynet 20h ago

100% agree with this. I hate being "held hostage" by a game when I can only decide to quit at certain times. Had this ages ago with Bioshock Infinite. I've had enough for the evening, got work the following day and all that, only to find "If you quit now, you'll lose 20 minutes of progress". So I'm forced to keep playing until I finally reach a sodding checkpoint.

Or as you say, the alternative being "Oh dear, you died. To punish you, replay the last 15 minutes of the game you've just completed". That's not fun, it's deeply irritating - and I don't play games to be irritated.

These days if I find a game is checkpoint-only for saves, I will just give it a miss. I can live with not being allowed to save during battles (ie, the Mass Effect-style system), but when everything is calm and I'm not allowed to save and quit at that point, the devs don't deserve my money.

→ More replies (39)

54

u/ReadsAsSarcasm 22h ago

When you can jump or you can move, but you can’t jump and move towards anything in a single motion.

→ More replies (3)

103

u/Gmoney86 22h ago

Real life timing gates that last longer than your play session for single player games. Having to wait hours or days for a bar to fill to allow you to progress side quests or story beats is bad design. Inquisition was the worst example of it off the top of my head.

→ More replies (2)

85

u/rhelg224 18h ago

Being forced to walk slow.

Fuck you. If I want to run through my own house like a dog in heat on rollerskates, I will.

→ More replies (1)

77

u/IatetheCamel 21h ago

When "crafting" is actually only a rng lottery mechanic. See the horadric cube in diablo 4 for example.

→ More replies (7)

305

u/InsaneBasti 22h ago

Time management. Its the main stress factor in rl, why tf would i want that in games? "Oz you missed this event better wait a whole ingame year"

→ More replies (26)

98

u/8bit95 20h ago

Anything that forces multiplayer on an otherwise singleplayer game. Looking at you, trade evolutions.

→ More replies (6)

33

u/blckndwht44 19h ago

There was an Alone in the Dark game where you had to manually make your character blink or else your POV gets blurrier until it goes dark. This game also had an inventory system where you had to look down at your coat and your coat pockets.

11

u/Okurei 17h ago

My favourite part of that stupid game is early on when the protagonist sees some horrifying new monster/boss enemy screeching at him, but he just gets annoyed and goes “FUCK YOU!”

9

u/WeekendBard 18h ago

that game is so cursed lol

I love a cutscene early on when a possessed person questions Carby about some mcguffin stone, and his response is "I don't have your stone. And fuck you anyway."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

941

u/DBFargie 22h ago

Almost all games that have a durability mechanic on weapons and armor. 90% of the time it adds nothing to the game, and in most cases takes away from it.

490

u/randalljhen 21h ago

At no point has anyone ever played a game without a durability mechanic and thought, "You know, this game would be so much better if my shit broke at the worst possible time."

→ More replies (17)

43

u/onemanandhishat 20h ago

Surprised no one has mentioned Far Cry 2, the chance of a weapon jamming in the middle of a fight adds to the already chaotic feeling of the combat. It fits with the setting as well, alongside your character suffering from malaria, really brings it to life.

Normally I agree about it, but in FC2 I think it makes the game better.

→ More replies (3)

82

u/Vegetable-Cabinet871 22h ago

The Witcher 3 Remaster has an option to just eliminate durability (and carry limits too if that others you) and man I forgot how annoying that was my first playthrough

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (116)

167

u/Onyxidian 21h ago

Tiny font with no option to enlarge it. It's like all developers think everyone has a 4k TV 5 inches from their face like they do while making it

14

u/Ershin- 20h ago

Dead Rising on a CRT was my first experience with this.

10

u/DigNitty 19h ago

Playing Age of Empires II on a 65 in screen does this.

They never predicted someone would “couch play” the game. So the number for all your resources like logs in 1/3in tall and you have to walk to the tv to see it.

→ More replies (3)

164

u/3rdCoffee 22h ago

Stun lock.
Loss of character control is the most frustrating design.

10

u/kasakka1 17h ago

This is one of the few things that cause me rage in games. Constantly getting knocked down and not being able to do anything.

28

u/FartKilometre 19h ago

As a kid I found out I could cheese Streets of Rage 2 by not finishing a combo. Just 3 hits, pause, 3 hits, repeat. The enemies would just be stun locked with the right timing.

Turns out one of the later boss characters who looks like Ultimate Warrior can break that stun lock. After like 2 or 3 cycles he'll duck and cover to block all your shots, then do a wolverine style rage scream and swing his arms out on both sides which knocks you back before he lauches off at you for his attacks.

→ More replies (4)

136

u/UnsignedRealityCheck 21h ago

QTEs. I can take a few, but if the whole game is based on "see green button, press green button. see blue button, press blue button" i'm out.

14

u/Porrick 19h ago

How about QTEs that scale with difficulty? The Xbox 360 Wolverine game had one in a Sentinel fight of the "mash X to pass this cutscene" variety, but on Hard you had to mash it faster than my finger could mash a button. What a stupid way to gate the rest of the game.

64

u/enterdapanda 20h ago

QTE during cut scenes are especially diabolical. You go for a piss and come back and you're dead. I'm looking at you, Resident Evil.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

84

u/Loafman15 18h ago

Most hacking mini games blow.

Bioshock is one of my all time favourite games but once you’ve hacked your 40th turret or vending machine it is just straight tedious

→ More replies (14)

29

u/Big_Cassowary 18h ago

You have been captured and all your gear is gone.

→ More replies (1)

517

u/Not_My_Emperor 19h ago • Bravo

Weapon durability.

I have never seen it implemented in a way that isn't just "oh no! Your weapon broke! Better go through a bunch of in game menus to fix it! And until you do it's damage is basically down to 0."

Witcher 3 being the absolute worst example. It adds nothing to the game other than forcing you to navigate menus.

RDR2 is the only one that did it halfway right, where the damage stats on your guns go down slightly when it's dirty, and to fix that you get a kinda fun animation cleaning them. That said, I can see that being super onerous for anyone who doesn't love that game, so the entire idea of the mechanic to my mind can go in the bin.

73

u/ConfidentAlya 18h ago • Bravo

weapon durability is only fun when it creates interesting decisions. if it just means stopping what youre doing to open a menu and repair something, its basically maintenance disguised as gameplay

→ More replies (3)

89

u/haji1823 19h ago

i feel like monster hunter games did it fine. its a super quick button combo to sharpen your weapon and adds complexity to fights because you pretty much have to do it in the middle of every fight at some point. Doesnt take long to do and you need to time it well to not take damage

→ More replies (13)

166

u/shasaferaska 18h ago edited 16h ago

Breath of the Wild was terrible for that. "Here's the weapon of our champion, passed down through the generations" - breaks after 5 enemies.

→ More replies (15)

152

u/msprang 19h ago

My wife and son are both playing BOTW, and the weapon durability is almost hilariously bad. At least in Fallout you can repair them.

→ More replies (35)

11

u/heikkiiii 18h ago

Well done in KCD, have to actually get to a grind stone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (84)

28

u/fistoic 19h ago

limited bag space in RPG. Not in survival game but in RPG. Dude, we using magics and shit but bag weight is where you draw the line??

→ More replies (1)

74

u/the_Athereon 17h ago

RPGs that scale encounters to your level. Preventing you from being able to over level to get past an area or boss when you're stuck.

15

u/ricree 15h ago

Or worse: unoptimized levelling makes you relatively weaker.

44

u/Gremmer_mistakes 20h ago

While not THE worst, I'm going to throw in the game I love to hate on. When you died in Too Human, there was a 30 second, unskippable, scene that played. You had to watch it every time.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/CantSpellMispell 20h ago

Surprise QTE in the middle of a long cut scene. Because half the time I tend to put my controller down when I’m watching a cutscene. 

Also, when there is a boss fight, and then when it’s 99% defeated, they’ll throw a final surprise QTE in that you can fail and then have to start over.

I’ve hated QTEs since the 90s lol

101

u/CanaDoug420 21h ago

Degrading weapons. “Oh cool sword. Better never use it so it doesn’t break”

18

u/DBRU00 21h ago

Escort quests in which the NPC walks super slow, and you get spammed with mobs.

Hello there, World of Warcraft.

51

u/TrueBrit77 22h ago

I hate timing mini-games for skills checks. They make sense but I have the timing reflexes of a sloth. I've given up entire genres of games because of them.

11

u/Zestyclose_Bed4202 17h ago

If I'm playing an RPG, then my CHARACTER'S success at a task should be based on my CHARACTER'S skill, NOT MINE!!!!!

→ More replies (3)

76

u/Vore_Daddy 22h ago

Subscription service for a single player game

→ More replies (2)

49

u/lessmiserables 21h ago

All I know is a significant number of new-ish games mistake "difficulty" with "makework tedium".

19

u/LotusPrince 18h ago

Hard mode = same as before, except now enemies take twice as long to bring down

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

47

u/The_FireFALL 21h ago

I think most of the main ones have been absolutely nailed on the head, so i'm going to be really specific and say the maleria mechanic from Farcry 2. Just destroyed the game completed by having to keep that in check all the time.

34

u/Wild-Man-63 20h ago

Speaking of far cry. The capture party mechanic from Far cry 5. Happens way too often and has 0 checks to prevent it from happening. So while it may be cool the first time it becomes progressively more annoying throughout the game and can just pull you out mid side mission.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (11)

45

u/H4llifax 20h ago

Pokemon splitting each edition in two. Especially the earlier ones where the main difference was just what Pokemon you can find.

29

u/WeekendBard 18h ago

I think the idea was to incentivise people to socialize and trade with other players

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/Normal-Reality-8467 18h ago

Invincibility phases.... mainly when your character is obviously overpowered af.

11

u/WeekendBard 17h ago

Borderlands 3 suffers a lot from this. Some bosses spend so much time in invincibility phases.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

66

u/GunstarGreen 22h ago

Not necessarily a mechanic, but I wish screens weren't so cluttered with information.

18

u/oliberg360 22h ago

Dead Space is my favorite when it comes to this

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Mammoth_Mail4585 22h ago

Full HUD customisation should be standard in all games nowadays! Similarly text size.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/ikantolol 22h ago

Ghost of Tsushima is a real nice breath of fresh air in terms of this, the screen is so... clean, and it allow you to just stop for a moment and look around the beauty of the landscape.

even the quest guide is just a gust of wind, no clutter in screen. Wish more games do it like that.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Candiedstars 20h ago

Game over / death screens that send you back to the title screen without an option to continue or respawn (looking at you, Symphony of the Night...)

30

u/Popplio3233 20h ago

Losing in an RPG when one important character dies. The worst offender is the Persona games. Every pisses their pants when their leader goes down, including the healer who has a full revive skill. Also, I stockpiled countless revival items, YOU HAVE THE MEANS TO BRING HIM BACK. WHY ARE YOU FREAKING OUT?

82

u/RemoveByFriction 21h ago

XP debt. In old "City of Heroes" mmo, each time you died you'd get "xp debt", which decreased your xp gained by 50% until you gained a certain amount of xp, and the debt stacked, so if you died several times in a row, you'd be getting half the xp for quite a while. It was very demoralising, in an otherwise quite fun game.

42

u/_borT 20h ago

Beats FFXI. In that game if you die you LOSE xp and could actually level down lol

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (9)

14

u/captainmagictrousers 21h ago

When dating sims started adding "fog of war." Um, how am I supposed to find the cutest date if I can't even see them?

13

u/pedro-ribeiro2582 20h ago

Rubber-banding in racing games: the pack shouldn't get a supernatural speed boost just because I'm winning.

62

u/MuffinRacing 19h ago

I'll just come out and say it. Crafting. It's an exercise in hunting through menus and becomes tedious as hell

9

u/LotusPrince 18h ago

For me, let's less about the menuing and more about the shoehorning. Instead of combining widget A and widget B to make a small medkit, couldn't I just find the fucking medkit, instead

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

24

u/Subject_Sun_1860 18h ago

Weapon durability, merchants with EXTREMELY limited gold(cough cough Skyrim)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Necessary_Host_5839 21h ago

Unskippable tutorials that force you to learn mechanics you figured out five minutes ago.

12

u/SecondSonThan 21h ago

Oh you nade a fire build? Too bad this boss is just immune to fire because why not

54

u/GEARHEADGus 20h ago

Making the player drive all the time when the NPC is perfectly capable of driving us

41

u/Pulmonary_Archery_ 20h ago

Yes, why is Arthur Morgan, the hardest working man in camp, stuck driving everyone around in the stagecoaches. Can't I get a break to just enjoy the scenery once in awhile?

→ More replies (5)

26

u/D3M4NUF4CTUR3DFX 20h ago

Special mention to Cyberpunk 2077. V gets chauffeured around by the NPCs quite a bit.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/rocknrollpizzaria 20h ago

I was SO happy with L.A. Noir for letting me ride shotgun. The only thing I hate more than driving in real life is driving in a video game

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Cascadejackal 21h ago

Quick time events. I can't think of any time they've ever added anything to a game except frustration..

→ More replies (1)

21

u/weareeverywhereee 22h ago

Escort missions

10

u/Hennessy_Halos 20h ago

swimming/diving and water in almost any game not built around it. it always feels awkward and boring after 10 seconds.
might not be worst ever but it’s something that’s consistently unenjoyable at least for me.

26

u/Megaspids 22h ago

dailies

9

u/Thangail 21h ago

Quick time events. I know its to make cinematics more interactive. But you literally have made an interactive medium. And then you get it a timing button presses/mash button thing. Why not build the event in the gameplay? 

17

u/MooseEatGoose 18h ago

most survival game mechanics tbh.

I've never played a game where grinding to get food was fun. The most tolerable example that i've played was subnautica, and even then, it was tedious until the midgame where it became totally trivial because i set up farms, and then what's the point?

30

u/meatlessboat 21h ago

Timed missions or level. Followed by escort missions.

100

u/Nine_Gates 18h ago

Dying in Dark Souls 2 reducing your max HP. 

The point of the Souls formula is

  • You encounter a difficult section or boss 
  • You die repeatedly trying to clear it 
  • You keep respawning with the same resources 
  • Eventually, you get good enough to beat it 

Dark Souls 2 completely ruins this with the max HP loss mechanic. You can end up at half your maximum HP. Reversing it requires an item with limited availability. 

It turns the spirit of the game from "get good" to "be good before you start".

20

u/captainA-A 17h ago

To be fair, Bloodborne also goes against that formula, because healing items in BB are consumables. So if you die too much trying to clear a boss, you'll have to leave and farm more blood vials.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Aryionas 17h ago

True but also, didn't mobs have a limited respawn? I think if you kill them like twelve times, they won't respawn. Either way, good point.

→ More replies (10)

25

u/Admirable_Admural 17h ago

Demon souls would change the entire zone if you died too much. World tendency was a bizarre mechanic

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (22)

16

u/McGruffin 22h ago

Unpausable cinematics, and boss fights that start with a long cinematic that you can't skip.

8

u/MoistTomatoSandwich 21h ago

I personally hate the realistic (using that loosely) building mechanic that requires you to hold each building material individually. That mechanic is in Sons of the Forest with the logs and Grounded.

8

u/HeyZenOfficial 20h ago

In RDR2, your guns teleporting from your back onto your horse after dismounting.

So goddamn annoying…

8

u/Redsourpatchkid_ 19h ago

Npcs repeating dialogue telling you to hurry up while your solving a puzzle.

43

u/lakynkylin 22h ago

The looting from RDR2 is up there. Phenomenal game but holy crap that was redundant

→ More replies (12)

27

u/tidus1980 21h ago edited 20h ago

Micro transactions and day 1 dlc

Edit: and horse armour

→ More replies (2)

7

u/thrillho613 21h ago

Mini games where you have to be absolutely perfect to get gold rank.

Mini games that require you to press a button an x amount of times. Playing Mario Odyssey right now and noped out of the volleyball and jump rope moons

7

u/RealDaBaby416 21h ago

Adaptability in Dark Souls II

7

u/ginfish 19h ago

Breath of the wild's weapon breaking system. Destroyed my enjoyment of the game to a point where I just dropped it.

12

u/RaspberryJammm 22h ago

Seriously limited inventory + having to build hundreds of crates to store items. Drives me mad. 

→ More replies (1)

12

u/DevilPixelation 20h ago

Losing money/XP/whatever whenever you die. I’m already dead, why punish me even further for no reason?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Revenge_of_the_Khaki 20h ago

For console gaming, when they give you a tiny little cursor in the middle of your screen and they expect you to pick things up with it that you can barely see and give no indication that you've walked over them.

Most often done when ported from PC where that isn't the most annoying thing in the world.

6

u/Lokarin 19h ago

I recently played Kotor and is uses every single mundane puzzle known to man by the end... you have 'lights out' and 'tower of hanoi' in the same level!

Don't do that

6

u/Own-Slide-3171 18h ago

Quick time events replacing combat

23

u/Please_Snd_boobs420 21h ago

"CJ, FOLLOW THE DAMN TRAIN"

→ More replies (4)

5

u/spamlettispaghetti 20h ago

In Skull & Bones ships have stamina bars...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/NergalsMace 20h ago

If we're talking actual game mechanics, then breakable weapons have to be up there, especially in the BOTW fashion.

5

u/Nuclear_Space_Cat 19h ago

When crafting in single player games takes one button click, but then you have to wait for 5 minutes for it to complete. I don't want to wait for this ore to smelt, I want it now.

5

u/LightDrinkerMidir 18h ago

First thing that comes to mind is escort missions.

I adore Metal Gear Solid 2 but that one part of the game with Emma where you have to drag her by the hand, followed up by a long ass sniper section where she moves slower than a snail, is absolutely horrific.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Stahl_Scharnhorst 16h ago

The escort quest NPC is faster than walking speed, but slower than running speed.

15

u/lee-hussain564 21h ago

Enemies that scale with your level. Nothing makes a level-up feel more pointless than the whole world leveling up with you.

12

u/Avalanche_Snows 22h ago

Unskippable credits rolling. Especially when you are supposed to beat the game multiple times or can have the credits rolling multiple times on the same save file

→ More replies (2)

12

u/MulleDK19 20h ago

The Last of Us has the worst mechanic in history. Run away from enemies: their accuracy becomes near 0% and their shots do nothing, run towards them, their accuracy becomes 100% and all their hits will set your speed to zero.

24

u/Topgunshotgun45 22h ago

Climbing that gets interrupted by random rainstorms.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/klaymarion 22h ago

weapon durability,

8

u/Nananahx 21h ago

Carrying weight where it slows you down if you carry too much

4

u/carbonite1983 20h ago

Escort missions. Full stop.

4

u/reluctantwordsmith 20h ago

Stripping player power or abilities to increase challenge because players were given too much power.

Warframe is terrible about this. You spend all your time outside of story missions grinding power, jumping all over, melting enemies. Story time? Here's a new, somewhat poorly explained mechanic you'll do at the pace we tell you. Oh, by the way, this mechanic will rarely show up again in a meaningful way, if ever.

4

u/Solazarr 20h ago

Exit to title screen or menu instead of exit game

4

u/WesWordbound 20h ago

Being required to eat and drink without an option to turn it off. I already struggle to choose what to eat in real life, I don't need that in my games.

4

u/IgorPasche 20h ago

Sense of pride and accomplishment

For those that don't remember, you had a limit to how many credits you could get from playing Battlefront 2 in order to make you pay for items in the game. This was a 60$ game, by the way.

4

u/lurking_not_working 19h ago

Long intros before you can do anything in the game. Like I just want to dip into it and see if the game is something I might like. Not spend 40 mins of back story then 30 mins of tutorial.

4

u/BFFBomb 19h ago

Enemies in an action game that dig into the ground and can't be hurt until they pop back out. It just ruins the pacing and throws off your groove

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DrScienceSpaceCat 19h ago

Unskippable cutscenes and unpausable cutscenes

7

u/Most-Plant3530 22h ago

Seemingly infinite upgrade menus and inventory management that interrupts the flow of gameplay

9

u/Slave35 22h ago

Anything that is not skippable. With biggest mention to intros. Just let me play the fuckin game.

→ More replies (4)