r/AskReddit • u/Kolah-KitKat-4466 • 15h ago
Serious Replies Only [Serious] What is an unsolved mystery that you find deeply disturbing that you also feel doesn't get talked about as much as other unsolved cases?
661
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 15h ago
Attention! [Serious] Tag Notice
Posts that have few relevant answers within the first hour, and posts that are not appropriate for the [Serious] tag will be removed. Consider doing an AMA request instead.
Thanks for your cooperation and enjoy the discussion!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
79
u/AustisticGremlin 8h ago
Sydney John Doe (2012) - No body has ever been located, all that was discovered was a puddle of blood large enough that the individual was unlikely to survive losing that much. The fact the blood was inside a cubby house on a school playground only makes it more disturbing when you consider the fact that authorities suspect that this victim may be a child.
94
u/troyzein 15h ago
What happened with the New Jersey drones?
634
u/Fly_Of_Dragons 11h ago edited 9h ago •
…maybe i’m just too familiar with them, but so far most of these comments seem to be about well-known mysteries? so here are some that at least i consider little-known. i research cases in the western US (primarily California) from the late 1960s up to the early 1980s; this comment features just a few of many specifically in California. also heads up that this comment gets a bit long lol:
Debbie Shelton was a 12 year old middle schooler from a small beach town in Northern California. during her Christmas break she told a friend that she met a cute boy who didn’t go to their school. two days after New Years 1969 her mother gave Debbie permission to go bike riding with the boy, so long as the boy’s sister came too. a few hours later, an unknown young man called the Shelton household, asking for Debbie’s mother; she was out running errands, so Vicki (Debbie’s younger sister, who had answered the phone) told the caller when their mother would be back. sure enough, a couple hours later, Mrs Shelton received a call from what sounded to her like a boy in his early teens. the youth told Mrs Shelton to bring $500 to a nearby road and he’ll give Debbie back. Mrs Shelton, thinking it was a prank by Debbie’s friends who knew she was running late getting home, brushed it aside. however, Mrs Shelton quickly grew concerned when Debbie didn’t arrive home within the hour, and called law enforcement (LE). despite searches, they couldn’t find Debbie, so they chalked it up to a runaway situation. two months later, a young boy playing with his BB gun in a wooded (yet well-traveled) area less than a mile from the Shelton home discovered Debbie’s body lying under a tree. near Debbie’s body was a shallow hole that someone had started to dig but eventually gave up on, presumably because the ground was too cold. her clothes were disheveled, her hands bound behind her back, and her underwear had been tied around her mouth as a gag. the body was too decomposed to determine whether any SA took place (though it’s strongly believed given the circumstances), but it was determined she had been strangled to death with her underwear. the identity of the ransom caller, as well as that of the boy Debbie went bike riding with that day, have never been determined, though a local claims to have known a teen boy who killed himself a couple years after Debbie was found, and he had the same first name as the one Debbie gave her mother for the boy she was meeting.
[ETA another strange twist that i had forgotten to include originally! Vicki, Debbie’s younger sister who had answered the first ransom call, later disappeared in 2001. it’s believed that Vicki’s disappearance is unrelated to Debbie’s murder, and that Vicki unfortunately was likely killed by her ex-boyfriend, but her body has never been found, and her daughter is still looking for answers]
there was another unsolved murder in that same county a couple years later. Rosa Linda Zuniga was a recent high school graduate in Watsonville who had gotten a job as a live-in housekeeper in San Jose. a few weeks after getting the job, she called her mom asking to come pick her up so she could spend the weekend with family, but her mother’s car was in the shop and Rosie didn’t have enough money for a bus. she was last seen alive by her employer trying to hitchhike home, but she never made it. her family reported her missing to San Jose PD, but they threw out the report because they figured she’s an adult and not known to be in immediate danger, so it wasn’t pressing to them. (imo it’s also unfortunately not unlikely that they heard “Hispanic housekeeper” and decided not to care.) more than two weeks after Rosie went missing, her body was found in a field in the city of Santa Cruz by a young man who was out training his pet falcon. she was fully clothed except for her shoes, her hands tied behind her back with a bandana she owned, and a sheet had been placed over the body where it was left underneath a tree. she had no injuries except for a single stab wound to the throat: she died from blood loss and asphyxiation. Rosie’s case is so little known, in fact, that i only found out about it while skimming newspaper archives, and i had to really push LE to add Rosie to their Unsolved Homicides page. why she wasn’t featured there alongside other cases (including Debbie’s) is unclear, as they have never arrested anyone or identified any suspects in Rosie’s murder.
i also found out about Kurt Kaikinger’s murder through newspaper archives, and LE has confirmed the case is still open but refuses to put him on their Cold Case page (because apparently they only feature one case at a time on the site…). Kurt had wanted to become a professional pianist, however after serving as an Army medic during Vietnam he seems to have given up on that dream and fell into a depression. he was last seen alive at a local bar on a cool autumn night. nobody reported him missing (his family lived across the Bay so wasn’t in daily contact with him). a few days later, Kurt was found in a secluded field wearing only a t-shirt and swim trunks. someone had beaten him to death with a crow bar or tire iron severely; he suffered broken ribs, skull fractures, and broken fingers, and had been dumped in the field after death. his dad put out multiple rewards for information and even conducted his own investigation into the murder, but died without any answers.
(i may come back and reply to this comment with some more if i feel like it, because there are a ton of cases that don’t get enough attention at all, while others are always repeated…)
[also as i always like to clarify in my posts, no AI was used at any stage in writing these summaries or the linked write-ups :)]
edited to fix some wording and a couple typos
129
u/fracking-machines 14h ago •
The Nannup Four - Australian family of four go missing and were never heard from again. Lots of theories about their disappearance.
514
u/TizzyTonks 15h ago •
The whereabouts of Keith Bennett's remains. His poor mother died with never having found them despite never giving up waiting and searching. Keith was one of Ian Brady and Myra Hindley's victims. I think about Keith and his family often, and I always hope he is found someday to be put to rest near his mother, Winnie.
63
u/CalligrapherCheap64 11h ago
https://www.news10.com/news/greene-county/24-years-since-audrey-may-herron-disappeared-in-greene-county/amp/
This is local to my area, what really sticks with me is that in all this time they’ve never found her car either. And it was a jeep grand Cherokee, a big car. They’ve done water searches, nothing. No signs of an accident, nothing.
The other one I think about a lot is The Lane Bryant murders. Imagine just shopping in a quiet store on a Saturday morning and someone comes in, tied you up and shoots you for no apparent reason. I can’t imagine what the sole survivor lives with on a daily basis knowing that the maniac who did it is still out there.
111
u/Carmelized 7h ago •
All the whistleblowers who mysteriously die under convenient circumstances. Statistically a few probably have died from sudden illness or accident, but there’s too many for it to be a coincidence. To be clear, I don’t think it’s one person or group doing it, but I think when you have a lot of money you can make people go away.
There’s recent ones, like Suchir Balaji from OpenAI and John Barnett from Boeing. And then there’s much older ones, like Karen Silkwood from a nuclear facility and Dave Bocks from Fernald Uranium.
105
u/zfinne 14h ago edited 10h ago
Michael J Madore of Milo, Maine - 1996. He was last seen cycling downtown and virtually vanished into thin air. No real theories or leads. Crazy how someone can virtually disappear. It was 30 years ago though. I’m betting that he was hit by a car and they panicked, put him in their trunk and dumped the body somewhere.
50
u/TheFemale72 4h ago
Reed Jeppson. 15 year old who disappeared in 1964 with both of his dogs. People suspected that his neighbor, a doctor was involved in his disappearance. After the doctor died, new owners bought his house. They were digging in the basement (I can’t remember why, but I think it was a maintenance issue) and found skeletal remains. It turned out to be the bones of 2 dogs- one small and one large (Like Reed’s dogs). Reed Jeppson has never been found.
289
u/jittery_raccoon 13h ago edited 13h ago •
Ones where they are oficially solved but there's a good chance they got the wrong people.
Holly Bobo comes to mind. The case is quite grotesque and the circumstances are pretty creepy. The police honed in on some local methheads. But their connection to her is not clear. And they targeted a group of people, which often leads to false confessions. It also happened in a short window, yet 6 men were implicated. Also her brother saw her talking to one person. Just overall doesn't make sense. The case was closed fairly quickly so no one talks about it any more. But there were several other suspicious people connected to Holly that the police didn't look at much once they decided it was this group of guys
The West Memphis 3. I think it's pretty obvious these boys didn't do it. Even though they've been released because of a change in public opinion, they are still officially guilty of the crime. But the most disturbing part is if they didn't do it, someone else did. And there's been almost no investigation into anyone else since it's officially solved
42
u/LannahDewuWanna 8h ago edited 8h ago
The 2007 still unsolved disappearance of Aeryn Gillern. Aeryn was from NYS and moved to Austria in 2003 where he made a life for himself and had a good job with UNIDO. He had a close relationship with his mother and they would visit each other back and forth between New York State and Austria.
Aeryn was a gay man with no history of drug abuse or mental illness. He had been living in Austria for 4 years and was in a relationship. On a winter night in 2007 he apparently ran naked out of a bath house, that he frequented, apparently afraid for his life. The police have been of little help as have the business owners.
As per wiki: Police have asserted that he may have been suicidal and jumped to his death in the Danube,[3] a hypothesis Gillern's acquaintances do not believe;[4] others, including his mother, argue that the investigation into his disappearance was hampered by police bias against Gillern's sexuality.[5] The Austrian police changed their statement multiple times, as well as denying the presence of any witnesses, despite a phone call they had received from a couple only a day after Gillern was declared missing.
Aeryn's mother is still actively searching for any answers and travels back to Vienna often to keep the case alive.
83
u/Snoo_90160 11h ago edited 11h ago
The Disappearance of Monika Bielawska: https://www.solvethecase.org/case/1994-58/Monika-Bielawska We know who's responsible but we don't know what happened to Monika.
Bogdański Family Disappearance: https://thesuitcasedetective.com/2025/11/03/krzysztof-bogdanski/
Mysterious death of Polish physicist Zbigniew Wołoszyn less than a year after Chernobyl disaster: https://trojka.polskieradio.pl/artykul/3694094,wiedzial-ze-dobrze-mierzyl-niewyjasniona-sprawa-zbigniewa-woloszyna He was measuring the radiation levels.
Rather well-known case of Iwona Wieczorek's disappearance: https://tvpworld.com/78322993/police-say-new-tip-off-may-help-solve-14-year-old-cold-case-of-missing-polish-teen-
Murder of former Polish PM Piotr Jaroszewicz and his wife: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piotr_Jaroszewicz
1.9k
u/BArhino 15h ago •
Epstein files. If it takes down "half the government" as they said then fuck them. Take it down, no one likes the US Government anyway and I'm tired of rich pricks getting away with everything
34
u/downwithMikeD 9h ago
Max DeVries… the other Aruba case.
57
u/Seattleman55 11h ago
There’s 2 near Seattle that come to mind.
One being somewhat recent of Jonathan Huang.
The next which is even crazier is an Everett 22 year old went missing in 2016 then in 2019 his foot washed up on shore. Name is Antonio Neill.
24
u/shah-vishal_99 10h ago
The Flannan Isles lighthouse disappearance. A remote station, vanished keepers, and no definitive answer make it eerie without needing a conspiracy.
24
u/queen_beruthiel 8h ago
The disappearance of Bung Siriboon, who was a 13 year old girl. She was walking to school in a suburb of Melbourne, Australia. She never made it to school, and she was never seen again. One theory is that she was lured into a car, as it was raining that day and the driver offered her a lift, but she was so close to school, a lift was pointless, so it's more likely she was forced into the car. Another theory is that she was the victim of the uncaptured child rapist and murderer, Mr. Cruel.
235
u/Gretal122 15h ago
The disappearance of the 3 Beaumont children( in South Australia ,in the 1960's) It's never been solved, there were' suspects' but never proven who took them..
136
u/Anachronisticpoet 14h ago
Anyone responding with “Epstein files” didn’t read the post
40
u/SomeGingerDude419 9h ago
Somewhere in the midwest a surgically removed heart was found in a salt pile.
56
u/Quantum_Tiddies 6h ago •
How legitimately creepy quantum entanglement really is. Like in certain circles its talked about a lot, but the general public not really at all. How in the hell can it be possible that, no matter the distance, two entangled particles can influence/change the state of the particle its entangled with..instantaneously?
The fastest thing in the universe is the speed of light, but that looks like a snail place compared to how quickly things work at the quantum level if in fact they are communicating by some sort of signal. So how can it be possible? What signal or mechanism could exist for something to move THAT fast. And if its not using a signal then how can one particle know what the state of the other is and when it changes instantly?
Honestly the strongest evidence for simulation theory imo is this creepy science of quantum entanglements.
129
u/GloInTheDarkUnicorn 12h ago
Asha Degree, from North Carolina. She was 9 years old when she vanished from her bedroom during a big storm. She was witnessed walking alone down highway 18. Her backpack was found a year later, buried at a construction site. There’s no apparent motive for her leaving, and no other evidence has been found.
149
u/SinkOne5599 13h ago
The disappearance of the Sodder children. Five kids vanished after a house fire in 1945, and their parents never found convincing evidence that they died in it. The uncertainty is haunting
16
u/ThatBlueFoxyote 10h ago edited 10m ago
The disappearance of Fay Rawley from his house in Summum Illinois in 1953.
He's believed to be buried in a nearby strip mine along with his brand new Cadillac.
70
u/Geoff_Kay 14h ago edited 8h ago
The disappearance of Jennifer Kesse. Happened in Orlando, FL in 2006 (I think). No clues as to what happened to her, but some guy (that no one recognizes) parked her car in an apartment complex parking lot a mile from her home the day after her disappearance.
**Edited for clarity
30
u/Summerof5ft6andahalf 6h ago
Théo Hayez, an 18 year old Belgian backpacker who vanished after leaving a bar in NSW in 2019. A cap was found that seems to have belonged to him, but otherwise there's no indication of what happened to him. (There's a bunch of theories, of course.)
37
u/Rigel-tones 12h ago
I recently learned about the disappearance of Barbara Bolick, and as someone who reads a lot about mysterious disappearances, I was shocked I had never heard of this one.
I am quick to believe disappearances in wilderness to be misadventure, as the wilderness is unforgiving, and I think it’s probably still the most likely in her case. But it is very bewildering considering the location, her experience, and the alleged timing of events based on the person who was with her.
50
u/Much-Injury1499 15h ago
The Lead Masks Case out of Brazil
22
u/bumbleb33- 13h ago
Thr disappearance of Ben Needham from Kos in the early 90s. His poor mum
11
u/netflist 3h ago
There’s a whole website devoted to this premise called The Charley Project, which I highly recommend everyone follows. It documents thousands of missing persons cases that have been under-reported in the media - there are some truly insane rabbit holes to go down there.
10
u/jessiemagill 7h ago
The death of Keith Warren
32
u/BiscuitCat1 11h ago
Wasn’t the question for mysteries that AREN’T well-known?? This is a re-hashing of cases that are always talked about. Pay attention people.
9
u/iffyClyro 15h ago
Alan Bryant’s disappearance.
17
u/Jappers1980 8h ago
Russell and Shirley Dermond. So many bizarre circumstances with this case.
35
u/crazyshadylady 13h ago
Lindsay Buziak
156
u/Zealousideal_Gap432 15h ago
Epstein files , especially with the new autopsy reports coming out. It goes way deeper than we all think
22
u/Gone_Girl 12h ago
Claudia Lawrence, who went missing in York, UK. I just finished listening to a podcast series about her and there is something very weird indeed about this.
14
u/ZacBogus 8h ago
tbh it feels like the community just collectively decided to move on and pretend it didn't happen. like, people are out here mackin on at clubs and worrying about rent hikes, meanwhile some family is literally checking their phone every single day hoping for a notification that never comes. there's this weird guilt in forgetting, you know? like if we stop talking about it, did we erase him? i don't know. it's just heavy. everyone has their own mysteries they carry around, but this one feels like it belongs to the whole city and nobody wants to pick it up. idk man. just tired.
14
u/stackjr 6h ago
A woman that was friends with my family disappeared back in 1997 and we have no idea what happened to her. The police found her car, along with the night's deposit from the bar she worked at, but never found her. Almost 30 years later and nothing has been learned. She's just gone.
23
u/aidenccpy 9h ago
what came before the big bang
10
u/bigtiming77 8h ago
the case of the Dermond kids always gets me. two children vanished in broad daylight in Ohio and nothing happened. i remember reading about it when i was younger and thinking how messed up it is that people can just evaporate. decades later we still have zero resolution. it feels like time is mocking us. i keep thinking about what their parents went through waiting for news that never came. it's too much. honestly sometimes i think we're all just forgetting on purpose because remembering hurts too bad.
31
u/ContentDot8973 14h ago
Disappearance of Brian Shaffer
4
u/Wishart2016 5h ago
Theo Hayez, the Belgian backpacker. Byron Bay and the Northern Rivers region of New South Wales have a lot of missing people and there are cults and possibly a serial killer operating in this area.
4
u/DonutWhole9717 4h ago
Jessica Lee Caldwell of Bell CO KY
She was last heard from on June 15th 2018. She told her family that if anything were to happen to her, to go after her abusive boyfriend. She was supposed to call one of them by a certain time, and then didnt. He is in jail/prison on other charges, drug related iirc. Plenty of local theories- my own is that shes buried deep in coal country. Whether that's Bell, Harlan, Leslie, or Pike counties, or plumb across the state lines into WV
7
u/OkQuarter4098 10h ago
The disappearance of the Beaumont children in Australia. It happens when on daylight at a beach
9
u/LemmieDovato 13h ago
Look up the disappearance of Tamara Keepness.
9
u/Londonvibe39 10h ago
I don’t know but the red grid mark phenomenon is super weird to me. My boyfriend had those marks once. We have no idea what it was from. He woke up with them.
9
u/rooftrash 8h ago
Jason Jolkowski. Kind of known but there being ZERO leads in all years since is so scary to me
11
u/slow70 8h ago
Look into the deaths of plasma and antigravity scientists and the disappearance of cleared personnel connected to it.
•
u/DungeonFam30 35m ago
I am so intrigued by the case of Thomas Brown, a teen from a small town in Texas - Canadian, TX to be exact.
Long story short, after hanging out with his friends until close to midnight, there was footage shown of Thomas driving past a gas station towards the outskirts of town. The next morning, his car was found abandoned but he was nowhere to be found. Even after a search party got together to scan the area they found nothing.
Sometime later, Thomas' backpack randomly appeared in the area, and I believe his body was eventually found too, even further away.
No one in that town is admitting what happened to Thomas - not the (former?) sheriff who was acting a bit shady regarding the case, nor the brother whose car was seen heading the same direction as Thomas' on the same reel of footage, some minutes after Thomas drove by.
12
u/KestrelWindhover 12h ago
The Springfield Three
7
u/Lopsided_Arachnid_37 6h ago
The dyatlov pass incident keeps me up sometimes, nine hikers cutting their own tent open in the snow and nobody ever fully explained why… it gets a lot less airtime than the usual true crime stuff, don’t you think?
15
u/SailorVenus23 13h ago
The death of Kris Kremers and Liseanne Froon. They were international travelers in Panama who either got separated or wandered away from a hiking group. Only a few pieces of them were found, including a camera with a picture of the back of a head, a full backpack, and a boot with the severed foot still inside it.
27
u/Iowa_Dave 14h ago
The DB Cooper case .
In 1971, a man calling himself D.B. Cooper hijacked a Northwest Orient flight, claimed he had a bomb, and demanded $200,000 and parachutes. He released the passengers in Seattle, then had the plane take off again with a small crew. Somewhere over the Pacific Northwest, he jumped out into the night with the money and was never conclusively found. The case became a legend, part mystery, part pop culture, with only scraps of cash ever turning up years later.
I like Comedian Kyle Kinane's theory that it was a story concocted by the crew, they tossed some money and parachutes out the plane's rear hatch. They hid the money somewhere in a maintenance compartment and retrieved it later.
4
u/Responder343 15h ago
What is the answer to the Dorabella cipher.
4
u/ComparisonPopular235 11h ago
I still really hope we find out who was mailing that antharax
2
u/Fantastic_Step8417 3h ago
Anything Epstein related
•
u/Lepronna 53m ago
The Chicago Tylenol poisoning is so disturbing to me, I feel awful for those families.
Also The Monster with 21 Faces, not as disturbing but absolutely fascinates me. To do so much damage so loudly and then disappear is crazy.
3
u/Art_and_dogs 12h ago
Gareth Williams
5
u/PieIndependent9782 9h ago
the Malaysian airlines flight 370
1
u/Mewbey 1h ago
Luke Joly-Durocher