r/AskReddit • • 6h ago

People in the US, how would you feel about a constitutional amendment to allow a super majority of congress to overturn a presidential pardon limited in scope to a current president's time in office?

124 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

35

u/Educational_Disk_226 5h ago

I want a constitutional amendment removing the president’s authority to pardon themself or anyone in their administration. I would be also be open to preventing a president from pardoning family members. Make it retroactive.

8

u/314R8 5h ago

Only pardons approved by a committee can go to the president.

3

u/Safety_Drance 5h ago

I like all of these ideas. A pardon approved by the president after going through congress makes complete sense to me.

5

u/MoS29 5h ago

Congress has been gridlocked for years. They've been abdicating their duties to the executive over the course of decades on both sides of the aisle for the most part. Pardons going through Congress means next to no pardons happen.

3

u/cd85233 5h ago

Does the president need to pardon himself? I guess maybe for things prior to office, but now the president can do whatver they want during their time with impunity. 

4

u/Safety_Drance 5h ago

Does the president need to pardon himself?

It's a legal theory that hasn't been tested previously and is going to end up before the Supreme Court for sure.

3

u/nsomnac 5h ago

The current SCOTUS effectively ruled that the president cannot be prosecuted for anything they perform as an official act while in office - which is effectively no different than a pardon.

1

u/gringledoom 1h ago

Future-SCOTUS can always do the “gosh, all of you simply misunderstood what we meant when we wrote those words down!” 180

•

u/Human_Strike8489 49m ago

That's an idea that should've been stipulated in the conditions of qualifying for pardon. Guess when they wrote it they never imagined there would come a time when a president has no integrity 

9

u/Efficient-Slide-8377 5h ago

The tricky part is deciding how to prevent self-serving pardons without turning Congress into an appeals court for presidential decisions. Any amendment would need very narrow grounds and clear safeguards against partisan abuse.

2

u/Safety_Drance 5h ago

Any amendment would need very narrow grounds and clear safeguards against partisan abuse.

Completely agreed. A constitutional amendment is a big deal and needs to be written and thought out completely.

1

u/gerbilsbite 4h ago

I can think of worse things than restoring the legislative veto to Congress. It worked well enough for a long time before the Court killed it in the 80s.

14

u/Headoutdaplane 5h ago

I would take it away completely or at the very least be confirmed by the Senate.

4

u/Safety_Drance 5h ago

No argument there. A president being able to just pardon away every crime they and their friends committed shouldn't have any place in society.

4

u/The_Comm_Guy 5h ago

A president can’t pardon themselves.

5

u/Tarantula_Saurus_Rex 5h ago

Yes they can, there's no explicit ban on doing it. Because a pardon is granted it's assumed to be given to someone else, but there's no language stating otherwise. It would have to be challenged in court... if it ever happens. There is a past SC ruling stating "no one may judge their own case", but that's not the same as a pardon, a pardon isn't a court trial, just a wave of immunity.

2

u/ms_directed 3h ago

it becomes a circular argument considering SCOTUS ruled that a POTUS is "immune" for any act he does while "doing his presidential duties", the dissenting justices warned this would prevent any justice for unlawful acts because the president can just hide behind the vagueness of "a presidential act" - so there's no reason he would need to pardon himself for anything since everything he does can be deemed as "an official act"

Sotomayor even gave the example of a POTUS ordering the military to kill a political rival during the oral arguments and Roberts dismissed her hypothetical in the majority ruling as "fear mongering".

1

u/superbackman 5h ago

I love it, just make pardons follow the same process as any SCOTUS nominee: President nominates someone for pardon, then the senate has to confirm them. Or better yet, the House (more representative than the senate).

3

u/mogelijk 4h ago

My issue is that this may lead to it becoming to political. I'm sure the House or Senate of the last two years would have approved pretty much all Trump's pardons; and in the next two years they might just automatically refuse all the pardons and not judge each individually.

What I'd prefer is a group of Congresspersons -- maybe the leadership of both parties in the House/Senate, where you have equal numbers from both parties, or the leadership appoints a certain number from their party to do the job. By having an equal number, it is more likely they actually look at the pardons and judge them fairly.

112

u/bitemytail 5h ago

Getting a super majority to agree to reverse a pardon would be basically impossible.

44

u/ZAlternates 5h ago

At that point, impeach and remove from office if they are abusing pardoning power.

7

u/davideogameman 4h ago

sounds nice, but we've never successfully removed any president by impeachment. I think only a cabinet official or two have gotten axed. Nixon did resign under imminent impeachment, but Trump has done just as bad if not worse and clearly impeachment couldn't push him out.

7

u/ZAlternates 3h ago

It’s a fictitious world where you’re able to get a supermajority vote against the president to undo or block a pardon. If you’re able to do this, you have enough to impeach and remove.

20

u/-notapony- 5h ago edited 58m ago

Limiting the vote to during the president’s term in office incentivizes the President to shift all of their pardons to their last few hours in office.  

*edited an odd autocorrect issue

4

u/TheRedLions 2h ago

Oh yeah, like any president would do that /s

(Ftr: Biden, Trump, Obama, Clinton, Bush Sr, and Reagan all pardoned one or more people immediately before leaving.)

•

u/-notapony- 56m ago

Understood, but if the only restriction on the pardon power was that they were all untouchable once their term was over, this is the obvious way to defeat the restriction.  It’s also one that, to your point, Presidents have already grown accustomed to, if only to lessen any political blowback on providing them. 

76

u/Alaska_Jack 5h ago • Bravo

I think a better idea -- and one pretty much all Americans would agree on -- is:

No pre-emptive pardons. In other words, a president can only pardon someone who has actually been convicted of a crime.

14

u/Cynical_Manatee 4h ago

This is the most sensible take so far.

Have the pardons only apply to convictions under the current law. Then if a president abuses the pardon, Congress can impeach the sitting president, and if the impeachment is successful, then all pardons from the president is void.

And to prevent last minute pardons, Congress is allowed to impeach former presidents up to a certain limit.

4

u/juggles_geese4 3h ago

That would really suck for the people that get pardoned that have no relation or connection to the president though. Though I think Trump was selling pardons last presidency (or it was rumored anyway) and that’s crossing a line as well and I think actually might break some laws we already have but you know we have an immuned king anyway so what do laws matter.

4

u/davideogameman 4h ago

eh, lets keep brainstorming. Impeachment hasn't stopped Trump from doing anything yet but keep his cool. It hasn't been very effective historically either.

1

u/mannyman3000 1h ago

I agree, impeachment and removal should cause all pardons issued by that president to go through the same process. So the senate needs a 2/3 majority to negate any pardon by the removed president.

•

u/PMMeUrHopesNDreams 42m ago

What would impeaching a former President do? Impeachment is just a trial to determine if they should be removed from office. Being removed from office is the punishment. You can't remove someone from office if they're no longer in office.

2

u/mannyman3000 2h ago

In order to receive the pardon, don’t you have to admit guilt to the crime being pardoned?

And I think Jimmy Carter pardoned anyone accused of dodging the Vietnam war draft, and it was issued in such a way that the pardon extended to people whose draft-dodging hadn’t come to legal light yet.

1

u/morningwoodx420 1h ago

To take this further, a certain amount of time needs to have passed since the conviction. That way, a president cannot pardon people who may have committed crimes on their behalf.

0

u/7LeagueBoots 2h ago

And the pardon doesn’t remove the crime or record of the crime. And it doesn’t prevent states from pursuing their own legal paths.

0

u/tismij 2h ago

Also how about a limit on the number of pardons?

65

u/vaporeng 5h ago

I'd rather ban presidential pardons.

24

u/quesoandcats 5h ago

I like the idea of a pardon but there should be limits. Maybe start with banning the president from pardoning himself, his family members, or anyone in the executive branch

3

u/IAMA_Shark__AMA 1h ago

Yeah. I'm not sure who it serves when we have presidents handing out pardons to people whom our justice system has deemed guilty - especially when their crimes were violent in nature!

Pardoning Vietnam draft dodgers? Sure, ok. Pardoning the guy who triggered the My Lai massacre? What a fucking joke.

7

u/ProfessorBackdraft 5h ago

I would rather see two things, 1)a prohibition on a pardon eliminating any financial judgments and 2)prohibiting a pardon for any conspiracy in which the President was a fellow conspirator, a pardon for which the President received remuneration of any kind, or any pardon resulting from the carrying out of duties delegated by the pardoning President.

8

u/boakes123 5h ago

Why not just eliminate it altogether?

3

u/Emperor_Neuro 5h ago

Because there are three branches of the government and they all interact with the law differently. The legislative branch, Congress, makes the laws. The judicial branch, the Supreme Court, ensures those laws are in keeping with the other laws in the system. The executive branch, which the president is directly in charge of, is the branch for law enforcement. The executive cannot create new laws on their own, but they do have the power to veto and/or decline enforcement of laws the other branches have made. The judicial branch can also strike down laws so this power is not necessarily only the president’s. And if a president is abusing this power? That’s what impeachment is for.

3

u/TrendWarrior101 5h ago

Congress is already too partisan as it is, and having the supermajority to overturn the pardon is very tough and be subject to political considerations. Besides, why should they be given the roles where they are other suitable ways like having some kind of clemency board reviewing pardons?

3

u/Friendly_Tea7679 5h ago

I'd support it, especially for pardons that appear to protect the president or people involved in their own administration. A pardon shouldn't be a blank check against accountability.

3

u/DoxieDachsie 4h ago

The President can issue all his pardons on his last morning in office. No way to reverse that.

3

u/mogelijk 4h ago

I'd prefer a pardon committee, of some type. Maybe a group made up equally of both parties, perhaps the majority (to include the Speaker) leader and whip, as well as the minority leaders meet do approve Pardons/commutations approved by the President. Alternatively, maybe a panel made up of half the Supreme Court justices.

3

u/EuphoricCrashOut 2h ago

How about just no Pardons. Serious question, when was a Pardon ever used in the best example of why it exists?

•

u/Kelby091 44m ago

I believe Obama pardoned a bunch of people going to prison for non violent drug possession charges.

•

u/Thin-Rip-3686 16m ago

Vietnam draft dodgers.

The power of the pardon needs to be reformed, not abrogated.

5

u/chuckop 5h ago

No, but I would support some sort of common-sense restrictions on Presidential pardons.

Like no pardons for future prosecutions.

6

u/Charming-Papaya9742 5h ago

Nah then you are mixing the powers of the branches.

-2

u/stewie3128 5h ago

We already do that by Senate confirmation of cabinet members etc.

3

u/Charming-Papaya9742 5h ago

Yep checks and balances

Pardons are judicial checks and balances from executive 

2

u/Weary_Management_566 5h ago

Eh, I'd rather we just didnt elect openly corrupt grifters

2

u/nicubunu 5h ago

If it is a good amendment, it must not be limited to a current president. If the current president is bad, use the supermajority to impeach him, not to pass a temporary constitutional amendment.

5

u/stewie3128 5h ago

It would be more worthwhile to limit the president to a single pardon of a single human person per administration (not per term) who has been found guilty of a crime.

Additionally, they also get a single commutation of a single human person.

Cannot be themselves, their immediate or extended family, anyone who has been employed or paid by their administration, or who has functioned in an official or unofficial consulting/advising capacity.

The idea is to limit it to pardoning the wrongly convicted.

2

u/sengirminion 5h ago

They can keep it as is but make it so if someone was ever an employee of the Federal Government, they are not able to be pardoned for any crimes.

2

u/stewie3128 5h ago

Then Trump-like presidents will hire people to do their crimes and de facto run their admins as outside consultants.

4

u/erkose 5h ago

Just end pardons. Getting a super majority in these extreme partisan days is too difficult.

3

u/Euphoric_Anxiety_162 5h ago

no - there is a catch in there.

3

u/cathbadh 5h ago

Overturn? No. Once it's done, it's done However, some form of review/approval for blanket pardons exceeding a few months (such as "all crimes committed over a decade"), mass pardons ("everyone who ever sold drugs"), or members of that President's administration above a certain level/rank.

Every President has done some shitty pardons. It's unavoidable. But limiting the most outrageous ones is in our best interests.

4

u/Dont_Ban_Me_Bros 5h ago

Why the hell does the pardon exist? Why is justice allowed to be overruled or avoided entirely by one person?

11

u/abqguardian 4h ago

Its a check on the judicial branch

1

u/LysergioXandex 3h ago

The judicial branch is already kinda strange because of the escalating appeals process.

Like, there is no congressional “appeal” really… I guess a federal law could supersede a bad state law (or is it the other way around, like for cannabis legalization?)

Or maybe the concept kind of exists for the executive branch, since you could escalate your complaint to the president if, eg, the head of the FDA wasn’t listening.

But the presidential pardon seems like a unique form a “check” by completely extracting specific instances from the judicial process, and without a way for the judicial branch to overrule (like congress can overrule a veto).

1

u/kingjoey52a 2h ago

What would a congressional appeal be? Laws passed by Congress get appealed through the courts, do you mean something else?

1

u/LysergioXandex 1h ago

I mean, the judicial system as an escalating hierarchical review system inside itself (all the way up to the Supreme Court) while that system isn’t really something you see from the other branches.

So a “check” on the judicial branch is an extremely strong power (since there are internal mechanisms within the branch that also check the power at various levels in the appeal process). And when that pardon “check” gets used, it can’t even be overruled like a presidential veto can. You can’t get a bunch of judges together to override a pardon, for example.

-4

u/SurturOfMuspelheim 3h ago

People still believe checks and balances work lol

-1

u/TortieByNature 2h ago

i don't believe anyone said they work... :/

-1

u/SurturOfMuspelheim 2h ago

If so they should word their comment differently. Such as "it's supposed to be"

7

u/amelia3136 4h ago

Pardons can be a safety valve: a punishment may be lawful yet unjust. That's a reason to preserve clemency, not give presidents a blank check.

4

u/gerbilsbite 4h ago

The ability to quickly and decisively overturn a miscarriage of justice is good. Repositing all that power in a single individual is what’s most troubling to me. Many states have solved that issue with pardon boards.

-1

u/frddtwabrm04 2h ago

Shouldn't it be done at some board level vs one arbitrary person?

I mean look at how both Biden and trump abused it

3

u/mschuster91 2h ago

Biden didn’t abuse it though, the Republicans made it exceptionally clear they’d go on a revenge witch hunt

-5

u/ropean 4h ago

It’s an artifact of a bygone era; the founders didn’t want a king, yet they gave the president a king-like power to override the legal system they carefully crafted to be as protective of the innocent as possible. I’d rather the pardon power be taken away since it’s too often used in corrupt ways, especially by this administration.

2

u/mrbeck1 5h ago

I don’t think it’s “due process” if Congress can vote you re-guilty. That’s not much different than a bill of attainder.

1

u/Bac0ni 5h ago

It would be mostly pointless and impossible to pass. Maybe we should start impeaching presidents who pardon criminals that are undeserving

1

u/Akchika 5h ago

There should be limits on pardon power for sure. For starters mandatory minimum time served and type of crimes.

1

u/TruckerLogix 5h ago

As part of several new amendments, to avoid the current horsecrap going on, absolutely!

As well I'd love to do term limits on congress, making side money via bribes (legal or not), and playing with stocks a crime if you are in government. Make the position a public service position, instead of a get rich and help your buddies position. Then we might find people who actually are able to do the job that they are obligated to do.

Just imho

1

u/stewie3128 5h ago

Most presidents pardon a bunch of their friends/donors on their way out the door in the last 48 hours of their administrations (Jan. 19/20).

1

u/billysacco 5h ago

Maybe or even just a regular majority. Some kind of check for this power.

1

u/0rbitalDaydream 5h ago

There definitely needs to be some accountability. No president should be able to use pardons to protect themselves or their friends.

1

u/PaxNova 5h ago

I would not do that for any president’s term, nor would I pass an amendment for anything if it were limited to one term.

1

u/Macster_man 5h ago

On the condition that double jeopardy applies, no voting a pardon out and recharging someone with the same crime.

1

u/Acrobatic-Echo-3460 5h ago

I’m 100% for it, especially in terms of this administration, there are such clear ties to quid pro quo pardons it’s not even a question as whether or not these people deserve pardons.

They should also, as others said limit pardons over all, and in my opinion, due away with preemptive pardons. Why the TF do you need a pardon if you didn’t commit a crime? If you did commit a crime and the current administration just that let it happen, but then you investigated and found guilty by the following administration, well, that’s just justice.

1

u/Crazy_names 4h ago

That sounds very targeted at one particular individual in one particular time frame. To me, a better idea would be a super majority to overturn a pardon for a particular charge deemed egregious enough to defy the executive branch with a super majority. It creates an opening to really hold someone accountable despite a pardon but with such a high bar for it to only be used in the rarest of cases.

1

u/DanteRuneclaw 4h ago

Along the same lines as overriding a veto. I’d be fine with it. It should probably have to be within a specific time frame of the pardon being issued, so there’s some finality.

1

u/D1rtyH1ppy 3h ago

I'd like to have an amendment that can force a vote of no confidence and trigger an automatic election for any elected official 

1

u/Human_Strike8489 1h ago

Great idea,  current administration would never let it happen.  

•

u/perez_jennifer_70 58m ago

I'd support it if each pardon required a public written rationale, so lawmakers and voters could judge the stated reason against the case.

•

u/Snail_Paw4908 42m ago

I'd ask why you are wasting time on this instead of passing the universal healthcare the people really need.

•

u/sophie_g-11649 11m ago

I'd support a narrow override only if the person affected gets notice and a chance to be heard; Congress shouldn't decide their fate without hearing them.

1

u/userlivewire 5h ago

There should be no power that a President has that can't be overturned by a large enough percentage of Congress.

1

u/Mo_Jack 1h ago

get rid of presidential pardons especially the ones signed by presidents that are felons.

0

u/AlfredRWallace 5h ago

Pardon power is too easy to abuse. Just remove it completely.

0

u/MrX2285 5h ago

Presidential pardons are wild. The whole idea is that we are trusting a partisan actor above judges. In very rare cases with classified information I get it, but that's not how it's used

0

u/Yiplzuse 5h ago

Presidential powers are so wildly out of control this would be a good idea. You could trigger a trial in the Senate if the house gets a certain number of votes challenging a pardon. This would be the way you stop…oh…I don’t know…maybe if you had a convicted felon as president…sounds really crazy but this would be the way you stop them from selling a pardon. The Senate trial would examine the reason for and person to whom a pardon was granted.

0

u/Defiantfellow 5h ago

“No pardon issued by the president will take effect earlier than 90 days from issuance and during this 90 day period the US Senate may by majority vote preclude the pardon from taking effect.”

Such a constitutional amendment would have likely prevented Hunter Biden’s pardon as well as the January 6th insurrectionists.

-7

u/AdamoMeFecit 5h ago

That would be unconstitutional. You would need a constitutional amendment to enable that.

5

u/Safety_Drance 5h ago

I literally said it would be a constitutional amendment. Constitutional amendment is in the title.

5

u/AmbulanceChaser12 5h ago

Read the question again.

2

u/AlfredRWallace 5h ago

OP said constitutional amendment

-4

u/superbackman 5h ago

How about this: the president can pardon anyone for any reason, but he has to swap places with the pardoned person and serve out the rest of their sentence and pay their fines.