r/AskStatistics • u/Impressive_Food_6005 • 18h ago
First post on reddit, uh I have a statistics problem
I live at point H, which is exactly a 7-minute walk from two train stations, Station A and Station B.
The three points form a right-isosceles triangle, with H as the 90° angle. Stations A and B are connected by the train line, which forms the hypotenuse.
The train travels along the route in this order:
A → B → C → D → E ...
Some additional information:
Trains arrive every 10 minutes.
The train travels at 20 mph.
It stops at each station for 50 seconds.
My destination is Station D.
Walking to either Station A or Station B takes exactly 7 minutes.
The train takes 2 minutes to travel from station A to B after leaving the station
The question:
Would it be more efficient to walk to Station A, which is earlier on the train route, or Station B, which is closer to my destination?
More specifically, does boarding at Station A give me any advantage in terms of the probability of catching a train, or is Station B mathematically the better choice since I have the same walking time but a shorter journey aboard the train?
Is there a mathematical way to determine which station is optimal?
Also, I've simplified the above problem a tad.
During rush hour, two trains run on the track. One only stops at station A, C, E, G, etc, wheras the other only stops at stations B, D, F, H, etc. (though both inevitably stop at my destination)
The same rules apply to them, meaning that Train 1 arrives at station A every ten minutes, and Train 2 arrives at station B every ten minutes.
Does this change the outcome of the problem?
Hopefully I can make my commute more efficient :)