Hey everyone,
I've been experiencing severe FPS drops and random stuttering on my ASUS TUF Gaming A16 for quite some time. I initially dismissed it as game optimization issues, but after several hours of troubleshooting and logging with HWiNFO, I finally have some data showing what's happening.
I'm hoping someone with similar hardware or experience with AMD's STAPM limits can help me understand this.
Laptop specifications
- Model: ASUS TUF Gaming A16 FA608PP
- CPU: AMD Ryzen 9 8940HX
- GPU: NVIDIA RTX 5070 Laptop GPU (8 GB)
- RAM: 32 GB DDR5
- OS: Windows 11 26H2
- BIOS: V322 (updated from V311)
- Control software: ASUS Armoury Crate
- Power: Original ASUS charger
The problem
I've experienced severe FPS drops and stuttering in both Red Dead Redemption 2 and Remnant: From the Ashes.
So far, I've only captured HWiNFO sensor logs for Remnant. During that test, HWiNFO intermittently reported average CPU core clocks near 0.55 GHz, coinciding with significant FPS drops.
RDR2 has been particularly inconsistent, sometimes running above 80–100 FPS before dropping into the 20s.
Initially, I suspected the RTX 5070, GPU selection, graphics settings, or drivers. However, the issue persisted even after explicitly selecting the dedicated GPU.
I eventually started recording HWiNFO sensor logs to investigate.
Test 1: Performance mode
Recorded while playing Remnant: From the Ashes.
The complete recording is approximately 442 seconds, with the selected gameplay window spanning approximately 16–126 seconds. Sensor polling was approximately every 2 seconds.
Findings:
- 11 samples showed reported average CPU core clocks below 1 GHz, ranging from approximately 544–793 MHz.
- Every sub-1 GHz sample coincided with APU STAPM at 99.6% or higher.
- The global CPU frequency limit dropped as low as 730 MHz.
- Maximum CPU temperature across the recording: 96.1°C.
- HWiNFO's HTC and PROCHOT flags remained "No".
The strangest behavior is how STAPM fluctuates.
During the problematic interval, STAPM repeatedly alternates between approximately 50% and 100%.
When it approaches 100%, the reported average core clock frequently drops toward 550 MHz. When it returns to approximately 50%, reported clocks recover to around 2.6–3.5 GHz.
The pattern repeats multiple times.
Before these rapid fluctuations begin, between approximately 28–54 seconds of the recording, CPU package power stays almost perfectly flat at approximately 49.7 W, suggesting a possible sustained power cap.
There's also a measurable FPS difference.
During the problematic interval (~80–126 seconds):
- The 11 sub-1 GHz samples averaged approximately 39 FPS.
- The other 13 samples averaged approximately 76 FPS.
- Average dGPU utilization was approximately 16% in the low-clock samples versus 41% in the others.
However, average effective-clock readings were similar between the groups (approximately 503 versus 518 MHz). Therefore, I don't consider the sampled 550 MHz core-clock readings proof that the CPU continuously operated at that frequency for several seconds.
The FPS degradation and STAPM correlation are real, but the exact throttling mechanism remains uncertain.
The abrupt STAPM fluctuations make me suspect platform-level power management or embedded-controller behavior, although cooling or another limitation could also be involved.
Test 2: Turbo mode
I repeated the Remnant test using Armoury Crate's Turbo profile.
The difference was substantial.
- No recorded average core-clock readings below 1 GHz.
- Lowest reported average core clock during gameplay: approximately 2.89 GHz.
- Maximum recorded STAPM: 83.4%.
- Average CPU package power during gameplay: approximately 65 W.
- Gameplay was noticeably smoother.
However, Turbo isn't thermally comfortable either.
- Maximum CPU temperature: 96.9°C.
- The CPU thermal-limit sensor was at or above 99.5% for 44 of 54 gameplay samples, approximately 88 seconds at the recording interval.
- CPU fan reached 6,200 RPM.
- GPU fan reached 6,600 RPM.
- CPU frequency limits were still being reduced under thermal pressure.
- HTC and PROCHOT flags continued reporting "No".
The Turbo recording was also shorter: approximately 134 seconds compared with 442 seconds for Performance mode.
STAPM reached 83.4% during the recording, so I cannot conclude that Turbo would remain unaffected during a longer gaming session.
Turbo avoided the extreme reported clock collapses in this test, but that doesn't establish that the cooling system is healthy or that the profile is stable indefinitely.
Troubleshooting already performed
- Updated motherboard BIOS from V311 to V322.
- Updated NVIDIA VBIOS and graphics drivers.
- Explicitly selected the RTX 5070 in Windows Graphics settings.
- Tested Standard and Ultimate GPU modes.
- Compared Armoury Crate Performance and Turbo profiles.
- Reproduced poor gaming performance in RDR2 and Remnant.
- Logged CPU clocks, effective clocks, power, temperatures, STAPM, thermal limits, GPU utilization, and fan speeds.
The BIOS update did not eliminate the Performance-mode issue.
I've experienced stuttering for quite some time, including before the recent Windows 26H2 update, so I'm hesitant to attribute everything to Windows.
One additional detail
The laptop was opened on the day of purchase for RAM and SSD upgrades.
I haven't personally repasted the CPU or modified its voltages or power limits.
I don't know whether anything involving the cooling assembly was disturbed during installation. Normally, RAM and SSD upgrades shouldn't require removing the CPU heatsink.
I'm mentioning this because I don't want to rule out a physical issue without proper inspection.
Questions
- Has anyone else with an ASUS TUF A16 or Ryzen 9 8940HX experienced similar reported 500–600 MHz clock drops?
- Could the rapid STAPM fluctuations indicate an embedded-controller/firmware power-management problem, or could cooling issues produce similar behavior?
- Why would Performance mode show such extreme clock-limit behavior while Turbo maintains higher clocks despite operating close to the CPU's thermal limit?
- Is there anything else worth checking before taking the laptop to an authorized technician?
I've attached two graphs generated from sanitized HWiNFO logs, comparing the operating modes and the relationship between STAPM and reported CPU clocks.
The recordings use approximately 2-second sampling. The game runs were not synchronized to identical scenes, so the graphs should not be interpreted as controlled, scene-matched performance benchmarks.
I also have sanitized CSVs containing the underlying sensor measurements and elapsed time, and I'm happy to share a link if anyone wants to examine them.
I'm planning to have a local technician who also handles ASUS systems inspect the laptop, and if necessary, pursue service through my ASUS warranty.
I'm not particularly concerned about getting the absolute highest FPS. I just want the machine to perform consistently without severe stuttering.
Note: The graphs were prepared with AI assistance using real HWiNFO sensor logs. All measurements are from my laptop, and the plotted values were cross-checked against the original CSVs.
A Ryzen 9 and RTX 5070 shouldn't need divine intervention to run Remnant or RDR2 smoothly. 🫠
Any insights would be appreciated!