r/AttackOnRetards • • 1h ago

Discussion/Question How would have Erwin dealt with Zeke and Yelena?

Post image
3 Upvotes

In season 4, zeke and yelena were hugely responsible for putting paradise into great political turmoil. Starting with the wine plan. They placed such a lethal weapon that wiped most of paradise millitary officers in one swipe.

A huge reason for this was that Hange as a commander did not put a tight leash on the volunteers. This lead to yelena pleading with the government and ultimately marleyan prisoners be given jobs in restaurant where they served the tainted wine on yelena's command.

Most of Zeke's plan relies on yelena. The wine communicating with eren, introducing kiyomi, helping form the yeagerist, taking over paradise millitary. If yelena fails, so does majority of Zeke's plan.

If Erwin was alive and the commander, How could he have dealt with them. Do you think Zeke would be able to outsmart him with the wine. Hange was good in sone areas regarding leadership and command, but she lacked the authority to keep everyone in line

Also it really baffles me how zeke, who has spend most of his life planning for his euthanasia plan, who quite easily manipulated both Marley and paradise to get what he wants, trusted yelena for his plans. What would yelena have done to gain his trust that he entrusted the whole plan to her. We all know that eldians are looked down on.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 1d ago

Discussion/Question Should we have gotten another season in between 3 and the final?

Post image
34 Upvotes

I just ask because maybe it would have made the changes fell less abrupt and give more time to explain everything.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 2d ago

Stupid take The ending is bad because Eren got redemption.

Post image
11 Upvotes

I don’t understand some people who think that Eren got redemption in the ending. What redemption? We were just shown his reasons for why he caused the rumbling and how painful all those actions were for him. Moreover, after Eren’s death, many will treat him as a devil, not as a savior.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 2d ago

Discussion/Question Is this statement belong to isayama or is it fake?

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/AttackOnRetards • • 2d ago

Rant The outside world in Attack on titan was way too comically evil

Post image
0 Upvotes

I understand that humans are inherently prone to hate and stuff, btu there is no possible way that it could become this widespread. Even during the height of segregation there were stll plenty of non-black people who considered it unfair and wanted it to end. Even with Nazi Germany, who the outside world is modeled after, was restricted to one nation, who no one trusted all that much and lasted a very brief period of time relatively speaking., Also, it's not like the Ancient Eldian Empire occupied the entire world, there should be plenty of countries with absolutely no history with the Eldians who are just suddenly expected to feel the same fanatical hatred that the Eldian Empire's former territories do?

Am I the only one that finds it all pretty unrealistic?


r/AttackOnRetards • • 3d ago

Let's all just go outside and touch grass. If you ever felt stupid just remember 4 years from now there still Pro Genocide fans that still cope like this.

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Context: just scrolling through IG and saw this little SOB brother still believes Eren gave up on doing the rumbling and keeps believing Eren did it for Paradis.

What part of him admitting he was wrong and was force to because of the vision this brother didn't understand its really funny ton of ending haters are either coping, wants Eren to be a dark gigachad mass murderer.

I mean since season 1 Eren always view himself as stupid and selfish and childish he's basically an immature version of Ed from FMA and a tragic ending of Sasuke from Naruto.

Like imagine years from now fans like this existing yet again if Snyderverse fans thrieve what the odds these haters existing till 2080 lol.

I know IG is just a mess up page like reddit but this just laughable.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 3d ago

Discussion/Question My problem with Eren's supposed stupidity.

0 Upvotes

One of the explanations that Eren did not attempt to change the future to his liking (to achieve full rumbling and protect the lives of all his friends including Hange) was because he was Idiot, next to grandfather's paradox, his love for his friends and his destructive desires.

I DISAGREE.

Before timeskip Eren showed multiple times that he is not the idiot, when not clouded by his anger , he killed two kidnappers of Mikasa by lulling them into false sense of security and using makeshift spear, he was able to see through false persona of Christa Lenz and he properly deducted that he was able to control use coordinate thanks to physical contact with Dina Fritz. After Timeskip he was many times suprised by events that he did not forsee with his clayvoirance, yet managed to deal with them. He located position of Warhamer's crystal and found the way to crack it. He saw through Pieck's bluff in chapter 116 and later he managed to convince Ymir to help him, by his emotional Speech. Yet, when gifted with immensely powerfull powers of Founder, whose limits are not specified, he allowed Hange to die, himself to be killed (and strip himself of seeing view of 100% of the outside world destroyed), left his friends in middle of postapocalyptic world, that was likely to fall into the war over limited resources and exposed Paradise to very likely retribution. All of that so Ymir could (maybe) lift the curse and make powers of titan dissappear, which was not guarented and he did not know, whether that would happen or not. The fact that his plan worked, was more due to luck than his effort, yet earlier we saw him being quite intelligent and capable of devising solid plans. Combined with his immmense willpower and determination (dude became 5 best soldier in 104th training corpe through sheer grith and literally maimed himself to infiltrate enemy city as cripple) this makes his choices in the last 8 chapters of the manga even more puzzling, especially he was granted vast and god-like powers of the founder. Fo example, he could, erase the memories of Jaegerists, so they would not oppose them in the port, lure alliance to him, erase their memories (like he did in ch 131), disarm them, finish the rumbling, return to Paradise, simulate going mad of the guilt, announce via Paths he is about to destroy the Paradise, allow alliance members free themselv, let Mikasa kill him, curse is (hopefully) lifted in the end. My point is with his vast powers, high willpower and solid inteligence Eren should come with better plan to achieve his 3 main goals: see the full outside world as the blank state devoid of human life, protect his friends, secure Paradise's future. The only reason, I can think why he did not do that was because, he was broken by knowledge that he killed his mother and and due to grandfather paradox was unable to change that , but he would not give up without the fight against the paradox. He would attempt to change the past that did not suit him and fight against it evein in vain. The problem is, we did not see him struggling against paradox and being broken by futility of his efforts, nor we did not see any other explanation why he procedeed with so risky and contrary to all of his goals plan. Equivalent of such sudden explanation would be compressing Reiner's backstory, that lasted few chapters in two pages.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 4d ago

Humor/Meme I know that not all of this is fair, but Eren doesn't get nearly as much slander as he deserves

Post image
209 Upvotes

r/AttackOnRetards • • 4d ago

Discussion/Question Stupid Question, but did Yaegereist assisted in poisoning Paradise top command with spinal fluid or were they put before facts accomplished? I am asking, because I have only access to scanlations and translations vary.

3 Upvotes

Basically the title.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 5d ago

Discussion/Question What goes through the minds of people who genuinely believe Eren didn't go far enough?

Thumbnail youtube.com
4 Upvotes

I recently watched a video titled "Eren Yeager Is a Hero. Change My Mind." defending the full Rumbling and arguing that Eren should have finished the job.

Seriously, what goes through these people's heads?

The story explicitly presents alternatives, like the 50-year plan. Chapter 131 makes it clear that Eren's motivations weren't purely about protecting Paradis. He literally admits that part of him wanted to wipe the outside world away because it wasn't what he'd imagined.

And somehow, people watch the Rumbling, see innocent children like Ramzi being crushed, and their conclusion is that Eren didn't kill enough people?

Even worse, some fans dismiss entire chapters as "not canon" because they contradict their preferred version of Eren.

I understand sympathising with Eren and wanting Paradis to survive. But there's a massive difference between understanding his motivations and arguing that exterminating the entire outside world was the only reasonable solution.

Did we even watch the same story? How do people finish Attack on Titan and genuinely come away thinking Eren's biggest mistake was not completing the genocide?


r/AttackOnRetards • • 5d ago

Humor/Meme Eren Yeager: the biggest hypocrite In Anime Nuff said

Post image
0 Upvotes

When he called out Reiner and Berdoldht for not being heroes or warriors but for being mass murderers killing so many innocent people who committed genocide and the ones who turned this world into a living hell I was so on board with him then season 4 came along and I was like….Eren you might be one of the characters of all time to eat their words and swallow it all until he PUKES lmao


r/AttackOnRetards • • 5d ago

Art Eren Jeager and The Attack Titan by George Bilianidis

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/AttackOnRetards • • 8d ago

Stupid take The irony of this moral LARP dipshit

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

You can’t say the shit shown in slide 1 and then cross your legs like you got kicked in the nuts elsewhere


r/AttackOnRetards • • 9d ago

Negativity Mystery Box ruined AOT

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/AttackOnRetards • • 10d ago

Discussion/Question I genuinely lost brain cells reading this.

Thumbnail
gallery
158 Upvotes

These guys really think when Eren was ripping his chains off he was thinking about his child. Not that zeke was about to win and enact his plan. I can’t believe this shit lmao. Why are these guys so obsessed with Historia being some Type of trad wife breeding machine for Eren when there is 0 evidence in the story that had anything going on but being platonic friends.

It was already confirmed several chapters ago that the person who got her pregnant was a person she grew up with. And she approached him. Why do they want Eren to be a dead beat dad so bad? Why would Eren have kids knowing he’s gonna die? Eren doesn’t care about passing his legacy down Eren literally hates himself.

They make up head cannons about the story and when those head cannons don’t come true they cry retcon and blame isyama🤦‍♂️😂


r/AttackOnRetards • • 11d ago

Discussion/Question From here grisha can't go and rod can't repair hardening so when grisha going out from here to chapel surface in his titan form how he destroy chapel because cave is fully covered by crystal and chapel is on crystal please let me known

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/AttackOnRetards • • 12d ago

Negativity "Pieck also needs to be blamed and punished"

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

It honestly gets exhausting to see comments and posts claiming that Pieck is also to blame (and shows no remorse), and that she faced no consequences for her actions in Ragako village (or that she doesn’t deserve a "good" ending). People also question why Connie would join the Alliance when Pieck is part of it.

Last season explored why certain individuals became warriors and what they went through. Just imagine living in a racist nation, a country that uses your own people as weapons, where killing an Eldian, even for something as minor as theft, is considered acceptable. If you were to desert, that same nation would likely kill everyone you knew and cared about just to make an example of you (which, I assume, is exactly what would have happened).

AOT isn't really about who is "more" guilty or who has or hasn't been punished enough. Yet, people keep arguing over characters like Pieck, Reiner, Annie, and Bertholdt (debating whether they deserve any sympathy or who among them ought to face punishment, and who to blame)


r/AttackOnRetards • • 12d ago

News Attack On Titan 3 - NEW Screenshots #5

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/AttackOnRetards • • 13d ago

Analysis The myth of "Mikasa saved eren many times" and "eren would have died a 1000 times without mikasa".

Post image
12 Upvotes

People usually bring up Mikasa saving eren's life "so many times" to combat the argument that Mikasa is a useless character. But this couldn't be any farther from the truth. Let's have a closer look.

1- the human traffickers: eren is the one who saved Mikasa from them. She then saved him from the 3rd trafficker because he urged here to do so. If it weren't for Mikasa, he wouldn't be there in the first place. So he wouldn't need saving. Also she saved him after he saved and freed her.

2- in trost: Mikasa would have fucking died just like Miche did if it weren't for eren. He saved her life again.

3- against the female titan: it was levi who saved him. Not Mikasa. Mikasa would have been killed by Annie if it weren't for levi.

4- clash of the titans arc : she didn't save him from reiner and bertholdt. They managed to transform anyway despite her cutting them. They then overpowered eren and kidnapped him. How exactly did she save him here?

5- Clash of the titans 2: Mikasa didn't save eren here. Hannis died protecting both of them. Then eren saved mikasa's life by inadvertently activating the founder's powers and carrying her to safety.

6- royal government arc: she never saved him from anything. Historia willingly went against her father and freed him. Then eren saved the entire cast by using his hardness.

The only one time where you could genuinely argue that she saved him is in his fight with the Warhammer titan. Which was in the 4th season.

So without Mikasa, eren would still make it to the 4th season. While without eren, Mikasa would have been sold to slavery, would have died in trost, would have been eaten by the titans reiner threw at them would have been crushed by rubles in the reiss cave...etc. she wouldn't even survive the 1st season.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 14d ago

Discussion/Question We've gotta get children outta this forest

Thumbnail
gallery
158 Upvotes

Grisha was supposed to save em, but sadly he took Eren into the forest, and repeated the cycle of hatred. Tho Eren did still end up saving both Mikasa and Armin, sadly Eren had to bear the brunt of the sins of his race, the one he is trying to save, tragic.


r/AttackOnRetards • • 14d ago

Humor/Meme AOT Discourse

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/AttackOnRetards • • 15d ago

Humor/Meme What happened to birth control

11 Upvotes

Like srsly


r/AttackOnRetards • • 15d ago

Discussion/Question Some questions and plot holes about Finale Season

1 Upvotes

After rewatching the finale, I had some questions about the final act. Could you help clarify them and explain some plot holes? I just want to make sure I understood everything correctly.

Questions:

  1. Why did the wall titans stop after zeke was killed they should’ve acted like normal pure titans afterwards they were implied to be in season 2 after pastor nick told hange not to show sunlight in them to activate them
  2. How tf did eren transform into the colossal titan
  3. Why did Grisha give eren the serum if he knew that future eren was gonna do something evil

Plot holes:

  1. Falcos having 2 different titan forms and mastering his titan form after his 2nd shift.
  2. Eren altering Mikasas memories even tho ackermans are supposed to be immune to that
  3. Ymir’s having to be freed by mikasa even tho eren already freed her

r/AttackOnRetards • • 16d ago

Negativity r/animecirclejerk can sometimes have bad takes about AoT.

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes