Long one, sorry. I've been rewatching our build-against Victory, and I think the problem was structural, not effort.
What Victory gave us
Out of possession, Victory set up in a 4-2-4. Their front four went after our centre-backs and our double pivot, and behind that there were only two central midfielders. A block like that is there to be played through. Get a third player into central midfield and you have a 3v2 behind their front line, with the whole middle third open.
We never made that 3v2.
Why we couldn't
Our fullbacks went too high, too early. Both fullbacks pushed up to the line of the wingers. That stretched Victory wide, but it also took our two most natural extra midfielders out of the build-up. Their wide forwards could ignore our fullbacks and tuck inside, so our first phase was 4v4 against their front four, or worse.
The box fell apart. For build-up through the middle you want 2 CBs + 2 pivots in a box, with the pivots staggered so each one has a clean passing angle. Too often Gallegos dropped into the back line between the CB and FB, and the other was left alone, flat and easy to screen. Normann was constantly in Sawyers passing shadow. Our only option was to play across the field.
Bayliss did not come short to make the overload. Bayliss and wingers stayed high and wide, pinned against Victory's back four. Nobody dropped into the half-space to be the third man. That meant no 3v2 so no way to break the first line centrally.
What happened instead
We ended up with U-shaped possession, CB to fullback and back again, or a long ball for the striker to contest. That's exactly what a 4-2-4 is built to force. Our progression came from second balls and set pieces rather than from controlled build-up.
What could fix it
Invert one fullback into a back three during build-up, giving a 3-2 base deeper in our own half or into midfield to move to a 2-3 when Woud can play as an extra man.
Keep the pivots staggered (one higher, one deeper) but not dropping them into the backline so there's always a diagonal passing lane.
Have Bayliss or Rogerson/Brook drop into the half-space to make the 3v2 against their two midfielders, then play forward through third-man runs.
Hold one fullback deeper when the opponent presses with four up front, to keep a safe outlet
Second, too many crosses. We get into good areas then we end up crossing the ball that either is collected by the goalie, headed away or easily defended. Crossing is the least efficient option from out wide - we had Rogerson isolated against their fullback so often. We need our wingers to take on the 1v1 situation, try either go around, get to the byline in the box and cut back, or cut back inside early. Crosses produce low xG. Cutbacks from the byline are high xG. Let’s not waste possession in good areas trying to get Cosgroves head to it when he’s double teamed most of the time.
Keen to hear if others saw it differently.