r/AusProperty • u/Panopticon_37 • 23h ago
Markets The most expensive "sale" on our street never settled, but agents are still using it to justify asking prices
I've been looking to buy in the same area for about eight months, and I've started keeping a spreadsheet of every house that gets listed or sold within a few streets of where we're renting.
Not because I'm particularly passionate about spreadsheets. I've just reached the point where I don't trust my memory or the price guides anymore.
About seven weeks ago, a three-bedroom house around the corner went under contract.
It was a decent place. Nothing spectacular, but well maintained, good-sized block, updated kitchen. The agent had been talking about offers around $1.1m.
A few days later, the listing was marked SOLD.
There was a big sold sticker across the signboard, the agent posted about another fantastic result, and a neighbour mentioned that it had apparently gone for $1.12m.
Fair enough. Someone was willing to pay that.
Over the following weeks, two other houses in the immediate area came onto the market.
Both agents mentioned that sale when explaining their price expectations.
One literally told us, "With number 18 achieving over $1.1m, the vendors feel their expectations are reasonable."
Except last Thursday, number 18 appeared on realestate.com.au again.
Same photos. Same floor plan. Same house.
New price guide: $970k–$995k.
I called the agent because I genuinely thought there must have been a mistake.
Apparently the original contract fell through after the buyer couldn't obtain finance, and the vendor has decided to relist at a more competitive price.
Which is understandable. Contracts fall over. It happens.
But here's what's bothering me.
For nearly two months, everyone in the street has been treating that $1.12m figure as evidence of what buyers are currently willing and able to pay.
It was used in conversations about other properties. It influenced what sellers thought their houses were worth. It was presented as a successful sale.
And now we're back to the exact same property being advertised for roughly $130k less than the supposed result.
Obviously a contract price isn't the same thing as a completed sale. I'm not suggesting the agent invented a buyer or deliberately misled anyone.
But until the sale fell over, there was no obvious way for an ordinary buyer to distinguish a completed transaction from a property that had merely gone under contract.
The thing that really got me was checking another listing in the area this morning.
Its asking price hasn't changed, and the agent's description still mentions recent strong sales supporting vendor expectations.
I wonder how many buyers are negotiating against price expectations influenced by transactions that never actually completed.
We all talk about clearance rates, median prices, days on market and comparable sales.
But the more closely I follow individual properties, the more I realise how much information gets lost between "someone agreed to pay this" and "someone actually paid this".
I know not every failed contract means the price was unrealistic. Finance can fall through for plenty of reasons.
Still, if a property can be advertised as sold, used to establish expectations for neighbouring homes, and then return to the market at a substantially lower price, shouldn't there be a clearer distinction between under contract and settled?
For anyone working in property, how do you treat a contract that falls through when assessing comparable sales?
And for buyers, have you ever noticed a supposedly strong local sale quietly reappearing on the market?