It is not yet 7am on a chilly November morning in Canberra and Australia’s treasurer, Jim Chalmers, is outside St Christopher’s Cathedral, walking to his first appointment of the day, no staff in sight, hands jammed into parka pockets, deep in thought.
The image fits the narrative gathering around Chalmers in Canberra in recent weeks. As the face of the government’s tax reforms, stubbornly high inflation, rising interest rates and sluggish productivity, he has become something of an isolated figure, carrying on his shoulders the weight of the government’s problems.
“This guy has been on the receiving end of some of the most outrageous shit that I have seen in a fucking long time,” one Labor insider tells The Saturday Paper this week of the concerted campaign against Labor’s tax reforms.
“The inequities and the double standards that have built up over the years has created a huge number of very wealthy people, and other people aspiring to be wealthy, that suddenly see the bloody honey pot being taken away, and it’s all being directed at Chalmers.”
Not helping Chalmers in caucus is the perception he doesn’t consult backbenchers widely enough on budget changes and that he’s not made enough effort to cultivate backers in the media, especially in the parliamentary press gallery.
“I think Jim looks exhausted. He’s lost weight, he looks gaunt, his hair is greyer – you can see the toll this year has taken on him to the point where a few of us have been a little worried about him,” says one MP.
“It’s that pressure he’s clearly under, which is starting to affect relationships with key backbenchers.”
Another backbencher said they had talked to Chalmers about spending more time developing relationships with the media and carrying them along with reforms. “Does Jim cultivate the gallery? I’m not sure he does. Keating, though, he was always up there arguing, cajoling, browbeating, but, most importantly, charming the journos. I’d like to see Jim do more on that score.”
After Labor had promised before the last election not to touch negative gearing or the capital gains concession, Chalmers’ fifth budget, delivered on May 12, centred on changes to both policies that he framed as a fairer deal for first-home buyers and workers.
From July 1 next year, negative gearing on residential property will be limited to new builds, while the 50 per cent capital gains tax discount will be replaced by cost base indexation, with a 30 per cent minimum tax rate on gains. Arrangements stay unchanged for investments made before May 12 this year.
From July 2028, a 30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts will also be applied, closing a loophole that has allowed high-net-worth individuals to avoid paying the top marginal tax rate of 47 per cent.
Those measures were designed to help fund the Working Australians Tax Offset, a permanent annual offset of up to $250 that will take effect from July next year, lifting the effective tax-free threshold on working income by nearly $1800, to $19,985, or up to $24,985 for those who also qualify for the Low Income Tax Offset.
Public opposition to the changes, especially from the tech sector, has put the government on the backfoot at times and forced a series of policy changes and carve-outs in the months since, creating the impression that budget reforms were rushed and had not been properly thought through.
According to the Labor insider, the tax changes have flushed out a self-interested crowd – some of whose criticisms are well-intentioned – who are trying to defend an unfair system and insisting it should stay that way at the expense of everyone else.
“He can’t stand up and say it like that, but that is what it is,” the source says.
“A lot of people have been on a very good wicket, avoiding the top marginal rate of tax by every means available. But now he’s closing it down, they might actually have to pay their fair share of tax like other workers, and they don’t like it.”
Former Labor treasurer Wayne Swan, whom Chalmers served as chief of staff from 2010-13, and who has been a long-time mentor to Chalmers, tells The Saturday Paper that Labor MPs worried about the electoral fallout from the pile-on should ask themselves three questions: Are the reforms worthy? Are they sustainable? And are they what Labor needs to do to get the country right?
“The most reliable pattern in Australian politics is the hard right’s talent for camouflaging greed as national interest,” Swan says. “Running a close second is its insistence that inequality, unemployment and human suffering are the prerequisites of a strong economy…
“Our opponents love to try to back us into a corner by deploying their favourite trick time and time again, the old false dichotomy that you can choose growth or equality, but you can only choose one. This small-minded, miserable thinking simultaneously shrinks the nation’s soul and its finances. I never accepted it as treasurer, and since then my resolve has only grown. None of us aspire to an even slice of a smaller pie.
“But in rejecting this, we need to be clear-eyed about always, always making an argument for growth. We can’t entertain Greens-style economic stagnation any more than we can accept Liberal Party austerity. Growth is the price of admission. Productivity matters. Good intentions don’t suffice. Equality of opportunity fuels growth. You don’t get unsustained productivity from an unhealthy, undereducated, insecure workforce.”
Inside the federal Labor caucus, some of Chalmers’ colleagues concede a degree of anxiety over the government’s slump in the opinion polls, as well as Liberal leader Angus Taylor’s more focused attacks on the government’s economic management, and the rise and rise of Pauline Hanson’s One Nation.
Earlier this month, four days after influential political commentator Niki Savva warned in her column that tensions inside Labor would “explode” unless the economy improved, and that Chalmers could end up the scapegoat, The West Australian’s political editor, Andrew Greene, asked Environment Minister Murray Watt whether he would like to “see an end to the undermining and leaking” against Chalmers.
“Yes, I would,” said Watt. “As a member of a government, I take seriously the responsibility to work together to support government policies and also to get out there and support each other in what are at times very difficult times.
“I think that Jim Chalmers is doing an excellent job as a treasurer in what are very difficult economic times,” he added. “I think it’s pretty obvious that there’s all sorts of people making all sorts of comments. Many of the features that are impacting on our economy are of course well outside any treasurer’s control, and I very much support Jim Chalmers in his efforts.”
Privately, Watt, who has a reputation for plain-speaking, was emphatic that there was no ulterior motive behind his comments and that he was simply stating the obvious. Still, his comments sparked more speculation about whether the prime minister was mulling over a move against Chalmers.
“That’s bonkers, that sort of talk,” one Labor minister tells The Saturday Paper. “Putting aside the fact that we all own the budget tax reforms, all of us in cabinet and all of us in caucus, the person most damaged by a move like that would be the prime minister himself. It would be an act of self-harm that we would not, in my view, recover from. This is a media narrative; it’s not actually being contemplated by anyone serious.”
When Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek was asked about Chalmers’ performance later that week, she was unequivocal in her support. She said his approach had been excellent.
“We’re in difficult economic circumstances globally; he’s steadied the ship,” Plibersek said. “And I’d also say every single time we have a treasurer that is bold, that does difficult things that the nation needs, there’s a pile-on.
“The idea that Paul Keating got all this support from people to deregulate the banking sector and, you know, make the Reserve Bank independent and open our country by reducing tariff barriers – that was vociferously opposed and constantly criticised by his opponents, the same opponents who are now saying, ‘Oh, the golden days of reform under Hawke–Keating.’ ”
Plibersek made clear that when a minister attempts reform, they will usually receive negative attacks. “And that’s unfortunately just part of the job of being a reforming treasurer.”
Nevertheless, there is an increasingly strong sense within Labor that Chalmers’ chances of succeeding Albanese as Labor leader have suffered a setback. This is explained by the fractured state of Labor’s national Right faction, Chalmers’ lack of a factional powerbase in his home state of Queensland, Chalmers’ own admission that he should “make more time for” his caucus colleagues, and media reports of a flare-up in tensions between Albanese and Chalmers.
Close observers say this is not new: the chance of Chalmers becoming leader was always remote.
“Not much has actually changed,” says the Labor minister. “Jim’s claim to the leadership has always rested on his ability to communicate with the electorate, not on the numbers he brings to the table through caucus, and that remains the case.”
Outside the corridors of Parliament House, there is support for Chalmers’ tax changes, with economists such as The Australia Institute’s Richard Denniss urging Chalmers to stay the course.
“Jim’s just landed some of the biggest tax reforms in my lifetime,” Denniss says. “But here’s the thing: the term ‘tax reform’ sounds like an objective, a political science phrase, but, of course, tax reform in Australia means tax cuts for powerful people. Well, Jim’s just done real tax reform that’s upset some powerful people. So even though it’s big reform, even though it’s Labor values reform, and even though it’s good economic reform that’s good for the budget, he’s made a lot of people who usually own the phrase ‘tax reform’ quite sad.
“Jim has done some big bold stuff that the budget needs, that first-home buyers need, and that economists like. Indeed, he’s done a lot of stuff – like changing the way trusts are taxed and the capital gains tax discount – that economists have been calling for for decades.
“But that’s upset the other group of people who think they have a monopoly on what tax reform means. I think that what Labor’s done with negative gearing and capital gains tax is a wonderful reform that’s good for the economy, good for the budget and good for Australia. But it’s made house prices cheaper, and someone in Labor – and I don’t know who – clearly thinks Labor shouldn’t take credit for making houses cheaper.”
Denniss is not the only economist prepared to back Chalmers’ reforms.
UNSW Sydney emeritus professor Chris Evans, who specialises in comparative taxation, capital and wealth taxation, tax law and administration, believes Chalmers was right to wind back the capital gains tax discount and remove negative gearing for investment properties.
“It was inevitable that there would be a reaction. Whenever you hit the hip pocket of the wealthy, and it is primarily the wealthy who will suffer as a result of [tax reform], then it’s inevitable that there will be a backlash, because those vested interests have very powerful voices. It doesn’t surprise me the reaction, but I’m very pleased that Chalmers has actually done it, and so far has held his nerve on it. I do think he needs to be applauded for that.”
The capital gains tax discount was an abomination, says Evans, that was grossly unfair in all sorts of ways, particularly on younger generations, and was also incredibly inefficient because of the way it distorted investors’ behaviour.
“As for negative gearing – Keating tried to remove it in the 1980s, and the backlash got so bad they finally had to back down, but they should have stuck with it,” Evans says. “This is real tax reform, and the policy change needs time to settle down, so I would urge Chalmers and the government to stick with it.”
Professor Robert Breunig, director of the Australian National University’s Tax and Transfer Policy Institute, agrees that Chalmers does not deserve the criticism he’s getting.
“He’s actually doing what commentators have been calling for for 20 years, which is trying to reform the tax system, and what we are learning for the nth time is that you can’t change the tax system without creating some winners and losers, right?
“Even if your tax system has stuff that makes no sense, when you change it, you’re going to create winners and losers, right? And the losers squeal, and they will fight, and they will use any tactics they can possibly find, including trying to run someone down politically.”
An insight to the personal nature of the media campaign against Chalmers was revealed last week by The Saturday Paper columnist Paul Bongiorno, who wrote that reporters at Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp had been instructed to get Chalmers.
“A News Corp source told the treasurer’s office they have been urged to bag Chalmers every day, with a guaranteed front-page run,” wrote Bongiorno.
Dr Kristen Sobeck, a lecturer in economics at the University of Canberra, who also supports Chalmers’ tax reforms, says it’s important for people to try to understand how Australia taxes different kinds of savings at different points, at different rates, through different kinds of taxes, leaving a system she calls “a bit of a hot mess”.
The most lightly taxed savings, such as owner-occupied housing, require a large upfront deposit, and are therefore the hardest for people with low savings to break into, while money parked in a bank account is taxed every year.
“By making negative gearing less generous, by changing the taxation of trusts and capital gains, they will be able to collect more revenue there,” Sobeck says. “And I’m hoping that, in exchange, what they’ll do is increase this working age tax offset, which would put more money back into the pockets of wage earners, which is, I think, what really needs to happen.”
One reason for the pile-on against Chalmers, posits Sobeck, is that most wage and salary earners didn’t really benefit from the tax changes.
“I think the majority of workers didn’t feel any relief, so they’re not out there loudly supporting the changes. But those who have to pay more income tax, well, they’re loud and very privileged.”
As for criticism that Chalmers has not done enough to rein in government spending, thus keeping inflation higher for longer, Sobeck says it’s worth remembering that at the last election most Australians voted for a party that stands for bigger government.
“Within this context, where Aussies seem to want bigger government, I think what we need to work out is how much bigger.”
Sobeck argues that one policy the Albanese government should reconsider is an export tax on natural gas.
“I actually think that’s a sensible policy and would be a good way of collecting some extra revenue, since the petroleum resource rent tax doesn’t seem to be doing its job very well for a whole other set of reasons,” Sobeck says.
While it is true that the 2026 budget will play a major role in Chalmers’ chances of succeeding Albanese as Labor leader, it’s worth noting that with two more budgets up his sleeve before the next election is due, Chalmers still has plenty of cards left to play.
“If we were going to an election in May next year, I would be worried,” says the Labor minister. “But this is an act in three parts. First, deliver on what we promised. Second, we took a tough decision that deep down everyone knows needed to be made. Third, we deliver the sweeteners, the tangible benefits that we hope voters will easily grasp, and that’s got to be more than just tax cuts.”