r/AvatarLeaks • u/___BostonThreeParty • 1d ago
If Karthik ends up being morally gray, I’ll be curious to see how some in the fandom contend with that.
Especially having seen the leak of he and Nisha months ago. And based on what Sehaj Sethi, the head-writer and co-producer on the show said in regards to Karthik in that AMA, emphasis mine:
“We always wanted him to grapple with very difficult issues and not make simple, clearly pious choices. He is a very complex character and that will only deepen as AVSH progresses.”
I’ve seen so many people lately arguing in the subs or on social media about characters and redemption arcs and what makes a character deserve one, etc.
Even folks saying Azula doesn’t deserve one despite the fact that she was in the same boat as Zuko, also a kid/teenager, but with no positive influence unlike what he had with Iroh.
Azula’s character choosing to stay in that head space and not wanting to change in the comics is way different than if she was to pick a different path and try to make up for what she did. It doesn’t mean everything is forgotten/forgiven; just that the character has the capacity and want to change and actively works towards doing better.
I don’t mind redemption arcs as a whole as long as they’re done well. The Avatar series all seem to be okay with them or characters getting a redeeming moment: Iroh (mainly off-screen though Zuko tells Aang that Iroh has a “complicated past.”), Zuko, Varrick*, Hiroshi, Kuvira in the comics. Even Zaheer gets a moment, to my dismay, as he doesn’t demonstrate any remorse for what he did to Korra. Because she goes to him and he gives her advice that helps her in Book 4.
* Varrick’s annoys me because did he even face *any* repercussions for his horrible actions in Book 2?!
TL;DR: I like that Karthik is going to be complex and not some perfect, all knowledge-having character. I don’t care if damn near every antagonist they face in Books 1-4 is able to grow and change and does better so long as it’s well written. Give me all the nuanced and complex storylines lol.

